Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Walkaround · 30/11/2022 16:07

@MarshaBradyo - not giving it a swerve because I have an interest in the effect it has had on children - I have children of my own and work with children, after all. I am not interested in the tiresome trying to chase people like @noblegiraffe off the thread, though.

Walkaround · 30/11/2022 16:04

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 30/11/2022 16:02

People who have complained about the derailing attempts generally have pretty good ideas why they think that's happening, so there's no reason to expect anyone's egotistical cod psychology to be treated as though it's got any value.

Only their egotistical cod psychology applies, you mean? And you are the arbiter of all their opinions, but are not yourself arrogant. Anyone would think tou are trying to set the parameters of the thread. Remarkable.

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 16:04

What of it if people express emotions anyway?

Who is to say what others feel. People said it at the time and met a lot of negativity and now are free to say it again. Just give it a swerve if it’s not useful or interesting.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 30/11/2022 16:02

Walkaround · 30/11/2022 15:49

Nice try. I’m not trying to set the parameters of the thread, just suggesting a reason why people on here think it keeps getting derailed… It’s not me that’s bothered by the derailing, after all. But keep letting it get derailed by accusing others of arrogance if you want. I still don’t think that’s healthy, though…

People who have complained about the derailing attempts generally have pretty good ideas why they think that's happening, so there's no reason to expect anyone's egotistical cod psychology to be treated as though it's got any value.

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 16:00

There’s a huge difference between derailment and development of a discussion.

It is derailing to keep bringing it back to teachers and in particular old threads on here. It isn’t derailing to discuss the title of the thread and I’m a bit lost as to why you think others are derailing.

Walkaround · 30/11/2022 15:49

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 30/11/2022 15:23

It is unhealthy and self-pitying to waste anger on re-inventing history and claiming to have been far more clear sighted at the time than any of the people who were stuck in the position of having to make the decisions. It is not wrong to want to discuss the harms done and try to process them in ways that don’t actually just go round in circles and repeat the same angry, negative emotions.

It isn't actually for you to decide that, though. You're not qualified to decide what constitutes unhealthy for other people, it's pure arrogance to imagine that you are. And nobody is preventing you from having a discussion about harms done under the parameters that you set out. You could start a thread for it if you wanted. The fact that you haven't done that and have instead chosen to tell other people they're doing it wrong is telling.

Nice try. I’m not trying to set the parameters of the thread, just suggesting a reason why people on here think it keeps getting derailed… It’s not me that’s bothered by the derailing, after all. But keep letting it get derailed by accusing others of arrogance if you want. I still don’t think that’s healthy, though…

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 15:32

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 30/11/2022 15:23

It is unhealthy and self-pitying to waste anger on re-inventing history and claiming to have been far more clear sighted at the time than any of the people who were stuck in the position of having to make the decisions. It is not wrong to want to discuss the harms done and try to process them in ways that don’t actually just go round in circles and repeat the same angry, negative emotions.

It isn't actually for you to decide that, though. You're not qualified to decide what constitutes unhealthy for other people, it's pure arrogance to imagine that you are. And nobody is preventing you from having a discussion about harms done under the parameters that you set out. You could start a thread for it if you wanted. The fact that you haven't done that and have instead chosen to tell other people they're doing it wrong is telling.

This too, well put

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 30/11/2022 15:23

It is unhealthy and self-pitying to waste anger on re-inventing history and claiming to have been far more clear sighted at the time than any of the people who were stuck in the position of having to make the decisions. It is not wrong to want to discuss the harms done and try to process them in ways that don’t actually just go round in circles and repeat the same angry, negative emotions.

It isn't actually for you to decide that, though. You're not qualified to decide what constitutes unhealthy for other people, it's pure arrogance to imagine that you are. And nobody is preventing you from having a discussion about harms done under the parameters that you set out. You could start a thread for it if you wanted. The fact that you haven't done that and have instead chosen to tell other people they're doing it wrong is telling.

JenniferBooth · 30/11/2022 15:22

Spot on @CoffeeWithCheese

CoffeeWithCheese · 30/11/2022 15:13

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 08:04

The thing is, there are a lot of threads about school funding and it was not only school aged children who were affected by lockdowns. It would be good to get the thread back on track, tbh.

Apparently this continues to be not allowed on here - we weren't allowed to discuss it during lockdowns and we're not allowed to discuss it now. If we do - apparently it's me telling the world that teachers are lazy and wanted to sit and eat muffins... I don't recall ever mentioning muffins - teachers are more nice chocolate biscuit eating creatures in my experience, then pretending to really enjoy one rice cake for lunch afterwards and being very virtuous.

The damage caused was absolutely catastrophic for some kids - in terms of them being so disengaged from school that they're never likely to re-engage. Of course then you have the ones rejoicing that their home schooling of Tarquin meant that the gap between him and his peers is now a gaping chasm and that it's another excuse to win at competitive arsehole parenting.

Or you have those middley kids who are just about doing OK - but without all of the chaos would have been doing WELL and might never get that chance back. And those kids who are now starting school with speech and language needs way beyond what they'd have in a normal year school starting cohort, and a system for SALTs that is absolutely and completely overloaded, broken and with the added "bonus" that this year's SALT graduates are the ones who had a year and a half of online learning and a much higher drop out rate than normal - so less newly qualified ones out there who'd normally be picking up a lot of the paediatric clinic work (a friend of mine is a new band 5 and has a caseload of over 150! - you can never offer a service against that level of need). There's a shitload of research out there about the impact of poor language skills on future life chances - not just in terms of employment, but friendships, self-esteem, health, mental wellbeing.

Then the GCSE/A-Level age group who got completely screwed over by algorithms, university demand and offers meaning universities got swamped so they get a shit student experience and end up having to camp out overnight to get rented houses for their second year.

Or my area - adults with learning disabilities where half of my caseload is people who had a really solid routine of day centres and activity projects - all lost overnight, in homes where their carers STILL have masked faces, and random lockdowns when cases broke out in the setting - I see people whose families no longer visit them, or ones whose mental health suffered so much during all of this that they now present with some very challenging behaviour, self harm or are now too scared to leave their rooms at all. I'd say about 75% of my current caseload referrals contain the words "things have really deteriorated during and after the lockdowns" or words to that effect.

And we NEED to have the freedom to speak out and tell these stories because otherwise we will never ever learn - and we won't see what the need is to begin to repair the damage - and we MADE these people, many of whom weren't able to understand enough to even consent by themselves, put their lives on hold to keep others safe - so now we have an absolute moral obligation to make sure that we do all we can to get their lives back on track afterwards.

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 15:06

I’m not particularly angry. Not sure why you’re assuming that. I’m glad this thread exists. And in the most part has let people talk freely about impact.

A pity it couldn’t have been done before but better now than not at all. The majority yanbu is good to see too.

Walkaround · 30/11/2022 15:01

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 08:28

Absolutely. Re ‘Self pitying’ well avoid the thread then.

It’s obvious what the topic is. Don’t try to shut it down as before.

I’m not trying to shut down the thread, and frankly think it is extremely disingenuous to quote people selectively in an attempt to claim they are saying something different from what their whole post actually said.

I am pointing out that there is a difference between talking about the negative effects of what was done and what people experienced, which is how the thread started and is a very valid exercise in trying to understand and come to terms with a traumatic experience, and pretending that all those harms could have been avoided. It is unhealthy and self-pitying to waste anger on re-inventing history and claiming to have been far more clear sighted at the time than any of the people who were stuck in the position of having to make the decisions. It is not wrong to want to discuss the harms done and try to process them in ways that don’t actually just go round in circles and repeat the same angry, negative emotions.

bookworm14 · 30/11/2022 12:37

Spot on as always, Bogroll!

BogRollBOGOF · 30/11/2022 12:29

Discussions about the impact on children and mothersparents were always shut down and minimised.
Just put a puddle suit on and kick some leaves...
Babies don't need toddler groups...
Sing nursery rhymes...
What about teachers/ grannies/ CEV...
In Scandinavia they don't start school until 7 anyway...
Children are resiliant...

It's a damn sight easier to be resiliant when you have a support network and social contact, and when the majority of society isn't simultaneously plunged into survial/ crisis mode at the same time.

Not every problem originates from Covid measures, but it took out a year or so of dealing with many problems when services were already stretched in the first place and added a lot of additional load into the mix. Some thought that stacking up these problems at the time was a bad idea, but few wanted to listen.

And now we can see the consequences, some people are still trying to deflect back to issues they were discussing at the time and parent-shame rather than being prepared to reflect that restrictions fell disproportionately heavily on to children and young people for minimal benefit.

Services for children were hit hard as they often aren't profitable major industries, are unionised or rely on the voluntary sector. Sometimes it wasn't outright legislation that was the issue but the impact of guidence being incompatible with the behaviours of young people or extra caution where places such as venues for hire went beyond the necessary. Children also lack official voices/ representation to speak for their collective needs.

BordoisAgain · 30/11/2022 11:55

I remember being told on here, by a childminder no less, that toddlers could just be strapped into their buggies all day so parents could work.

Or that we could do our work once children were in bed.

I can laugh now, but at the time it was almost enough to send me over the edge when I'd spent weeks trying to juggle everything and was failing my kids.

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 08:28

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 08:26

to look forward to what could be done to try to remedy the situation, but self-pitying and unhelpful to pretend that the problems could all have been avoided

I’ve seen posts like this a lot whenever people try to mention what happened to them and their children, as if it is somehow wrong or self indulgent to acknowledge what happened. I really dislike it - it puts me in mind of when my mum died and I cried and some idiot relative said ‘now there is no point in crying.’

There is every point in crying and every point in talking. It’s cleansing: it allows you to process and reflect and understand. Things aren’t always and shouldn’t always be solution focused. I read a fascinating book (pre covid!) about evacuees experiences during the war which acknowledged huge harms were done to families in this time. It wasn’t suggesting that it was wrong as such - it simply was.

Saying ‘This is what happened. This is how it affected me and my children’ is the opposite of unhelpful and is certainly not self pitying and I believe you have deliberately chosen that phrase - it belongs with others such as dramatic, wallowing and so on.

We learn by going backwards. That is the whole purpose of our study of history: who are we and how did it come about?

I for one resent being told I can’t talk about my experiences and can apparently only focus on a future which I can only consider in the context of the past.

Absolutely. Re ‘Self pitying’ well avoid the thread then.

It’s obvious what the topic is. Don’t try to shut it down as before.

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 08:26

to look forward to what could be done to try to remedy the situation, but self-pitying and unhelpful to pretend that the problems could all have been avoided

I’ve seen posts like this a lot whenever people try to mention what happened to them and their children, as if it is somehow wrong or self indulgent to acknowledge what happened. I really dislike it - it puts me in mind of when my mum died and I cried and some idiot relative said ‘now there is no point in crying.’

There is every point in crying and every point in talking. It’s cleansing: it allows you to process and reflect and understand. Things aren’t always and shouldn’t always be solution focused. I read a fascinating book (pre covid!) about evacuees experiences during the war which acknowledged huge harms were done to families in this time. It wasn’t suggesting that it was wrong as such - it simply was.

Saying ‘This is what happened. This is how it affected me and my children’ is the opposite of unhelpful and is certainly not self pitying and I believe you have deliberately chosen that phrase - it belongs with others such as dramatic, wallowing and so on.

We learn by going backwards. That is the whole purpose of our study of history: who are we and how did it come about?

I for one resent being told I can’t talk about my experiences and can apparently only focus on a future which I can only consider in the context of the past.

AntlerRose · 30/11/2022 08:25

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 08:04

The thing is, there are a lot of threads about school funding and it was not only school aged children who were affected by lockdowns. It would be good to get the thread back on track, tbh.

I agree that its fine to have a space for a hood old moan.
I tecognise that it was not just school aged children who were impacted by lockdowns, but who do you think is turning up in reception these next few years with huge needs. But yes that probably is a different thread.

Walkaround · 30/11/2022 08:15

Harm was definitely done to children by the restrictions. Harm would definitely have been done to children if there had been zero restrictions. Society is not a collection of disparate, unconnected groups. Maybe the problem with this thread is people saying they want to talk about the harms done, but then actually straying into fantasising about how their children could have lived pretty normal lives through a global pandemic if only this or that had been done differently. It’s useful to discuss the effects of what was done, to see what can be learnt for future pandemics, and to look forward to what could be done to try to remedy the situation, but self-pitying and unhelpful to pretend that the problems could all have been avoided.

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 08:04

JeanniesDiary · 29/11/2022 22:23

But this thread was about the impact on kids. A lot of people felt unable to voice their fears at the time (lest they be accused of wanting people to DIE) and now are finding it more possible/acceptable to do so - and others are pointing out that many fears and predictions have come true.

It's a shame it's descended into a "safe-schools" debate. There were plenty of threads about that back in the day.

I know most teachers have had a rough time and work incredibly hard and expecting them to bring kids to the level they would have been without Covid, with no extra support, is asking the impossible.

But stuff about distancing and masks and air filters in schools and pointing out that Covid was passed on in schools (like most places!) isn't the point when people on this thread were specifically discussing the knock-on harms/long-term implications of RESTRICTIONS on kids.

Bringing it up on this thread might suggest to some that they are arguing that these harms were a price worth paying to prevent teachers or pupils getting Covid. Which may be opinions honestly held, and people are entitled to feel however they like and to take this stance, but perhaps this should be made clear if so

I suspect they, and most people, are reasonable and accept the whole thing was a mess - no one wanted anyone to be harmed, but harm was done and now we need to assess the costs and benefits to learn for the future. And allow people to talk about harms - be they from Covid or as a result of measures to contain it.

Agree with this, especially first para. It was a good thread to share impact. Often not possible during the time.

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 08:04

The thing is, there are a lot of threads about school funding and it was not only school aged children who were affected by lockdowns. It would be good to get the thread back on track, tbh.

AntlerRose · 30/11/2022 07:59

I cant answer for noblegiraffe.
I think its nice to have a space to share that the have been consequences just to recognise them which much of this thread has been.

But id like to see much more talk about what needs to be done next and i guess because i work in school finance, i also want people to see that these harms happened and are not being tackled or even being made worse by the current funding and expectations.

Blackcatinanalley · 30/11/2022 07:46

What do you want people to say on this thread, giraffe?

noblegiraffe · 30/11/2022 07:39

now that vaccines are rolled out, is a full life and all its vibrancy really worth sacrificing in a vain attempt to never get ill ever?

Well that's a straw man and a half...

People were talking about the impact of restrictions on their kids.

You'd have thought they'd also be interested in discussing the failures to deal with those impacts over the last two years and the situation that is currently impacting kids. Or how to deal with the impact on kids 🤷‍♀️

JeanniesDiary · 30/11/2022 07:15

It's not that people are avoiding talking about Covid mitigations and cases in schools. It was discussed repeatedly.

People were talking about the impact of restrictions on their kids.

And I did everything I could to protect the teachers at our school - wore masks, kept DC off repeatedly isolating when we were ill, tested regularly, so I don't want to be painted as someone who doesn't give a damn about teachers. And it's not on them to pick up all the pieces. But there have been loads of threads about schools and Covid.

Illnesses spread in schools - no, it isn't great, it's rubbish, but we've all been breathing "unsafe" air for decades. There's danger from pollution as well as viruses and yes it would be good if it was cleaner. No one wants to get ill but we treated it as a part of life, and for the average person, now that vaccines are rolled out, is a full life and all its vibrancy really worth sacrificing in a vain attempt to never get ill ever? And treating each other - and kids - like dirty disease-factories rather than humans?

Swipe left for the next trending thread