Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not allowed siblings at my sons nativity play .. including my breast fed baby??

793 replies

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:28

My daughter is 4 months old and breastfeeding.

My two other sons are involved in the school nativity play. The school will be having two performers one at 2:30 and one at 7:00.

I have been informed that the school has a ‘no sibling rule’ to watching so I will not be allowed to bring my daughter. The issue is these times are both when she has milk.

I was also told by the head that she may make noise and interrupt the performance !!

Really sad as I don’t want to miss it ! But do not feel happy leaving my baby at these times!

OP posts:
alizee21g · 24/11/2022 21:29

Islandgirl68 · 24/11/2022 18:39

That's not true for every baby, my first coukd feed hourly some times, didn't always know when they would need fed.

This! My baby was feeding without any pattern but she'd pretty much be content anywhere as long as she's had access to my boob.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 21:26

Yes, can you actually imagine what a twat OP would make of herself if she turned up with the baby and told them they'd have to phone the police to stop her trespassing? She'd be legendary!

Mañanarama · 24/11/2022 21:24

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 21:12

Schools aren’t private businesses though are they? Parents of the school are allowed to watch their own child in the nativity play. The Head isn’t going to accuse a mum of trespassing when coming to watch her child in the play. The HT thensrelf can’t orevent her from entering the premises without calling the police which frankly they aren’t going to do (yes obviously if it was a safeguarding issue etc) but otherwise… not necessary.

maybe discrimination is the wrong term to use? Sorry for not being a qualified solicitor here. I obviously don’t have the breadth of knowledge and experience that you do but my opinion is that a blanket ban applied to all siblings is discriminatory to breastfeeding mothers. This is not about self interest as I have said. As a single mum, I’ve struggled with childcare, as a working mum I’ve struggled to get time off to see my children in events. Working in a school I can see how these things snowball and all the headteacher needs to do is apply some commonsense without fear that it is somehow going to cause some horrific problem. If another parent approaches and asks to bring her 6.2 month old child the HT can use their discretion to decide whether that is appropriate or not. If 22 parents all want to bring breastfed babies maybe the HT decides to do something different. But being inclusive to breastfeeding mums during the first six months should surely be encouraged. It doesn’t give you the right to ‘go anywhere’ and I didn’t suggest it did. But to your own child’s school nativity play… that’s a very different thing to say for example, the opera.

if you lawyers know the equality and discrimination law inside out and know that it is being described incorrectly then presumably you will have less understanding of how primary schools are run and what DfE guidance is.

I was quoting the Dept for Educations guidelines for access to schools. It confirms they are private property and that those entering uninvited are trespassing.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/controlling-access-to-school-premises/controlling-access-to-school-premises

I’ve worked in both law and eduction. Neither taught me more about how annoying kids are at school events, than being a parent myself. Personally, I couldn’t bear pissing off all the other mums and dads who’d had to move heaven and earth to get to the nativity.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 21:23

Discrimination is the wrong term to use, yes. Glad we finally got there.

And no schools aren't private businesses, nobody said they were. They're usually private property, as per the link above, which isn't the same thing. You've been talking absolute nonsense.

On the other point, the comments about being practically unable to prevent entry mean nothing without some idea of the premises. Our assembly hall has quite a narrow door that could easily enough be physically blocked by a headteacher or anyone desiring to prevent a person entering. Unless you're about to suggest OP try and fight her way in...

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 21:12

Mañanarama · 24/11/2022 20:45

What’s that Mingey? Schools are private property? People do not have an automatic right to enter? Anyone who breaks those rules would be trespassing?

Well, well, well.

Schools aren’t private businesses though are they? Parents of the school are allowed to watch their own child in the nativity play. The Head isn’t going to accuse a mum of trespassing when coming to watch her child in the play. The HT thensrelf can’t orevent her from entering the premises without calling the police which frankly they aren’t going to do (yes obviously if it was a safeguarding issue etc) but otherwise… not necessary.

maybe discrimination is the wrong term to use? Sorry for not being a qualified solicitor here. I obviously don’t have the breadth of knowledge and experience that you do but my opinion is that a blanket ban applied to all siblings is discriminatory to breastfeeding mothers. This is not about self interest as I have said. As a single mum, I’ve struggled with childcare, as a working mum I’ve struggled to get time off to see my children in events. Working in a school I can see how these things snowball and all the headteacher needs to do is apply some commonsense without fear that it is somehow going to cause some horrific problem. If another parent approaches and asks to bring her 6.2 month old child the HT can use their discretion to decide whether that is appropriate or not. If 22 parents all want to bring breastfed babies maybe the HT decides to do something different. But being inclusive to breastfeeding mums during the first six months should surely be encouraged. It doesn’t give you the right to ‘go anywhere’ and I didn’t suggest it did. But to your own child’s school nativity play… that’s a very different thing to say for example, the opera.

if you lawyers know the equality and discrimination law inside out and know that it is being described incorrectly then presumably you will have less understanding of how primary schools are run and what DfE guidance is.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 24/11/2022 21:12

Nowthenhere · 23/11/2022 18:18

That's indirect sex discrimination. Even when lockdowns were going on, children under one weren't included in ratios.
You could actually sue because of the welfare of your baby.
Getting in and out of a school and driving home adds time and the baby can't sit in a freezing cold car.
I would actually get all the research and forward to the head.

It's not good enough.

No she really couldn’t. Stop spouting shit.

echt · 24/11/2022 21:11

I have never seen a child upset by a baby crying

Fair enough, for you. But it's safe bet that every adult will not be pleased to have their enjoyment interrupted in this way.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 24/11/2022 21:03

And if the baby cries? Just as someone else’s child delivers their ONE line. Totally reasonable. In my school we allow parents who really can be separated from performers siblings to watch the dress rehearsal. Imagine if all the parents wanted to be the exception. Your daughter can be fed before and after the performance.

keeprunning55 · 24/11/2022 20:59

This has turned into a rather bizarre rant at how unfair life is & we should all just accept it.
I’ve been an infant teacher doing nativities for a very, very long time. I have never seen a child upset by a baby crying.
Last year’s nativities were the worst as they had to be filmed out in the freezing cold at my school with nobody watching live thanks to covid.
Let’s try and gain some perspective here.

JudgeJ · 24/11/2022 20:58

Islandgirl68 · 24/11/2022 18:27

You are not being unreasonable, no siblings should not include babies under 6 months, school are being unreasonable, and you can sit near the door and nip out if they cry. Hope you get it sorted.

I know from experience that if you set a limit then there'll be the Oh but s/he's only a week over 6 months, blah blah blah brigade, I'm special so it can't apply to Moi!

JudgeJ · 24/11/2022 20:55

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 24/11/2022 20:07

Aww, the wannabe lawyers are still trying to claim this is discrimination. Is this what happens when you watch Judge Judy all day?

I think the Head is quite right and the poor li'l OP is being ridiculous if she can't organise herself better. That's the JJ verdict!

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 24/11/2022 20:47

I don’t think it matters what logic you raise @SirMingeALot - mummies know best, far better than the lawyers on this thread.

Mañanarama · 24/11/2022 20:45

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 20:35

Some useful guidance on who's automatically entitled to be on school premises.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/controlling-access-to-school-premises/controlling-access-to-school-premises

What’s that Mingey? Schools are private property? People do not have an automatic right to enter? Anyone who breaks those rules would be trespassing?

Well, well, well.

ButterCrackers · 24/11/2022 20:43

MatronicO6 · 24/11/2022 20:31

This whole thread proves exactly why no exceptions can be made. OP thinks she deserves special treatment as she is breastfeeding, single mum's are chiming in they feel they deserve special treatment because of childcare, people with siblings at school feel they should be given priority as their actually goes to the school and of course there are people who feel they should be allowed in with theirs because 'it's about families.' On a side note siblings at school most likely will see it in school and it's not about families, it's note even really about baby Jesus, it's 100% down for the kids to shine and take centre stage and share their hard work.

Breastfeeding can be altered and adapted at the very worst baby maybe a little bit grouchy waiting for mum to get home. But the worst for the school is that a neurodivergent child, or a shy child or indeed any child who has worked their socks off by a baby suddenly wailing in tears as no one heard their line or the baby made them freeze. I guarantee you if it was your child who was in this position, you would be gutted. The same goes for every child up there!

It's half an hour. It has clearly been a problem for the school before, they wouldn't make this ban to exclude but to make sure every child has their moment. Being a bit adaptable for 30 mins isn't a huge request.

Agree. There’s usually other rules like not standing up to get a better view, two guests per family, no phones to be used, phones on silent, no eating or drinking (I’m not relating this to breastfeeding), not moving the seating, not holding a seat for someone, not putting a bag/coat/feet up on a seat, leaving the hall row by row as directed by the teachers to avoid pushing, mobility reduced people being assisted as they need, no large bags or umbrellas (left away from the door outside the hall. Things like this ensure the kids on stage are respected and also that the audience knows what is acceptable.

VerbenaGirl · 24/11/2022 20:37

Our primary used to welcome babies to the dress rehearsal, so breastfeeding mums could see it then. Maybe you could suggest that?

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 20:35

Some useful guidance on who's automatically entitled to be on school premises.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/controlling-access-to-school-premises/controlling-access-to-school-premises

SpideyCraw · 24/11/2022 20:35

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 20:03

It’s discrimination to prevent a women from breastfeeding a child younger than 6 months old in a public place. Licensed premises may be different because of the hazards posed. Nightclubs, theatres, operas etc. but we are talking about a school nativity play. The HT doesn’t have special legal powers to stop a woman feeding her baby.

A school isn’t a public place.

Which section of the equality act would apply section 17 of the equality act to a school play?

I don’t know how many people have to point out that you can’t prevent a woman who is in a public place with her baby from breastfeeding her baby, and you can’t ask her to leave because she’s breastfeeding, or make comments or jokes about her breastfeeding.

absolutely nowhere, unless you’re going to point me to a specific section I’ve not come across despite practising in this area since the act came into force, does the equality act entitle a breastfeeding mother to demand that she be allowed to take her baby with her wherever she wants when other children are not allowed. Breastfeeding mothers can’t be treated unfavourably because they are breastfeeding. This is not the same thing as exceptions being made for them to rules as to who can or cannot attend private events. The no siblings policy applies to everyone. Section 17 is not an indirect discrimination provision.

By all means advocate for women to be able to take babies with them to nativities but please stop calling it discrimination.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 20:34

stuntbubbles · 24/11/2022 20:31

What about teaming up with other breastfeeding mums and doing three babies balanced on each other’s shoulders in a trench coat, it’s literally illegal not to let them in like that.

Lmfao yes, and then all pop off to the phonics lesson together afterwards!

MelchiorsMistress · 24/11/2022 20:33

Children in nativities are not put off or upset by babies crying.

Yes, they are. If you haven’t been an adult working on a nativity you might not have noticed it, but of course children will be put off by babies crying.

If they’re nervous, it’s normally because parents are there.

Well yes, obviously. They’ve gone from practicing in their classroom and an empty hall to standing in front of a room packed with people looking at them. The audience are supposed to be there to support those children, the least they can do is quietly sit still while they’re supposed to.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 20:32

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 20:27

I fully understand the legislation, I don’t understand your remark regarding it. I may not be a lawyer, but have plenty of experience with legislation in education and understand only too well how schools can make blanket statements without realising they are walking into a potential midfield. I expect the school in question wanted to limit numbers for practical and fire safety reasons. I guess they thought a blanket sibling ban was fair. I doubt they thought through the implications of banning breastfeeding woman from attending with her <6 month old. No doubt they felt that allowing this Mum to bring her child would in some way ‘open the floodgates’ but of course it wouldn’t. The sibling ban could still be applied. HTs use their discretion. They do not ‘ban’ babies. They request cooperation so that events such as nativity plays run smoothly. They don’t have legal powers to prevent any parent bringing a child into the school premises.

The fact that you think the head must be acting in convention of equality legislation here is in itself evidence that you don't understand it. There is no freestanding right in equalities legislation for a breastfeeding woman to bring the baby wherever she's going or it's discriminatory. If there was, you'd be able to quote the relevant provision.

And it's a shame, because this is a genuinely important issue. Women's breastfeeding rights matter sufficiently that it's bad for all of us when people show themselves up conflating not being allowed into a place with being prevented from breastfeeding.

MatronicO6 · 24/11/2022 20:31

This whole thread proves exactly why no exceptions can be made. OP thinks she deserves special treatment as she is breastfeeding, single mum's are chiming in they feel they deserve special treatment because of childcare, people with siblings at school feel they should be given priority as their actually goes to the school and of course there are people who feel they should be allowed in with theirs because 'it's about families.' On a side note siblings at school most likely will see it in school and it's not about families, it's note even really about baby Jesus, it's 100% down for the kids to shine and take centre stage and share their hard work.

Breastfeeding can be altered and adapted at the very worst baby maybe a little bit grouchy waiting for mum to get home. But the worst for the school is that a neurodivergent child, or a shy child or indeed any child who has worked their socks off by a baby suddenly wailing in tears as no one heard their line or the baby made them freeze. I guarantee you if it was your child who was in this position, you would be gutted. The same goes for every child up there!

It's half an hour. It has clearly been a problem for the school before, they wouldn't make this ban to exclude but to make sure every child has their moment. Being a bit adaptable for 30 mins isn't a huge request.

stuntbubbles · 24/11/2022 20:31

What about teaming up with other breastfeeding mums and doing three babies balanced on each other’s shoulders in a trench coat, it’s literally illegal not to let them in like that.

echt · 24/11/2022 20:29

keeprunning55 · 24/11/2022 20:17

It’s ridiculous. It’s not fair for single mums who haven’t got anyone to look after the children or as in this situation, tiny babies.
If babies cry, sit by the door & take them out.

Children in nativities are not put off or upset by babies crying. If they’re nervous, it’s normally because parents are there.

It's not fair on anyone who can't make it for whatever reason. Most if not all of the teachers running this will never see their own children perform. Life isn't fair.

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 20:27

I fully understand the legislation, I don’t understand your remark regarding it. I may not be a lawyer, but have plenty of experience with legislation in education and understand only too well how schools can make blanket statements without realising they are walking into a potential midfield. I expect the school in question wanted to limit numbers for practical and fire safety reasons. I guess they thought a blanket sibling ban was fair. I doubt they thought through the implications of banning breastfeeding woman from attending with her <6 month old. No doubt they felt that allowing this Mum to bring her child would in some way ‘open the floodgates’ but of course it wouldn’t. The sibling ban could still be applied. HTs use their discretion. They do not ‘ban’ babies. They request cooperation so that events such as nativity plays run smoothly. They don’t have legal powers to prevent any parent bringing a child into the school premises.

luxxlisbon · 24/11/2022 20:24

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 20:10

I don’t think a HT can ban a baby from entering the school premises

Of course they can, just as they are banning all other older siblings too. No kids other than those preforming.
A pretty basic and easy to follow rule, unless you’re a total dick.