Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friendship ruined after holiday?

195 replies

ToFilmOrNotToFilm · 23/11/2022 14:49

Just came back from a long haul holiday with a childhood friend.

I'm very private and not a big photo taker. DF's the opposite.

We went to the national park on day 2, and our entire 5 hour walk was captured on video. I wouldn't mind so much if she'd just filmed the walk but I was in 70+% of the video because she didn't want it to look like some stock video taken off YouTube! Told her I didn't want to be in her videos but since she's not uploading it to social media apparently she doesn't see the big deal?

Got into an argument later that night and she simply could not understand that it doesn't matter if no one but her will see it!

Next few days were really uncomfortable, she didn't film anymore, just took a few pictures as she felt like she could find photos/videos on google if she wanted to remember the place. She won't film with just herself in the videos because she thinks it's awkward/pointless and I don't feel comfortable talking when I know the camera's rolling.

The whole trip was basically ruined tbh. Everyone was unhappy — she adopted this attitude of 'I'll just go look at pictures on google/YouTube' and I honestly really do not like having my every move recorded so wasn't going to compromise there.

Was I being unreasonable here? We haven't spoken since we came back. All those years of friendship and money down the drain. :(

OP posts:
Kinderslice · 24/11/2022 22:12

@Keyansier

Kinderslice · 24/11/2022 22:10

Disagree with you.
This is a generational/societal thing I think.
Unfortunately we're now in a place we're you're being snapped or videoed all the time and we do have to speak up and say no thanks !!

Toomuchtrouble4me · 24/11/2022 21:39

Keyansier · 23/11/2022 15:05

Completely disagree with this, I think the OP sounds quite entitled. If the friend is not known to be an influencer and isn't uploading videos of her in anywhere, then why should the OP care?

Also, the other poster mentioning 'permission' Hmm You can take a photo or video of anyone you want, it's not illegal.

It doesn’t matter that it seems trivial to you, or yo Op’s friend: “Why should the Op care” - she DOES care and that’s enough. You do not film people who do not wish to be filmed - end of. It’s not for another person to judge if she ought to allow it.
I would hate for my every move to be filmed, no way I’d be able to relax.

Booklover3 · 24/11/2022 21:19

I would absolutely hate this

DaughterofZion · 24/11/2022 21:01

Both of you are extreme. Op, why didn’t you suggest videoing her instead of her videoing you? That way, she got the memory and the journaling experience but you wouldn’t be in it. Since she’s your childhood friend, I feel like both of you could have handled things better with more compromise and kindness on both sides.

Bleachmycloths · 24/11/2022 20:37

Video/photo-taking friend sounds an absolute PITA. Very irritating and intrusive. I’d want to tell her to F**k off and leave me alone.

jazzybelle · 24/11/2022 20:34

ToFilmOrNotToFilm · 24/11/2022 18:01

The big deal is that it makes me feel tense when I know I'm walking with someone and they have the camera rolling permanently. All our conversations are being recorded, I have to watch where I am constantly if I don't want to be in the frame.

Has filming everything become so normalised now that we're not allowed to feel uncomfortable with being filmed by our friends while on holiday? Many people don't mind if their friend strapped an iPhone turned GoPro to their chest to record their entire day like we're on some TV show, even if it's not posted anywhere. Many do mind.

Well, that's your problem. The footage is not going to be shared. The holiday is over. Why are you making such an issue about it now? Forget it.

seafish · 24/11/2022 20:13

I think YABU. Since the video isn't going anywhere and just for memories I think it's harmless. I don't post pictures/videos but I like taking things for memories and looking back at them. Imagine watching that video 15 years from now and reminiscing, would be great to remember. Although I do think a heads up should be given.

FootieMama · 24/11/2022 20:09

OP you aren't being unreasonable at all. I dislike being filmed specially in someone's disse device. I will accept a few minutes if in a group . 5 hours is a lot!
I have friends that are very keen on social media and I dread girls night out because they are constantly taking pictures and making videos and get upset if I don't take part. I hate not being able to veto what images of me are posted online

Scooopsahoy · 24/11/2022 19:58

I never understand people like your friend - if you’re somewhere beautiful and amazing look at it through your own eyes, not through a small phone screen. Plus there’s nearly always professional photos/videos available which is going to be much better quality than a shaky iPhone.

I bet the vast majority of video she takes is never watched after the event anyway. Does she really while away a spare 5 hours watching your entire walk in real time?

amispeakingintongues · 24/11/2022 19:50

MoreTeaLessCoffee · 23/11/2022 15:13

You're both extreme. It's strange she feels such a strong need to film everything, particularly hours at a time. It's also strange that you are so dead set on not being recorded when it's not going anywhere public. You should both have met in the middle imo.

This

Bluegreenlily · 24/11/2022 19:47

YANBU At the end of the day, this was not something you wanted to compromise.
It ruined your holiday which should have been a lovely memory for both of you to remember.
But no matter what, this is a friend you have known for a long time and I believe you will not loose anything by trying to forget this unfortunate time, forgive her and continue your friendship. Time is too short, everyone have their quirky sides but other than what happened on holiday, if you enjoyed having her as your friend before,
take a forward step😊

LaDamaDeElche · 24/11/2022 19:45

MoreTeaLessCoffee · 23/11/2022 15:13

You're both extreme. It's strange she feels such a strong need to film everything, particularly hours at a time. It's also strange that you are so dead set on not being recorded when it's not going anywhere public. You should both have met in the middle imo.

This!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 24/11/2022 19:34

Oversharing, recording every event that takes place, is killing spontaneity and the enjoyment of the moment.

It would drive me insane if I'd gone on a break with someone doing this.

helpplease01 · 24/11/2022 19:33

You are well with in your rights to feel mighty pissed of with your friends moronic behaviour.
Of course you should ask permission to film someone in the first place.

But you should feel able to be straight up and say 'No' to the film being posted. Also, permission should be asked for prior to posting. It's common decency and manners.

venus7 · 24/11/2022 19:30

Keyansier · 24/11/2022 19:08

Er, no Confused

If I'm in someone's house (that I know and not just a random person) I will announce I am going to use their toilet. I don't ask for specific permission if I'm already in their house and I've been invited in.

Tbh though, I can hardly see how the two examples are comparable to each other in the first place.

They're not comparable; I was just pointing out that we often ask permission for things that are 'not illegal', as previous poster asserted.

Gagaandgag · 24/11/2022 19:18

I agree with you OP I dont like being in photos or videos either. She should respect that and move on

YDBear · 24/11/2022 19:15

After 27 years of marriage the number of pictures I have of my other half can’t be more than a dozen. This is one hugely camera-averse person. This doesn’t stop us taking pics of places we visit to enhance the memories thereof. I
think your friend is just an inconsiderate arsehole, frankly. The attitude of “well I can just find pictures of Google” is utterly ridiculous. A shame you had to find this out on a presumably expensive holiday, but that’s life.

Keyansier · 24/11/2022 19:08

venus7 · 24/11/2022 17:46

You can...and should...ask permission for many things which are 'not illegal'.
Presumably you ask permission to use someone's bathroom?

Er, no Confused

If I'm in someone's house (that I know and not just a random person) I will announce I am going to use their toilet. I don't ask for specific permission if I'm already in their house and I've been invited in.

Tbh though, I can hardly see how the two examples are comparable to each other in the first place.

Rosie22xx · 24/11/2022 18:56

Bit weird her wanting to record you all the time tbh... then sulking that she can't. Wtf. No problem to just record the surroundings and no one in it, the whole point is that she recorded it whilst there and can think back on the memory, its not the same as looking on YouTube. I just find it really odd she either records you, or doesn't record at all. Strange.

THEDEACON · 24/11/2022 18:38

5 hours ?! -her video equipment would be somewhere the sun doesn't shine after 5 minutes if that was me

Batiqueattic · 24/11/2022 18:35

I'm 100% with you OP, I would have absolutely hated that, nothing to do with where the video might or might not end up, nothing to do with what I look like or sound like. I just would NOT WANT TO DO THAT THANKS ALL THE SAME. And that should've been the end of it. Why should you be made to feel uncomfortable for someone else to be happy? Nope.

MysteryBelle · 24/11/2022 18:28

She doesn’t understand that you don’t want the whole trip filmed. It really makes one feel self conscious if conversations are being recorded. I have an aunt like this. She wants to take pictures of absolutely everything and everyone, at all times. Makes no sense. She was with me on the school run once to pick up my child and she started filming all the children walking out of the school. I told her casually that it might not be a good idea as their parents wouldn’t want other parents/strangers taking videos of their kids. She got so angry at me I didn’t think she’d ever speak to me again. She took it as if I were lecturing her and thought she was acting like a child/silly, she said. But I had to tell her to stop.

SnoozyLucy7 · 24/11/2022 18:20

ToFilmOrNotToFilm · 24/11/2022 18:01

The big deal is that it makes me feel tense when I know I'm walking with someone and they have the camera rolling permanently. All our conversations are being recorded, I have to watch where I am constantly if I don't want to be in the frame.

Has filming everything become so normalised now that we're not allowed to feel uncomfortable with being filmed by our friends while on holiday? Many people don't mind if their friend strapped an iPhone turned GoPro to their chest to record their entire day like we're on some TV show, even if it's not posted anywhere. Many do mind.

Yes, sadly, it has become very normalised. Social media has brainwashed people into thinking that every aspect of their life needs to be documented - endless photos, recordings and similar, and then having to share those on all different social media platforms, that will ultimately stay on the internet for ever. There’s a lot less privacy these days.

You have these Instagram parents who from the first ultrasound picture plaster their pages of pictures that show every aspect of their child’s life - when they are sleeping, what they are eating, how they are feeling- you see loads of these of young children crying and in distress about something but their parents deem it ok to upload those videos because they think it’s funny, and it’s extra internet points. It’s just vile behaviour. These kids haven’t given their consent and yet their entire lives are documented on Instagram or wherever, by the very people that are meant to be protecting them. It’s so messed up but sadly I do think that this is increasingly the norm.

Tiani4 · 24/11/2022 18:07

Recording not reviewing