Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument with husband tonight

87 replies

colourPink · 23/11/2022 20:35

So my husband and I have a joint bank account where both of our wages go into the same account each month. We essentially earn the same (I do earn slightly more but my pension outtake is so high we take home about the same).

Today, my sister text me and asked me to borrow some money (£50) and I agreed. My husband is now fuming that I didn't check in with him about it and that I lent her money in the first place. He's super anti (and always has been) lending money and we've had a row about it as it's "our money". He's not wrong and we always check in before big purchases but this wasn't that to me.

I feel that I don't need his permission to spend my money. Of course it's our money but I should be able to do this without having to ask first. I also think that she is paying us back on Friday, so two days time. We will not miss that £50 in the next two days. I tried to explain to him that IF we were struggling or needed that money he would have a right to be annoyed but as long as she pays it back when it's due - what's the problem?

He feels that my sister has got herself in a financial mess and she's not our responsibility. She owes my other sister quite a substantial amount which she's paying back monthly. I told him that agreement is between the two of them and nothing to do with us. My sister is 45 and we're both 27 so he also feels like shes built this kind of life for herself and shouldn't even be asking us. I've always had the impression he doesn't particularly like her.

She's a single mum that wanted to go for dinner and drinks with her friends tonight - she doesn't go out much and I didn't want her to miss out. He doesn't know why I lent the money as he didn't ask but I know if I tell him he'll just be angrier as it wasn't even essential.

I hate that he's kicked off and stomped around like a toddler and I don't feel like I can back down as I genuinely didn't mind lending the money. We've had quite a heated argument about it so I'm feeling rubbish now.

But AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pinklyn · 25/11/2022 17:43

Is this a reverse?

I think you've been disloyal to your mum actually. your sister isn't taking her debt seriously.

TomPinch · 25/11/2022 17:30

YABU to the comment above that it's "50% your money". It's not, it's family money for the family's upkeep. 50% is just the OP's contribution.

Sarahcoggles · 25/11/2022 17:18

YABVU.
I'd be furious if someone lent some of my money to someone who already had a big debt, just so they could go out on the piss.

As usual on MN, if you'd posted to say you were annoyed that your husband had lent his feckless brother £50 from the joint account, everyone would support you.

DashboardConfessional · 25/11/2022 16:52

sheepdogdelight · 25/11/2022 09:34

Doesn't matter what the other money was for. The priority should be paying it back and building up some savings to mitigate against further emergencies.

lot of posters on here saying £50 is not much - it's a lot when you have no money and are in debt. I'm thankfully not in that position but I still wouldn't be spending £50 on dinner and drinks out with friends. There are cheaper ways to socialise.

Exactly! I can't phone Halifax and say the minimum payment for my credit card will be £50 short as I fancied a night out. They don't care whether I used the card to buy a Chanel bag or children's shoes.

sheepdogdelight · 25/11/2022 09:34

Doesn't matter what the other money was for. The priority should be paying it back and building up some savings to mitigate against further emergencies.

lot of posters on here saying £50 is not much - it's a lot when you have no money and are in debt. I'm thankfully not in that position but I still wouldn't be spending £50 on dinner and drinks out with friends. There are cheaper ways to socialise.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/11/2022 09:13

4thdegree · 23/11/2022 20:36

this is why it’s foolish to pool money (other than a joint account you both pay a set amount into that covers the mortgage and bills etc)

This.

ConnieTucker · 25/11/2022 06:56

Dotcheck · 24/11/2022 22:47

The amount borrowed from the other sister - we don’t know what that was for , only that it wasn’t paid back. THAT is the amount we were referring to.

But that was prior borrowing. She doesnt have a spare £50 to go out drinking. Borrowing it means she owes it. That means she wont pay the other sister back that £50 for the substantial amount she borrowed there. It is irresponsible to decide to go out drinking when owing a substantial amount of money.

Dillydollydingdong · 24/11/2022 22:53

Surely £50 is neither here nor there? If it was £500 it might have been a different matter, but it doesn't sound as though you're short of cash. Certainly nothing to have a big argument over.

Dotcheck · 24/11/2022 22:47

ConnieTucker · 24/11/2022 20:08

Your comment makes no sense. It was borrowed to go out drinking.

The amount borrowed from the other sister - we don’t know what that was for , only that it wasn’t paid back. THAT is the amount we were referring to.

ConnieTucker · 24/11/2022 20:08

Dotcheck · 24/11/2022 19:14

And if the amount borrowed was for a roof repair?

Your comment makes no sense. It was borrowed to go out drinking.

iloveyankeecandle · 24/11/2022 19:19

I have an older sister who always asked for money and either never paid it back or did but asked to borrow again. Going into the hundreds at one point. She would waste her money but was also a single parent so I'd feel sorry for her. Always had separate accounts with husband. We then had a baby and husband said that it needed to stop. I shouldn't be financially supporting her when I had a small family of my own. I agreed and stopped lending. We now have a joint account and if someone asked me to borrow money then I would consult him first. As I'd expect him to do of it was the other way round.

Dotcheck · 24/11/2022 19:14

ConnieTucker · 23/11/2022 22:50

Because she owes her other sister a lot of money yet borrowed more to go out with friends. Of course that is feckless.

And if the amount borrowed was for a roof repair?

gannett · 24/11/2022 13:54

Really weird that ALL your money is in a joint account.

Essentially, it's all joint money. It's reasonable for people to express an opinion on how joint money is spent, even if both parties are contributing equally. Normally that's as simple as deciding which electrician to use. Our joint account is strictly household/joint needs only.

I would absolutely have something to say if DP was lending joint money - our money, partly my money - to someone I didn't think would repay it.

I'd have nothing to say if he did it from his own account.

He probably has a point, but get separate accounts and it won't be his place to make that point.

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 24/11/2022 13:44

Well obviously it depends on circumstance! But generally lending money to people doesn't end well in my experience and when it's joint funds it's important to be transparent

watingroom2 · 24/11/2022 00:24

I would create a personal account and get my wages paid into that - and tell your DH to do the same - agree a 'set amount' to pool - but have some personal spends that are yours to do as you please

You then have a buffer should things go tits up!

Frostycarrot · 24/11/2022 00:19

I’d be annoyed if I’d avoided a few luxuries or frivolous spends for myself, then paid £50 for someone else to go on a night out

id never dream of borrowing money for anything other than necessities so I’d think she was a CF for asking too. Especially since she’s already in debt to your other sister. That’s very selfish of her.

if you’d lent it to her to buy essentials then I’d have no problem

Cornishclio · 24/11/2022 00:02

We have always had a joint account but also have separate spends account where we put the same amount into each. What we spend from our personal spends account is down to us but the joint account is for spends we both agree on so I would be miffed if he lent money from that but not so much if it was from his personal spends.

I would also have an issue about you lending money to family/friends as on the whole I do not think that ends well and if you spend any time at all on MSE you would see why. In that respect YABU to lend money without running it past your DH as it came from a joint account. Your sister needs to get her finances sorted and you and your sister are not helping her by bailing her out all the time.

tothelefttotheleft · 24/11/2022 00:00

Flamingogirl08 · 23/11/2022 21:10

Yanbu and I disagree with other posters who are sitting in judgement about the reason for needing the money. £50 for 2 days so your sister can have a bit of downtime with friends. No issue with that at all

Exactly. If I had a good relationship with my sister and knew she'd pay me back this would be a no brainer. Being a single parent is hard.

JockTamsonsBairns · 23/11/2022 23:55

StarlingC · 23/11/2022 20:50

He does have some very valid points - a 45 yr old borrowing from her 27yr old sister, whilst owing another sister a ‘substantial amount’.

I thought this too.

I'm 49, and I had to borrow £20 from my 15yo son yesterday 😳. He'll get it back on Friday which is payday.

I don't do it often, but I've got too much month at the end of my money so needs must.

AndysPandy · 23/11/2022 23:53

DashboardConfessional · 23/11/2022 20:54

It's why we don't have a joint account! If after bills and saving I want to lend £50, buy 10 scratchcards or a pair of shoes I don't need, that's my business.

Yep, no joint account here either. OP, maybe now is the time to set up your own accounts, and keep a joint account solely for bills (although we don't even have that).

RobertaFirmino · 23/11/2022 23:48

I suspect that if someone had posted, pissed off because her husband had lent £50 of 'family money' from the joint account to his brother so he could go out on the piss, the replies would be very different.

Maybe you do both need your own accounts. You'd certainly have more freedom to lend as you see fit.

TinySaltLick · 23/11/2022 23:34

It is a joint account, that means you have joint agency over the spend of the money. You are effectively two custodians over the money in there and therefore there is a degree of freedom in how you spend it. You don't need a two person approval process for every pound, even if he sees it as reckless in this instance.

CKL987 · 23/11/2022 23:27

Unless money is tight then it seems an over reaction to me. I pool with my husband and it wouldn't even cross my mind to tell him if I lent someone 50 quid. Everyone's relationship with money is different, it can cause so many relationship issues and I find the psychology of it really interesting. If pooling in this way doesn't work for you both maybe you should have a certain amount allocated to each of you to do what you want with each month.

bonzaitree · 23/11/2022 23:20

I think you both have a good argument to be fair.

I think the proof will be in the pudding. Will she pay it back on time???

ComfortablyDazed · 23/11/2022 23:19

A 40-something borrowing from their 20-something sibling to go out for drinks is pretty feckless….

Mortgages and car loans that enable people to live their lives are a bit different from getting into a load of debt and having to pay people back….