Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Child suffering - no doctor's appointments

217 replies

cofingalthetime · 23/11/2022 12:22

So a friend's little boy aged 3 had a cold that hasn't gotten better - he has a chesty cough, and his eyes are very very sore with green gunk - obviously conjunctivitis. She just cannot get a doctor's appointment. Last night she rang 111 and they said they would send an ambulance, but it would take 6 hours so she took him to A&E but after 5 hours, without even seeing a triage nurse, she brought him home again. On the phone to the doc again this morning, and no appointments. I've just seen the little boy - he's totally listless lying on the sofa, his eyes glued together, breathing sounds awful and his cough is terrible. He just needs some antibiotics? She tried the pharmacist but he would only give her a cough medicine. My friend herself sounds terrible, with an awful cough and she looks terrible, I think she has a chest infection. This must be being duplicated across the whole country - I can imagine people ending up in hospital with pneumonia because they couldnt see a doctor. What should she do... I said maybe go to the surgery with the child so they can see how sick he is...?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brokenunicorn · 26/11/2022 21:29

I've tried both private and public health care in a developing country. The public was very like the NHS if not better (obviously maybe not the same in different places and I'm not saying where it was!). You expected to wait all morning sitting in a corridor and you did see a qualified doctor within about five hours. The private was similar price to private GP here and exceptional. Either way, I'd rather be ill there.

Capri3 · 26/11/2022 20:02

ExtraOnions · 26/11/2022 16:57

I have to use “Out of Hours” GP service last week … DD came home from work to show me an infected toe.

Rang them at 9am, call back about 10:30, emergency GP appointment at 3:15, 4:30 we were out with anti-biotics - I have no complaints.

This.

If it’s not a huge emergency and your GP cannot book you in for an appointment, please try 111, and ask for an out of hours appointment.

We did this a couple of years ago about 9 pm, and ended up with a 1 am appointment, but were seen and back in the car with an antibiotic prescription within 30 mins. Far better than waiting for hours in A&E for several hours.

memorial · 26/11/2022 17:37

Bluekerfuffle · 26/11/2022 17:05

As an example, you didn’t have to wait 12 weeks for X-ray results while having quite severe breathing problems, and then another couple of months to see a consultant, as happened to a relative. If I had not been able to arrange for a private GP and consultant appointment, they wouldn’t have survived that long. In the country I grew up in all of this would have happened within days and they would have investigated instead of just assuming it was asthma that just came on out of the blue and fobbed them off with repeated steroids and antibiotics, leaving them to get to deaths door several times until it did finally kill them. Not only was the care there far better than the NHS, it was also superior to the private care you get here, by the same NHS consultant with the same indifferent attitudes.

I call bullshit. There is no where in the country that has waits of 12 weeks for a CXR.
I am also guessing that you uses private healthcare in your 3rd world country.
I am sorry you had a bad experience but you're talking bollocks

Bluekerfuffle · 26/11/2022 17:05

Bluekerfuffle · 26/11/2022 16:54

Sorry, don’t want to say, but I also grew up in a third world country and obviously used the health services and they were definitely better than here.

As an example, you didn’t have to wait 12 weeks for X-ray results while having quite severe breathing problems, and then another couple of months to see a consultant, as happened to a relative. If I had not been able to arrange for a private GP and consultant appointment, they wouldn’t have survived that long. In the country I grew up in all of this would have happened within days and they would have investigated instead of just assuming it was asthma that just came on out of the blue and fobbed them off with repeated steroids and antibiotics, leaving them to get to deaths door several times until it did finally kill them. Not only was the care there far better than the NHS, it was also superior to the private care you get here, by the same NHS consultant with the same indifferent attitudes.

ExtraOnions · 26/11/2022 16:57

I have to use “Out of Hours” GP service last week … DD came home from work to show me an infected toe.

Rang them at 9am, call back about 10:30, emergency GP appointment at 3:15, 4:30 we were out with anti-biotics - I have no complaints.

Bluekerfuffle · 26/11/2022 16:56

Bluekerfuffle · 26/11/2022 16:54

Sorry, don’t want to say, but I also grew up in a third world country and obviously used the health services and they were definitely better than here.

And yes…name change fail.

Bluekerfuffle · 26/11/2022 16:54

memorial · 25/11/2022 21:47

I'm curious which 3rd world health service you have experience of that is so wonderful? I grew up and trained as a doctor in a 3rd world African country and I can absolutely assure you that even at its very worst the NHS is significantly better!

Sorry, don’t want to say, but I also grew up in a third world country and obviously used the health services and they were definitely better than here.

WildOats5678 · 26/11/2022 14:59

memorial · 25/11/2022 21:47

I'm curious which 3rd world health service you have experience of that is so wonderful? I grew up and trained as a doctor in a 3rd world African country and I can absolutely assure you that even at its very worst the NHS is significantly better!

I’m also curios too! All 3rd world areas that I have worked in definitely did not have good or even anything that reflected healthcare.

Brokenunicorn · 26/11/2022 13:48

Creameggs223 · 26/11/2022 01:33

If a mother can't commit 9 hours to get medical help for her child that the child so desperately needs then that says more about the mother than any NHS service, am a single working mother but my child's health comes before anything so if it takes 9 hours or 9 days that's my priority!!!

A job, other children with needs, other caring commitments. It's not sustainable. You're victim blaming.

Creameggs223 · 26/11/2022 01:33

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 25/11/2022 09:29

We have a broken third world system if a sick child has to wait nine hours to be seen in an emergency department of all places. Of course there will be many parents unable to take this time away from home and work commitments every time their child needs medical attention.

If a mother can't commit 9 hours to get medical help for her child that the child so desperately needs then that says more about the mother than any NHS service, am a single working mother but my child's health comes before anything so if it takes 9 hours or 9 days that's my priority!!!

memorial · 25/11/2022 21:47

Tootrumparp · 25/11/2022 20:42

I have experience of them and they were a darn sight better than this. At least you got seen when you needed to, got follow up appointments in a suitable time period and saw doctors who were determined to get to the bottom of things and not just get rid of you as soon as possible. Not saying all are, but certainly the ones I experienced. The health system here is dreadful, it’s not designed to cater for the size of the population and I don’t know if that’s why a lot of the medical profession (consultants and doctors more than nurses) seem disinterested in their job and treat patients like statistics instead of people.

I'm curious which 3rd world health service you have experience of that is so wonderful? I grew up and trained as a doctor in a 3rd world African country and I can absolutely assure you that even at its very worst the NHS is significantly better!

Tootrumparp · 25/11/2022 20:42

Kitcaterpillar · 25/11/2022 16:49

I would suggest people saying we have a 'third world' healthcare system have little to no experience of hospitals in the developing world.

That said, a 5 hour+ wait for a scheduled appointment is ludicrous and, at the very least, someone should be managing the situation. The NHS certainly has no shortage of managers. People have children, jobs, myriad other responsibilities that don't allow for a day sat about for something that was booked and it's not unreasonable to be incredibly annoyed by it.

I have experience of them and they were a darn sight better than this. At least you got seen when you needed to, got follow up appointments in a suitable time period and saw doctors who were determined to get to the bottom of things and not just get rid of you as soon as possible. Not saying all are, but certainly the ones I experienced. The health system here is dreadful, it’s not designed to cater for the size of the population and I don’t know if that’s why a lot of the medical profession (consultants and doctors more than nurses) seem disinterested in their job and treat patients like statistics instead of people.

Kitcaterpillar · 25/11/2022 16:49

I would suggest people saying we have a 'third world' healthcare system have little to no experience of hospitals in the developing world.

That said, a 5 hour+ wait for a scheduled appointment is ludicrous and, at the very least, someone should be managing the situation. The NHS certainly has no shortage of managers. People have children, jobs, myriad other responsibilities that don't allow for a day sat about for something that was booked and it's not unreasonable to be incredibly annoyed by it.

User1437957 · 25/11/2022 14:07

@kittensinthekitchen i am not going to be thankful for waiting for over 4 hours. Will have a 15£ parking ticket too at the end of this to add insult to injury.

User1437957 · 25/11/2022 14:05

It’s a routine appt in a part of hospital that doesn’t deal with emergencies!
All around me people have come with books. I am cursing myself for not bringing my headphones. And am very close to walking out if it hadn’t taken 3 years to get this appointment.
I am amazed how people will go to great lengths to defend the NHS. It really needs a big overhaul.

kittensinthekitchen · 25/11/2022 12:39

User1437957 · 25/11/2022 11:51

Well I am sat here in the hospital for my routine appointment and am told it is a 5 hour wait!! referral was done pre covid and had to be chased and re chased, how can they be running 4 hours late for an appointment that was pre scheduled.

beyond a joke . And to the person who said third world system imo it is an insult to third world countries

There are obviously appointments that have over run due to being more complex than expected, or maybe a member of staff is off sick so those there are doing double the work.

Or maybe there's been an emergency come in. Be thankful the emergency isn't you.

Can you go away and come back later?

User1437957 · 25/11/2022 11:51

Well I am sat here in the hospital for my routine appointment and am told it is a 5 hour wait!! referral was done pre covid and had to be chased and re chased, how can they be running 4 hours late for an appointment that was pre scheduled.

beyond a joke . And to the person who said third world system imo it is an insult to third world countries

memorial · 25/11/2022 11:05

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 25/11/2022 09:32

The specific time wasn't mentioned in that post. Yes there are GPs who stop off occasionally with someone they're worried about on their way home. Where I live. Sorry if that makes you feel inadequate.

Are you 12? 🤣🤣

kittensinthekitchen · 25/11/2022 10:58

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 25/11/2022 09:27

Doctors would rather see these children if their parents have a genuine concern.

Absolutely.

But it still doesn't follow that parents always know when their kids are ill.

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 25/11/2022 09:32

memorial · 24/11/2022 02:06

You know GPs who make impromptu house calls to viral children at 2am?? No you don't
I have been known to call a patient I am concerned about to follow up or inform them of blood results etc but I don't know a single GP who would do an impromptu house call at 2am. Not since OOH was removed from the contract in 2004....and even then it would have been very unusual.
Are you sure you aren't thinking of the TV soap doctors ....

The specific time wasn't mentioned in that post. Yes there are GPs who stop off occasionally with someone they're worried about on their way home. Where I live. Sorry if that makes you feel inadequate.

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 25/11/2022 09:29

Creameggs223 · 25/11/2022 00:33

Yes there is a nhs issue but am referring to this case a mum who has done nothing but try a gp for 2 weeks when her child is sick then blames nhs for child suffering!! No the child is suffering because mother give up waiting to be seen and had she of waited then the issue would off been sorted alot sooner, you can't say your child is to sick to wait in a&e if they are sick and you no they need some sort of treatment you wait!!

We have a broken third world system if a sick child has to wait nine hours to be seen in an emergency department of all places. Of course there will be many parents unable to take this time away from home and work commitments every time their child needs medical attention.

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 25/11/2022 09:27

kittensinthekitchen · 25/11/2022 08:25

Noone is saying that parents never know that their child is ill, just that the "parents always know best" isn't true. If it were, every single child that is taken to a GP would have some sort of prescription or treatment. Whilst I don't know the figures (do any gps or practice staff have figures for that?), I do know that isn't the case. A massive number of people take their children to a doctor sure that they need medical treatment, and don't.

Doctors would rather see these children if their parents have a genuine concern.

Starlight86 · 25/11/2022 09:16

I think its utterly ridiculous that parents are vilified for taking their children to the doctors.
If you child is unwell we are programmed to try and manage at home for as long as possible.

Why should parents have the pressure of deciding whether its a cold, viral or an infection. Why should we feel ashamed or embarrassed by taking them to the doctors to get our children checked out.

Literally as parents we should be protecting our children which also means taking them to a doctor when they are unwell.

I was so guilty for it, we waited 6 days when my daughter had bacterial meningitis, I knew something wasn't right, we had taken her to the doctors on day 3 and told it was viral....I should have picked her up and walked into A&E right then and there.

The NHS is not broken by the public.

kittensinthekitchen · 25/11/2022 08:25

Noone is saying that parents never know that their child is ill, just that the "parents always know best" isn't true. If it were, every single child that is taken to a GP would have some sort of prescription or treatment. Whilst I don't know the figures (do any gps or practice staff have figures for that?), I do know that isn't the case. A massive number of people take their children to a doctor sure that they need medical treatment, and don't.

FlippityFlippityFlop · 25/11/2022 07:57

memorial · 24/11/2022 00:50

Erm that may have been the case years ago. And I will always take a parents "feelings" I to consideration. But I see 100's of children a month whose parents "don't feel right". And 99.99% of them are wrong.....

No - Not years ago. 1 year ago to be exact. And yes - I knew he wasn't right. The fact that he has lost his colour and was looking"grey" (evident in the photos that we had of him over the past few days), that he has pronounced chest breathing, was very sleepy/heard to wake and wasn't taking any milk, but we were told that he was ok was when they shone be a light in his eyes he responded. I knew he wasn't. If I had taken my baby hinge that night I dread to think what would have happened his sats were so low.

No - I don't take my child to the GP or A&E for everything. I try to self medicate first - I also realise that for viral infections there is not a lot you can do except rest and keep hydrated. And I'm not one to push for antibiotics. Indeed, when my baby had COVID at 4 months old I wasn't at panic stations,I just assessed the situation and although he was unwell he was coping fine. BUT - when I know they are not ok and it feels scary (yes - you do get that feeling when you know that something is dangerously not ok) then I will push to get my child the treatment they need.

No one is blaming health care professionals for being understaffed - we know that they are trying their best with limited resources. It is a failure of successive governments that we have ended up like this. But - this does mean that sometimes we have to advocate for others when we "know" that it is more serious.