Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Delatron · 25/11/2022 15:54

Just read a very interesting research paper comparing the impact of school closures in Finland versus not closing the primary schools and pre-school settings in Sweden. Bizarrely it may seem to some - rates of infection were similar in the country that closed schools versus the country that didn’t.

It’s almost as though a virus is going to do what a virus does.

I’ve attached the very interesting findings.

Also claiming children are not big spreaders of Covid (which I believe to be true - I never caught Covid off my children - only other adults ditto most people I know).

So therefore mass testing and isolation of close contacts for weeks on end does seem to have been complete overkill and hugely disruptive to healthy and well children.

Some children isolated for many separate periods of 10 days - even if they were not ill. So much unnecessary disruption.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…
Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…
noblegiraffe · 25/11/2022 15:20

Or you could read the thread I linked to, hamster which shows that your recollection is bollocks.

hamstersarse · 25/11/2022 15:17

@BlueRidge

my recollection is very different

Thread after long thread about ‘how to keep schools open’ which made ridiculous demands and even worse assumptions about how to stop covid being in schools

“If us teachers can’t have every child masked, sitting 6ft apart, a new ventilation system, testing 4x a day, no talking, no singing, all windows open even though it’s -2,….then the risk is too high and we can’t keep schools open”

BlueRidge · 25/11/2022 14:54

Please explain exactly how my post silences anyone.

MarshaBradyo · 25/11/2022 14:28

BlueRidge · 25/11/2022 14:18

"As much as people don’t want others to post, as per usual. Same as during the pandemic."

Who are you suggesting is trying to silence others?

You. I’m surprised you need to ask.

The pandemic response caused damage and people will discuss it on threads like this. Particularly as they felt silenced during it by many on here.

BlueRidge · 25/11/2022 14:18

"As much as people don’t want others to post, as per usual. Same as during the pandemic."

Who are you suggesting is trying to silence others?

MarshaBradyo · 25/11/2022 14:00

No re writing from me. As much as people don’t want others to post, as per usual. Same as during the pandemic.

No point in blaming anyone for highlighting the harm caused. The damage is there and people will talk about it.

BlueRidge · 25/11/2022 13:51

Yes, there is a lot of re-writing of history on this thread. There is also a lot of wilful misunderstanding.
But it's not coming from @noblegiraffe who, from my recollection, made a stirling effort to inform people of the state of affairs in schools at the time and how best we could minimise Covid's impact.
Same old names popping up on this thread, doing their bit to contribute to the mass exodus of school staff from the profession. Well done, all.

Delatron · 25/11/2022 13:42

My Yr8 and 9 haven’t been offered a flu vaccine. Norovirus struck down 40 teachers at our school. I was far more ill with that than Covid. And flu. Took me 3 months to recover from flu.

Anyway I’m derailing the thread for a change.
My point is when I say ‘people don’t care about Covid anymore’. I mean other illnesses are far more serious to children. And always have been.

AntlerRose · 25/11/2022 13:35

With regard to flu, children are vaccinated in school and many schools pay for staff to be vaccinated.

With regard to norovirus, schools call public health or whatever its called now, and get advice if a threshold is met. This generally involves extea cleaning, permission to use bleach, extra handwashing and indeed closures if necessary.

MyBuggyIsOutToGetMe · 25/11/2022 13:32

@XelaM , you’re quite right. But the expectations here are different for children in school than they would be in other countries.

So the expectations in Year 3, academically, will be the same as pre-pandemic for children who’ve had three years of uninterrupted education, whereas this cohort have had two very interrupted first years (when much more of the curriculum is play-based). Understandably, a lot of these children are struggling.

Delatron · 25/11/2022 13:31

Children missing pre-school and seeing friends and family. Toddler groups. Mother and baby meetings. None of these happened. That will have had a profound impact on those young children. Plus the lack of immunity that they have now to many common childhood illnesses.

Delatron · 25/11/2022 13:30

Do you care about flu @noblegiraffe or the Norovirus that is going around? It’s not about Covid anymore. But sadly we are still seeing the impact on children. Covid really isn’t the worst virus around. That’s what I mean when it’s not a worry for people. If I was a teacher I’d be far more worried about flu right now.

That’s my exact point. Children do not exist in a vacuum. So an adult is just as likely to pick up Covid in a workplace/ on a bus/ at a party and give it to a child as a child pick it up at school and give it to an adult in the home. Viruses spread. That’s what they do. Rates in schools reflected rates in the local
community. We need to judge whether our response was proportional to the threat and was focused on the right demographic.

Children were disproportionately affected by the ongoing school closures. And we are still seeing the impact.

MarshaBradyo · 25/11/2022 13:29

XelaM · 25/11/2022 13:20

Can I just ask about the Year 3s and people saying that's the worst affected group because they missed Years 1 and 2... in most countries children don't go to school until they are 6-7 years old. I personally didn't start school until I was 7. I actually think starting school at 4 is way too young. So I'm surprised that year group has been so badly affected.

Formal schooling may start later but peer socialisation for children is apparent. Knowing personally from family in Germany I googled anyway to see if it was backed up

In Germany, 94% of 3-year-olds and 98% of 4-year-olds participate in pre-primary education (ISCED 02), which is well above the OECD average

XelaM · 25/11/2022 13:20

Can I just ask about the Year 3s and people saying that's the worst affected group because they missed Years 1 and 2... in most countries children don't go to school until they are 6-7 years old. I personally didn't start school until I was 7. I actually think starting school at 4 is way too young. So I'm surprised that year group has been so badly affected.

noblegiraffe · 25/11/2022 13:19

You making all about yourself again @noblegiraffe doesn’t change this fact.

Maybe go back and read through the thread and realise it was the posters telling me I was rewriting history or shouldn’t be posting here that made it about me.

The harm of lockdowns and missing education and socialising was far greater than the spread of Covid for children.

You seem to think that children exist in a vacuum when it comes to covid, spreading it amongst themselves with no impact on the wider population.

I’m not claiming Covid didn’t spread in schools. It still is. But nobody cares.

People do care, absence due to covid is still an issue. But the people who care work in schools so can be safely ignored, right?

Delatron · 25/11/2022 13:04

I’m not claiming Covid didn’t spread in schools. It still is. But nobody cares.

I’m claiming anyone who thinks we could stop the spread (without harmful lockdowns) is being wilfully thick and not understanding what everyone on this thread is saying. You got your face masks anyway so what is the problem? I can’t remember what else you wanted.

The harm of lockdowns and missing education and socialising was far greater than the spread of Covid for children.

We treated children appallingly.

You making all about yourself again @noblegiraffe doesn’t change this fact.

Maybe go back and read through the thread if you’ve failed to understand the impact this has had on children.

Schools should have been open for far longer than they were. (In my mind they should never have closed at all).

Schools closed in Jan 2021 because the government pushed the second wave in to Winter by keeping everything shut down for too long. That was the issue. Of course Covid spread everywhere when we opened up.

noblegiraffe · 25/11/2022 12:45

It was government policy on lockdowns that shut the schools. Nothing to do with crappy mitigations that have been shown to do f all.

Ignoring the DfE evidence posted upthread where schools who introduced masks had significantly fewer absences due to covid.

The government had to close schools in Jan 2021 because they tried a lockdown with schools open in Nov 2020 and it wasn’t effective enough at bringing down the death rate because the highest level of infection was in school children.

Anyone still trying to claim that covid didn’t spread effectively in schools is presumably being wilfully thick.

Brighty1 · 25/11/2022 12:43

I think there will be an impact for a while. My 14yo (year 10), has recently started counselling as she’s struggling with depression, self harm and suicidal thoughts. I think her first two years of secondary school having so much home learning definitely had a major impact on forming strong friendship bonds.

Delatron · 25/11/2022 12:08

And yes I would be far more worried about flu for vulnerable children. On the news last night that there are record rates of hospitalisations. RSV is bad in young children and again is a far greater threat to them than Covid ever was.

This is all thanks to a lack of immunity due to lockdowns. The gift that keeps on giving.

Delatron · 25/11/2022 12:06

Vaccines are amazing. But at some point these will wear off.(and immunity will take over)

I have seen in real life and on here many who thought they were ‘vulnerable’ to Covid caught it and were fine. Including FIL who hid himself away claiming he would die if he caught it then had a mild cold with it. Sadly his health deteriorated significantly due to him being too scared to even go for a walk outside. Such fear mongering.

I know the vaccines helped make it a less severe disease for many whilst we built up immunity. But I think Covid is far more random than we believe (and has more of a genetic element to it in terms of seriousness). So many of those who thought they were vulnerable were actually not.

1dayatatime · 25/11/2022 12:05

@TigerRag

"And that makes it ok?

Are people also forgetting there are vulnerable children in schools too? Oh silly me, no one cares about them"

+++

To be blunt for vulnerable children in school, right now I would be more worried about rising flu cases which present a much greater danger to vulnerable school children than Covid ever did.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-63341574.amp

And yes I would seriously at least consider re introducing face masks to prevent this.

1dayatatime · 25/11/2022 11:59

@orchid220

"I appreciate that many people on here don't think that their children should have been inconvenienced in anyway just to save the lives of those they consider unimportant (not just of the elderly but also those with underlying conditions) "

+++

It's not a question of inconvenience. It's was always going to be a hard choice but the choice was to save the lives of the elderly and CEV, at a price of a greater loss of life at a later point (I.e now):

www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-are-excess-deaths-higher-now-than-during-covid/

Plus mental health issues, lost education, greater poverty, missed education, less funding for services including schools and overall a lower quality of future life for young people with 70 to 80 life years ahead of them.

Presumably you were happy with this choice? Of course you could argue that "hey should we have just let the old and vulnerable die?" but equally "hey should we just let a greater number of people die now particularly those with a greater number of life years ahead of them ".

I get it was a really horrible choice to make but unfortunately that was what it was.

Delatron · 25/11/2022 11:58

TigerRag · 25/11/2022 11:55

And that makes it ok?

Are people also forgetting there are vulnerable children in schools too? Oh silly me, no one cares about them

But most people have had Covid multiple times. We kind of realised that was inevitable. Funnily enough you can’t stop a virus spreading. (Unless complete permanent lockdown).

Magentax · 25/11/2022 11:57

I have a year 3 and he’s an only child. It was an awful time and while he seems ok now I really worry that the awful disruption to his schooling will have a long term effect. He’s now having to face the effect of a hugely demoralised under paid teaching staff and schools crumbling under a funding crisis.

Its dreadful all round

Swipe left for the next trending thread