Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not allowed siblings at my sons nativity play .. including my breast fed baby??

793 replies

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:28

My daughter is 4 months old and breastfeeding.

My two other sons are involved in the school nativity play. The school will be having two performers one at 2:30 and one at 7:00.

I have been informed that the school has a ‘no sibling rule’ to watching so I will not be allowed to bring my daughter. The issue is these times are both when she has milk.

I was also told by the head that she may make noise and interrupt the performance !!

Really sad as I don’t want to miss it ! But do not feel happy leaving my baby at these times!

OP posts:
NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 23:16

fannyfartlet · 24/11/2022 23:09

Your opinion is BS though and you have again stated that the rule isn't legal and it is totally within the right of the school to do this. You are again spouting your opinion which is factually inaccurate, but please feel free to continue to do so. And you're right, it isn't a complex case but a very simple one.

So tell me, when a HT imposes a ‘no sibling rule’, how would it actually be enforced? Is it a request, issued by the HT to guide parental expectation and behaviour or is it a legally enforceable rule, if broken sanctions to be applied by the judiciary after reporting to police and case being prepared for CPS? If a parent raised a complaint against this ‘rule’ the HT would use their skills in diplomacy and apply commonsense to resolve the issue. As a Headteacher you can create rules for the children of the school, and apply your own sanctions, but you are confusing rules and requests and guidance issued by schools with laws, such as no parking etc. a headteacher can’t apply to the courts if a parent brings a sibling to the school nativity. At a push they could pursue the complaints policy internally and ban them from the premises but very unlikely, particularly given the sensitivity of this issue.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 24/11/2022 23:14

Seems harsh to me. DD school always state that babies are welcome as long as we leave if they cause a disturbance. DS used to breastfeed right through (he was virtually welded to my boob at 4 months, no chance of bringing feeds forward or back!).

RamsayEaster · 24/11/2022 23:12

@NastyPastie

The OP doesn’t NEED to have her baby with her , she has a partner / sister who can sit with the baby

If the baby feeds on demand how on earth does she know the baby will need fed then at the time she would be at the play

If OP is in a routine 30 mins out isn’t going to kill mum or baby

What OP will have is two deviates little boys who didn’t see their mummy at their Nativity

OP isnt being discriminated against because she is breastfeeding

The school rule is no siblings - the day is about the kids in the show I’m sure you could give them that

fannyfartlet · 24/11/2022 23:09

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 23:04

I have as much right as you to post my opinion and won’t be bullied about it. The ‘rule’ that the school imposed is not legal. It is a request. It has no legal basis and would not be enforced. Your attitude is thoroughly unpleasant an unsupportive to the OP. We are talking about a mum wanting to watch her children in a nativity play. Not a complex discrimination case that only qualified solicitors can pass comment on.

Your opinion is BS though and you have again stated that the rule isn't legal and it is totally within the right of the school to do this. You are again spouting your opinion which is factually inaccurate, but please feel free to continue to do so. And you're right, it isn't a complex case but a very simple one.

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 23:04

I have as much right as you to post my opinion and won’t be bullied about it. The ‘rule’ that the school imposed is not legal. It is a request. It has no legal basis and would not be enforced. Your attitude is thoroughly unpleasant an unsupportive to the OP. We are talking about a mum wanting to watch her children in a nativity play. Not a complex discrimination case that only qualified solicitors can pass comment on.

fannyfartlet · 24/11/2022 23:00

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 19:15

But her right to have her baby with her is protected by equality law. Like it or not. This trumps the ‘no sibling’ rule that the school have enforced. The HT should be aware of this an should of course admit babies under 6 months of age without question

Irrelevant as a school is NOT a public place. Stop posting shit that you think you understand when you have no proper knowledge of the legislation.

RamsayEaster · 24/11/2022 22:54

@restingbitchface30

Would you honestly take 4 month old twins into a nativity and not give a s if they started getting restless , crying etc and disrupted the play

I really don’t get it 😞

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 22:47

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 24/11/2022 22:42

The voice of reason

Ha, good one!

I don’t understand this place

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 22:44

Blueink · 24/11/2022 22:36

Huh?! Unless she is unwell or some other factor (which OP hasn’t mentioned) a 4 month old baby wouldn’t typically feed more than 2 hourly. If OP is in in U.K. right now dehydration is very unlikely. OP/her baby also seems to be feeding on something of a schedule.

I was encouraging the OP to go if she wants to and not feel she has to miss out if she cannot get an exception to attend. I never made any comment about breastfeeding in public or anything about what should or shouldn’t be allowed at the nativity. Having a rant is not helpful to the OP.

You said she ‘should’. I simply questioned why should she have to change what she is doing in line with other people’s views. You say ‘having a rant’ is not helpful to the OP. I doubt the OP will ever return for us to find out. I most definitely am concerned to help the OP and will rant as much as I like about it if that is what you call people have a discussion on a discussion forum

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 24/11/2022 22:42

The voice of reason

Ha, good one!

Blueink · 24/11/2022 22:36

Huh?! Unless she is unwell or some other factor (which OP hasn’t mentioned) a 4 month old baby wouldn’t typically feed more than 2 hourly. If OP is in in U.K. right now dehydration is very unlikely. OP/her baby also seems to be feeding on something of a schedule.

I was encouraging the OP to go if she wants to and not feel she has to miss out if she cannot get an exception to attend. I never made any comment about breastfeeding in public or anything about what should or shouldn’t be allowed at the nativity. Having a rant is not helpful to the OP.

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 22:22

Blueink · 24/11/2022 22:14

At 4 months she should be able to manage a couple of hours after a feed and not need you on constant standby. Perhaps start to bring the timing of her feeds slightly forwards in the lead up. If possible express and freeze milk so your sister can offer this as a back up, but not sure how necessary this is, surely the nativity will be a fairly short event.

She doesn’t have to ‘manage’ though. She can just feed her baby the way she has been doing in line with every bit of advice and support she has received until this point. Maybe the midwives in hospital should alter their guidance to say don’t feed on demand, actually consider bringing feeds forward, express and freeze milk so your sister can feed your baby and be aware that primary schools do not welcome babies that cry to nativity plays, harvest festivals, Easter services and so forth, but don’t worry they are only short. You and your baby will be fine, your baby won’t become dehydrated and you should really learn that, although you are perfectly welcome to feed your baby in cafes, restaurants, on buses, in libraries, sometimes people feel very uncomfortable about the fact that you will feel you have an equal right to share space with other people, and they will insist that although you are welcome, your baby is not. But that is just life, not discrimination. So keep up the good work now, get the latch right, feed constantly if needs be to build up your supply, relax, try not to feel uncomfortable feeding in front of others… it won’t be until about the four month mark that people will start feeling that your presence is an inconvenience to them.

Blueink · 24/11/2022 22:14

At 4 months she should be able to manage a couple of hours after a feed and not need you on constant standby. Perhaps start to bring the timing of her feeds slightly forwards in the lead up. If possible express and freeze milk so your sister can offer this as a back up, but not sure how necessary this is, surely the nativity will be a fairly short event.

Dacadactyl · 24/11/2022 22:04

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 22:03

I don’t understand the vitriol - working in a school, realistically we ask for no siblings. Mum turns up with babe in arms. She isn’t going to barge into the hall. She’s going to queue up with everyone else and walk in and the school aren’t going to consider it trespassing because they know she is a mum with a child at the school who has been invited to attend. The ‘no sibling rule’ isn’t law. It doesn’t mean she can’t set foot in the school. It depends how she feels about it. Probably intimidated and belittled and. made to feel unwelcome judging by many posts. If it was me, years on from when I was more concerned about not causing other people to be inconvenienced in any way by my existence, I’d just walk in with my baby, as I do believe that in terms of equality legislation the school wouldn’t want to ask me to leave. Realistically my baby would be happier being fed than being left with someone in a car for a couple of hours.

The voice of reason

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 22:04

Crazyinlove123 · 24/11/2022 21:50

It’s quite simple really, if the school say no siblings just don’t take siblings. If you can’t leave them for whatever reason then you can’t go can you. It’s sad but hopefully one parent/grandparent can go to see the nativity.

That is your view. You could also enter into a dialogue with the school to clarify their position on bringing in small babies who are breastfeeding. If I satisfied with their response you could challenge it and/or complain. It is your right to do this.

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 22:03

I don’t understand the vitriol - working in a school, realistically we ask for no siblings. Mum turns up with babe in arms. She isn’t going to barge into the hall. She’s going to queue up with everyone else and walk in and the school aren’t going to consider it trespassing because they know she is a mum with a child at the school who has been invited to attend. The ‘no sibling rule’ isn’t law. It doesn’t mean she can’t set foot in the school. It depends how she feels about it. Probably intimidated and belittled and. made to feel unwelcome judging by many posts. If it was me, years on from when I was more concerned about not causing other people to be inconvenienced in any way by my existence, I’d just walk in with my baby, as I do believe that in terms of equality legislation the school wouldn’t want to ask me to leave. Realistically my baby would be happier being fed than being left with someone in a car for a couple of hours.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 24/11/2022 22:00

restingbitchface30 · 24/11/2022 21:41

Some of these replies are awful! I have 4 mo twins and trust me when the want feeding they want feeding! Why should the baby have to wait because the school doesn’t want the play ‘disrupted’. It’s a stupid rule. If the child can sit on a knee I can’t see why they can’t be there. Not everyone has family or friends around to watch their child/ren. I’m with you op.

So you’d take two 4 month olds who scream blue murder when they want feeding, and who cares if nobody can hear the play over the howling? How lovely.

Crazyinlove123 · 24/11/2022 21:50

It’s quite simple really, if the school say no siblings just don’t take siblings. If you can’t leave them for whatever reason then you can’t go can you. It’s sad but hopefully one parent/grandparent can go to see the nativity.

restingbitchface30 · 24/11/2022 21:41

Some of these replies are awful! I have 4 mo twins and trust me when the want feeding they want feeding! Why should the baby have to wait because the school doesn’t want the play ‘disrupted’. It’s a stupid rule. If the child can sit on a knee I can’t see why they can’t be there. Not everyone has family or friends around to watch their child/ren. I’m with you op.

Volhhg · 24/11/2022 21:39

That's ridiculous not to allow siblings, no idea why the school are being so precious about this. Did they actually specify not even a babe in arms? I doubt it. Just put baby in a sling and turn up they won't send you away. Lots of parents at my kids school plays come with younger siblings because they're single parents or the other parent is working and they have no childcare. It seems really OTT of the school to have such rules and is definitely not the norm at schools in my northern city. Is this a strange competitive London school thing?

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 21:38

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 21:32

But she wouldn’t would she? She’d take the baby in and the school wouldn’t ring the police because they are in the real world. What head is going to call the police to prevent a woman from watching her own child in the play?

As explained in my previous post, you'd need to know something about the physical layout of the place to ascertain whether OP could barge into the hall or not. Our hall could be blocked, perhaps theirs could.

Still, I suppose we should all be glad you've abandoned the legal arguments.

Dacadactyl · 24/11/2022 21:36

OMG this thread has gone ridiculous😂People are just bonkers.

OP, hope you get to watch the nativity xx

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 24/11/2022 21:34

I tend to apply a basic rule of thumb that if I have to rely on someone not calling the police to get what I want, I shouldn’t be doing whatever I’m thinking of doing. But that’s just me.

NastyPastie · 24/11/2022 21:32

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 21:26

Yes, can you actually imagine what a twat OP would make of herself if she turned up with the baby and told them they'd have to phone the police to stop her trespassing? She'd be legendary!

But she wouldn’t would she? She’d take the baby in and the school wouldn’t ring the police because they are in the real world. What head is going to call the police to prevent a woman from watching her own child in the play?

CaronPoivre · 24/11/2022 21:29

keeprunning55 · 24/11/2022 20:59

This has turned into a rather bizarre rant at how unfair life is & we should all just accept it.
I’ve been an infant teacher doing nativities for a very, very long time. I have never seen a child upset by a baby crying.
Last year’s nativities were the worst as they had to be filmed out in the freezing cold at my school with nobody watching live thanks to covid.
Let’s try and gain some perspective here.

I’m not a teacher but have been to many, many nativities.

I agree it’s not the children who get upset and generally it’s not the little ones who are disruptive. Some parents tend to be far more selfish and inconsiderate, standing up, taking phone calls, taking photos, talking loudly.