Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think of shy colleagues at work?

116 replies

shessoquiet · 22/11/2022 22:57

I'm really shy, I can't help it and I try my absolute hardest to speak up more, but often times in certain work settings (like brain storms where we all are expected to just jump in and start saying ideas), I feel mute.

I often leave work feeling defeated, embarrassed and guilty. I'm a hard worker, but my shyness really lets me down.

If you have a shy colleague, AIBU to ask what you think about them? Please be honest, don't worry about offending me

OP posts:
Newlifestartingatlast · 23/11/2022 08:55

I used to be very shy. I am also an introvert
early in my career I was like this- never speaking out
shyness has to do with confidence- doesn’t mean you are lacking self esteem, more that you are socially anxious about what people will think of you and ill at ease
Introversion is part of peoples make up- can’t change that. It is like the battery charging.Extroverts get it from interaction with people, introverts with self reflection. Introverts batteries drain in too much company. It’s most likely to be something to do with sensory overload. Yep, you can develop strategies to mamange it- but it is what you are

but you can do something about shyness…

I had the most brilliant manager in my early career. He picked up in my shyness almost straight away. He started me in team meetings just giving a 1 min presentation on something he’d allowed me to prepare earlier. And he started to specifically ask for my opinion on something he knew I did have an opinion on and positively reinforcing it. He then progressed me to delivering a training package lasting 20 mins- I had to deliver it maybe 1-2per month and gradually as I got to know the slides, materials and I I relaxed. He just kept building up my confidence in speaking up and speaking out. He knew if he made sure I was prepared and it was on topics I knew I would gradually overcome it (yes, he was a star, and was well recognised as one of the best people developers in the company worldwide)

by 5 years later, I sometimes had to be reminded not to interrupt someone in a meeting (🤦‍♀️🙄yep horrible habit), and delivered off the cuff presentations, and 3 day training classes. No one at work would have known I was once shy. Yep, they knew I was introverted- I was clear with people about that in a jokey sort of way…but not shy to them. My old bosses investment in time to work with me on this and his effort paid off as far as company was concerned. I worked for them for over 25 years, ending as a global technical consultant - couldn’t have done that if I had been still been shy at work.

I’m still shy at heart, don’t like social events where I don’t know a lot of people, and feel ill at ease - but over the last 25 years have developed tactics about how to deal with it..asking others lots of questions first is one way- to avoid talking about myself! But once I’m on a topic I know we’ll, have confidence in my opinions and experience I’m fine.

so, my advice, talk to your boss. Enlist their help as “development” . You may not be so fortunate to have such a fantastic people developer boss as mine was, so you may need to spoon feed him a bit about what you need. But please pluck up courage to ask for help to gradually get used to speaking out. Yes, you can manage your career being shy- but it will hold you back from senior positions if this is what you want.

Feef83 · 23/11/2022 08:55

What can be very frustrating are shy people that do have views but don’t verbalise them.

Instead going back to their desk post meeting and whinging / bitching to colleagues.

PuppyMonkey · 23/11/2022 08:48

Brainstorming sessions are a million times worse than any shy person will ever be.

BraveGoldie · 23/11/2022 08:46

Zero issue for me if you don't take part in non-work banter and are quiet. In fact, I'd appreciate that and instinctively probably trust you more.

However, anything that makes you less effective at your job, I think it's worth finding tactics/ building your skills to overcome.

Eg brainstorming. Find out the topic in advance if possible, have ideas written down, and I think it's largely an issue of self discipline to make yourself say one or two. Or suggest a silent brainstorm - people adding ideas to their own postits and putting them on a wall, then quietly browsing and clustering, then discussing (much nicer process for most introverts) Or just give yourself a target of sharing one idea (try to go for early - the psychological barrier tends to increase the longer you don't speak).

Most jobs rely at least a bit on communication and relationship building too. Hard to work well in a team if you never talk to your team mates. So if you don't like the group chat, fine - but what are you doing? Eg Try to have quiet, individual chats with team members at opportune times - asking them about or congratulating them on something positive in their lives that you overheard from the group chat, or asking for their ideas on something you are working on, or just complementing them on something you appreciate about them, or something they did well at work etc.... this goes a long way to clarify that you are a friendly, benign presence - just quiet, rather than withdrawn because you don't like people or think you are better than them.

Hope this helps!

Feef83 · 23/11/2022 08:44

back office

Feef83 · 23/11/2022 08:44

The key is What is their role?

if back off book keeper, and job spec made no reference to team working or meetings - and suddenly a meeting sprung on them, I would be far more understanding if very shy and basically withdrawn from meeting.

it however clear from job spec that team working and meetings and contribution expected - then quite honestly, they would not be performing

fruitsaladsweets · 23/11/2022 08:43

It really depends on the job. If you're in a senior position or a role where you are actually required to verbally contribute, then being 'shy' is actually a hindrance to your job and problematic, because you are not communicating things that you need to.

If there are other ways you can contribute/ communicate then it doesnt really matter.

KatherineJaneway · 23/11/2022 08:43

I don't think anything really but I do expect them to pull their weight, just as I would any other colleague.

If brainstorming was a regular part of your role, I would be annoyed you were not contributing. However I also think it is on the manager as well to allow different ways of collating feedback such as comments in Teams or post it notes on a flip chart in person.

SnowyPetals · 23/11/2022 08:37

plinkypots · 23/11/2022 07:41

I wont hire shy people onto my team. Introverted is fine but shy is not. Shy to me means overly sensitive and unlikely to contribute in a team meeting even when they have something important to say. I haven't got time to have a million 1:1 meetings when it could have been solved in the team call. Introverted to me means they say what they need to but often are slow to warm and may not participate socially which is all fine.

I agree with this. Shyness that takes up additional time is very draining. It's really annoying if we have a team discussion, shy person doesn't contribute but then sends their points by email later, thus requiring separate discussion. But if you don't do a lot of group work then that's less important so it might not matter so much.

Snoken · 23/11/2022 08:33

I'm not particularly shy myself, but I am also not the life and soul of the party, but I gravitate much more towards shy people than loud, attention grabbing people. I find the latter category harder and harder to tolerate the older I get. I'd much rather hear the views of someone who spends time thinking and reflecting than someone who just shouts out every idea and thought they have.

Bobshhh · 23/11/2022 08:32

I have a shy person in my team, she never speaks up in meetings, rarely turns her camera on in zoom, and hasn't built a network. Honestly I find it challenging but mainly because she's also confident she should get a promotion but I haven't seen the skills demonstrated to take her to that level (in our industry I'd expect you to be leading meetings, building a network, actively stepping up to work on other projects).

Newlifestartingatlast · 23/11/2022 08:30

oopsfellover · 23/11/2022 07:53

I've occasionally mistaken someone for being arrogant/aloof when they were actually shy. My mistake.
My advice would be to be yourself and don't worry about the things that you're not - you say you work hard, and I bet you're absolutely fine.
I wouldn't want to spend too much of my life feeling defeated, embarrassed and guilty though, so I guess anything you can 'work on' (as they say) to avoid that would be a good idea.

I’ve had this levelled at me “aloof” when I’m naturally shy

Droppit · 23/11/2022 08:27

My shy colleague is great at her job and communicates well in smaller groups. It's just the bigger meetings where she struggles (eg 8+ people). It would be a real loss to the team if she left. This is not a high power job. Why shouldn't the manager chair the meeting in such a way which encourages all attendees to voice their views?

RagingWoke · 23/11/2022 08:25

I hate brainstorming sessions, much rather just get on with my job. I find that type of thing is dominated by the loud type, who IMO don't generally add much value to the sessions.

I have been told people think I'm aloof, rude or whatever but it's always by those who dominate everyone and every conversation. Those who actually have a conversion with me don't have an issue, I just don't have the headspace for the 'I'm mad me!' crowd.

I've worked hard on my confidence, when I started I thought the goal was to be more like the extroverts but actually I'm now confident enough to say no to meetings, defend my positions and contribute when I feel it's relevant and I'm comfortable.

I should also caveat I mask a lot, I have a very distinct 'work personality' that I slip into. I'm sure colleagues would be horrified at the awkward, stimming, anxious mess behind it.

BankseyVest · 23/11/2022 08:21

A good leader will realise you need both introverts and extroverts in a team. The extroverts will jump in with ideas straight away, with little thought process. Your introverts will really think about the issue or situation and only talk when they have something valuable to contribute. You need both, especially in brain storming sessions as the extroverts will keep the energy going and float idea around, but it's usually the shy ones that solve the issue or come up with a valid idea

DiamanteFan · 23/11/2022 08:21

as long as you pull your weight in terms of workload I'd have no issues with you being shy.

Trees6 · 23/11/2022 08:20

We have a mix of personalities on our team but our role is casework (financial sector) which involves no brainstorming type activities. We look at escalated complaints so it’s all methodical, detailed, mathematical stuff. Shyness is neither here nor there.

TBH OP I think you should try to contribute in these brainstorming meetings if they are part of the role. I appreciate it’s not simple though. But to answer your question, I’d maybe feel that you were not pulling your weight if you sat there silently.

KarmaLlamaagain · 23/11/2022 08:17

@tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz Very well said, completely agree.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/11/2022 08:16

CowPie · 22/11/2022 23:41

Surely it depends on the nature of the job? I have zero interest in whether you engage in jolly banter on lunch breaks, but if your role involves coming up with ideas, arguing for them, confident ad-lib public speaking, and/or handling yourself in a cut-and-thrust environment, then whether or not you’re shy can’t be allowed to impact on your performance.

I think this is a really good point in that there are occupations that are going to be a more successful fit for certain people

Doingmybest12 · 23/11/2022 08:14

I think if you are meant to come up with ideas and contribute to the group you really have to develop some skills to do this. I am reserved but have had to do this as part of my role. If you notice what others do usually people have certain themes they fall back on, have an idea they adapt to suit the next situation. I am sure you have ideas if you know your job and area of work. I think as part of your development talk to your manager about this. Or can you follow up an idea someone else suggests even to say , that is a good idea or I've not thought of this. You do need to find your own voice in a work setting to contribute. Whether you want to engage with banter etc is more your choice but you need to build working relationships.

KarmaLlamaagain · 23/11/2022 08:14

I’d take a shy considered colleague over a gobby loud person who doesn’t listen any day lol

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/11/2022 08:13

Anyone with an ounce of emotional intelligence and compassion will know you cant judge a person on their "outgoing-ness".

I used to be a trainer and learned lots both theory and through facilitating groups that it takes all sorts. Sometimes in smaller group settings it would be the person who has barely said a word who suggested the most incredible ideas that would blow everyone away.

As a fairly shy and introverted person myself, and mum to a kind, funny, beautiful yet incredibly shy DD I totally get you. And I think provided you look for other ways to be involved, contribute and be part of the team, it doesn't matter a jot.

Many outgoing people who appear the life and soul have lots to say but bugger all of substance or use. They just lurrrrrrve to be heard Confused

Feef83 · 23/11/2022 08:08

Why should managers be expected to bring out shy people.

FGS. These are grown assed adults that went for a job presumably knowing that they were part of a team, there would be meetings, they would be expected to contribute and engage with their colleagues, some of whom they will hardly know. So if you knew this about the job AND you knew that you are very shy and this would mean you would struggle to fulfil this aspect of the job role - then you went for the wrong job!! And yet now some posters expect management to spend time and energy in bringing out shy people?

TWAWmearse · 23/11/2022 08:06

XenoBitch · 22/11/2022 23:09

I am shy. Less than 24 hours into one job, I had a complaint that I was not joining in the banter in the rest room. Said banter was about sex.
The job was cleaning in a hospital.

And I bet the complaint was by a man?

Id much rather a shy colleague than a loud, irritating knobhead!

emptythelitterbox · 23/11/2022 08:06

I've been called aloof, off-putting, snobby, weird.

Are you interested in being less shy?

Medication, therapy with role playing scenarios, and toastmasters have helped immensely.

No, I didn't became some flaming extrovert, loudmouth, life of the party but am able to contribute and hold a conversation and I'm happy with that.