Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not allowed siblings at my sons nativity play .. including my breast fed baby??

793 replies

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:28

My daughter is 4 months old and breastfeeding.

My two other sons are involved in the school nativity play. The school will be having two performers one at 2:30 and one at 7:00.

I have been informed that the school has a ‘no sibling rule’ to watching so I will not be allowed to bring my daughter. The issue is these times are both when she has milk.

I was also told by the head that she may make noise and interrupt the performance !!

Really sad as I don’t want to miss it ! But do not feel happy leaving my baby at these times!

OP posts:
stuntbubbles · 24/11/2022 02:44

No is seeking legal advice or taking a school to court over a half-hour nativity play, FFS. And no one is discriminating against breastfeeding mothers. The fact of being breastfed in general isn’t a Get Out of Jail (Or Into Nativity) Free card: OP has said the baby is cranky at this time, what if she’s crying/screaming/“fussing” (almost worse than screaming – most parents will exit at screaming, but merrily disturb everyone for yonks with ongoing fussing), she’s not breastfeeding then, is she? She’s crying.

By the “but breastfeeding!” defence brigade logic, OP should also be allowed up on stage to do it. No one can stop her! It’s the law!

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 24/11/2022 02:34

britneyisfree · 24/11/2022 02:29

Yeah that'll stand up in court. Adult only function at a school comparable to a night club? Be serious. @JennyNotFromTheBlock

It's an analogy, @britneyisfree . What I'm saying is that it's ridiculous to say it's illegal when it ever so clearly is not illegal. It's legal to have adults only functions or places. In fact, it's a legislated right.

britneyisfree · 24/11/2022 02:29

Yeah that'll stand up in court. Adult only function at a school comparable to a night club? Be serious. @JennyNotFromTheBlock

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 24/11/2022 02:24

britneyisfree · 24/11/2022 02:10

Breastfeeding isn’t a protected characteristic under the equality act and there is no legal prohibition on indirectly discriminating against breastfeeding women specifically.

Not a specific characteristic no but it is protected. We even had to let people bring their breastfeeding child into uni if they wanted to. Illegal to say no. People talk so much shit.

Not when the rule states no children, point blank. It's the same as places that are adults only, like strip clubs or concerts etc. It is not a protected characteristic, RTFT where others have explained this. Adults only functions or performances are legal.

britneyisfree · 24/11/2022 02:10

Breastfeeding isn’t a protected characteristic under the equality act and there is no legal prohibition on indirectly discriminating against breastfeeding women specifically.

Not a specific characteristic no but it is protected. We even had to let people bring their breastfeeding child into uni if they wanted to. Illegal to say no. People talk so much shit.

britneyisfree · 24/11/2022 02:08

Illegal.

Breastfeeding is an exemption under the equality act 2010 they can't not allow you entry with her full stop.

Ignore people who just tell you to find another way, you don't have to.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 24/11/2022 01:23

The no siblings rule is usually introduced for the benefit of the children performing, not any of the adults.

Quite. And it's really sad that some posters are not getting this. That it's about the children performing, not about the adult themselves. That they see it as being all about them and not the children whose work it is, says a lot about their priorities. They can't even put their own needs and wants aside for children.

SpideyCraw · 24/11/2022 01:22

Discrimination, not discontinuation sorry

SpideyCraw · 24/11/2022 01:21

Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 00:56

So, "no siblings" is a blanket restriction. A blanket restriction can be discriminatory if it disproportionately effects a protected group, in this case a section of women.

The school can still do it if they choose.

I think the entitlement is the adults who want to prioritise their own right to be undisturbed above some dc's wish to have their parent come to their play.

If your argument is that applying a policy of not having siblings to an event is indirectly discriminatory because it puts women at a particular disadvantage (because they are more likely to have caring responsibilities) then a) that’s got nothing to do with breastfeeding specifically, it would apply to women with the additional care of any child and b) it’s legally capable of being justifiable as being a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. This would probably be dressed up as “promoting the educational enhancement of the students by providing a quiet environment for their performance” or something but ultimately comes down to it not being fair on the students to have their performance disrupted by there being shitloads of pre-school children in the audience.

Breastfeeding isn’t a protected characteristic under the equality act and there is no legal prohibition on indirectly discriminating against breastfeeding women specifically.

there is a specific provision about unfavourable treatment of bf women but that isn’t the same thing as indirect discontinuation, and doesn’t give a positive right to take a baby somewhere you otherwise wouldn’t be able to.

Henuinequest · 24/11/2022 01:15

Move on. There’s no room,
and/or if they make an exception for you everyone will be whinging about their child: toddler/‘baby with the special circs… and yes your baby may put the kids off or make a distraction so just deal with it.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 01:14

Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 00:56

So, "no siblings" is a blanket restriction. A blanket restriction can be discriminatory if it disproportionately effects a protected group, in this case a section of women.

The school can still do it if they choose.

I think the entitlement is the adults who want to prioritise their own right to be undisturbed above some dc's wish to have their parent come to their play.

The no siblings rule is usually introduced for the benefit of the children performing, not any of the adults.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 24/11/2022 01:10

Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 00:56

So, "no siblings" is a blanket restriction. A blanket restriction can be discriminatory if it disproportionately effects a protected group, in this case a section of women.

The school can still do it if they choose.

I think the entitlement is the adults who want to prioritise their own right to be undisturbed above some dc's wish to have their parent come to their play.

Some discriminations are necessary, to protect people's rights, such as the rights of the children in the class in this case. Being a woman with extra kids is not a protected characteristic. And it's entitled and selfish to think because you had more than one child, that you have the right to interrupt the whole classes work. Only someone extremely entitled and selfish would put themselves above 30 odd other children. You either find a babysitter or you don't go. It really is that simple. And it should not even need to be explained. Some places you can't take babies and children. That is what society is about.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 00:56

So, "no siblings" is a blanket restriction. A blanket restriction can be discriminatory if it disproportionately effects a protected group, in this case a section of women.

The school can still do it if they choose.

I think the entitlement is the adults who want to prioritise their own right to be undisturbed above some dc's wish to have their parent come to their play.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 00:45

Mañanarama · 23/11/2022 19:27

You are joking? Breastfeeding mums cannot leave their babies for an hour, ever? What an absolute load of rubbish!!

…. if you can’t manage that you’re doing it wrong.

I mean, my dc are plenty older now, but no, at 4 months I was still feeding on demand.

Glad to know you think I was "doing it wrong". Astonishing the dc have made it the high school, really.

If only I'd known that the actual god of parenting was available to dispense advice on mn. I'm sure I could have learnt so much.

UWhatNow · 24/11/2022 00:35

“It’s nothing to do with breastfeeding. If the baby needs to be with mum then the mum can stay at home, or outside of the school.

The mum is not obliged to attend the show. No one will force her. She won’t be held at gun point. Nobody is denying the baby access to its milk. It is the mums choice to attend alone or stay at home with the baby. That’s it. It shouldn’t even be up for debate.

Honestly it’s not rocket science. So many entitled idiots.”

So entitled that they get indignant even when the bleeding obvious is pointed out to them. But of course they’re special and the rules don’t apply to them… 🙄

DuplicateUserName · 23/11/2022 23:52

In fact the only person denying the baby access to milk would be the mother, if she insisted on attending the nativity.

But again, possibly too simple for some to understand.

DuplicateUserName · 23/11/2022 23:51

FlissyPaps · 23/11/2022 23:44

You are completely missing the point.

It’s nothing to do with breastfeeding. If the baby needs to be with mum then the mum can stay at home, or outside of the school.

The mum is not obliged to attend the show. No one will force her. She won’t be held at gun point. Nobody is denying the baby access to its milk. It is the mums choice to attend alone or stay at home with the baby. That’s it. It shouldn’t even be up for debate.

Honestly it’s not rocket science. So many entitled idiots.

Exactly @FlissyPaps

It's so so simple

I genuinely cannot understand why so many on this thread just don't understand it.

They see the words 'banned', 'breastfed' and 'baby' and lose all sense of comprehension it seems.

FlissyPaps · 23/11/2022 23:44

FatGirlSwim · 23/11/2022 23:03

It has everything to do with breastfeeding because a breastfed baby needs to be with mum.

You are completely missing the point.

It’s nothing to do with breastfeeding. If the baby needs to be with mum then the mum can stay at home, or outside of the school.

The mum is not obliged to attend the show. No one will force her. She won’t be held at gun point. Nobody is denying the baby access to its milk. It is the mums choice to attend alone or stay at home with the baby. That’s it. It shouldn’t even be up for debate.

Honestly it’s not rocket science. So many entitled idiots.

TheKeatingFive · 23/11/2022 23:43

your understanding is wrong.

I can't say one way or the other. However if the OP wants clarity on the legals I'm suggesting she look outside of this thread. It's a topic that seems to generate a lot of heat on here.

DuplicateUserName · 23/11/2022 23:38

@TheKeatingFive your understanding is wrong.

A mother is allowed to breastfeed (as long as it's safe to do so) anywhere that she and her baby are allowed to be, and in this case the baby is not allowed to be there.

Just like I couldn't march into a nightclub with a baby and demand they let us in as it's breastfed.

Ditto trying to march into anywhere that babies aren't allowed.

CloudyYellow · 23/11/2022 23:32

In my experience parents of crying babies rarely leave the hall.

CloudyYellow · 23/11/2022 23:31

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:35

I could do this but she is not happy usually at these times. I may try and do a test run to see how she is and if I can leave her. My husband can attend the evening to at least he will see it.
i feel that in this day and age I shouldn’t be put in this position.

Why do you think you have the right to potentially ruin the play if your baby cries?

You sound like hard work.

RamsayEaster · 23/11/2022 23:30

@Tiani4

I think everyone understands OP wants to watch her children but so does every other parent and watch the nativity in peace not to be interrupted by a 4 month old or the mother trying to settle them

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 23/11/2022 23:27

Tiani4 · 23/11/2022 23:26

Omg it's a baby
A bf baby
I have 3 DCs, got abandoned by my now ex H early on even when wee were married, and my primary school has never excluded me

Babies don't often cry as you can't feed or calm them or take them out. Utterly ridiculous that a primary school os making untenable riles. Op ofc isn't selfish she just wants to see her primary aged child at this event

Jess the entitlement from PPs in this thread!

Other parents also want to see and to hear their child, the level of entitlement of parents who only think of themselves and bring crying babies to events like this is off the charts!

Tiani4 · 23/11/2022 23:26

Can not can't! Lolz