Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
kegofcoffee · 24/11/2022 10:06

Comedycook · 23/11/2022 21:23

I adored being a mum before

Lockdown also made me dislike being a mum. I was fine before but the combination of dh WFH and the schools being closed made me so depressed. I genuinely found it unbearable never ever being alone. All I wanted was to be left alone. I still feel like that. Dh is still WFH and I absolutely dread school holidays as it is a horrible reminder of that time

100% this.

The nowhere to go.
The lack of socialising for my baby.
The having to keep pre-school children quiet so my DH could work.
Not being able to access support for my high-needs baby.

It destroyed me. I'd go to bed wishing I wouldnt wake up in the morning.

It was shit, and I think my ongoing MH caused by the pandemic has had as much of an impact on my children as the lockdowns themselves

Luckycatt · 24/11/2022 10:03

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 09:59

My year 11 is doing well at school but never goes out to socialise. At his age, I lived for going places with my friends, I was hardly home. He goes to school, the gym and then home. Doesn't go anywhere at weekends. I think his friends are the same

My Ds is in year 10 now. He's exactly the same. School, gym and football training with his club. Those are the only places he goes. He has never hung round a shopping centre with his mates. They don't go to the cinema or McDonald's. They don't go to teenage parties. He is very popular but they are all like that. It's very odd. I've offered to take him places, said he can have his mates round but no. It's sad.

This is my experience too, with my Y9 child. I've started threads on here about ideas for activities to do with him and was told by quite a few that he was too old for his mum to be organising his social life - well he doesn't know how to because he's been in lockdown since primary!!

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 10:02

That should say in court... Bloody autocorrect

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 10:01

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/11/2022 09:44

This is simply factually incorrect. The state does not demand that children attend school. It requires they receive an education, how this is delivered is left up to parents

Really? so why fines for non-attendance, then? serious question, like I said, I'm not a parent.

Once children are enrolled in a school, the or otherwise part of the law seems to not count any more and there are separate statutes that come into place for attendance. They are quite vague but have been tested in first and seem to mean whatever the la deems it to be, NOT the parent.

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 10:01

I find it so strange that for nearly a year we were locked in our homes (at times couldn’t even sit on a bench in the park without apparently breaking the law) and it like, has been mostly forgotten about?

It's insane. My sister was stopped and questioned by police because she was walking through a park with her toddler. It's fucking unbelievable looking back

Luckycatt · 24/11/2022 10:00

I'm interested Y8 is mentioned. While they had a hard time leaving primary during the pandemic, current Y9 had a far more difficult transition with starting secondary and often being confined to bubbles and classrooms.

I have a y9 child, who missed out on any transition. He spent the first year of secondary in a class bubble, sat in one classroom all day long in a school he didn't know. At the start of year 8, this cohort didn't know anything about the school yet we're treated like 'normal' year 8s. I understand from old colleagues that some schools did offer transitions out of lockdown, but my son's did not and he really suffered for it. It's only this year in year 9 he's begun to understand the systems and routines in school, and find out where everything is.

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 09:59

My year 11 is doing well at school but never goes out to socialise. At his age, I lived for going places with my friends, I was hardly home. He goes to school, the gym and then home. Doesn't go anywhere at weekends. I think his friends are the same

My Ds is in year 10 now. He's exactly the same. School, gym and football training with his club. Those are the only places he goes. He has never hung round a shopping centre with his mates. They don't go to the cinema or McDonald's. They don't go to teenage parties. He is very popular but they are all like that. It's very odd. I've offered to take him places, said he can have his mates round but no. It's sad.

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 09:56

Alaldlccmemsjzja · 24/11/2022 09:45

I find it so strange that for nearly a year we were locked in our homes (at times couldn’t even sit on a bench in the park without apparently breaking the law) and it like, has been mostly forgotten about?
we couldn’t leave the house more than once a day

what the hell was that?

It was never a law in England that we couldn't leave the house more than once per day and there was never a time limit. These were made up rules that politicians spoke about, that were then repeated on TV and the press and everyone believed to be true.

This, for me was one of the upsetting things, that people accepted an even more draconion set of rules than obliged to Including police forces in some areas. It was horrifying that they were in charge of upholding a law they hadn't bothered to acquaint themselves with.

When Boris Johnson first announced that we could meet one other person for exercise, I thought how strange they've made such a fanfare of it. There was always provision for that in the original covid legislation and actually the for exercise was again Boris's spin, it wasn't the wording.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 24/11/2022 09:56

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 08:23

Yes, but given what you've already come out with, your opinions simply aren't of sufficient value to deserve anything other than laughter at your arrogance when you lecture other people about having a look at themselves.

Addressing the substance of what you write here, it is not 'absolutely clear'. It's a thing you have claimed. Let's take your argument at very highest and assume for the sake of convenience that it's correct: these parents were existing in the context of a governmental lockdown policy that had deliberate stoking of fear in the population right at the core and that treated societal networks as something that can be turned on and off. If you're going to pursue a blame game, that needs to be addressed.

You've also failed to explain why exactly the group you were demonising in your last post are so determinative that they amount to a reason why people critical of school keyworker place policies need to take them into account. Which is because it's tenuous bollocks, obviously, but worth spelling that out.

👏

thebellagio · 24/11/2022 09:54

Our HT has said that year 3 (my child) have been hit hardest. They had only done 1.5terms of reception before being booted out in March 2020, then missed half of year 1 as well, so the foundations that should have been in place have been completely missed. They've had to work even harder in year 2 and now in year 3 to catch up, but because those essential building blocks were missed, it's like playing a game of snakes and ladders - for every 2 steps forward, its a giant step back.

My child had speech therapy over zoom (which didn't fucking work) and she also had hearing issues, so she was already starting from a place far behind. She's a year behind where she should be in core subjects like maths and English. It now turns out that she has dyslexia and there is a HUGE link between kids needing speech therapy and dyslexia.

I paid for her to have a private screening test to confirm the dyslexia. It's genuinely terrifying to see that the projections are that younger children needing SLT has increased by 10% because these kids have spent their entire lives surrounded by masks/lockdowns and haven't been able to develop their language skills. There's absolutely no wiggle room in the education system for schools to have extra funding to support the growing numbers of children who will be statistically likely to have dyslexia, so this impact will be felt for an entire generation.

I've actually written to my lazy MP about it. Didn't even get a response.

Hills2022 · 24/11/2022 09:53

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/11/2022 09:44

This is simply factually incorrect. The state does not demand that children attend school. It requires they receive an education, how this is delivered is left up to parents

Really? so why fines for non-attendance, then? serious question, like I said, I'm not a parent.

Because once you sign up to school you have effectively delegated that responsibility to the school and there are rules around that, however any parent at any time including during covid can withdraw their child from school and elect to educate them themselves.

Luckycatt · 24/11/2022 09:51

I also look at children around me, anyone who was on the cusp of a change has struggled.

Absolutely. I currently (last decade) work in primary sector and there are issues with kids just starting reception this year (toddlers in lockdown), year 2 (first years of school in lockdown) right up to my own children who are secondary. My eldest missed the primary to secondary transition. The impact has been profound across the board, but in different ways. Every child 'lost' a stage.

hennybeans · 24/11/2022 09:51

My three are currently in years 11,9, and 5. Reading this thread, I think they definitely didn't have it as bad as so many but I can still see lasting effects.

My year 11 is doing well at school but never goes out to socialise. At his age, I lived for going places with my friends, I was hardly home. He goes to school, the gym and then home. Doesn't go anywhere at weekends. I think his friends are the same.

My current year 9 dd had it the worst of my DC, missing all the year 6 milestones and just dropped into high school. This is her third year of high school and she's had a different form every year. She makes friends then in the next school year she is put into a different form/ classes and never sees the old friends again as it's a big school. She's had three groups of friends already in high school. And I don't think she's really found true friends yet. She's not really bothered about seeing friends outside of school either. She spends too much time alone her room- a habit which started during covid.

Another thing that really took a toll on my DC is that even when they went back to school, they were constantly sent home for two weeks isolation due to exposure. Dd had 7 bouts of isolation in year 7. She still has never had covid.

Lastly, my youngest now in year 5. The hardest for him was when key worker kids were allowed back to school and he wasn't. 15/22 children from his class were in school. It was gut wrenching watching him counting down everyday until it was time for his 20 minutes zoom call with his class which he looked forward to so much. But it was so short and seeing all his friends at school together while he was home was really hard for him. I never knew if I should stop the zoom calls because it would have been easier for him mentally to not think about his friends together without him. His friendships suffered and he is often in the periphery of groups in class. He hasn't got any strong friendships now.

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 09:51

TempsPerdu · 24/11/2022 09:43

I would say the biggest factor was that you were a SAHM. Lots of us knew what our kids needed (even without a child development masters), but being able to always do what was best for them - all the time - was sometimes limited

@EndlessRain I get that. I recognise that I was in an unusually privilege position, and I feel angry on behalf of all those who understood this but were powerless to do anything about it. I was on here debating about lockdowns at the time and saw a lot of the abuse that was hurled at anyone daring to question the treatment of children - I came in for my fair share.

But I don’t agree that the majority of parents were alert to the damage that was being done; the majority of our circle, including some other SAHPs and many who were furloughed, absolutely bought into the ‘resilience’ rubbish, kept every guideline to the letter (or even went beyond in some cases, putting their DC in masks; avoiding public spaces even beyond lockdown etc), had their preschoolers using screens all day because they believed this was fine etc. So many believed their children would just ‘catch up’ later, and are now expressing surprise that they now have issues around various things. It was useful just to know, for instance, that there are relatively brief developmental windows for specific skills that once missed are difficult to make up, so we were able to make the most of the opportunities we did have to socialise DD.

Of course, the main target of any anger must be the government and decision makers who formulated the guidelines, but I do think that that there is a general lack of general awareness around ‘how children and young people tick’ that they were able to exploit - hence all the rubbish around resilience/adaptability/bouncing back that so many bought into unquestioningly.

Well I had my preschooler on screens all day sometimes because I was working. Did I think it was fine? No, of course not. I don't need a masters in child development to tell me that. I doubt your "friends" thought that it was perfectly ok either, but for whatever reason they did what they needed to cope.

"So many believed their children would just ‘catch up’ later,"

Yeah and why wouldn't they? That's, literally, what we were being told. That there would be lots of investment into schools to allow kids to catch up. I don't think you can blame people for (1) following the rules and (2) taking expert guindance as fact. People were not allowed to socialise. How do you expect they were to take advantage of that short socialisation window? Lots of people were desperate for social contact (for many reasons other than child development), but couldnt' and didn't have it because those were the rules.

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 09:50

There was such a lack of imagination too

I thought this was a real opportunity for thinking outside the box. I imagined I'd see schools adopt a more forest school scenario. I expected them to be able to borrow marquees and shelters. Of course that costs money - which I don't think was forthcoming. Instead we had bubbles and kids never knowing if they'd be in school or not the next day.

In general, I also expected to see more outdoor dining, but with the tier system, cafes couldn't risk spending money on those sort of resources in case they were told they had to shut down yet again.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 09:48

MeetPi · 24/11/2022 09:42

@SirMingeALot

Interesting value judgement there about sacrificing themselves, in response to a post that was actually about elderly people who wanted to see their loved ones, ie having their own automomy and feelings that didn't align with yours. My grandad didn't think he was sacrificing himself by wanting to spend what might easily have been the end of his life (he's 91) with his loved ones.

I was referring to sentiments often mentioned on Covid threads regarding the shielding of the elderly (or not). When people in their mid sixties started being referred to that's when I decided it was perhaps getting a bit out of control.

Thanks also for your kind thoughts on my relative, or lack thereof.

Yes, it was clear what you were referring to. You decided to leave out those elderly people whose own autonomy and views of their interests didn't align with yours, which is the problem. I wouldn't call someone in their 60s elderly myself, but people in that cohort had their own views on what constituted their interests and what amounted to sacrifices too and you don't get to decide what was a sacrifice for them and what wasn't. The whole point is that people had their own views on that.

Thank you also for your kind thoughts on my relative, or lack thereof.

TempsPerdu · 24/11/2022 09:47

And never clearly had to stay in for 10 days

@Tiswa We did - we just didn’t do it. We took DD to a remote country park at a time when we knew it would be quiet and let her run around. No way was I keeping a two-year-old cooped up entirely for ten days.

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 09:47

My Ds for the first time in his life actually started getting a bit chubby...he was year 7 in the first lockdown. Walking to school, PE lessons and playing football three times a week kept him fit. He had never been overweight. During lockdown we did our daily walk and I played table tennis with him at home but it was no substitute for the organised sports he had previously enjoyed. We were also spending lots of time baking and cooking as there wasn't so much to do.. Now life is back to normal, he's a healthy weight again.

Alaldlccmemsjzja · 24/11/2022 09:45

I find it so strange that for nearly a year we were locked in our homes (at times couldn’t even sit on a bench in the park without apparently breaking the law) and it like, has been mostly forgotten about?
we couldn’t leave the house more than once a day

what the hell was that?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/11/2022 09:44

This is simply factually incorrect. The state does not demand that children attend school. It requires they receive an education, how this is delivered is left up to parents

Really? so why fines for non-attendance, then? serious question, like I said, I'm not a parent.

TempsPerdu · 24/11/2022 09:43

I would say the biggest factor was that you were a SAHM. Lots of us knew what our kids needed (even without a child development masters), but being able to always do what was best for them - all the time - was sometimes limited

@EndlessRain I get that. I recognise that I was in an unusually privilege position, and I feel angry on behalf of all those who understood this but were powerless to do anything about it. I was on here debating about lockdowns at the time and saw a lot of the abuse that was hurled at anyone daring to question the treatment of children - I came in for my fair share.

But I don’t agree that the majority of parents were alert to the damage that was being done; the majority of our circle, including some other SAHPs and many who were furloughed, absolutely bought into the ‘resilience’ rubbish, kept every guideline to the letter (or even went beyond in some cases, putting their DC in masks; avoiding public spaces even beyond lockdown etc), had their preschoolers using screens all day because they believed this was fine etc. So many believed their children would just ‘catch up’ later, and are now expressing surprise that they now have issues around various things. It was useful just to know, for instance, that there are relatively brief developmental windows for specific skills that once missed are difficult to make up, so we were able to make the most of the opportunities we did have to socialise DD.

Of course, the main target of any anger must be the government and decision makers who formulated the guidelines, but I do think that that there is a general lack of general awareness around ‘how children and young people tick’ that they were able to exploit - hence all the rubbish around resilience/adaptability/bouncing back that so many bought into unquestioningly.

MeetPi · 24/11/2022 09:42

@SirMingeALot

Interesting value judgement there about sacrificing themselves, in response to a post that was actually about elderly people who wanted to see their loved ones, ie having their own automomy and feelings that didn't align with yours. My grandad didn't think he was sacrificing himself by wanting to spend what might easily have been the end of his life (he's 91) with his loved ones.

I was referring to sentiments often mentioned on Covid threads regarding the shielding of the elderly (or not). When people in their mid sixties started being referred to that's when I decided it was perhaps getting a bit out of control.

Thanks also for your kind thoughts on my relative, or lack thereof.

Hills2022 · 24/11/2022 09:39

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/11/2022 09:32

What we are seeing is what happens when parents aren't able to outsource all their parenting to the state

I'm not a parent so have been lurking but what a load of horseshit. Parents do not 'outsource all their parenting to the state' - for the majority of parents (those who don't homeschool) having the state educate their children is a legal requirement. The state demands that children attend school - and then in March 2020 the state promptly abnegated that authority with little to no warning and threw parents back on their own devices without any thought as to whether they could manage the job.

This is simply factually incorrect. The state does not demand that children attend school. It requires they receive an education, how this is delivered is left up to parents.

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 09:38

One of my kids was GCSE year. He had constant migraines from the time his place of learning shut down and felt like every piece of homework was going towards his final grade. So much pressure. He had friends who became suicidal and trauma from only being able to support them online and not knowing if they would be there the next morning. He's doing ok now but it was rocky.

My middle one was of an age where he was starting to want to and be able to do things with friends independently. Suddenly having our vibrant, active, sociable home ed routine shut down at this time was hideous. He went into lockdowns just going into his teens and came out having missed all that time of forming independence. He's now dealing with the aftermath and trying to do GCSEs. We've had a horrid couple of years of worry about him and that is ongoing.

My youngest was more unscathed but we had some like minded families who would meet up as soon as the govt remembered not all children go to school. The law provided that they could meet up for educational activities, but woe betide we got them together because they needed to socialise. We're a creative lot and managed it in people's homes, which was tricky because we also had lost teenagers who'd become noise sensitive and other adults trying to work from home. According to guidance, we were supposed to have risk assessments and all sorts in place, which we adhered to in case of neighbours reporting us. The optics of groups of home educating mothers and children in parks when everyone else could meet in 2's or sixes would have been terrible, so it has to be indoors and increase the likelihood of spreading the thing... Worrying still we knew from early on that the police had not aquatinted themselves with the law and people were doing what the TV told them, rather than checking what the actual law was.
For the other judge home educator - for various reasons we had to weigh up the detriment to our children of being approached by the police vs them legally being able to see each other.

RedToothBrush · 24/11/2022 09:36

@PorridgewithQuark we will do our best and hopefully we will get there. DS is a chilled out and smart kid. He is emotionally mature in some ways though immature in others. He has always been very matter of fact about covid rather than anxious about it. And he has always been pretty sociable and thats not changed.

Its frustrating that we've spent this term firefighting DS's behaviour to a large degree though. He's been copying the poor behaviour of other kids (to the point that we can identify which kids he's copying!) and we've had to make sure he knows it's absolutely not OK. This is normal to a degree for his age but the behaviours are more extreme. We are finding we have to be on him constantly over it and have masses of sympathy with the teacher. She's been brilliant but she's definitely been thrown in the deep end with this lot.

I think this element of poor behaviour having secondary effects on others further down the line is being massively overlooked because its easier to understand the covid effect and the direct impact.

To use an example: Last week DS came home saying that they were doing a catch up test in class and the out of control kid kicked off for over 30 mins shouting and screaming about how he wasn't going to do it and how he would deliberately get all the questions wrong. And he started being aggressive and violent to the staff. It's managable to a degree at this point as this kid is 7 and small. But these type of incidents are happening on a regular basis and there is no sign of it being under control. I just don't know what will happen - we and another parent are very fearful that there will be a major incident at some point as this kid has attacked our kids already. I just don't see how he makes it to the end of year 6. The other kid who this child has attacked was also reasonably well adjusted and doing fine post lockdown but is now starting to school refuse because this aggressive child dominates the class so much and creates stress on top of actually hurting other kids.

This year is proving hard work. For us having an only child actually works to his favour at this point as we don't have multiple kids we are helping to cope with the aftermath of covid. We can just focus on parenting him and gently explaining that certain children aren't that nice and hanging out with them might not be a good idea.

Of course similar situation with a different child or at a different age could go a totally different way. The peer pressure particularly at high school to not behave must be a factor in this too.

I personally think that the government did the right thing with lockdowns to a point. If it had come out that the death rate in kids was high, this would be a totally different conversation. We didn't know that for some time and we didn't know what would happen with a second wave (as traditionally second waves have been more deadly in pandemics). Plus the government were having to tackle the very noisy teachers unions who were pitching a fit.

There was a tipping point where it was clear that it was having an impact though. The justifications on schools definitely became a lot weaker as vaccines became available and the data showed kids were mostly fine with covid.

I remember that even some of the prudent and sensible people who were looking at the data got a load of shit particularly from teachers and the long covid mob. One poster I had a lot of time for got driven off mn by it.

The issue was there was no mood for change in attitude and a revised thinking mid way through things. You almost had to be pro massively lockdown or hardcore open everything up. Neither of which was sensible tbh. There was a more moderate approach and its hard to remember some of these voices and the pressures the government was trying to balance.

Unfortunately I do think if the teachers had been pushed more to return sooner, there would have been legal challenges and strikes over it (which would have had an impact on key services at a crucial moment too).

What hasn't happened has been a real materialisation and on going conversation in political circles about the impact on schools. Its not being prioritised and its not getting the attention it deserves. Because we've been almost overrun with the next crisis. Which has only served to compound issues in school.

I worry for my son's education as a result. I don't know that there is a better alternative out there - including if we go private. The problem is so engrained across society because the system has been overwhelmed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread