Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lots of homework set but never ever marked - is this usual for secondary?

42 replies

homeworkhellraiser · 23/11/2022 10:57

DD has just moved up to secondary so this is all new to us. They are set a lot of homework - in my (I admit totally uninformed) opinion it is far too much. DD has SEN so finds this hard and it is a real battle to get through it all and causes a lot of stress at home. Added to that the school is very quick to give detentions if work isn't done/completed or is forgotten etc so a lot of the children (not just my DD) get stressed about this.

However, despite all this not a single piece of her homework has been marked.
Why is so much set if it isn't even looked at? All this pain and stress and no feedback whatsoever. Is this normal? And, if so, can anyone explain the rationale - it is steadily making my DD increasingly stressed and hate school and learning even more.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/08/2023 18:22

It sounds like they are setting too much. Many schools are (very sensibly) moving away from setting lots of written homework that needs marking by the teacher and moving towards online homework tasks and things which can be quickly peer-marked in class, then setting a bigger marked written homework once or twice per half term or at the end of a unit of work.

EgyptianMummies · 04/08/2023 18:16

Marking and feedback are not interchangeable words. comprehensive feedback can be given with very little marking taking place. I’d check the school’s marking policy before storming in & demanding an explanation.

CallieApricot · 25/11/2022 10:41

I remember in the week before Easter holidays of year 7 dd being given 5 large projects to do over the holidays. Not just smaller homework but projects. I fed this back on a survey the school gave out and the Head responded. He agreed it was a lot. Probably was more amenable as I also provided some excellent feedback about other aspects of the school

CallieApricot · 25/11/2022 10:36

Dd had a ridiculous amount of homework in year 7. I did give feedback to the school and others did too. It did lessen after a while. Even during her A levels she wasn't as ridiculously overloaded as she was in Year 7 and she got good grades so it didn't harm her. Funnily enough a friend had a similar experience at another local school. Worth giving feedback.

homeworkhellraiser · 23/11/2022 22:36

@Risslan your DS sounds very like mine with their homework. That is great that you dropped some subjects - was it easy to arrange this? I have been thinking the same that DD is spread too think and would do better doing less subjects and having more time to get through the work. I think the school will say she can't do this though.

@waterrat I totally agree that too much homework is damaging. My DD has pretty poor mental health and I'm sure doing less homework and having more time to do exercise, get out and about, or just relax would be much more beneficial for her. And then the work she did do she would be able to concentrate on better.

OP posts:
Wehadabetamax · 23/11/2022 21:35

In the 2 secondary schools that I have worked in, the subject teachers don't even look at the homework. Maths, English and Science are done on an app and other subjects are done using knowledge organisers. The tutors just check that there is some work in their homework books under the correct date. That is it. Pointless for many students.

Risslan · 23/11/2022 20:11

My DS is Yr 8, has asd and adhd so homework is a huge battle. He doesn't get that much but like you I don't see any of it being marked.

I know for a fact that some is wrong but I can only explain it to him so many times before he gets really upset so if he's just not getting it I let him answer as best he can expecting the teacher to see his mistakes and help him. If this has happened it hasn't worked because he still can't do it.

I've contacted the senco, no explanation so far. I'll chase it at parents evening but really I've given up hope of him learning much at school and teach the basics myself.

OP be aware that your dc can drop some subjects to create less homework and give free periods during the day when they can do homework in school. Far better to do well in fewer subjects than do 10 and fail.

Seashor · 23/11/2022 20:01

We don’t mark work we assess work. We then address errors and misconceptions in class.

waterrat · 23/11/2022 19:43

I would personally be contacting the school if my child was finding homework stressful - particularly if SEN.

Many many ways in which homework is damaging rather than useful - my question would be - what else could the child be doing in that time. They could be playing physically outside - running/ jumping/ exercising/ they could be relaxing with family, enjoying hobbies - they could be seeing friends, doing drama/ art/ cycling.

We as parents need to push back at schools that give homework for sake of it. None of these things are set in stone as 'valuable' - it' is jsust what our current society/ culture deems valuable.

Stressedmum2017 · 23/11/2022 19:38

Exactly the same here, year 7 SEN child assigned stupid amounts of homework, never marked . But what really annoys me is the lack of time given. Elaborate art project assigned at 6pm on a Friday due in Monday is just a pisstake. Not only supplies needed but child needs lots of help and time to complete. Great if you have all weekend/plenty of funds but for me a nightmare.

AceofPentacles · 23/11/2022 19:35

Same here. So much stress and zero in return . Annoying

ThrallsWife · 23/11/2022 19:23

Because a lot of SLT don't have children, or children that age. They are the ones making the decisions.

homeworkhellraiser · 23/11/2022 19:03

Thanks for the replies - it is really interesting to see how homework is used. I think some of the things mentioned sound good - but why so much of it? Surely you don't need to do 40 mins work to consolidate work. It all seems such a slog.

OP posts:
Leggingslife · 23/11/2022 18:49

Peer assessment
Self assessment
Used for a discussion
Verbal feedback
Flipped learning
Consolidation
There are lots of types of homework and ways to give feedback - if it is appropriate to do so.

Squashpocket · 23/11/2022 18:46

Honestly this sounds a bit sad. I have no doubt whatsoever that it's not teachers fault in anyway that homework isn't marked, but the current situation sounds like such a massive downgrade on my secondary school experience 25 years ago.

We got homework for every subject every week (maybe not art and DT, but the rest we did). And we got feedback (a mark and maybe a comment) at the same lesson the following week. Without fail. It gave such a lot of encouragement and held us all accountable for actually knowing the work.

What has happened to the resourcing in schools over the last 25 years that this is no longer possible? I went to a state grammar. It was a good school but not particularly special or anything.

Shiningsilverargent · 23/11/2022 18:18

Are you sure that it isn’t being marked in class? It is pretty common for kids just to sit there when you’re going through stuff, unfortunately.

ThrallsWife · 23/11/2022 18:05

Not excusing the no marking, but every school I've worked in has a directive that says core subjects must give a piece of homework a week (often something ridiculous like an hour's work) and others once a fortnight, so yes, it's way too much, especially for Y7.

It often also happens that teachers are taken to task if homework isn't set that often (especially if an online system is being used to inform parents of homework, like Teams).

In reality, teachers have very little time to actually look at the homework in class and zero time to mark this on top of all the other marking they have to do, so many times it is forgotten. I try to carve out 5-10min/ week to mark homework in class with the kids - sometimes it doesn't happen, because other things take over. I always get round to it eventually, but it may not be on the due day, but I know many of my colleagues struggle to find the time to just set the work in the first place, let alone make time for it in the space of a lesson.

So that's the reality, sadly.

Curioushorse · 23/11/2022 18:03

Meh. Homework has limited value.

Marking a set of books just quickly takes me around two hours. A set of exam papers last week took me more like 5 and a half (sob). The value, even collectively, for the students, is not as much as that. Yes my exam students must have their exam papers marked, but for a class set, are they getting two hours worth of value out of my marking? Nope.

I have 5 classes. My school, which is 'outstanding' requires two pieces of work marked each half term per class. These are regulated, and pieces which must be completed during class time. I can set preparation for those as homework, but I am discouraged from setting anything which needs marking- because anything on top of the 20+ hours (at least!) of compulsory marking per half term seems silly.

But sometimes just the completion of a task is all I or the students need. What is my feedback going to achieve?

glamourousindierockandroll · 23/11/2022 18:03

I agree with the theory that the point of the homework is in the completion of it, not in the validation of the teacher. When I hear my children read every night, or practise their spellings or number bonds, we're not doing it for the teacher to check, we're doing it so that they'll be better at the stuff they do in class. Surely it's about independent practice?

Aishah231 · 23/11/2022 18:00

Sounds mad to me OP. I teach and where we are we have to mark something substantial and input a mark at least once a fortnight. Most of us mark weekly. The odd thing like a poster might just be quickly checked in the classroom.

HatRabbit · 23/11/2022 17:58

Marking policies at Primary are generally bonkers, so it does take some adjustment when you move to Secondary.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 23/11/2022 17:48

ilo · 23/11/2022 17:42

YANBU, they shouldn’t be setting that much homework if they’re too lazy to actually mark it.

It isn't about being lazy at all. Feedback is meant to have an impact on learning. Speaking to a child and going over where they went wrong verbally has more impact on improving their work than a bunch of crosses and ticks. It actually explains the concept again instead of saying - you got it wrong but I'll not tell you how to do it right as that is what a cross does. Learning how to give effective feedback is one of the most important things. Understanding ticks and crosses give no feedback on how to improve is one of the basics.

EscapeTheCastle · 23/11/2022 17:45

In my day sometimes you got an A and a positive few lines from a teacher, then as if by magic this positive feedback made you warm to a subject and help you feel good about yourself. Then a miracle happened, just like it does in "Dead Poets Society" you become inspired to achieve and feel transformed by an academic subject.. university beckons....
Now? NOTHING.

ilo · 23/11/2022 17:42

YANBU, they shouldn’t be setting that much homework if they’re too lazy to actually mark it.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 23/11/2022 17:41

Verbal feedback is more effective than written feedback. More and more schools are moving onto verbal feedback. The whole point of feedback is to have an impact on learning. What impact on learning does a tick have? None.