Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 22:56

XelaM · 23/11/2022 22:51

But most kids socialise via their phones/various devices anyway and outdoor activities were still allowed.

For your claim that they were only asked to give up school to be correct (as if that wouldn't be a huge deal anyway!) they'd have to have socialised exclusively on phones. Which obviously wasn't the case. Also, loads of outdoor activities weren't allowed so that generalisation is wrong too. It's a ridiculous argument you're attempting to make.

CanYouFeelMyHeart · 23/11/2022 22:55

Comedycook · 23/11/2022 22:15

By march 2021 she was a shell of her former self, she developed tics

My Ds also developed tics. It's so sad isn't it.

My worst day was walking up the street to my house, and I could hear my daughters constant swearing. And I mean constant. FUCK FUCK SHIT FUCK SHIT SHIT FUCK.

She couldn't control it, and was strangely unaware of how loud it was. When she went back to school she scared some of the Reception kids through ticcing, and I had to explain to her how obvious her swearing was, and that it might seem scary for very little kids.

She was devastated and sobbed her heart out in my arms. She was 9. A little kid herself.

sageandrosemary · 23/11/2022 22:55

My recently turned 3yo is scared of other children it they're inside. Outside is much better. It might be that he's just a shy child but I think it's due to the total lack of indoor play/classes/groups etc at the age he needed it. Outdoor play areas obviously opened sooner so he had more exposure there.

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 23/11/2022 22:55

"As early as April 2020 people who were raising concerns that there would be issues, that the collateral damage of lockdowns would be great were vilified and shut down.
I can think of many occasions on this site where people were shamed for suggesting that actually locking down was not the right way to go or that the country's pandemic policy established years previously was not being followed. Groups like Usforthem, Great Barrington Declaration etc etc were mocked but they were right. Lockdowns resulted in untold amounts of damage to children across the world (and not from covid)"

I never understood why this happened. There were highly educated and experienced people looking to manage this a different way but they were shut down every time. It was a discussion worth having!

I'd also like to thank those posters who spoke up. They gave me hope.
I did too, under a different name and was often rounded on.

Belleton · 23/11/2022 22:54

DS1 is in year 2 now. He is quite nervous, sometimes says his tummy hurts and his chest feels funny which I honestly think is anxiety. He was always of a more sensitive nature anyway but covid seems to have made it harder for him. His learning is doing well though. I was a teacher prior to having my disabled DD and wasn’t working at the time so was able to help him with home schooling.

DS2 is in reception now. I honestly don’t think he was affected too badly. He started nursery Sept 20 and was able to carry on through the following lockdowns which helped him enormously. His behaviour can be a challenge sometimes but honestly it was before lockdown as well.

DD is also in reception (twins). She has a learning disability and the first lockdown did her the world of good in terms of development. She loves being at home anyway and she started speaking more and signing more. We had a terrible few months with her after the first lockdown though, we couldn’t go inside anywhere with her e.g a shop, cafe, anything without her having a huge meltdown. Luckily she took to nursery well in Sept 20 and doesn’t seem too affected now.

I consider us to be very lucky.

Comedycook · 23/11/2022 22:54

But most kids socialise via their phones/various devices anyway and outdoor activities were still allowed

Nonsense. Playgrounds were locked. Football was cancelled. It was illegal for my DC to meet a friend in the park. And most kids don't solely socialise on their phones and devices... especially very young ones.

ChiefFinderOuter · 23/11/2022 22:53

XelaM · 23/11/2022 22:51

But most kids socialise via their phones/various devices anyway and outdoor activities were still allowed.

Your memory is clearly faulty. Outdoor activities were not allowed, for a long period of time. I distinctly remember being overjoyed that I could now meet one friend, outdoors. It’s mental, when you look back.

CarefreeMe · 23/11/2022 22:53

Although I do think children suffered, especially those who were experiencing abuse and things at home.

I do think a lot of it is an excuse for bad behaviour or to pass the blame.

There we’re many kids who had behaviour issues or didn’t want to go to school but now they can use the excuse of covid and MH and teachers aren’t allowed to question it.

There are many studies showing that children should start school at an older age.
There are also many people who homeschool.
Having extra time at home would not have caused any major issues (if it wasn’t abusive).

Yes the children will be emotionally younger but that’s because they’re usually pressured into acting much older than they feel - I don’t think it’s a bad thing for them to act their age.

I do think anxiety has increased but it was on the up way before covid, as well as behaviour issues.

I’m not saying covid didn’t have an effect but I don’t think covid is solely to blame.

Before covid I was pulled up for saying that a particular group was for girls and this boy couldn’t attend - it was a girls sports group.
After covid I was also pulled up for asking a boy to leave the room as we were discussing girls things and it was a girl-only group.

These sorts of issues of trying to be offended or trying to get out of lessons because they have X,Y,Z have nothing to do with covid and are just on the rise and would have continued to rise whether or not lockdowns happened.

1dayatatime · 23/11/2022 22:52

@XelaM

"Can I ask what exactly you think affected your kids/kids in general so dramatically?"

+++

A lack of sport particularly team sports
Missing mile stone events eg end of primary, Year 11 and Year 13 proms / balls.
Residential school trips
The media constantly pumping out "we are all doomed and going to die"
The expectation that once the virus goes away then things will get back to normal and a failing of things being "on hold". But waiting 18 months for something feels a lot longer when you are a child than when you are an adult.
A fear that they will lose their parents/ grandparents/ themselves.
If they were of the mindset of believing the hysteria then a fear that there was an evil virus around every corner out to get them.
If they did not buy in to the hysteria then a resentment that children were somehow a Covid incubator and schools were somehow a virus reservoir.
General resentment/ kick back against authority when even the youngest figures out the rules made no sense reinforced by view of parents.

I could easily go but is that enough?

IrishMamaMia · 23/11/2022 22:51

Nowadays we have a much better understanding of children's developmental psychology which we didn't have post - world war two in the same way. A bit silly to compare both situations when we have the knowledge we do now.

XelaM · 23/11/2022 22:51

SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 22:47

This is just factually incorrect. They were asked to do much more than stay out of school: they were asked to give up everything else outside the home too.

But most kids socialise via their phones/various devices anyway and outdoor activities were still allowed.

ChiefFinderOuter · 23/11/2022 22:50

StitchFanBeforeItWasCool · 23/11/2022 22:39

Also my colleagues who're teachers have said with primary especially they're seeing more and more cliques of children. The children who were in during lockdown, or the ones who lived close enough to sneak under the radar with rules so still saw each other are miles ahead socially than those left at home with just their parents and siblings for company. And a lot of the time now they're encouraged by the parents to be exclusive of their group, they see the others as babyish.

Our primary has a huge catchment as it takes in from a very rural area, so we have DC that live close and on the same street as each other than we have DC who are bussed in from 3-4 miles away who didn't see another child outside their family for months apart from on a screen so they struggle to play or talk to the other children.

This is interesting. My ds is year 3 and his class is just a load of small cliques. We’re all unsure how much that would have been the case anyway, but it’s markedly different to my year 1 child’s class. It makes sense when you think about it. They spent a year and a half of schooling either on their own or in enforced cliques (bubbles).

My boys are close, and only 2 years apart. They were incredibly lucky to have each other, and I was incredibly lucky to have an understanding employer who enabled me to devote a few hours to the children each day. The younger one benefited academically from basically sitting in on the older one’s homeschooling. Emotionally though, I’d say both were impacted. The younger one especially is still learning that you can’t treat your classmates the way you do your brother!

Comedycook · 23/11/2022 22:50

All the kids were asked to do was stay out of school (a dream for many kids) so I don't quite understand why it had such an enormous impact apparently

That wasn't all it was. Oh and all kids I know enjoy school, including my own.

My kids couldn't

See extended family
See their friends
Play sports
Attend extra curricular activities
Go to a playground
Go to parties

Their medical appointments were cancelled too.

Rosebel · 23/11/2022 22:49

My son was born in June 2020 and for the first year of his life we didn't socialise a lot, although he did 2 mornings a week at nursery from six months.
He is behind in his development and is still pretty much non verbal. No help as SALT are overstretched with long waiting lists. He also seems to get ill a lot (far more than his older sisters ever did) and he also struggles to fight off illness.
Can't help but think if it wasn't for Covid he'd probably have better immunity and might have got help with his speech.
As for my older two they seem more anxious. If me or their dad get ill they pani6. Eldest didn't do well in her exams and youngest is still more prone to outbursts due to anger.

SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 22:47

XelaM · 23/11/2022 22:45

I have to agree. All the kids were asked to do was stay out of school (a dream for many kids) so I don't quite understand why it had such an enormous impact apparently.

This is just factually incorrect. They were asked to do much more than stay out of school: they were asked to give up everything else outside the home too.

Takingabreakagain · 23/11/2022 22:47

eddiemairswife · 23/11/2022 22:42

How did we wartime children cope? I had disruption in Y2 when we were evacuated; we had to shelter in school during air-raids; time at home after school was bombed, then taught in a church hall with no desks where we knelt on the floor and rested our books on chairs. We survived, grew up, got married, had children, had careers. We are your grandparents.

Lockdown children were in some cases isolated from their peers, families and friends for months on end - wartime children were able to mix and socialise. War must have been terrifying for children. But it's the isolation and lack of contact that is causing the problem now. That's not saying today's children won't grow up to be 'ok' it's just acknowledging the harms caused so that it doesn't happen again.

Comedycook · 23/11/2022 22:46

eddiemairswife · 23/11/2022 22:42

How did we wartime children cope? I had disruption in Y2 when we were evacuated; we had to shelter in school during air-raids; time at home after school was bombed, then taught in a church hall with no desks where we knelt on the floor and rested our books on chairs. We survived, grew up, got married, had children, had careers. We are your grandparents.

It's not the same. I'm not saying one situation is worse than the other. But you have described your situation as disruption. Our children were not just disrupted, they were isolated. It's quite different. It's very very unnatural for children to go month and months on end without seeing another child and being able to play together. In fact, it's probably never happened before. Even in refugee camps you see children playing together. Not saying that's an ideal situation before anyone jumps on me.

XelaM · 23/11/2022 22:45

eddiemairswife · 23/11/2022 22:42

How did we wartime children cope? I had disruption in Y2 when we were evacuated; we had to shelter in school during air-raids; time at home after school was bombed, then taught in a church hall with no desks where we knelt on the floor and rested our books on chairs. We survived, grew up, got married, had children, had careers. We are your grandparents.

I have to agree. All the kids were asked to do was stay out of school (a dream for many kids) so I don't quite understand why it had such an enormous impact apparently.

SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 22:45

eddiemairswife · 23/11/2022 22:42

How did we wartime children cope? I had disruption in Y2 when we were evacuated; we had to shelter in school during air-raids; time at home after school was bombed, then taught in a church hall with no desks where we knelt on the floor and rested our books on chairs. We survived, grew up, got married, had children, had careers. We are your grandparents.

My grandparent, who lived through both WW2 and lockdown and preferred the former, said the major difference was the forced isolation.

PicaK · 23/11/2022 22:43

If you ask for the minutes of the governors' and/or trustees' meetings over the last 2 years for your child's school you'll be able to see the massive impact it had.

The government weren't being nice when the stopped SATs - they handily ensured a massive lack of evidence.

eddiemairswife · 23/11/2022 22:42

How did we wartime children cope? I had disruption in Y2 when we were evacuated; we had to shelter in school during air-raids; time at home after school was bombed, then taught in a church hall with no desks where we knelt on the floor and rested our books on chairs. We survived, grew up, got married, had children, had careers. We are your grandparents.

Iheartmysmart · 23/11/2022 22:42

I remember being so scared for DS. He was just about to take his A-levels and it was actually his 18th birthday the day lockdown was announced. We had a really difficult time with him in his early teens with self harm and suicidal thoughts but had started to make progress with counselling, music therapy and martial arts classes. All of a sudden all that support was gone.

He put on a brave face for us but he had a couple of years where he didn’t settle and drifted around doing any work he could find. Finally this year he made a decision to go to university and started in September. He still worries about the slightest thing and is a very anxious young man though.

IrishMamaMia · 23/11/2022 22:40

We suffered really badly in the initial lockdown whe nurseries were closed. I had a three year old who was tantruming constantly, not understanding what was going on and an infant to look after. I ended up unwell with depression. After these horrible weeks we spent the rest of the restrictions living as normally as we could within what was allowed. I am lucky that both kids are doing well now.
I work in a school and definitely notice effects.Current Year 7 seem very badly affected.
It was too much pressure on family units.

StitchFanBeforeItWasCool · 23/11/2022 22:39

Also my colleagues who're teachers have said with primary especially they're seeing more and more cliques of children. The children who were in during lockdown, or the ones who lived close enough to sneak under the radar with rules so still saw each other are miles ahead socially than those left at home with just their parents and siblings for company. And a lot of the time now they're encouraged by the parents to be exclusive of their group, they see the others as babyish.

Our primary has a huge catchment as it takes in from a very rural area, so we have DC that live close and on the same street as each other than we have DC who are bussed in from 3-4 miles away who didn't see another child outside their family for months apart from on a screen so they struggle to play or talk to the other children.

1dayatatime · 23/11/2022 22:38

I see the impacts every day and it breaks my heart.

@Fleabigg - I have also witnessed Years 9 and 10 being particularly problematic. This is a combination of low attendance, basic bad behaviour and aggression and also an inability / immaturity to cope with low levels of pressure / stress/ instruction. We were discussing this exact point and concluded that the emotional maturity to stress and pressure of years 9 and 10 is very similar to what would be expected from years 7 and 8 if put under similar pressure.

In the younger ages there is a much greater difference in ability than pre Covid both academically and socially. Of course there are always some children brighter or more sociable than others with most somewhere in the middle. But now it seems much more extreme and it seems half are perfectly fine and where they should be or ahead but the other half are so far less developed academically and socially- what might three years ago have been one or two children in this group is now more like 10 or 12.

And lastly boys and girls are equally affected although how it manifests itself differs.