Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Blackcatinanalley · 01/12/2022 15:56

I haven’t appointed myself the thread police at all Confused I have said that there is more to the effects of lockdown than schools. You think that’s ‘daft.’

Why would I report your posts? Genuine question. I have been bewildered by a few things in this thread but that one has totally lost me.

Walkaround · 01/12/2022 15:53

Blackcatinanalley · 01/12/2022 15:25

But most of your posts are (understandably) but this thread wasn’t.

Your analogy is more like someone insisting on talking about swimming in swimming pools when a thread has been started about swimming generally.

It really isn’t. Nobody on this thread is commenting on every effect that every young person experienced from lockdowns, they are commenting on their experiences of the impact on children. It’s really controlling to try to shut down a teacher talking about their perspective on a thread specifically expressed to be about kids feeling the effects of lockdowns, as a teacher has experience of the effect on far more children than the average parent does. I think you are wanting to limit the thread to the effect on individual families and their specific children - but that is not in accordance with the thread title, it’s just what you want to get out of it.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 15:46

But most of your posts are (understandably) but this thread wasn’t.

It’s 800-odd posts about various things. I’m not sure why you seem to have appointed yourself the thread police.

If you want to report my posts for talking about the situation in schools and its impact on children’s recovery from the pandemic on a thread that has the title “children still feeling the effects of lockdowns” then go ahead. But that would be daft.

PrincessConstance · 01/12/2022 15:36

bookworm14 · 01/12/2022 13:09

It’s not about ‘not knowing how to engage with each other in a family setting’, for God’s sake. How patronising. You really believe the reason so many children struggled during lockdown is because their parents don’t know how to talk to them properly? I talked, played with, read to and educated my child during lockdown, but that didn’t stop her becoming anxious, moody, withdrawn and lonely, because despite my best efforts I couldn’t replace all the things that had been taken away from her.

Dp, on the other hand, did not follow the home education given, they spent, months and months and months living in a 30 yr 30x10 ft caravan after our house buying was postponed playing out and generally messing about.

Both children have NO problems at all. Educational attainment is better.

Runaway1 · 01/12/2022 15:35

bookworm14 · 01/12/2022 13:09

It’s not about ‘not knowing how to engage with each other in a family setting’, for God’s sake. How patronising. You really believe the reason so many children struggled during lockdown is because their parents don’t know how to talk to them properly? I talked, played with, read to and educated my child during lockdown, but that didn’t stop her becoming anxious, moody, withdrawn and lonely, because despite my best efforts I couldn’t replace all the things that had been taken away from her.

Same. Thankfully she’s mostly better now, but some effects linger. We were chatting today about why she used to cry when she went to gymnastics after lockdown. She could remember crying but not why. I said it was because she was so used to just being at home with mummy and daddy. Separation anxiety was something we didn’t cause, the circumstances did. We worked through it, but lots of people told me I shouldn’t be putting her through it. If I’d listened? No gymnastics, swimming, Rainbows, play dates at other kids’ houses, parties. How small their worlds became. And for some that narrowing has persisted.

Blackcatinanalley · 01/12/2022 15:25

But most of your posts are (understandably) but this thread wasn’t.

Your analogy is more like someone insisting on talking about swimming in swimming pools when a thread has been started about swimming generally.

Walkaround · 01/12/2022 15:14

The consequences for all people have been far reaching. People’s lives were diminished and I think a lot of people are finding it hard to recover any sense of optimism as more bad news piles on pre-existing bad news. It didn’t even start with the pandemic, really - the rise of serious discontent and people just being angry with each other and cynical about everyone else’s motives started long before that.

As for the pandemic and lockdowns, it wasn’t even my children missing out on it, as they were already teenagers so had a different set of important life experiences to miss out on, but I still feel immensely sad at the thought of all the families who missed out on so many early childhood rites of passage and who lost the sense of security that comes from knowing and understanding what is expected and what is considered acceptable behaviour. At least my children were old enough to develop some of their own, independent thoughts on it all and were lucky enough to have had a background of solid, happy family, school and societal experiences to fall back on. They already had a strong sense of self, I guess.

I do agree with noblegiraffe though, that as schools are having the consequences dumped on them and appear to be expected to paper over the chasms of barely functioning professional mental health support, physical health support, social services support, provision of food, and a stable environment during the school day, on top of being expected to pretend children have not fallen academically and socially behind generally, that this is an inevitable part of any discussion on the consequences of the pandemic.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 15:13

It is daft. You didn’t follow-up a poster talking about swimming pools with “It’s not just about swimming pools” Hmm

I don’t believe I ever said it was only about schools.

Blackcatinanalley · 01/12/2022 13:57

No, Giraffe. I’m not being ‘daft’ Hmm

We had a lot of threads about safety or lack thereof in schools, and most of them were started by you. That’s fine; of course you should do so if you wish.

But while schools are a factor, there a myriad of other things people want to discuss.

Schools closing ✅ OK, relevant.

Extra curricular activities ❌ Not relevant to schools
Playgrounds being shut ❌
Nurseries and childminders being shut ❌
Toddler and baby groups closing ❌
Swimming ❌
Visits to relatives and friends ❌
Libraries ❌
Farms / zoos / aquariums ❌
Churches and other places of worship ❌

Not all the above are relevant and not all the above will be experienced by every single child. But taking them all away - and also the trips to the supermarket or cafe or pet shop - contribute to problems. They can’t not. They mean a child’s world is limited - you naturally use new words in new contexts - they mean they miss out on opportunities to exercise, to learn social norms, to work out their place in the world and how they fit into it.

And a lot of the above either haven’t started again following covid or have started in a very limited fashion. Take swimming, for example - you just cannot get in for love nor money (ha!) at my local leisure centre. So I pay (a lot) for swimming lessons for my own toddler, but not everyone is going to be able to do that, so that gap that already existed between a child from - hate to say it - a reasonably affluent background and a child from a poorer background becomes a chasm and a gaping canyon by the time we’re approaching school age.

I am not saying the damage is irreversible. But the things listed above with a red ❌ closing did have an impact - on physical and mental health, on speech development, on parents’ wellbeing and on all the aspects of the early years right through to teens. I know a teenager isn’t going to be disadvantaged by not going to the farm to see the lambs, by the way!

So it isn’t just about schools. It’s part of a big picture that needs to be carefully considered, and I’m certainly not ‘blaming’ anyone for things closing or for reacting to an unknown virus as they did, but it doesn’t mean the actions were without consequence and I would like to discuss some of those consequences without the thread constantly coming back to schools!

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 13:38

Blackcatinanalley · 01/12/2022 10:47

It’s not just about schools though, giraffe, which is why I think sometimes there is a ‘here we go again’ feeling when you turn up. I know that sounds a bit rotten but I’m not sure how else to put it.

It’s not just about schools so schools shouldn’t be mentioned?

The only posts allowed are ones which cover every single child in any given scenario? Don’t be daft, and that clearly hasn’t applied to any other post.

Seeing various contortions to try to pick fault with the content or topic of my posts instead of admitting that it’s just me that people don’t like is quite funny.

bookworm14 · 01/12/2022 13:09

It’s not about ‘not knowing how to engage with each other in a family setting’, for God’s sake. How patronising. You really believe the reason so many children struggled during lockdown is because their parents don’t know how to talk to them properly? I talked, played with, read to and educated my child during lockdown, but that didn’t stop her becoming anxious, moody, withdrawn and lonely, because despite my best efforts I couldn’t replace all the things that had been taken away from her.

PrincessConstance · 01/12/2022 12:33

trumpet50 · 23/11/2022 23:22

What we are seeing is what happens when parents aren't able to outsource all their parenting to the state. Children weren't at home alone, they were with their families. Abusive situations aside there is no reason why they shouldn't have developed good social skills and managed quite well. If parents didn't prioritise their children's development and wellbeing during lockdown then that is on them. If parent's were anxious and shared that anxiety with their young children, if they didn't engage with them socially, if they allowed their child to become withdrawn and isolated then those are failures of parenting not an inevitable outcome of lockdown.

I've read some of the backlashes to this post. However, I agree with it. Lots of posters are looking for links and causation correlations. What the lockdowns did prove was a substantial group of parents does not know how to engage with each other in a family setting. Another is a complete lack of resilience and basic life skills as individuals. Yet the real problem is home life and social media.

We're having the same outcry over inflation, cooking, and heating homes.
It's embarrassing.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 01/12/2022 11:57

MeetPi · 01/12/2022 11:50

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior

I reported you for trying to restart arguments from one thread on another, yes. That's a breach of forum guidelines and I'll be doing it again if you repeat it.

Ooh. I wasn't restarting arguments from old threads, anyway. I was discussing your mode of argument - completely different. Sometimes it helps other people to know that a wall of aggressive words is primarily illusion.

You made specific reference to you and I having had previous discussions, which as we hadn't at that point spoken on this thread, could only refer to arguments elsewhere. This means what you've just written here is demonstrably false.

Ultimately, you're a hypocrite. You don't like it when people do what you do. When you or people you've decided you approve of continually restate the same point, that's fine, but when it isn't to your taste it becomes problematised. That is all your recent posts amount to.

MeetPi · 01/12/2022 11:50

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior

I reported you for trying to restart arguments from one thread on another, yes. That's a breach of forum guidelines and I'll be doing it again if you repeat it.

Ooh. I wasn't restarting arguments from old threads, anyway. I was discussing your mode of argument - completely different. Sometimes it helps other people to know that a wall of aggressive words is primarily illusion.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 01/12/2022 11:35

MeetPi · 01/12/2022 10:10

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior

Absolutely, you having a view and refusing to change it is fine, but other people doing the same thing is wrong.

Posters sticking to long held views is fine and expected. What I don't do is hector other posters off threads and use absurd circular arguments to do so. (And get their posts deleted when called out on it.)

I reported you for trying to restart arguments from one thread on another, yes. That's a breach of forum guidelines and I'll be doing it again if you repeat it.

If you want to revisit our discussion about how some job losses were caused by restrictions, some by covid and some by a combination of the two, which is the only thing I can think of having argued with you about previously, by all means return to the relevant thread. Note that this is the very opposite of hectoring you off it.

Blackcatinanalley · 01/12/2022 10:47

It’s not just about schools though, giraffe, which is why I think sometimes there is a ‘here we go again’ feeling when you turn up. I know that sounds a bit rotten but I’m not sure how else to put it.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 10:18

But I am hoping that at least some posters will be connecting the dots between the crisis in schools and the current struggles of young people even while others are loudly pretending it doesn't have a place in this discussion.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 10:16

Well certainly if you want to make a case that it's relevant, you're liable to do better if you avoid telling people they should be addressing the matter in a particular way

I did (24/11) , and then got people telling me I shouldn't be on the thread.

The idea that I could somehow have posted on this thread about the issues in schools and school funding without having the usual crowd try to drive me off it is, quite frankly, laughable.

MarshaBradyo · 01/12/2022 10:15

I just saw that deleted post and thought it was a different personal attack. I didn’t report just responded to one below. I don’t bother to engage if I’m going to report.

I can’t remember what it says now but someone else must have objected.

MeetPi · 01/12/2022 10:10

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior

Absolutely, you having a view and refusing to change it is fine, but other people doing the same thing is wrong.

Posters sticking to long held views is fine and expected. What I don't do is hector other posters off threads and use absurd circular arguments to do so. (And get their posts deleted when called out on it.)

PrincessConstance · 01/12/2022 10:07

On a personal note, our children have seen vast improvements in their personal engagement with school and their friends. Dp's oldest daughter refused her 11 plus but is loving her local comp, settled, and striving ahead.
His youngest despite struggling with school academically has returned and is making great, great progress. I honestly think it's a familial problem with educational engagement, like malaise for some children.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 01/12/2022 10:07

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 09:52

Like telling posters that discussion of the current situation in schools and the lack of school funding and resources to deal with the issues caused by the pandemic isn't a suitable topic of conversation for this thread with the title "Kids still feeling the effects of lockdown" and should be posted elsewhere?

Well certainly if you want to make a case that it's relevant, you're liable to do better if you avoid telling people they should be addressing the matter in a particular way, as you have done multiple times on this thread. After all, there'd be nothing to prevent you from making that point without getting into the territory of telling people they're doing it wrong.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 09:52

Like telling posters that discussion of the current situation in schools and the lack of school funding and resources to deal with the issues caused by the pandemic isn't a suitable topic of conversation for this thread with the title "Kids still feeling the effects of lockdown" and should be posted elsewhere?

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 01/12/2022 09:37

I think going forward, it would be useful for it to be more generally understood that any version of telling people they're doing it wrong when it comes to the discussion of lockdown harms is not liable to be well received.

etopp · 01/12/2022 09:17

I said this at the time, OP (and not just about young children). I got a torrent of abuse for it, and MN deleted the "triggering" posts (i.e. the posts that said that lockdown was going to cause more damage than Covid, and that child development was going to be severely affected). So people were definitely silenced. I also agree with a PP that MN is much nastier than it was pre-Covid. It was not terribly nice before, but it's worse now.