Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Crunchymum · 24/11/2022 13:11

I've not read the full thread but what I have read has raised some interesting points actually.

I have a year 3 child (as well as a year 5 and a reception aged child) and I've been saying for ages that I think she was the one most disadvantaged by the whole Covid shitshow. She lost so much invaluable time at school. It's all very subtle and thankfully she isn't struggling like some but it's there and part of who she is now which is sad. She isn't educationally "behind" as such and her emotional regulation isn't a cause for concern but there is just something in her demeanour? Something in her personality that comes from the dark covid days.

I could cry when I recall the God awful times of having the work from home (still do) whilst managing x2 out of 3 children's home learning and managing a disabled toddler my DP worked out of the house I am pretty sure I did more harm than good.

What absolutely makes my blood boil is thinking about how my dad was told he'd have to wear a mask at my mum's funeral. It wasn't enough that we couldn't have a proper funeral or any kind of commemorative event after her small cremation. It wasn't enough that the rules of the time prohibited us all being together as a family but to tell a man in shell shock after watching his wife drop dead, and he failed to resuscitate her despite trying for 20 minutes, that he had to wear a mask just tops it for me.

We all suffered, we all endured and we are all scarred.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 24/11/2022 13:00

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 10:31

Well, I wouldn't be too happy if my so called friends suggested I was either entirely ignorant( or maybe just lazy) and let my kid sit on screens all day just for the sake of it. Maybe your friends are different.

Nice you had all those opportunities. Nice you had family nearby to share the load. Nice you had the spare time and money to take your DD on adventures. Nice you could bake and craft and had access to what you needed for that. Surely you can see though that not everyone would have had the same, and many people will have followed the rules/ law that you made the decision to flout.

It just comes across a bit smug to say "the reason my DD did so amazingly well vs everyone else is because I am so clever" when actually it probably mostly had to do with your circumstances (and, dare I say it, your privilege).

I agree with this and would add statistically these children achieved just as poor academic progress as the posters accusing WFH parents of not engaging with their child.

The data shows children REGRESSED on reading, writing and maths for primary so at best some children were treading water. This is why the government has had to spend so much on catch up in schools.

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 13:00

Of course the consequences of lockdown need to be analysed. Good and bad. We need to learn from our handling of the pandemic on a global level.

I understand that it's a bitter pill to swallow. We all made so many sacrifices, and for it even to be suggested that those sacrifices were in vain (in whole or in part) is really hard to hear. We, understandably, need to feel that it was all "worth it", that all that happened saved lives, or something.

But we cannot let that overshadow the facts. Or the need to scrutinise the decisions of those that rule us.

kc431 · 24/11/2022 12:45

That’s just your opinion, I don’t think they were necessary or the right thing to do at all, they don’t work. All they did was delay the spread into a concentrated wave once they opened up. They were based off some idiot scientist’s models that have never worked for any disease he’s consulted on. I’m convinced the long term costs and excess deaths will outweigh any benefits or lives saved at the time. The whole thing was total bullshit and basically sacrificing the young for the old. Let’s see what the enquiry comes out with.

I am really glad I broke the rules at the time because it was necessary for my mental health which was in the toilet. I remember reading a thread about “are you going to visit your family over Christmas” and seeing the vile, vicious abuse at anyone breaking the Tier 3 travel ban - I decided not to post….

namechangeagain3 · 24/11/2022 12:41

@somethinsomethin Funny enough this is how I feel. My kids both have Additional needs but always loved school.
The past year I'd say has been tough. They either can't get up in the morning for school because their sleeping is so bad or they just won't go. They are 6&7 and it's hard work. I am given a letter each month about their absence and they are down now as persistent absentees. But what can I do? I don't drive. They was fine before lockdown. And I can't physically drag them to school when they are like this. I too sometimes feel school creates more problems than I need and dream of escaping somewhere with them. You got my sympathies.
I honestly fear as they get older it'll get worse. Out of a normal school week they have at least 1-2 days off Sad.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 12:30

@JenniferBarkley No, multiple, lengthy lockdowns were not necessary. Especially when many of the ‘rules’ made no sense.

Kids can’t go to school but men can go to the pub.
Groups of 6 can meet in the pub. Because the virus can count. As long as they are discussing business - because the virus can differentiate between business meetings and socialising.

No wonder so many broke the largely ridiculous rules.

What happened every time we opened up after a lockdown? Rates of Covid sky rocketed. You can’t control a virus like this. As we’ve all seen. We would have been far better to not go from one extreme to another. E.g straight out of months and months of lockdown in to ‘eat out to help out’

The only bit of government policy I agreed with was when they ended all restrictions and luckily stuck to their guns. Look at China to see how effective long term lockdowns are. Look at Sweden to see how to manage a virus without decimating your childrens’ childhood and education.

MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 12:23

JenniferBarkley · 24/11/2022 12:21

It absolutely should be analysed, and I said as much. In time we will know which decisions were right and wrong. But that analysis needs to be unemotional and scientific, not raging on here about kill a granny ads.

People can submit their emotional as they like experiences to the consultation. It’s the only way the damage can be recorded then looked at overall.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 12:22

JenniferBarkley · 24/11/2022 12:21

It absolutely should be analysed, and I said as much. In time we will know which decisions were right and wrong. But that analysis needs to be unemotional and scientific, not raging on here about kill a granny ads.

That isn't for you to decide.

JenniferBarkley · 24/11/2022 12:21

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 12:12

Debating the pros and cons of lockdown will get us nowhere. They happened and they were shit for nearly everyone. What we need to do now is to compensate for them and try to repair the damage to adults and children alike. Raking over old ground doesn't help and we can't change what happened. We need to be focussing on where we go from here.

No, the discussion about whether lockdown was the right policy choice or not is vital. This is so we know whether it should be part of our pandemic toolkit in the future or not. That's going to require full understanding of all the harms, so we can do the best job we can at assessing whether those were justified by the benefits. It's going to be a huge project.

We need to do this as well as compensating. You're right about the importance of that, of course you are, but it's as well as not instead of.

It absolutely should be analysed, and I said as much. In time we will know which decisions were right and wrong. But that analysis needs to be unemotional and scientific, not raging on here about kill a granny ads.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 12:19

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 11:45

Can I also remind people that parents we officially advised to put kids as young as 5 years old into complete isolation should they even come into contact with covid.

FFS!
5/6 year olds in their room, food dropped at the door treated like the most nasty criminals for 14 days!!!

Those in secondary seemed to end up with back to back isolations.

That was just cruel.

Yes we mustn’t forget this. On this site people were defending isolating their primary school children for 10 days in their room. I liked to remind them that solitary confinement is a punishment for adult prisoners..

Was truly shocking. When your child is ill
you look after them and comfort them - who cares about themselves! Such selfish, batshit behaviour.

This will all make wonderful history lessons in the future. And those that put their children in isolation and left food outside the door - good luck explaining that to your grandkids.

Of course you want us to move on and forget about it. Because your behaviour was shocking and unforgivable. No, we shouldn’t forget. We need to discuss what the hell went wrong and how this can never happen again.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 12:12

Debating the pros and cons of lockdown will get us nowhere. They happened and they were shit for nearly everyone. What we need to do now is to compensate for them and try to repair the damage to adults and children alike. Raking over old ground doesn't help and we can't change what happened. We need to be focussing on where we go from here.

No, the discussion about whether lockdown was the right policy choice or not is vital. This is so we know whether it should be part of our pandemic toolkit in the future or not. That's going to require full understanding of all the harms, so we can do the best job we can at assessing whether those were justified by the benefits. It's going to be a huge project.

We need to do this as well as compensating. You're right about the importance of that, of course you are, but it's as well as not instead of.

JenniferBarkley · 24/11/2022 12:06

I literally remember spending hours on this site arguing that lockdowns were a terrible decision and the harms would outweigh the benefits, I got loads of abuse calling me selfish/stupid/granny killer.

But the lockdowns were necessary, especially at first. The communication was certainly poor with people thinking they were only allowed out for an hour, or that pregnant women needed to shield - neither of these were ever true but both widely believed. In time we will know more and be able to analyse the decisions and it will be clear that some decisions were taken too quickly or slowly, or that restrictions were too harsh or not harsh enough at different times and in different places.

But there needs to be nuance here.

Debating the pros and cons of lockdown will get us nowhere. They happened and they were shit for nearly everyone. What we need to do now is to compensate for them and try to repair the damage to adults and children alike. Raking over old ground doesn't help and we can't change what happened. We need to be focussing on where we go from here.

MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 12:06

thebellagio · 24/11/2022 11:45

The one good thing I hope about this whole mess is that history teachers can reframe how they teach WW2. Imagine now being able to show recent examples of propaganda, and showing how messages were used to scare people into compliance. As has been said on this thread, it's disturbingly clear to see how the Nazi's managed to convince an entire population to turn against Jewish people, and report them for anything.

I also hope that people start to see subjects such as media studies as actually quite beneficial. When I did my degree (not media, but something vaguely similar), we had lectures on the role of media bias, and how to identify the truth in what would now be known as 'fake news'. At certain times, my own parents kept saying I was on the verge of turning into a conspiracist - mainly because I've been trained to spot media bias, and I don't unconditionally believe what the Daily Mail tells me.

The best advice I can ever give anyone, is to always read multiple newspapers - broadsheet and tabloid/left leaning and right leaning. That way you'll start to see some of the truth in stories, away from the journalistic bias.

The way communications was handled during lockdown was abysmal. It was all designed to scare people into compliance with no thought whatsoever to the lasting effects of those communications.

Absolutely, the viciousness it inspired was off the scale.

I have some interest / background in the same and it was really something to see (although being at receiving wasn’t good). A time in history hopefully teaching us about propaganda and not to ignore the damage.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 12:01

MeetPi · 24/11/2022 11:58

@SirMingeALot

He isn't 92, and I said no such thing about his health.

This is what you said previously (I did get his age incorrect):

"My grandad didn't think he was sacrificing himself by wanting to spend what might easily have been the end of his life (he's 91) with his loved ones."

This implies he's still alive and 91 years old.

Yes. It doesn't imply that he's well.

MeetPi · 24/11/2022 11:58

@SirMingeALot

He isn't 92, and I said no such thing about his health.

This is what you said previously (I did get his age incorrect):

"My grandad didn't think he was sacrificing himself by wanting to spend what might easily have been the end of his life (he's 91) with his loved ones."

This implies he's still alive and 91 years old.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/11/2022 11:52

Buzzinwithbez · 24/11/2022 11:39

My daughter joined during lockdowns and was looking forward to making some more friends. After coping with zoom meetings, it was just a really chilly and wierd experience, but still she went along well after week, looking forward to getting back to normal. The best friend she made there left due to the wierdness.

In January this year they went back to zoom meetings for a while. My daughter couldn't bring herself to join in. She left this autumn term as windows would still have to be open, she'd still have to cart along her own chair etc rather than contaminated one in the church hall.

The leaders have really done their best and have been absolutely lovely. I'm sad she is leaving, but I understand.

We are back to normal now and thriving fortunately but I know it’s not case in every area lots of groups have closed. We have massive wait lists for younger ages.
We tried via zoom but it was hard last thing I wanted or they wanted after a day on zoom for work and school was more zoom. We met outside summer 21 a few times. But logistically difficult no toilets, risk of inclement weather plus needing to be and be seen to be fully compliant. Our church hall is back to normal but I know lots of rooms have stopped renting eg in schools or still have restrictions.

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 11:52

I also remember a testing station being set up in the car park of my dcs primary school. We were told we should get our kids tested. I refused but I remember being so angry seeing other parents queuing up to get their kids tested, mainly because I knew if one was positive, my DC would be sent home from school and told to isolate for ten days. It beggars belief that parents were queuing up to have their kids and tested and potentially isolate them. Madness.

kc431 · 24/11/2022 11:51

I literally remember spending hours on this site arguing that lockdowns were a terrible decision and the harms would outweigh the benefits, I got loads of abuse calling me selfish/stupid/granny killer.

I saw friends the entire way through (any that would be willing to see me) and saw my family for Christmas in Tier 3. My in-laws would only meet us on their drive sat in the car boot 2m apart and remember thinking how stupid and ridiculous it was. If I’d not been able to break the rules I probably would have committed suicide that winter, it was the worst depression I ever had.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 11:51

Delatron · 24/11/2022 11:44

Yes, can you remember every report of police pulling up someone for sitting in a bench or going for a walk or something ridiculous- it was always women. Not men..

I did see a few instances of men being targeted by police too. They were generally black, working class or both, by total coincidence of course. Like the man who was told he wasn't allowed to stand in his own front garden.

thebellagio · 24/11/2022 11:50

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 11:47

Yes @thebellagio one thing I remember is that anyone who questioned the government or the narrative at the time was accused of being a conspiracy theorist. It was like a modern day witch-hunt. Quite terrifying actually

really frightening wasn't it?

As other people have said, even just reading this thread back does bring back horrible memories.

Comedycook · 24/11/2022 11:47

Yes @thebellagio one thing I remember is that anyone who questioned the government or the narrative at the time was accused of being a conspiracy theorist. It was like a modern day witch-hunt. Quite terrifying actually

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 11:45

Can I also remind people that parents we officially advised to put kids as young as 5 years old into complete isolation should they even come into contact with covid.

FFS!
5/6 year olds in their room, food dropped at the door treated like the most nasty criminals for 14 days!!!

Those in secondary seemed to end up with back to back isolations.

That was just cruel.

thebellagio · 24/11/2022 11:45

The one good thing I hope about this whole mess is that history teachers can reframe how they teach WW2. Imagine now being able to show recent examples of propaganda, and showing how messages were used to scare people into compliance. As has been said on this thread, it's disturbingly clear to see how the Nazi's managed to convince an entire population to turn against Jewish people, and report them for anything.

I also hope that people start to see subjects such as media studies as actually quite beneficial. When I did my degree (not media, but something vaguely similar), we had lectures on the role of media bias, and how to identify the truth in what would now be known as 'fake news'. At certain times, my own parents kept saying I was on the verge of turning into a conspiracist - mainly because I've been trained to spot media bias, and I don't unconditionally believe what the Daily Mail tells me.

The best advice I can ever give anyone, is to always read multiple newspapers - broadsheet and tabloid/left leaning and right leaning. That way you'll start to see some of the truth in stories, away from the journalistic bias.

The way communications was handled during lockdown was abysmal. It was all designed to scare people into compliance with no thought whatsoever to the lasting effects of those communications.

Delatron · 24/11/2022 11:44

Yes, can you remember every report of police pulling up someone for sitting in a bench or going for a walk or something ridiculous- it was always women. Not men..

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 11:42

In the end I mainly took her out when my DP was around, or arranged for him to take her out himself at weekends, as we realised we got much less abuse when he was there - I suspect covid was used as an excuse by some to pick on and bully lone women

Of course it was. Easy targets. There's a poster on here whose mask exempt disabled teenage DD got loads of abuse. Bet those brave heroes would've been much less willing to stand up to maskless, brick shithouse sized blokes.