Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not allowed siblings at my sons nativity play .. including my breast fed baby??

793 replies

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:28

My daughter is 4 months old and breastfeeding.

My two other sons are involved in the school nativity play. The school will be having two performers one at 2:30 and one at 7:00.

I have been informed that the school has a ‘no sibling rule’ to watching so I will not be allowed to bring my daughter. The issue is these times are both when she has milk.

I was also told by the head that she may make noise and interrupt the performance !!

Really sad as I don’t want to miss it ! But do not feel happy leaving my baby at these times!

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 23/11/2022 21:38

You're being a bit precious.

Many have offered suggestions.

Your baby will very likely be just fine if fed early.
Even if your baby does start to cry at home while you're gone for an hour, so what! Your baby isn't going to go kaboom for crying.

Let the kids on the stage have their special moment.

BoardingSchoolMater · 23/11/2022 21:31

Interesting, @thenewduchessoflapland, as our children must be similar ages, but it couldn't have been more different. If one particular class put on some kind of show, their siblings in other classes were positively encouraged to attend, regardless of whether they were in Year 8 or Nursery. Schools clearly vary!

thenewduchessoflapland · 23/11/2022 21:28

The banning of siblings at the annual snorefest god am I glad I don't have to sit through that shite anymore nativity play has been going on since my nearly 19 year old was in infant school.

However my kids infant school allowed siblings in for the dress rehearsal.

It's only one feed on one day you'll have to muck about with however your other DC which be delighted to see you;the reason I always went was the fact I'd always see the kids faces searching out their parents in the audience which is why I always felt bad for the parents with weekday hours jobs.It's great the school does a 7pm show;how very thoughtful of them.

Munches · 23/11/2022 21:23

Our HT takes no shit. She’s great and I have a great relationship with her.
We have parents only performances and there is a few with siblings allowed I think, but our head does say if the siblings make noise and cry or whatever, then the parents will have to take them out.
It’s about the children in the Nativity as someone up thread said , not about their families. Nothing worse than watching a gorgeous little nativity play and having to listen other people’s kids screaming / whining etc and you miss out on your child’s one and only line or whatever. It’s ridiculous. And very unfair.

MatronicO6 · 23/11/2022 21:20

As a teacher, who has put on many nativities over the years, it's fair. It is so heartbreaking when kids put all that work in, make sure they learn their lines, build up the confidence to say those lines in a room full of people for them to be put off over a crying or cooing baby. I have had 5 year olds in tears over this. It's not fair on them or their parents who are desperate to see and hear their little ones.

There cannot be an exception to the rule, if one gets it, everyone will expect the same. Contrary to what PP's have said, t's actually not about the families or the community, it's about the kids performing, it is their time to shine.

I would work the baby timetable around, it's one day.

Munches · 23/11/2022 21:17

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:35

I could do this but she is not happy usually at these times. I may try and do a test run to see how she is and if I can leave her. My husband can attend the evening to at least he will see it.
i feel that in this day and age I shouldn’t be put in this position.

I think you are being a bit precious to be honest.
I can understand if it was a whole day or hours even, but maximum will be around an hour. It really is not a big deal.

I’ve been there and got the t shirt . Your child will cope without you for an hour.

bangersandmash2 · 23/11/2022 21:06

I don't think the feeding habits of the baby give it a special pass - I'd expect any younger siblings to be welcome, on the basis a lot of parents couldn't come if they weren't able to bring them. For me that trumps being able to hear every line in perfect silence. (And goes without saying crying children shld be taken out.)
And with regards the shy child - suspect that's still more about the parents being able to bask in their child's line, doubt the child cares that much.

Neanov · 23/11/2022 21:02

Disgusted at MN about smuggling the baby in good one until everyone turns around looking at OP with an unsettled baby... usually MN are one to follow rules 🤣

SpideyCraw · 23/11/2022 20:58

Stompythedinosaur · 23/11/2022 18:43

The Equalities Act literally says it is discriminatory to treat a woman disfavourably because she is breastfeeding. So I'm pretty clear it is discrimination.

I'm aware that only paying businesses are covered by the act, so there's no reason a school cannot choose to discriminate (except, y'know, a moral reason).

I’m a discrimination lawyer and you have fundamentally misunderstood this. It is not discrimination.

The Equality Act does not entitle you to take a breastfed baby wherever you please otherwise discrimination.

antelopevalley · 23/11/2022 20:53

@bangersandmash2 It is not a professional performance. But it is very upsetting for the shy children if no one can hear them because of noisy toddler or baby.
It is for the benefit of the children performing. Not their families.

StClare101 · 23/11/2022 20:51

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:35

I could do this but she is not happy usually at these times. I may try and do a test run to see how she is and if I can leave her. My husband can attend the evening to at least he will see it.
i feel that in this day and age I shouldn’t be put in this position.

Yes of course. Your desire to watch absolutely trumps every other parent 🙄

bangersandmash2 · 23/11/2022 20:50

Not very family friendly! It's a school Xmas play - the important thing is having family there - it's not a professional performance. I thought a school would be more community minded

RightBackAtYa · 23/11/2022 20:49

I support HTs on this
Don't just turn up and expect to be the exception to the rule, you'll make yourself very unpopular, you and every other parent have been told no siblings, so you make arrangements or don't go-the choice is yours

CarefreeMe · 23/11/2022 20:44

It’s very rubbish if you are a single parent but I do understand why they do it.

My DDs was 1 parent only and no partners or siblings and there were 2 performances so each parent could go separately and then it would be filmed and sold on DVD for any extended family members to watch.

THEDEACON · 23/11/2022 20:44

You are entitled If an exception was made for you every other sibling would need to be there too Just gobor don't go there is no go and take baby too option

stuntbubbles · 23/11/2022 20:43

Feetupteashot · 23/11/2022 20:42

Smuggle her in under a big baggy top

Dress her as a sheep and sneak her onstage. “Wah wah!” is pretty close to “Bah bah!”

kierenthecommunity · 23/11/2022 20:42

I can’t believe any mother would even contemplate missing her child’s nativity play. I am in a senior role and make sure every parent on my team gets to their child’s and can make up the work time if needed. Some moments in a child’s life are precious

Well, while it’s fantastic you’re a manager who appreciates the importance of work-life balance, and works for a company that can support flexible working, it’s not beyond your imagination that not all women have the luxury of being able to ‘contemplate’ or otherwise?

Feetupteashot · 23/11/2022 20:42

Smuggle her in under a big baggy top

BoardingSchoolMater · 23/11/2022 20:40

Whenever I go to any school function, I have one thing on my mind. MY child. I want to see my child, sing, dance, say the lines we practiced at home etc

I considered nativity plays etc to be a more 'community' thing than a 'my child is so important' thing. My children are obviously the most important people on the planet for me, but I do also appreciate that other people regard their children in the same way. Anyway, there was always one child who didn't stick to the perfectly-rehearsed script and who caused great merriment. But I appreciate that times have changed and parents now tend to regard their own children as the centre of the universe. Which we all do, obviously - but in the ancient past, we also recognised that other parents thought their own children were the most brilliant creatures ever born, including babes in arms and toddler siblings. We all smiled and understood, because we all felt the same. It's a shame if it's now 'each family for their own'.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 23/11/2022 20:38

geraniumsandsunshine · 23/11/2022 20:08

What!!! Shes a babe in arms. I'd pop her in a sling and turn up anyway. She won't make noise at that age- you just plug her into the boob!

Ah yes, we all know breastfed babies never cry. 🙄

One side effect of the hideous "breast is best" campaign (or rather, its smug campaigners) is that some breastfeeding women think they're some special and protected caste who can bring their baby anywhere.

Algor1thm · 23/11/2022 20:33

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:35

I could do this but she is not happy usually at these times. I may try and do a test run to see how she is and if I can leave her. My husband can attend the evening to at least he will see it.
i feel that in this day and age I shouldn’t be put in this position.

she's not happily usually at these times

She has 2 parents though right? That's up for dad to deal with... Feed her before you go so she's not hungry. Do you have to be the one there if she's unsettled? Does your husband never give you a break when she's crying?

I had an EBF baby but this wouldn't have been a big deal at 4 months. She's not a week old. 4 month olds can easily go a couple of hours between feeds and find other sources if comfort inbetween. And she's definitely old enough to ruin a performance by crying or shrieking.

geraniumsandsunshine · 23/11/2022 20:30

OK OK everyone... my school doesn't have issues with babies or even toddlers coming. I've taken my little one and he was fine because he was only a few months but if he hadn't been, I would have removed it. I've only got my DD school to base it one though so I don't know what the OPs auditiorium is like in terms of seating and space

NerrSnerr · 23/11/2022 20:29

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:35

I could do this but she is not happy usually at these times. I may try and do a test run to see how she is and if I can leave her. My husband can attend the evening to at least he will see it.
i feel that in this day and age I shouldn’t be put in this position.

If your baby isn't happy at those times it's best not to take them. I speak from experience it is so massively stressful having an unsettled baby/ toddler at a school event. Avoid taking them at all costs.

Catcharolo · 23/11/2022 20:29

That’s so not standard!!
Maybe in 2020 😷 but not now, and not before! There would be a lot of complaints if they said that at our school. We are allowed to bring as many relatives and siblings as we like. With mulled wine afterwards! It’s really not festive to ban babies from the nativity

mumonherphone · 23/11/2022 20:29

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 17:53

This is my first time posting on here and hoped it would be a supportive community.

some of the comments have been very helpful and made me look at the whole picture and see all sides. I will try and attend and leave my daughter ( after a feed) with my sister if she is happy, otherwise I will not attend , my husband will go in the evening. Due to safe guarding the school will not allow filming which is fair enough.

I am concerned with some of the rude comments. You can get your point across without being nasty about it! All I did was ask a question.

Thanks for those that’s gave constructive criticism I appreciate your time.

Op I breastfed my baby on demand and he wouldn't take a bottle, even of pumped out milk. It was very stressful and the amount of people that said "haven't you just fed him"/ "can't you feed him before you leave the house?" etc.. they just don't get it. It's not just about the milk it's also that babies' comfort. He wouldn't have a dummy or anything, just my boobs and then went to a sippy cup of water and solid food at 5 months. Never drank a bottle in his life.

This situation would have caused me anxiety and I really get it, but your baby isn't going to starve during a nativity play and will be safe with your sister even if she cries the whole time. Now my child is six I think I would go to the nativity if I had another breastfed baby as I wouldn't want to miss his nativity for the world. But you have my sympathy, not everyone understands why you can't just feed them before you leave the house and think everything will be alright. A breastfed baby at a nativity play isn't the same as other older siblings in my opinion.