Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
PorridgewithQuark · 24/11/2022 08:14

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 08:03

My issue is that while vulnerable and disadvantaged families and children were disproportionately disadvantaged, a whole bunch of people who do not fall into that category are absolutely absolving themselves of any responsibility for not having kept talking to their small children, kept their school children in a routine of getting up on time, getting dressed, doing school work, going out for an hour's walk etc. and so many parents talked so much in front of their impressionable children and teens about how everything was so unfair and impossible and all somebody else's fault, that the negative impact has been vastly greater than necessary.

This is a sufficiently idiotic take that the only appropriate response to you telling people they need to do some serious reflection is derisory laughter @PorridgewithQuark.

That's your opinion, and in my opinion it's incorrect.

There's a balance between the angry at the world, nothing can possibly be my responsibility attitude displayed on this thread, and recognising that many, many government level decisions during the pandemic were poor.

It's absolutely clear however that children and teens outcomes were as influenced by their parents' attitudes and response during the pandemic as by public policy. The expectations of schools seem to imply a belief on the part of some posters that teachers live in the stationery cupboard and didn't also have to deal with the pandemic outside school, with their own children to support.

The whole rhetoric of it being up to the vulnerable to shield is deliberately obtuse - the vulnerable doesn't just mean elderly people, but a whole lot of working age people with learning disabilities and severe mental illness.

Grimed · 24/11/2022 08:13

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 08:04

Yes, speaking as someone who also did a lot of lockdown breaking with like minded loved ones, I think it's important those of us who were in a position to do that recognise that there was luck involved there. There are people who didn't have any access to that kind of setup and/or whose neighbours would've grassed.

You are right and I am being cruel. It's just so utterly heartbreaking to hear all these stories. I wish more people would have told Boris to do one.

Teateaandmoretea · 24/11/2022 08:12

How did we wartime children cope? I had disruption in Y2 when we were evacuated; we had to shelter in school during air-raids; time at home after school was bombed, then taught in a church hall with no desks where we knelt on the floor and rested our books on chairs. We survived, grew up, got married, had children, had careers. We are your grandparents.

If you genuinely were in year 2 (not that this existed) in 1940 then you are now around 85. Amazing that you’ve managed to get to the age you have with such a narrow minded view of life.

You survived, grew up and got married. Not sure how you managed to have a career as well unless you are a man, that was very lucky. But the people who didn’t survive as well didn’t survive but I guess you’ve forgotten about them.

This is one of the arguments that makes me most angry if I’m honest and it was at the time. People in the war weren’t stronger or saintly, they bent the rules, carried makeup around in their gas mask boxes, looted, got drunk and fought. She’ll shock was a major problem that killed many in the long term from the horrific experiences.

HeraldicBlazoning · 24/11/2022 08:09

I can relate to this. My youngest child was in the transition year from primary to secondary in 2020, my oldest left school for uni in 2021.

They have missed out on so many events to mark the transition and it's been challenging for them. Things are improving now but my eldest, who was at home all last year sitting in his bedroom watching online lectures was very low and depressed and we were so worried about his mental health. So many more children in their peers groups who are anxious and with eating disorders.

Children were completely thrown under the bus for Covid which was never anything more than a very minor disease for almost all of them. Plus all the stuff on social media about groups of teenagers "flocking" places to play football or just get some social time with their friends.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 08:04

Yes, speaking as someone who also did a lot of lockdown breaking with like minded loved ones, I think it's important those of us who were in a position to do that recognise that there was luck involved there. There are people who didn't have any access to that kind of setup and/or whose neighbours would've grassed.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 24/11/2022 08:03

Good for you @Grimed that you broke lockdown 🤔 I personally don’t care that you did but to suggest everyone should have done that and there were lots of other like minded families nearby who wanted to and that’s why your children are fine is either stupid or disingenuous.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 08:03

My issue is that while vulnerable and disadvantaged families and children were disproportionately disadvantaged, a whole bunch of people who do not fall into that category are absolutely absolving themselves of any responsibility for not having kept talking to their small children, kept their school children in a routine of getting up on time, getting dressed, doing school work, going out for an hour's walk etc. and so many parents talked so much in front of their impressionable children and teens about how everything was so unfair and impossible and all somebody else's fault, that the negative impact has been vastly greater than necessary.

This is a sufficiently idiotic take that the only appropriate response to you telling people they need to do some serious reflection is derisory laughter @PorridgewithQuark.

Grimed · 24/11/2022 08:00

My children are home educated anyway. During lockdown I stopped all formal lesson, we played games, did art and crafts, watched lots of TV and never talked about COVID only to say that we were helping old people stay healthy. When they started getting lonely I started breaking the rules with like minded families. It's not COVID that has damaged the kids it's your response and school system.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 08:00

I felt very sorry for all those headteachers having to come up with new plans with sometimes only a few hours to spare. The governance in this pandemic was shockingly shit.

GuyFawkesDay · 24/11/2022 07:59

I'm noting all the "teachers should" "schools could"

You know, we could only do what we were told to do.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 07:58

Yes, the refusal to reopen schools for the final half term of the 2019-20 school year was batshit. Made no sense at all.

It's so important to acknowledge that even in the context of a restrictions based, multiple lockdowns approach, there are still things that could've been done to mitigate the impact on children that weren't.

GuyFawkesDay · 24/11/2022 07:58

Don't forget the impact on the adults in schools.

We switched to online learning overnight. I learned how to use Google classroom and zoom and worked tirelessly making online lessons. I came into school to cover keyworked and vulnerable students in school. I drove the minibus around delivering school lunch food parcels to vulnerable families.

I also had to home school my own children and deal with the same traumas everyone else did.

Long term there's been no allowance for the fact teachers also worked through the pandemic, nobody clapped for us, in face we got roundly dismissed as being rubbish despite the fact we were given no notice for the many tier changes, lockdowns etc and had to just adapt at the drop of a hat.

We are now dealing with the fallout of kids who are behind socially and academically and yet expected to "catch them up" as if we can make up those years whilst still doing everything else in school "as normal".

And now we have a recruitment and retention crisis in schools. It's a Sisyphean task.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 07:56

@Comedycook I agree. And I have no idea why they didn’t do a staggered schedule. I had a Yr 5 who didn’t go to school from March - Sept (apart from one week).

Rates were low ish from May 2020 onwards until the autum yet the government thought it would be a good idea to keep all the schools/Unis shut and then send everyone back all at the same time in Sept just as we go in to flu season. Genius idea.

They finally woke up that summer was a good time to remove restrictions in 2021.

Mookie81 · 24/11/2022 07:56

interstatelovesong · 23/11/2022 21:35

It completely destroyed my kids well-being and changed them all and not for the better

Mine were 5,10 and 13.

People who demanded lockdowns and school closures - I will never ever forgive you

The level of speech and language referrals I've had to do the last 2 years is ridiculous.
The twats on here clamouring for lockdown after lockdown after lockdown can go to hell as far as I'm concerned.
We should have funded shielding for the vulnerable (if they dont want to that's their business) and that's it.
Society has massively suffered and I don't think it was worth it or warranted.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 07:47

Did a higher proportion of teachers die in Sweden where schools were kept open? (They didn’t)

Nobody can think that it was right that we could all go to the pub but children couldn’t go to school? Seriously. That men could play golf but kids couldn’t go to school. That we could all go to the garden centre but kids couldn’t go to school.
I’d love to see the scientific rationale for all the outdoor sports being banned.

Now my children didn’t seem to badly affected but I’m not so short sighted or lacking in basic human empathy that I don’t understand that everyone’s situation was completely different. And I feel so sad for the thousands and thousands of children that were affected and that’s why I spent hours on here arguing. How anybody can read the stories on here then blame the struggling parents for wanting free childcare. Wow. Shame on you. Says so much about you as a person. And it’s not good.

And those that say ‘well my kids were fine so what’s the problem? Or well we lived in Germany so what are you on about?’

You are making yourselves look very stupid..

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 07:43

There was such a lack of imagination too...why couldn't schools run a staggered service? Maybe kids going in for one morning/afternoon/day a week with a very small group of other kids. There's 30 in a class...so six pupils a day for example? They could have had a catch up...teachers could have monitored how they were getting on. It would have been a useful safeguarding tool and helped kids mental health. But no, nothing. I still don't understand why schools didn't reopen in summer term 2020. It felt very much like, ah well, may as well have the whole year off now.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 07:36

MeetPi · 24/11/2022 00:33

Ah, this again - the elderly that supposedly want to sacrifice themselves for the children. This was trotted out so many times in defence of the worst arguments by those who simply didn't want to do what the Government asked them to do.

And it isn't just elderly people that die of Covid. You know this. Teachers can also become very ill and, yes, die. My 50yo sibling with cancer currently has Covid, is extremely ill and I'm really just waiting for a call. I'm sick of the silly minimising rhetoric here.

Interesting value judgement there about sacrificing themselves, in response to a post that was actually about elderly people who wanted to see their loved ones, ie having their own automomy and feelings that didn't align with yours. My grandad didn't think he was sacrificing himself by wanting to spend what might easily have been the end of his life (he's 91) with his loved ones.

PorridgewithQuark · 24/11/2022 07:31

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 07:21

The people furious about lockdown and bitter that their children didn't qualify for keyworker places because they were able to stay at home need to do some serious reflection

No.

And you evidently have an understanding yourself of exactly why the keyworker policy in the January lockdown was such a clusterfuck, the rest of your post articulates that well, so why pretend that this is about people who were working at home as against those working outside? You surely can't think no wfh parents had DC who were allowed into school? I've a bridge to flog you if so.

I'm a keyworker and had to work with medically and socially vulnerable people, doing massively more than my contacted hours in extremely difficult circumstances and then come home and homeschool (actively teach) my youngest child. My husband was initially in the office (not a keyworker but initially his company didn't allow wfh) then later home on back to back calls.

My issue is that while vulnerable and disadvantaged families and children were disproportionately disadvantaged, a whole bunch of people who do not fall into that category are absolutely absolving themselves of any responsibility for not having kept talking to their small children, kept their school children in a routine of getting up on time, getting dressed, doing school work, going out for an hour's walk etc. and so many parents talked so much in front of their impressionable children and teens about how everything was so unfair and impossible and all somebody else's fault, that the negative impact has been vastly greater than necessary.

Without lockdowns and masks it's entirely probable more of the vulnerable people I was looking after during the pandemic would have died. Lockdown was intensely hard with 14 young adults with learning disabilities in a residential setting and my own teens and pre teen at home, but both groups were influenced by the attitude of the capable adults they looked up to to in their day to day life.

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 24/11/2022 07:29

WindyKnickers · 24/11/2022 00:48

Without dismissing or minimising the very real genuine concerns and lived experiences on here i do think for many children it's pretty hard to attribute these issues solely to lockdowns. Lots of children would have emotional/ behavioural/ academic issues without covid. My DC are yr 3 and yr 7 and they are fine as are most of their friends. The ones who have struggled in my experience have parents who have also struggled and the anxiety or isolation issues have rubbed off on them. Again, this is just my observations of those around me, I understand others have different experiences.

This may be true but doesn't that just show that schools and playgrounds shouldn't have been closed?
And that limiting contact, especially outside, was not a good strategy?
Fine, limit yourself if you wanted to but not as an overall rule.
I remember two women getting fined because they met each other for a walk but had a coffee in their hands.
Just ridiculous.

FiveMins · 24/11/2022 07:24

I think it has also coincided with technology overuse. Mine are teens. I didn't have a mobile until the oldest was 3 (then just a Nokia) and no smart phone until they were 9. Now toddlers have endless access, parents at soft play etc on their phones rather than engaging. Lockdown for some of my kids friends meant unlimited screen use, this continues now. My kids screen use is far higher than it was and we are quite strict. The impact of this means the teens don't want to physically go out but just are attached to an Xbox, the difference between this and my 26 year old DSS is amazing.
We have been lucky with lockdown 1 not being too horrific, and the age of mine meant when they were allowed out they could go on their own with friends and have adventures and before that lots of games and walks, I was only working 25 hours from home so had time to do stuff Lockdown 2 with endless screen school and dark and wet weather was shit and I was back full time.

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 07:23

XelaM · 24/11/2022 06:32

I agree with this. I loved lockdown, as I was working from home instead of having to commute, saved loads of money, could work from Germany where my parents live and my daughter was still able to do her hobby (horse riding) and had structured online lessons (private school). We even had a nice holiday in 2021 in a waterpark in Germany that was open as long as you had a negative Covid test.

Well jolly good for your DD who had Grandparents available to interact with her and presumably she was also interacting with other adults and children at the stables. Wonderful to have a hobby which wasn't cancelled.

Children didn't have GPs on hand, we were actively discouraged from visiting. Or asking them for childcare help. Parents were burning the candle at both ends and in the middle.
Homeschooling while entertaining younger children and trying to work. Children who weren't even allowed to play with the children next-door at one point. 3 year olds saying we aren't allowed to play 'because of the virus'

It doesn't take a genius to realise that children must have suffered from lack of interaction with other people. It was a completely unnatural way for children to live.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 07:21

The people furious about lockdown and bitter that their children didn't qualify for keyworker places because they were able to stay at home need to do some serious reflection

No.

And you evidently have an understanding yourself of exactly why the keyworker policy in the January lockdown was such a clusterfuck, the rest of your post articulates that well, so why pretend that this is about people who were working at home as against those working outside? You surely can't think no wfh parents had DC who were allowed into school? I've a bridge to flog you if so.

Fleabigg · 24/11/2022 07:15

WindyKnickers · 24/11/2022 00:48

Without dismissing or minimising the very real genuine concerns and lived experiences on here i do think for many children it's pretty hard to attribute these issues solely to lockdowns. Lots of children would have emotional/ behavioural/ academic issues without covid. My DC are yr 3 and yr 7 and they are fine as are most of their friends. The ones who have struggled in my experience have parents who have also struggled and the anxiety or isolation issues have rubbed off on them. Again, this is just my observations of those around me, I understand others have different experiences.

So what do you think might have happened in the period since 2020 that’s made the rates of each of those issues you describe skyrocket? Glad your kids are fine. Mine is too. Many are not.

Tiswa · 24/11/2022 07:02

For me one of the biggest impacts was the fact that lockdown happened.
most of us went into 2020 with a certain expectation of what the year would hold. Be it exams/leavers prom/holidays etc all stuff they were looking forward to. And in the blink of an eye it was taken away. That is huge having to understand at a young age that one minute life is going along a certain path the next life is completely changed. You can’t see friends or family for 3 months and then you have to choose which friends you do see in what numbers.

then for months not really being able to look forward to stuff. Yes things opened but you had to pre book and hope that no one you had been in contact with tested positive. We had to cancel a break away over May half term 2021 because DD spent 3 minutes saying hello to a friend in another class who came down with Covid that she hadn’t seen for awhile.

we did friends fest with some friends July 2021 and it was only just before we went we knew we could all go.

then the impact of receiving the email to say the class is shutdown spend 10 days indoors. DS class went down twice and once himself. A whole month spent indoors

and not being able to hug as well my parents are massively involved in my children life. 3 months of once or twice a week visits on the driveway

PiddleOfPuppies · 24/11/2022 07:01

There is so much to write about how lockdowns affected my children, their mental health and their education, but I can't put it into words yet as I'm still too angry. I just remember the constant in-out-in with close contact isolations being just as hard as the actual school closures. Online learning when you're locked in your house for being near someone who might be ill, while the rest of your friends are carrying on as normal is not how to encourage a love of learning in my teenagers.

The posters at the school bus stops telling them not to kill granny and "could you look him in the eye" were pure fear porn. Society considering you as germ vectors will have an effect - children were never blamed for the War, so comparison between lockdown and the blitz is unfair.

I am baffled by the small amount of people on this thread who still, despite being faced with actual evidence of personal experience, say that it was a "good thing" to keep people inside.