Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
1dayatatime · 24/11/2022 09:34

TommyShelby · 24/11/2022 09:24

A friends son went into year7 this past September and the head of year remarked that the children are much ‘younger’ mentally than previous years. She said when you watched them on the yard it’s like they were two years younger - which I suppose, they are really.

We had pretty much exactly the same discussion this week on this same observation.

DangerNoodles · 24/11/2022 09:33

I was thinking this today, the kids at DCs school are so glum compared to children in years gone by. At drop off many of them stand close to thier parents instead of getting a bit of play time in before school.

I think the social isolation, coupled with the amount of screen time children had over lockdown has made them forget how to be kids.

I was not popular with the school when they reopened the school nursery, they begged parents to sign a document saying they weren't going to send thier DCs in unless they are key workers. I refused as I believed going back was in DS's first interests, especially given that he is a summer born and many of the key worker children were autumn borns. I'm so glad I sent him back as he has coped better at starting school than many of his peers.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/11/2022 09:32

What we are seeing is what happens when parents aren't able to outsource all their parenting to the state

I'm not a parent so have been lurking but what a load of horseshit. Parents do not 'outsource all their parenting to the state' - for the majority of parents (those who don't homeschool) having the state educate their children is a legal requirement. The state demands that children attend school - and then in March 2020 the state promptly abnegated that authority with little to no warning and threw parents back on their own devices without any thought as to whether they could manage the job.

Tiswa · 24/11/2022 09:32

And my year 9 missed a whole lot of practical curriculum in Year 7 (and other years) when classes were just in classrooms and labs/art rooms were shut. It just wasn’t the same - various key events through out the year were missed. Some have never got to do a nativity play

1dayatatime · 24/11/2022 09:31

@TempsPerdu

This fits with what I have seen.

Pre Covid you would have those children that were fully resilient and never wobbled from anxiety issues performed well academically etc etc. Then you those children with issues who under performed academically and had a wobble every day. But the majority were somewhere in between with maybe an anxiety wobble once a week or so and whilst not academic star archives were doing OK.

What I now see is more extremes - there are those that seem to have no issues at all and do well with school work and those that do have anxiety issues etc who significantly underperform academic wise but what I do now see is much fewer children in between these two extremes.

Throw in to the mix a cost of living crisis and it's sad to say but most of the children that are struggling are from poorer backgrounds which then creates a really uncomfortable divide.

Tiswa · 24/11/2022 09:30

@TempsPerdu you were lucky that she was young you were a SAHM and avoided any Ill effects. And never clearly had to stay in for 10 days

i stand by though the biggest issue for older children was the uncertainly- no one (not even Chris Whitt/JVT etc) had the answers of knowing how long it was going to last - and the effects of that are huge. And the stop start nature each time a new variant appeared and the calls for lockdown

a year ago Omicron was about to properly hit - so many of us had holiday plans including going abroad that one minute was looking ok with testing and then suddenly all hell broke loose. A good friend was due to visit grandparents in South Africa looking forward to it and the bam it’s on the red list

and the testing processes we made secondary school children go through

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 09:28

I only remember seeing it right at the start, in March 2020 when we didn't know how long it was going to carry on. I think at that stage thinking a month or two of taking the eye off the educational ball wouldn't be the worst thing was an understandable view. (Mine weren't school aged.)

Yes, especially as the curriculum had been suspended at that time. It's not like anyone consented in advance to schools are shutting for most of the next year for the majority of them, and I doubt most people made plans on that basis.

The real inequality in respect of schools kicked in during the 2021 lockdown. Although at least in England we did have nurseries open that time, which was something.

rhowton · 24/11/2022 09:28

I feel like we got off quite lightly.

Both my children were off school from end of March, April and May, but were back at nursery from June. They havent had an overly interrupted education and we refused to test our DD, so they went in to nursery regardless.

We moved in with my parents (my parents accepted added risk) during lockdown and I was luckily on maternity leave. We were the annoying people taking our children to every shop to socialise them, and were the first in the restaurants when they opened, and the last to leave when they closed. We saw friends throughout both lockdowns and accepted the ability to interact with other children and adults outweighed the risk of Covid.

Looking back now, I am so grateful we ignored lockdown measures. I will be forever thankful for that.

TommyShelby · 24/11/2022 09:24

A friends son went into year7 this past September and the head of year remarked that the children are much ‘younger’ mentally than previous years. She said when you watched them on the yard it’s like they were two years younger - which I suppose, they are really.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 09:23

PorridgewithQuark · 24/11/2022 08:44

Oh the irony of you calling my post arrogant! Yours mixes arrogance and acerbity with wooly accusations to too great an extent to be worth unpicking. We'll agree to differ.

Parenting and parental attitudes did play a role. Some families genuinely couldn't cope, others who could publicly declared their intention not to even try to homeschool or keep their kids in a school day routine all over social media and internet forums, and are now claiming that it's not their fault their children fell behind.

The specific reason you're so hilariously, lane ignoringly arrogant is because you felt yourself qualified to tell other people they need to look at their behaviour. I haven't done that, as such your no I'm not you are response, predictable as it was, falls flat.

Meanwhile, I note with interest that you've not told us how the existence of this group, if we assume for a moment that they do, is in any way related to your high and mighty order that parents who are angry about their DC being on the wrong side of the January 2021 school entitlement rules need to have a look at themselves. Because there's no nexus between the two, that's clear, but I'm going to make very sure it's spelled out for those reading.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 09:22

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:21

"Why is DD so far ahead? Not because she’s innately superior in any way, but because of my professional background"

I would say the biggest factor was that you were a SAHM. Lots of us knew what our kids needed (even without a child development masters), but being able to always do what was best for them - all the time - was sometimes limited.

Well exactly.

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:21

TempsPerdu · 24/11/2022 09:17

The many personal accounts on this thread are heartbreaking to read. Children’s social and developmental needs really were all but forgotten during the pandemic.

DD has recently started Reception. When we visited her school last week for a casual drop-in visit her class teacher described her as ‘extraordinary’, and the most well-adjusted, school ready child she has taught in the past two years. In my personal opinion, DD, while lovely and certainly above average ability wise, is by no means extraordinary. In a ‘normal’ school year there would be a big group of similarly mature, able, well prepared children - but by the admission of the school, this year and last these children are largely missing.

So many of DD’s peers have significant issues: undiagnosed special needs, having missed out on professional scrutiny and early intervention during lockdown; social anxiety and other emotional issues; speech delay; general immaturity (my daughter comes across as a good couple of years older than most of her peers).

As a former primary teacher, I recognised immediately that there were an unusual amount of challenges among this year’s cohort. I’m also a governor at the school, and this was confirmed at our most recent meeting - this year and last, the Early Years teachers are mainly fire-fighting and trying to unravel some of the damage that has been done by lockdowns, widespread professional abandonment of children and the lack of crucial early social connections. Now compounded my the lack of funding to support them, and an almost total lack of recognition by government that these problems even exist.

Why is DD so far ahead? Not because she’s innately superior in any way, but because of my professional background (I also have a Master’s in a subject allied to child development). I recognised exactly what the impact of covid measures on young people would be and was able to mitigate some of the damage. I’m currently a SAHM, so was able to bake with her, craft with her and provide her with the stimulation she needed. As a family we pushed the ‘guidelines’ to the absolute limit - I still took DD to shops and on public transport, ignoring the glares and muttered comments about ‘superspreaders’ that I got from many members of the public. We met up outside (and, by the final lockdown, inside) with a couple of like-minded families so DD could have social contact. We saw both sets of grandparents after the first month or so of lockdown. We were fairly relaxed about the virus from the outset, especially once the minimal threat to young children became clear, and have thankfully avoided passing on any hang-ups about germs and cleanliness (I’m aware of at least two of DD’s friends who are now terrified of medical procedures due to frequent traumatic PCR tests, or now have issues around frequent compulsive hand-washing).

The ‘resilience’ line, trotted out so frequently during lockdown, was a total lie, used to assuage the guilt of those clamouring for ever tighter restrictions on children’s lives, and we are now dealing with the fallout. I am only grateful that the U.K. avoided a few of the worst excesses (masks on toddlers, as per the U.S. and others) and that DD appears to have escaped largely unscathed.

"Why is DD so far ahead? Not because she’s innately superior in any way, but because of my professional background"

I would say the biggest factor was that you were a SAHM. Lots of us knew what our kids needed (even without a child development masters), but being able to always do what was best for them - all the time - was sometimes limited.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 09:19

@PorridgewithQuark

So just to be clear. You are saying if every parent did a good job of home schooling then this would have mitigated all the effects of lockdowns that we are seeing in children and teenagers? Wow. I’m not sure you can even homeschool a teenager.

What about those trying to hold down a full time job? Is it their fault they couldn’t spend a full school day teaching their kid?

What about those children who hated being homeschooled?

Your view is mind dumbingly simplistic and very insulting to parents with children who really struggled and still are from the effects of lockdowns.

What about those reception age children who arrived at school with little social skills? Were the parents supposed to magic up socialising for young children too?

It’s far more complex than you are suggesting. You’re implying every child is the same. Which we know would be a ridiculous thing to suggest….

TempsPerdu · 24/11/2022 09:17

The many personal accounts on this thread are heartbreaking to read. Children’s social and developmental needs really were all but forgotten during the pandemic.

DD has recently started Reception. When we visited her school last week for a casual drop-in visit her class teacher described her as ‘extraordinary’, and the most well-adjusted, school ready child she has taught in the past two years. In my personal opinion, DD, while lovely and certainly above average ability wise, is by no means extraordinary. In a ‘normal’ school year there would be a big group of similarly mature, able, well prepared children - but by the admission of the school, this year and last these children are largely missing.

So many of DD’s peers have significant issues: undiagnosed special needs, having missed out on professional scrutiny and early intervention during lockdown; social anxiety and other emotional issues; speech delay; general immaturity (my daughter comes across as a good couple of years older than most of her peers).

As a former primary teacher, I recognised immediately that there were an unusual amount of challenges among this year’s cohort. I’m also a governor at the school, and this was confirmed at our most recent meeting - this year and last, the Early Years teachers are mainly fire-fighting and trying to unravel some of the damage that has been done by lockdowns, widespread professional abandonment of children and the lack of crucial early social connections. Now compounded my the lack of funding to support them, and an almost total lack of recognition by government that these problems even exist.

Why is DD so far ahead? Not because she’s innately superior in any way, but because of my professional background (I also have a Master’s in a subject allied to child development). I recognised exactly what the impact of covid measures on young people would be and was able to mitigate some of the damage. I’m currently a SAHM, so was able to bake with her, craft with her and provide her with the stimulation she needed. As a family we pushed the ‘guidelines’ to the absolute limit - I still took DD to shops and on public transport, ignoring the glares and muttered comments about ‘superspreaders’ that I got from many members of the public. We met up outside (and, by the final lockdown, inside) with a couple of like-minded families so DD could have social contact. We saw both sets of grandparents after the first month or so of lockdown. We were fairly relaxed about the virus from the outset, especially once the minimal threat to young children became clear, and have thankfully avoided passing on any hang-ups about germs and cleanliness (I’m aware of at least two of DD’s friends who are now terrified of medical procedures due to frequent traumatic PCR tests, or now have issues around frequent compulsive hand-washing).

The ‘resilience’ line, trotted out so frequently during lockdown, was a total lie, used to assuage the guilt of those clamouring for ever tighter restrictions on children’s lives, and we are now dealing with the fallout. I am only grateful that the U.K. avoided a few of the worst excesses (masks on toddlers, as per the U.S. and others) and that DD appears to have escaped largely unscathed.

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 09:17

Grimed · 24/11/2022 08:00

My children are home educated anyway. During lockdown I stopped all formal lesson, we played games, did art and crafts, watched lots of TV and never talked about COVID only to say that we were helping old people stay healthy. When they started getting lonely I started breaking the rules with like minded families. It's not COVID that has damaged the kids it's your response and school system.

Wow. What a very smug post from a fellow home educator.
It was shit for many families and children for all manner of reasons that have nothing to do with how an individual family handled it, nor the school system. It just was shit.

It sounds like your children were young enough to enjoy those things, that's lovely for you and them.

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:15

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 09:10

Exactly as what I said 3 into 1 doesn't go!

Yes, sorry I was agreeing with you on that part.

I disagree that it's not ok to say "home schooling isn't my job" in those circumstances though. We all have responsibilities to our children in tough time, which takes into account education of course. But home schooling wasn't my job. My job was my job, and my role as a parent was keeping my children happy and lookin g after their wellbeing (and mine, given they were stuck in a house with me) and, only if it didn't compromise their happiness, my sanity and our financial stability, was home schooling anywhere near what I would describe as "my job".

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 09:14

@AntlerRose if I thought it would make a difference I would. Unfortunately today of all days first teachers strike since the 80s I just wish they'd pay the teachers a decent wage and get them back to work.

AntlerRose · 24/11/2022 09:12

Can everyone feeling stressed and angry about this write to their MP about school funding and cahms funding.

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 09:10

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:04

Home schooling wasn't my job. My actual job - that paid for our house and food - was my job. Except i was doing a really piss poor job of it as DH was going off to work (in an office) and I was left to (1) do my job (2) look after a 2 yr (3) home school (4) try get food! Our school was awful in their support too in the first lock down - a weekly package of sheets to do in the post, that was is. No calls, no zoom, no support, no guidance. Once in a while we would get an email with the additional "suggested" work we could do.

I was, literally, the closest I have ever been to a breakdown. I was not ok for ages afterwards. The home schooling (and the guilt associated with not doing it, because something's got to give and I prioritised our well being over shitty work sheets) was a huge factor in that.

Exactly as what I said 3 into 1 doesn't go!

1dayatatime · 24/11/2022 09:09

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:00

This whole thread makes me angry. All the rhetoric at the time, "kids are resillient", the go out and you kill your granny advert, the whole thing. There's an entire generation of kids who will have real long term consequences as a result of this, but because "kids will be fine" (like they were in the war, apparently) noone can raise it without apparently wishing lots of people died of covid instead. Same on the MH thread. People dying of covid is not the only negative consequence of this pandemic.

Actually excess deaths now (from missed cancer diagnosis etc ) are higher than during the Covid period:

www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-are-excess-deaths-higher-now-than-during-covid/

EdgeOfACoin · 24/11/2022 09:06

Oh you silly mummies.

All you had to do was buy your child a horse and take them to stay with relatives in Germany and everyone would have been fine! What is the fuss about?

🙄

JenniferBarkley · 24/11/2022 09:05

bookworm14 · 24/11/2022 09:01

Has everyone forgotten how many very privileged, comfortable parents declared from day one, before they'd even tried, that homeschooling wasn't their job and they weren't going to do it or make their children do it?

I don’t remember anyone on MN saying this. I do remember multiple posts from people desperately worried that they couldn’t properly supervise their kids’ online learning because they themselves had to work full-time, or people watching their kids become less and less engaged with the work despite their own best efforts.

I only remember seeing it right at the start, in March 2020 when we didn't know how long it was going to carry on. I think at that stage thinking a month or two of taking the eye off the educational ball wouldn't be the worst thing was an understandable view. (Mine weren't school aged.)

I didn't hear it at all once the grind truly set in. I saw parents on their knees struggling to cope with all of their demands, only to be told they were terrible parents on one thread and terrible employees on the next.

I have enormous sympathy for parents of school aged children and know many who have been fundamentally changed by the experience.

1dayatatime · 24/11/2022 09:05

@GuyFawkesDay

"We are now dealing with the fallout of kids who are behind socially and academically and yet expected to "catch them up" as if we can make up those years whilst still doing everything else in school "as normal".

+++

And all without the necessary funding because as Liz Truss found out that there simply isn't any money left after £450 billion was spent on Covid measures.

I remember that at the time extra funding for education was promised and thinking it will never happen and once again non voting children and young people have been thrown under a bus in favour of the interests of the voting older generations.

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:04

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 08:59

I don't know any parents who said Home school wasn't their job.
But I know 3 into 1 doesn't go.
Trying to concentrate on your job
Looking after preschoolers
And teaching school children
All at the same time doesn't work.

Could you imagine before lockdown taking a preschooler to work with you. He'll be fine in the corner with crayons. You'd have been shown the door.

Home schooling wasn't my job. My actual job - that paid for our house and food - was my job. Except i was doing a really piss poor job of it as DH was going off to work (in an office) and I was left to (1) do my job (2) look after a 2 yr (3) home school (4) try get food! Our school was awful in their support too in the first lock down - a weekly package of sheets to do in the post, that was is. No calls, no zoom, no support, no guidance. Once in a while we would get an email with the additional "suggested" work we could do.

I was, literally, the closest I have ever been to a breakdown. I was not ok for ages afterwards. The home schooling (and the guilt associated with not doing it, because something's got to give and I prioritised our well being over shitty work sheets) was a huge factor in that.

bookworm14 · 24/11/2022 09:01

Has everyone forgotten how many very privileged, comfortable parents declared from day one, before they'd even tried, that homeschooling wasn't their job and they weren't going to do it or make their children do it?

I don’t remember anyone on MN saying this. I do remember multiple posts from people desperately worried that they couldn’t properly supervise their kids’ online learning because they themselves had to work full-time, or people watching their kids become less and less engaged with the work despite their own best efforts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread