Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Delatron · 27/11/2022 20:33

I wouldn’t use anything from Sage to prove my point. They were well known for releasing ‘information’ to influence the behaviour that they wanted (or the government wanted)

@CallmeAngelina I’ve already linked to a research paper that is a comparison between 2 similar countries- one that closed the schools and one that didn’t. As this is relevant to the thread.

You’re a teacher - read the thread!

This thread isn’t about the teachers. It’s about the kids that have missed out on so much. And are still suffering. Nobody is blaming you. (Unless you supported the endless school closures). This is on the government.

You’re detracting from the thread by trying to prove the school closures were necessary. When we don’t have that information and people are sharing their stories about how their children have been affected.

noblegiraffe · 27/11/2022 20:28

Do you not understand the difference between data analysis and modelling?

CallmeAngelina · 27/11/2022 20:23

Such as what, Delatron?
Keen to see these "much better sources."

Delatron · 27/11/2022 20:20

Ah the wonderful Sage and their accurate modelling. Did they actually get anything right during the pandemic?

Every single model wildly overstated the actual death rate. I hope there’s an enquiry in to them.

I would not use them as a source of research for anything to do with the pandemic. Far better sources out there.

noblegiraffe · 27/11/2022 19:56

If we look at data from the UK, where we actually live, leading up to the school closures in January, we have kids and young people massively more infected than adults, and we also have the minutes from the SAGE committee saying that children were more likely to be in the first in a household with covid (where were they catching it, hmm?) and more likely to pass it onto family members than adults were to pass it to them.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…
Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…
orchid220 · 27/11/2022 17:59

EndlessRain · 27/11/2022 17:51

That doesn't really make sense.

In any case, the schools being open does mean you could track how children spread and reacted to covid.

holidays are also holidays for adults. Who will not be going to work, commuting etc. If kids really were these superspreaders that you claim, why were families with children not disproportionately negatively impacted by Covid?

Most adults still work during school holidays and even if they aren't they will be going out and about. They don't usually stay at home. I haven't said that school children are superspreaders. That doesn't mean that they don't spread it though, particularly if they are all close together in small classrooms.

EndlessRain · 27/11/2022 17:51

orchid220 · 27/11/2022 17:45

In that case you can't argue that Sweden not closing schools had no impact on deaths either. Or you could just use common sense. It's pretty clear that in the UK, covid cases go up during term time and down during school holidays. Before vaccinations and treatments covid cases increasing led to an increase in covid deaths.

That doesn't really make sense.

In any case, the schools being open does mean you could track how children spread and reacted to covid.

holidays are also holidays for adults. Who will not be going to work, commuting etc. If kids really were these superspreaders that you claim, why were families with children not disproportionately negatively impacted by Covid?

orchid220 · 27/11/2022 17:45

EndlessRain · 27/11/2022 17:23

It doesn't though. Because schools weren't the only restriction they didn't impose. They basically imposed nothing at all. So there is no way you can say schools open = the increased deaths.

In that case you can't argue that Sweden not closing schools had no impact on deaths either. Or you could just use common sense. It's pretty clear that in the UK, covid cases go up during term time and down during school holidays. Before vaccinations and treatments covid cases increasing led to an increase in covid deaths.

Delatron · 27/11/2022 17:44

This is the summary from the report I posted earlier comparing Sweden and Finland.

It says ‘In conclusion closure or not of schools had no measurable direct impact on the number of laboratory confirmed cases of school aged children in Sweden or Finland.

Outbreak investigations in Finland had not shown children to be contributing much in terms of transmission and in Sweden a report comparing risk of Covid 19 in different professions showed no increased risk for teachers.

If you read this report the cases actually went up in Finland when they closed the schools.

My own personal view, based on what I’ve read and seen happen, is that children, especially young children were not huge spreaders of Covid. Teachers were not dropping dead in Sweden.

Children were far more likely to pick up Covid from adults. And adults spread it amongst themselves.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…
MarshaBradyo · 27/11/2022 17:27

EndlessRain · 27/11/2022 17:23

It doesn't though. Because schools weren't the only restriction they didn't impose. They basically imposed nothing at all. So there is no way you can say schools open = the increased deaths.

Democrat v Republican states are useful. Florida seems to be doing well from approach, politically it’s gone down well

EndlessRain · 27/11/2022 17:23

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 23:59

It does take away your point. Compared with countries that closed schools and had similar health services and demographics i.e. Denmark, Norway and Finland, covid deaths in Sweden were higher. This means that when everything else was equal, closing schools reduced covid deaths.

It doesn't though. Because schools weren't the only restriction they didn't impose. They basically imposed nothing at all. So there is no way you can say schools open = the increased deaths.

EndlessRain · 27/11/2022 17:21

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 20:18

Better healthcare, they brought in restrictions/advice before it was too late and probably a more sensible population. They generally also have larger classrooms with fewer pupils in each one compared with the UK.

They didn't bring in restrictions though, that's the whole point. They were basically carry on as normal, but be a bit careful. My sister lives there and was, more or less, going about life as normal. With a bit more hand sanitiser and handwashing.

JenniferBooth · 27/11/2022 15:22

Its disgusting @EmmaAgain22 Awards being dished out before an enquiry shouldnt be happening.

Walkaround · 27/11/2022 07:38

1dayatatime · 26/11/2022 23:26

Hmm let me try and clarify.

Coronaviruses are a group of viruses that cause respiratory illnesses in humans and animals. SARS and the common cold coronaviruses for example are avian in origin, MERS rather bizarrely originated in camels and Covid 19 most likely from bats.

All seven types mutate (as do most other viruses)

So I I am not pretending all seven types are zoonotic in origin, I am stating it's a scientific fact as is the point that most viruses mutate. I concede that Covid is "new" or at least newly identified with some evidence showing that the first covid cases were in 2012:

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/seven-year-covid-trail-revealed-l5vxt7jqp

But my point is that @RedToothBrush deliberately omitted mentioning the four known relatively harmless coronaviruses, only focusing on the two lethal types (MERS and SARS).

Are you suggesting that the likelihood of one of the common cold human coronaviruses that has been common in humans for a very long time spontaneously mutating to become lethal is the same as a newly mutated animal virus not yet specialised to humans initially being pretty lethal? Or are you admitting that recent history demonstrated that newly mutated animal coronaviruses could be lethal and that therefore another one seemingly suddenly appearing in China, shortly after SARS and MERS was legitimately a cause of alarm?

noblegiraffe · 27/11/2022 00:13

I mean, you're suggesting that Italy overreacted in the face of an unknown, new, and highly contagious virus that was killing people, and that the media were wrong for reporting exactly what was happening in other countries.

noblegiraffe · 27/11/2022 00:11

You appear to be viewing the situation with the benefit of hindsight.

1dayatatime · 27/11/2022 00:10

@noblegiraffe

"Are you saying that the situation in Italy was merely "media reporting" and not actually happening?"

+++

Italy was one of the first countries in Europe to be impacted by Covid with the first cases diagnosed in February 2020. Although there is evidence on lung cancer screenings that it was prevalent before September 2019.

Once diagnosis of Covid started coming in Italy tried to handle it with very strict isolation measures (as did the UK with early patients whipped off to secure highly infectious disease isolation hospitals).

However given the sheer number of patients this wasn't feasible (as it isn't today) leading to scenes of beds in corridors etc heavily reported in the media at the time. The actual death toll in these initial phases (peaking at c 400 per day) was lower than later phases.

In short you could easily recreate in the UK today the scenes witnessed in Italy in March 2020 by insisting that everyone who is diagnosed with Covid must go to an isolation hospital and be treated by doctors in Hazmat.

orchid220 · 27/11/2022 00:07

Delatron · 26/11/2022 21:14

They had far less ‘restrictions’ than we had though. Most things stayed open. They were ‘advised’ to do things rather than it being the law. Great approach. So it was nothing to do with them bringing in early restrictions. The government advised working from home where possible and advised social distancing.

Their healthcare is far better yes and this played a big part. But at the time they were very much criticised for not locking down. Now it seems as though for them, it was the right choice.

Great approach if advice works. The Swedish are known to trust government agencies and follow advice but the UK not so much.

Dinoteeth · 27/11/2022 00:01

There was a thing ignore what was happening in China, but the world took note of Italy.
There was a real fear of the NHS not being able to treat people. And people who could be saved dying because of lack of treatment.
I know someone in NHS procurement being asked to source 1000s of bodybags.

Once things had settled people were still reluctant to have kids back in school but someone also explained to me, Vaccines were Plan A, if they failed then building natural immunity in kids and younger adults was the unofficial Plan B.

Did English secondary kids have to wear masks all day at any point in time? I think they were mandatory in Scotland secondaries from August 2020 to May 22? Happy for someone with secondary aged kids / teacher to correct me.

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 23:59

1dayatatime · 26/11/2022 21:20

I would certainly agree with both these points:
Sweden"s average BMI is 24.1 compared to 27.2 for the UK. Indeed of all developed countries Japan has the lowest BMI and also had the lowest Covid mortality rate.
On health care Sweden spends a third more on healthcare and I don't think many would disagree that the NHS has been underfunded for years.

However all of this doesn't take away from my point that whether schools were or were not shut during the pandemic really had no impact on Covid death rates.

It does take away your point. Compared with countries that closed schools and had similar health services and demographics i.e. Denmark, Norway and Finland, covid deaths in Sweden were higher. This means that when everything else was equal, closing schools reduced covid deaths.

noblegiraffe · 26/11/2022 23:43

Absolutely many parents were scared shitless on the media reporting at the time.

Are you saying that the situation in Italy was merely "media reporting" and not actually happening?

"And to be blunt I didn't have a problem with parents choosing to keep their children at home. Besides less children in a classroom reduces the risk of transmission as well as making teaching a smaller class easier."

You clearly have no idea what it was like in schools at the time. Very little teaching was going on in schools as no one knew what was going on, kids and teachers were disappearing daily and kids were panicking every time anyone coughed. And the kids who were at home were getting nothing.

1dayatatime · 26/11/2022 23:39

@noblegiraffe

"Are you sure it wasn't the awful scenes from the hospitals in Italy that did that?

Before the official school closures in March schools were more than half empty due to parents taking their kids out (my school) or already closed due to lack of staff (my DCs' school). No one has actually been able to explain how it would have been better if, in those circumstances, schools had tried to limp on."

+++

Absolutely many parents were scared shitless on the media reporting at the time. And to be blunt I didn't have a problem with parents choosing to keep their children at home. Besides less children in a classroom reduces the risk of transmission as well as making teaching a smaller class easier.

What I do object to is that freedom of choice being taken away by the Government ordered school closures. I also object to the failure to introduce (at a much earlier stage) the wearing of face masks by pupils and other sage guarding measures rather than go for the nuclear option of shutting schools down completely.

But what I really really object to is the failure of the Government to deliver on the promised post Covid "catch up" funding of some £13.5 billion.

This now seems to have been quietly forgotten about or now dismissed as unaffordable all at the same time as teachers and pupils are supposed to pick up where they left off and pretend that the Covid school closures never happened or didn't impact children's education.

1dayatatime · 26/11/2022 23:26

Walkaround · 26/11/2022 22:21

@1dayatatime - I fail to see what existing human coronaviruses have to do with a newly mutated zoonotic virus, though? You are pretending to compare like with like, but you actually aren’t.

Hmm let me try and clarify.

Coronaviruses are a group of viruses that cause respiratory illnesses in humans and animals. SARS and the common cold coronaviruses for example are avian in origin, MERS rather bizarrely originated in camels and Covid 19 most likely from bats.

All seven types mutate (as do most other viruses)

So I I am not pretending all seven types are zoonotic in origin, I am stating it's a scientific fact as is the point that most viruses mutate. I concede that Covid is "new" or at least newly identified with some evidence showing that the first covid cases were in 2012:

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/seven-year-covid-trail-revealed-l5vxt7jqp

But my point is that @RedToothBrush deliberately omitted mentioning the four known relatively harmless coronaviruses, only focusing on the two lethal types (MERS and SARS).

noblegiraffe · 26/11/2022 23:20

This is actually a really good example of the deliberate scaremongering and misinformation during the pandemic that led to the public support for the lockdowns including school closures.

Are you sure it wasn't the awful scenes from the hospitals in Italy that did that?

Before the official school closures in March schools were more than half empty due to parents taking their kids out (my school) or already closed due to lack of staff (my DCs' school). No one has actually been able to explain how it would have been better if, in those circumstances, schools had tried to limp on.

MeetPi · 26/11/2022 23:19

@orchid220

There was plenty of aggression on both sides. The CEV (many of whom still are btw) probably had to deal with the most.

Absolutely agree with this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread