Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
PorridgewithQuark · 24/11/2022 07:01

WoolyMammoth55 · 23/11/2022 22:22

This is a sad thread. My heart goes out to everyone whose children are suffering.

I've got a 5 yo in Y1 and a 22 month old starting nursery in Jan. It's been tough on them both, but luckily for us nothing too extreme.

I did want to gently suggest that the government and decision makers are more worthy targets for rage than other parents? It was a complete unknown and a lot of people were terrified, with good reason...

I had a lovely friend of 39 who was an ICU nurse with 2 little kids, in perfect health, loved her family and her job. She died of Covid in the first wave. We are trying our best to spend time with her kids, and to remind them how lovely their mum was, without adding to their trauma.

I don't think it was unreasonable at the time to want to follow the rules to keep people alive. But I'm really sorry for those of you that felt shouted down.

Exactly.

The people furious about lockdown and bitter that their children didn't qualify for keyworker places because they were able to stay at home need to do some serious reflection.

Mind you I do think that the UK was so free and easy with the definition of "keyworker" meaning that in some places the balance tipped too far to a (big) minority homeschooling while a (small) majority were in school. That does create division.

Where I am only those with both parents keyworkers unable to work from home were allowed to go to school, which also meant the teachers weren't supervising classes and did set proper work from early on (and for secondary school taught on line, though in our old fashioned, rural area primary did actively require parents to teach work sent out, which UK parents wouldn't have accepted and which did exacerbate the social divide).

FlirtyMelons · 24/11/2022 06:59

I would say any kids of school age would have been affected TBH, my DS1 was 14 at the time and personally for him it was fine, DS2 was Y7 when it happened so his last full year was Y6 and then with the exception of a few covid isolations did most of Y9. That is missing out on an extremely vital socialisation and apparently current Y10 year groups in many schools are struggling socially and displaying behaviours expected of Y8s when it comes to disagreements and general 'playground' behaviour. Luckily mine DCs aren't too affected by it all from what I can tell but I totally understand why many will be and for different reasons dependant on age.

Doowop1919 · 24/11/2022 06:53

Just read through the whole thread and it was such a sad read. I'm so sorry so many of your children have been affected by the pandemic and lockdowns.

I personally struggled a little as DS was born summer 2020. We waited years for him after infertility and suddenly no one could come visit or help or meet him (I live in the EU). We missed out on a lot but I seem to be feeling much better about it today now that I have seen family again and we are out and about going to nursery / tumble tots / meeting up with others again. But I realise I have some leftover anxiety when he's ill and I know we're now at home again all week with nothing to do. It reminds me a bit of those early days when I had a screaming colicky baby and my only escape were baby classes which were all cancelled.

DS is, however, fortunately unaffected by it all. He's advanced in his speech, loves going outside and has taken well to nursery. He was very nervous around other children at first but I think that's just his personality, he's a sensitive softie. So I do feel lucky there that DS doesn't seem to have been affected at all.

JenniferBarkley · 24/11/2022 06:47

XelaM · 24/11/2022 06:32

I agree with this. I loved lockdown, as I was working from home instead of having to commute, saved loads of money, could work from Germany where my parents live and my daughter was still able to do her hobby (horse riding) and had structured online lessons (private school). We even had a nice holiday in 2021 in a waterpark in Germany that was open as long as you had a negative Covid test.

Individual children of course would have struggled but this thread is full of professionals saying that whole cohorts are far out of line with the norm. It's no surprise that those cohorts are the ones that missed out on crucial school years.

If you had a nice time in lockdown that's lovely, but to read some of the stories on this thread and then post about it doesn't exactly mark you out as a generous person.

At this stage no one can claim ignorance of the very difficult circumstances many families endured. Enjoyable working from home, quality online education, holidays, improved financial positions, continuing hobbies are all very far from the norm of that time (and I say that as someone who was privileged and didn't suffer too badly despite the new baby and a bereavement).

XelaM · 24/11/2022 06:32

WindyKnickers · 24/11/2022 00:48

Without dismissing or minimising the very real genuine concerns and lived experiences on here i do think for many children it's pretty hard to attribute these issues solely to lockdowns. Lots of children would have emotional/ behavioural/ academic issues without covid. My DC are yr 3 and yr 7 and they are fine as are most of their friends. The ones who have struggled in my experience have parents who have also struggled and the anxiety or isolation issues have rubbed off on them. Again, this is just my observations of those around me, I understand others have different experiences.

I agree with this. I loved lockdown, as I was working from home instead of having to commute, saved loads of money, could work from Germany where my parents live and my daughter was still able to do her hobby (horse riding) and had structured online lessons (private school). We even had a nice holiday in 2021 in a waterpark in Germany that was open as long as you had a negative Covid test.

PaTCh64355 · 24/11/2022 06:30

trumpet50 · 23/11/2022 23:22

What we are seeing is what happens when parents aren't able to outsource all their parenting to the state. Children weren't at home alone, they were with their families. Abusive situations aside there is no reason why they shouldn't have developed good social skills and managed quite well. If parents didn't prioritise their children's development and wellbeing during lockdown then that is on them. If parent's were anxious and shared that anxiety with their young children, if they didn't engage with them socially, if they allowed their child to become withdrawn and isolated then those are failures of parenting not an inevitable outcome of lockdown.

Don’t be unkind. If your family coped wonderful, but respect that you were privileged. You must understand that others had very different experiences. Single parents desperately trying to WFH and homeschool children. Families living in flats. Children with additional health needs.. overnight families lost all of their support networks.

Puffykins · 24/11/2022 01:00

The other issue now, in schools, is the amount of time it's taking to get a referral to CAMHS or to get an ECP - which are needed if the child is to get extra funding/ the one-to-one they so need (and the rest of their class so needs them to have.) Where we live, there's a two year wait in some cases - so yes, there are classes that are really hard to teach because there literally aren't enough staff in the room.

WindyKnickers · 24/11/2022 00:48

Without dismissing or minimising the very real genuine concerns and lived experiences on here i do think for many children it's pretty hard to attribute these issues solely to lockdowns. Lots of children would have emotional/ behavioural/ academic issues without covid. My DC are yr 3 and yr 7 and they are fine as are most of their friends. The ones who have struggled in my experience have parents who have also struggled and the anxiety or isolation issues have rubbed off on them. Again, this is just my observations of those around me, I understand others have different experiences.

caroleanboneparte · 24/11/2022 00:44

My youngest has really felt it. He's basically missed out on 1 or more years of development. I think of him as being younger. He's nowhere near where the others were at his stage.

But thankfully MH wise all mine have been spared.

DC at uni partied away in halls despite the rules.

I was really against lockdown and we did only what we had to (laws rather than guidance).

I think it was a massive policy failure in the long term.

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 00:43

People in Glasgow had the longest restrictions in Europe. They weren't allowed visitors from 1st September 2000 through to End of May 2001.

Softplay was closed for all of that to. In fact I don't think they opened at all from March 2000 to June 21.

MeetPi · 24/11/2022 00:33

Takingabreakagain · 23/11/2022 23:36

Schools could have continued to operate as normal. It was quickly established who the vulnerable people were and it was not children or (most) teachers.
We have sacrificed children and young people to 'save' elderly people who quite often didn't want to be 'saved' . They actually wanted to see their grandchildren and know they were living instead of existing.
I do blame the government and also the media, they embarked on a huge propaganda campaign to scare people and it worked. Far too many people were scared or just didn't look any further into things than what was shown on TV. Moderate voices were shut down and ridiculed.

Ah, this again - the elderly that supposedly want to sacrifice themselves for the children. This was trotted out so many times in defence of the worst arguments by those who simply didn't want to do what the Government asked them to do.

And it isn't just elderly people that die of Covid. You know this. Teachers can also become very ill and, yes, die. My 50yo sibling with cancer currently has Covid, is extremely ill and I'm really just waiting for a call. I'm sick of the silly minimising rhetoric here.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/11/2022 00:21

trumpet50 · 23/11/2022 23:48

Whilst all that is true, we were not in a situation where we as a nation were confined to our own houses for the duration of the pandemic. We had various periods of varying levels of controls but the way people are carrying on you would think that we were all not allowed out of our houses for 6+ months at a time.

The govt provides nursery hours to get parents back to work and because some parents are pretty awful and fail to parent their children adequately so the state needs to step in. Peer socialisation can happen outwith a formal childcare setting in normal circumstances. There is no need for children to attend pre school in order for them to develop along typical milestones

The rules on who/ how many/ where you could meet up were very restrictive for the vast part of 12 months and pretty much all of it if you were in Leicester, with Manchester then Birmingham not far behind.

If your family weren't local, friends bubbled up with their local families and the people you knew were strict about following the rules (and many people went beyond the minimum) then there wasn't the company to meet up with.

I took my children out as much as I could. We walked (and walked and walked), we climbed into empty playgrounds, we went to zoos and as many outdoor attractions as we could in the window when they reopened, but we couldn't force other people to change their priorities to socialise.

In autumn 2020 it was legal to meet friends from 5 households in the pub to go for a drink as a group of 6... but it was illegal for 2 families of 4 to meet up with each other for a walk. Which was the higher Covid risk? Who did the laws prioritise?
Playgrounds legally opened on 4th July with the pubs. Many remained shut far longer as land owners and insurance companies sweated over details of social distancing and cleaning... even though they were outdoors where the virus rapidly degrades and used by a low-risk demographic. The whole playgrounds opening bit was a last minute afterthought in the first place because there was an outcry that pubs were going to open first.

For various reasons, many childrens activities were out of action for prolonged periods. Junior parkrun 13m (5k parkrun 16m) volunteer groups often didn't reopen until Easter 2021 for outdoors activities, September 2021 to function normally. Life stopped, and started and stopped repeatedly. It was a very unstable time and routines were repeatedly broken sometimes within weeks such as Nov 20/Dec 20/Jan 21. It's only really since spring this year, after 2 years that many schools are operating normally again including plays, sports days, fetes, parents evenings.

That's a huge chunk of time in childhood.

Blaming the parents is so Spring 2020 along with "flocking", "flouting", "selfish" and "granny-killer"

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 00:17

XelaM · 23/11/2022 22:51

But most kids socialise via their phones/various devices anyway and outdoor activities were still allowed.

Primary and younger do not socialist via phones. They had nothing to talk about, nothing to say.

I bought my then 9yo an Xbox so he could play and chat with pals. It was horrific he was shuffling food around on his plate. The signs of depression were kicking in.

My then 3yo didn't appear to suffer but his speech is very poor for his age.

Some children with furloughed parents it was all a great big holiday. Out bike rides in their sweet wee family bubble.

For others it was the telly in the corner. Wall to wall cartoons while mum and dad were trying to work from home.

As for shite about WW2 kids coped, well actually most of them were still at home going to school and nursery.

They didn't have a telly in the corner spouting how many people died that day.

However those who were evacuated will have very different experiences and some will have been left with long term issues even if it was never officially recognised.

Littlemisspawpatrol · 24/11/2022 00:10

greenstrawberries · 23/11/2022 22:31

I can so relate to all of you who said it killed your love of motherhood. My boy was only 8 months old but I still feel traumatised from being trapped in my house with an unsettled and whinging baby for months on end. Beforehand I’d planned more children but the only positive during lockdown was that I only had the one. Still only got the one.

Also it has definitely had an impact on his development. He’s extremely sensitive and finds many things too noisy. He’s struggled massively to feel comfortable around other children, he will ask to leave a playground if it’s busy or children come near him. He’s in school nursery now and is not interested in any of the other children. Everything is scary. He loves being at home and if you ask him what he wants to do he will say ‘stay home’.

My dd is the same! She was 10 months old when lockdown started and we were just beginning to thrive, with me adjusting to motherhood, the routine of groups, and her learning to walk. I'm so sad for who she was when she was a baby compared to now. She used to shout at people across the street as a baby and go up to kids in the park to play as a one year old (before too many months of lockdown had happened), and now she's selective mute and doesn't know how to get children to play with her.

hamstersarse · 24/11/2022 00:10

@trumpet50 I'm presuming you are on a wind up. No one can be that stupid to believe children can have healthy development without any peer interaction.

Although it always baffled me how these lockdowns passed so easily with parents and maybe it's because there are many more Trumpet50's lurking amongst us than I dared to believe

It's heartbreaking to hear of all the impact this has had on children. Not surprising in any way, but nevertheless still heart breaking

PuttingDownRoots · 24/11/2022 00:06

Not all families had the same experience.

Flats vs houses with large gardens
Parents on furlough vs parents trying to wfh vs parents working outside the home
Only children vs siblings close in age
Friends and family close by vs isolated
Online lessons vs virtually no input from school

Its no wonder that some kids suffered more while others thrived.

1dayatatime · 24/11/2022 00:05

@trumpet50

"
That is literally proving my point, what you have illustrated is a failure of parenting not an inevitable result of lockdowns. Yes parenting became much much harder, but the onus is on the parent to mitigate the difficulty, not just transfer the difficulty onto the child."

+++

Hmm OK let's look at the example in my post.
Why was the child at home in the first place? Well that would be because there was a lockdown.
Why was the mum working from home and not in the office?Well that would be because there was a lockdown?

This is not an example of a failure of parenting but a result of a lockdown policy that placed a mum in a situation she would otherwise have not been in and in which she tried to the best of her abilities to balance the need to keep her job and look after her children.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 24/11/2022 00:05

Yes parenting became much much harder, but the onus is on the parent to mitigate the difficulty

i’d also really love to hear the genius ideas of how parents were supposed to mitigate the ‘difficulties’ of a national lockdown?

HackettGreen · 24/11/2022 00:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 24/11/2022 00:02

For all those kids that suffered in lockdown, many thrived.

Huge amounts of data would suggests that the vast majority did not.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 23/11/2022 23:59

trumpet50 · 23/11/2022 23:50

That is literally proving my point, what you have illustrated is a failure of parenting not an inevitable result of lockdowns. Yes parenting became much much harder, but the onus is on the parent to mitigate the difficulty, not just transfer the difficulty onto the child.

having a parent so arrogant and ignorant to spout such crap and with such little empathy or understanding of broader society is far more harmful in the ranking of parenting fails.

JenniferBarkley · 23/11/2022 23:59

JenniferBooth · 23/11/2022 23:52

@JenniferBarkley There was a female doctor in South Africa trying to tell other countries Omicron was fairly mild for most people She was shouted down.

And with hindsight isn't it wonderful that she was right, Omicron turned out to be the answer almost as much as the vaccines.

After multiple waves, if you were in a position of power and the decision of whether to close schools or otherwise lockdown rested in your hands, with a new strain that appeared to transmit more easily and that the vaccines weren't as successful at stopping - how much evidence that it was mild would have convinced you?

I don't think all the right decisions were made all the time, but I'm sympathetic to the fact that life couldn't carry on as normal and decisions did need to be made.

I'm must less sympathetic, and in fact furious, at the lack of effort to mitigate the longer term effects now that we're past the initial sort term uncertainty.

jtaeapa · 23/11/2022 23:58

You have to consider that if we had not locked down and cancelled the summer term of 2020 that more teachers would be dead. All very well for small kids to go out into covid and be fine, but at that stage there was no vaccine and people of all ages were dying. My db is a teacher and caught covid after having 3 jabs. He almost died, ventilator in ICU. Now if he had caught it with no jabs in summer term 2020, he would most definitely be dead.

For all those kids that suffered in lockdown, many thrived. Many escaped bullying for example. Many worked hard independently. Many spent time with their family that they wouldn't have otherwise had - I know someone whose dh used to commute to London and stay the week every week. Kids hardly knew him until lockdown happened.

Most comparable european countries locked down. It was not unreasonable for us to lock down. People weren't vaccinated. Hindsight is a wonderful thing anyway!

JenniferBooth · 23/11/2022 23:56

Not all of them @BestMammyEver there are still a couple of them around.

MichaelFabricantWig · 23/11/2022 23:52

roarfeckingroarr · 23/11/2022 21:36

Do people now have more understanding of those who were a little loose with Covid rules at the time? I don't mean wild parties, but still seeing one or two people at a time, inside, when it wasn't allowed? I have no regrets about trying to keep my v young son's life as normal as possible and he doesn't seem to have been affected.

I wish I’d ignored the lot of it, pile of shite that it was.

Never again will the government tell me who I can and can’t have in my private dwellinghouse.