Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not allowed siblings at my sons nativity play .. including my breast fed baby??

793 replies

WinnieLovett · 23/11/2022 16:28

My daughter is 4 months old and breastfeeding.

My two other sons are involved in the school nativity play. The school will be having two performers one at 2:30 and one at 7:00.

I have been informed that the school has a ‘no sibling rule’ to watching so I will not be allowed to bring my daughter. The issue is these times are both when she has milk.

I was also told by the head that she may make noise and interrupt the performance !!

Really sad as I don’t want to miss it ! But do not feel happy leaving my baby at these times!

OP posts:
Barbie222 · 24/11/2022 18:05

i feel that in this day and age I shouldn’t be put in this position.

It's about putting the children in the performance first though and not impinging their one moment to speak with a noisy sibling, though, isn't it? I think schools are right to hold firm on this.

alizee21g · 24/11/2022 18:01

I've not read whole 20 pages but I wouldn't be happy with that rule. It's not.just about baby being breasted but having childcare available. I've had literally no one to look after my youngest at that age, it was just me and their dad who was always at work. Had i not been allowed to bring her with me I'd not seen my eldest christmas Concert at all. Never had an issues bringing baby to school performances at our school x

Fbearsmum · 24/11/2022 17:59

From the other side, at the leavers assembly my friend couldn't hear her dds speech due to a non stop crying baby. She'll never get that moment again and it was inaudible on various recordings. The mother didn't take the baby out so we all missed a lot of the speeches too.

Desdichado · 24/11/2022 17:56

Irridescantshimmmer · 23/11/2022 17:58

Your baby needs feeding then you feed her because the school will be breaking the law by stopping you from BF your baby.

"The Equality Act 2010 says that it is discrimination to treat a woman unfavourably because she is breastfeeding. It applies to anyone providing services, benefits, facilities and premises to the public, public bodies, further and higher education bodies and association. Service providers include most organisations that deal directly with the public."

Maternity Action

Nobody is stopping her feeding the baby. They are stopping the baby attending the performance, but this isn't limited to babies, it is siblings of any age. Hardly discriminatory. 🙄

amispeakingintongues · 24/11/2022 17:52

Very unreasonable of them OP and discriminatory towards you. You have a breastfed baby with you not a whining toddler. Just go and keep the boob in the mouth and sit by an exit. The school surely won’t cause a scene and escort a breastfeeding mum from a nativity?! Give me strength.

Tessabelle74 · 24/11/2022 17:49

This day and age?? What?? A baby crying through the performance at any day and age is unfair on the other parents, and if they let you bring your baby, then Molly's mum will want to bring her 2 year old because you have a sibling, then Jonny's mum will too and before you know it, it's chaos! I've breastfed 4 babies, all of them could have timings tweaked a bit, take her to the 2.30 show and leave her in the car with Dad then you can feed before you go in and as soon as you come out, then Dad can go in the evening it's not that complicated

Macca8 · 24/11/2022 17:49

This is completely normal as it's also to do with how many they can have in the hall for fire regulations. These things only last half an hour, you could try and feed a bit earlier there are probably a few mums in the same situation so if they let one they have to let everyone

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 24/11/2022 16:09

DayOfTheTentacle · 24/11/2022 14:40

....and why is that? why cant siblings go along like they used to and watch their family performing????? we are not talking high art....these are little kids....performing for family...honestly....so precious with all this crap about 'but I want to see just my child and hear them' life will be hard for your kids if you are going to get them expecting exceptionism.....Panto's? full of kids....babies breastfeeding and these are professional performers....truly....too much being uber precious for nothing.

Just as a little point. Life is hard for some children, just getting through each day is difficult.

Children who are neurodiverse, who have sensory issues, who need the smaller accomodations that you wouldn't necessarily notice.

My DC wants to be able to be in the class nativity, wants to be the same as his mates, desperately wants to be able to say his line loudly and clearly, but finds it incredibly difficult and stressful just being in a room full of people.

Babies crying when he's trying to concentrate would stress him terribly. He would already be on the edge and quite tightly wound. Somebody's fussy baby crying resulting in him missing his prompt could tip him over the edge into full panic and meltdown.

It's not theater, or professional, it's little children who have worked hard and overcome all sorts of obstacles that you can't see. They deserve the best chance to not have that ruined by someone else's whinging little sister.

You are 100% right, @DayOfTheTentacle - the children performing the play are the stars of the nativity, not the siblings of the performers, or anyone else in the audience. They should all be given the best possible chance to perform their part in the play, and when there are children who need as calm an atmosphere as possible, like your son, this should absolutely be the priority.

I hope he gets to enjoy being part of the nativity this year.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 15:56

pinkyredrose · 24/11/2022 15:03

😂

I genuinely laughed at this.
Can I bring a donkey to add to the immersive manger experience? Maybe a few sheep?

ButterCrackers · 24/11/2022 15:46

Dacadactyl · 24/11/2022 14:50

While I sympathise; you are asking for exceptions to be made for your child, just like the breastfeeding mother is.

This child is a pupil at the school. Their needs come before that of non pupils. That’s the way it works at schools fortunately - everything will be done (I hope) to enable all kids to take part in the event

cantkeepawayforever · 24/11/2022 15:39

There are schools where, in certain year groups, there are no children who cannot be photographed. These are often schools in nice MN-favoured neighbourhoods.

There will also be schools where there is no year group that can be videoed.

And heads with some years that can be videoed may make a blanket 'no DVD ' rule for every year group, because there is nothing worse than all the parents looking at the foster mum or the new arrival in the playground and saying to one another 'well, we could have the performances filmed like Year 4 do if it wasn't for YOU'.

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 15:35

DVD / recording can be really difficult for safeguarding reasons, if there are children who cannot be photographed or filmed for all the obvious reasons of safety

Ok, sure, but DDs' school always managed it.

cantkeepawayforever · 24/11/2022 15:34

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 14:03

@Solonge

I suggested having one performance in the evening without siblings as they usually film one and do a DVD. It would be nice to actually hear the children on the DVD - lovely thing to look back on years later.

DVD / recording can be really difficult for safeguarding reasons, if there are children who cannot be photographed or filmed for all the obvious reasons of safety.

Some schools allow a 'whole cast' photo at the end (with adults briefed to quickly bundle certain children out of the way), but if there are too many children who can't be photographed, that becomes increasingly problematic. And for children who are already singled out and often isolated from family for many unavoidable and difficult reasons, saying they can't be in one of the performances because it's being filmed for everyone else's relatives is obviously unreasonable.

TallulahBetty · 24/11/2022 15:31

Hobnobswantshernameback · 24/11/2022 12:04

Ah nature is healing
first post covid nativity play hysteria I've seen for a while

Dear reader, I actually lol'ed.

SnotRag22 · 24/11/2022 15:21

Dacadactyl · 24/11/2022 14:50

While I sympathise; you are asking for exceptions to be made for your child, just like the breastfeeding mother is.

Yes, because he is a pupil at the school and he is the schools priority. Not Denise who doesn't want to leave her baby. He would (rightly) trump her.

pinkyredrose · 24/11/2022 15:03

Princessbananahamock · 23/11/2022 17:20

But the nativity is about a baby being born. Having little ones there can add to the sounds and smells of the manger a total immersive experience.
why can’t they live stream via a parent portal like teams or something?

😂

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 14:53

But I already know most parents do not really care about ND kids having access to all parts of the school curriculum. Most people are very selfish.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 14:52

@Dacadactyl Neuro diverse kids are pupils at the school. That is who the plays for and who the teachers primary concerns are. So their needs come first.

Dacadactyl · 24/11/2022 14:50

DayOfTheTentacle · 24/11/2022 14:40

....and why is that? why cant siblings go along like they used to and watch their family performing????? we are not talking high art....these are little kids....performing for family...honestly....so precious with all this crap about 'but I want to see just my child and hear them' life will be hard for your kids if you are going to get them expecting exceptionism.....Panto's? full of kids....babies breastfeeding and these are professional performers....truly....too much being uber precious for nothing.

Just as a little point. Life is hard for some children, just getting through each day is difficult.

Children who are neurodiverse, who have sensory issues, who need the smaller accomodations that you wouldn't necessarily notice.

My DC wants to be able to be in the class nativity, wants to be the same as his mates, desperately wants to be able to say his line loudly and clearly, but finds it incredibly difficult and stressful just being in a room full of people.

Babies crying when he's trying to concentrate would stress him terribly. He would already be on the edge and quite tightly wound. Somebody's fussy baby crying resulting in him missing his prompt could tip him over the edge into full panic and meltdown.

It's not theater, or professional, it's little children who have worked hard and overcome all sorts of obstacles that you can't see. They deserve the best chance to not have that ruined by someone else's whinging little sister.

While I sympathise; you are asking for exceptions to be made for your child, just like the breastfeeding mother is.

DayOfTheTentacle · 24/11/2022 14:40

....and why is that? why cant siblings go along like they used to and watch their family performing????? we are not talking high art....these are little kids....performing for family...honestly....so precious with all this crap about 'but I want to see just my child and hear them' life will be hard for your kids if you are going to get them expecting exceptionism.....Panto's? full of kids....babies breastfeeding and these are professional performers....truly....too much being uber precious for nothing.

Just as a little point. Life is hard for some children, just getting through each day is difficult.

Children who are neurodiverse, who have sensory issues, who need the smaller accomodations that you wouldn't necessarily notice.

My DC wants to be able to be in the class nativity, wants to be the same as his mates, desperately wants to be able to say his line loudly and clearly, but finds it incredibly difficult and stressful just being in a room full of people.

Babies crying when he's trying to concentrate would stress him terribly. He would already be on the edge and quite tightly wound. Somebody's fussy baby crying resulting in him missing his prompt could tip him over the edge into full panic and meltdown.

It's not theater, or professional, it's little children who have worked hard and overcome all sorts of obstacles that you can't see. They deserve the best chance to not have that ruined by someone else's whinging little sister.

Dacadactyl · 24/11/2022 14:27

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 23/11/2022 22:48

Yes we know it wouldn't bother you and you wouldn't give a shit, because you are that selfish that you don't care about anyone other than yourself. That is very clear from your posts.

This thread shows that the parents who want to take their children are the very same ones who are so pig ignorant and selfish they wouldn't take a crying baby out. These type of parents are the EXACT REASON the rules exist.

Lol OK then!! 😂

You must've missed my post (literally 2 posts or so under my initial comment) stating that my opinion comes with the caveat that OP is sat near a door and has the common sense to leave as soon as the baby starts fussing.

I mean, it's not rocket science. I would be dumbfounded if the school tell OP that a breastfeeding baby isn't allowed in. Never happened to me when I rang school and said I'd be bringing a baby. They know me and my family and it's the sort of school where parents and children know how to behave.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 14:09

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 14:03

@Solonge

I suggested having one performance in the evening without siblings as they usually film one and do a DVD. It would be nice to actually hear the children on the DVD - lovely thing to look back on years later.

That sounds like a sensible idea.

Pantos are different, the performers will be properly mic'ed up.

stuntbubbles · 24/11/2022 14:05

Solonge · 24/11/2022 13:49

Pretty sure the school could cope with that too....no?

Entirely different.

Four-month-old EBF baby spends 30 minutes with her aunt instead of her mother = the baby will cope and not notice/remember, her mother will cope and probably not notice/remember and in any case enjoy watching her older child, maaaaaybe at an Olympic-level stretch the aunt, who will cope, will not especially enjoy holding a grouchy baby.

Four-month-old baby grouches through 30-minute performance = affects every child in the nativity, every person in the audience, all the teachers, and mum, who ends up sneaking out with the baby anyway, literally no good outcome for anyone.

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 14:03

@Solonge

I suggested having one performance in the evening without siblings as they usually film one and do a DVD. It would be nice to actually hear the children on the DVD - lovely thing to look back on years later.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 13:56

And if I was a teacher I do not think I could be bothered doing extra stuff like plays that always causes issues with some difficult parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread