Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why should I have to pay money to keep people safe?

57 replies

Bibo · 22/11/2022 18:36

I don't suppose this will go down well so have NC and donned my hard hat.

Walking through the city centre today I was approached by a teenager chugging for an organisation and asking for donations to stop knife crime. He had an attitude when i politely declined.

As I walked away I couldn't help but think to myself - why should the general public who are largely struggling with the COL increase, have to pay to lower our chances of either us or our loved ones being stabbed.

Why is it our responsibility to manage and mitigate the effects of other people's crap parenting and in alot of cases, the young person just being a little shit.

AIBU? Would you donate?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bibo · 22/11/2022 23:15

They're also committing fraud if these comments are anything to go by, and there are many more.

Why should I have to pay money to keep people safe?
OP posts:
MajorCarolDanvers · 22/11/2022 22:09

It's a personal choice which Charity to support, if any.

You don't want to support this charity and prefer to support others.

That's ok.

It's also ok for others to have different views to you.

Bibo · 22/11/2022 22:08

Devoutspoken · 22/11/2022 22:05

So if someone gets cancer as a result of bad lifestyle choices, smoking, alcohol etc - you won't want your money going to those causes then?

The two are not remotely comparable.

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 22/11/2022 22:07

Googlecanthelpme · 22/11/2022 21:51

Thinking that the kids get into these lifestyles because they’re just a “little shit” or the product of ‘shit’ parenting is the epitome of privilege.

It is virtually impossible to escape what you are born into.

So what's the point in the charity if there's virtually no escape?

Devoutspoken · 22/11/2022 22:05

So if someone gets cancer as a result of bad lifestyle choices, smoking, alcohol etc - you won't want your money going to those causes then?

Mardyface · 22/11/2022 22:05

This is why charity is a stupid way of doing things. Because dyslexic kittens would get all the cash and live in palaces while lumpen arsey teenagers or stinky alcoholic old men would be on the streets. You can give money to who you want OP or withhold it as you wish as well of course but people shouldn't have to beg to get what we should all be providing anyway.

Bibo · 22/11/2022 21:59

Googlecanthelpme · 22/11/2022 21:51

Thinking that the kids get into these lifestyles because they’re just a “little shit” or the product of ‘shit’ parenting is the epitome of privilege.

It is virtually impossible to escape what you are born into.

Have you read my posts? Privilege?

I grew up in those environments. I'm coming from a place of personal experience. I can't talk for everybody but the people I knew who carried knives were, by their very nature, little shits, and that's me being very generous.

If it was virtually impossible to escape what you were born into I wouldn't be where I am today.

Personal responsibility.

I can't bare all of the fluffy "behaviour is communication" excuse finding crap. Oh they've had a hard life, well haven't we all.

These aren't poor little children, they're far beyond the age of criminal responsibility and are accountable for their own actions.

OP posts:
Googlecanthelpme · 22/11/2022 21:51

Thinking that the kids get into these lifestyles because they’re just a “little shit” or the product of ‘shit’ parenting is the epitome of privilege.

It is virtually impossible to escape what you are born into.

Bibo · 22/11/2022 21:47

A bit of both, Vlad.

As I touched on upthread I've had alot of personal experience of knife crime blighting my life and the lives of people I care about. I know for an absolute fact that there is nothing that an organisation like inside success could do to prevent those people from carrying knives and attacking people. I feel like knife crime is an emotive topic, understandably, and orgs like this are piggybacking off the back of people grief/fears. As is usually the case with things like this the vast majority of the money goes to the people at the top sat on their arses.

Dispite how I feel towards teenagers and young adults who carry knives, i also think young people are being exploited by orgs like this.

After looking into it a bit more tonight I can see the whole premise is about selling the organisations magazine. That is how they're getting kids "off the street" - they're just putting them on a different street after teaching them high pressure sales techniques and encouraging them to harass people.

Then what you have is young people who are antisocial by nature, and quite intimidating really, bullying people in the street to hand over money.

In any other situation it would be deserving of a call to the police but stick an anorak on them and its simply fundraising.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 22/11/2022 21:33

Is it the cause that bothered you or more the chugging itself? I am more likely to donate to a knife crime charity but will not give chuggers money.

LikeAStar1994 · 22/11/2022 21:24

I don't donate to charities/fundraisers at all now. Whenever somebody sends me an invitation to donate to a fundraiser, I just ignore it. It's the one thing I should feel guilty about but I really don't.

Bibo · 22/11/2022 20:52

I've just been reading about this organisation on reddit. Somebody said they've looked up their accounts on Company House and could see that 75 percent of their sale amount went to commission in 2014. That says it all I think. I doubt much has changed.

OP posts:
Booklover3 · 22/11/2022 20:39

What pisses me off is that they’ve started knocking on my door.

Georgeskitchen · 22/11/2022 20:29

Knife crime statistics will not improve until Judges statt handing out proper sentences for carrying knives.
On the subject of chuggers, my experience was, not chugging but a cold call a few years ago, a young man trying to sell me an insurance policy which would pay out if i contracted one of the female cancers ( although he probably wouldn't be able to say "female" nowadays)
I said no thanks I'm not interested.
He got shirty and said, what,? Your not interested in female cancers?
I just replied "I'll take my chances with everyone else thanks"

felded · 22/11/2022 20:16

@Bibo can't have supply without demand

carefulcalculator · 22/11/2022 19:41

jetadore · 22/11/2022 18:45

Here we go, everybody whinge about chuggers. The real answer to your question is because we keep voting for cunts.

Agree. Knife crime and county lines are just two of the awful consequences of the Tories' decision to cut so many police officers and such a lot from budgets of all aspects of law enforcement.

Bibo · 22/11/2022 19:39

felded · 22/11/2022 19:32

Why is it our responsibility to manage and mitigate the effects of other people's crap parenting and in alot of cases, the young person just being a little shit.

Can't really ignore the drug trade though & the consumers

That's another area I have personal experience of unfortunately.

Nothing, short of being locked up, will stop those drug dealers from wanting to deal.

My ex did it. The same one who threatened me with a knife. He didn't need opportunities he needed a good hiding and a lengthy prison sentence.

They don't do it out of desperation, they do it because to them it's easy money, it fits the image they want to portray. They wouldn't want a proper job if you offered it to them.

OP posts:
Cw112 · 22/11/2022 19:38

"Why is it our responsibility to manage and mitigate the effects of other people's crap parenting and in alot of cases, the young person just being a little shit."

I would say it's actually much more predatory than this, at least where I live. I've seen young people move to a new area via the care system knowing nobody and within their first day there, they've been recruited by other vulnerable young people, offered substances for 'free' and then that freebie is called in as debt. Then that debt is recalled by way of a favour such as transporting weapons/recruiting other vulnerable kids etc etc. It's grown men puppeting vulnerable young people who they know fine well have limited support systems to help them get out of it again. So just calling them little shits really minimises the scale of the issue which is actually exploitation of individuals and communities.

Bibo · 22/11/2022 19:35

MojoMoon · 22/11/2022 19:26

Were they "Inside Success"?

Common around London, groups of teenagers, usually black. Selling a magazine often say it's about fighting knife crime.

It's not a charity and not registered with the charity commission.

It is a community interest company, a type of private company that is supposedly doing good.

Kids are set very high selling targets and not paid if they don't get it.

Often these are kids who wouldn't have lots of job opportunities so possibly getting some sales experience might help them then get other proper jobs - but that's as much good as it does I think..

I've just checked online and yes that's the one.

OP posts:
felded · 22/11/2022 19:32

Why is it our responsibility to manage and mitigate the effects of other people's crap parenting and in alot of cases, the young person just being a little shit.

Can't really ignore the drug trade though & the consumers

MojoMoon · 22/11/2022 19:26

Were they "Inside Success"?

Common around London, groups of teenagers, usually black. Selling a magazine often say it's about fighting knife crime.

It's not a charity and not registered with the charity commission.

It is a community interest company, a type of private company that is supposedly doing good.

Kids are set very high selling targets and not paid if they don't get it.

Often these are kids who wouldn't have lots of job opportunities so possibly getting some sales experience might help them then get other proper jobs - but that's as much good as it does I think..

willstarttomorrow · 22/11/2022 19:25

@Bibo but it is not guilt tripping. There are many agencies and countless third party initiatives that do work hard to keep people safe. The welfare system has been very broken for a long time and the current government will not fund any preventative programmes because they will not do long term. At some point, even those who think they will never need it, may find a reason to look for support. It may be gang related stuff for young people (which can cross over into 'normal families' not just the very vulnerable groups such as care leavers etc), vulnerable older people such as those with alzheimers, sudden life-limiting illness, bereavement, disability. For lots of people life can change in an instant and many are very surprised that the 'safety net' is not what they thought it was. I am surprised chuggers still exist but many charities are a real lifeline.

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 19:23

I'm always a bit skeptical of cold calling fundraisers, it's usually pretty common that they need to fundraise their own wage first and then anything after that gets to the actual charity and I don't feel that's the best way to accrue funds. Also if I'm donating then I want to have clear explanation of where my money is going and how it will be spent so I generally donate to charities I've worked with that I know are ethical. I also think government underfunding key services such as the care system/healthcare system/ provision of accommodation/ education system etc is something they should be held accountable for rather than charities being put under pressure to ask joe public to fund them more so they can pick up the slack that government cuts create.

That being said, most of the young people I work with have carried knives and weapons of some description at some point. Most of them have been homeless and slept rough at some point and feel they need something to defend themselves with if they are attacked and knowing them I honestly don't think any of them would carry with the intention of using aggressively (as in not self defense). The rest are care experienced and have grown up in an environment where they have experienced extensive trauma and have learnt the hard way that they need to be seen as tough so they aren't seen as weaker targets by other young people in similar backgrounds and then abused further as a result. It's a pretty brutal environment to grow up in and we have to do a lot of work to convince them that they don't need 'protection' (as they see it) when they're in our centre and to use the sharps box we provide to dispose of weapons. None of our young people now carry regularly which is a sign they're doing better, feeling more confident and are more able to trust others and have better social groups. It also usually means they're living in more secure and stable accommodation. Obviously not every young person whos homeless or from a care background will carry but it makes it much more likely that they'll feel the pressure to. That being said I also think the issues we have here around knife crime are slightly different to the culture of knife crime that parts of England for example have so geography has an impact on it too.

TitsInAbsentia · 22/11/2022 19:23

They're out on the streets by me a lot, and knife crime is a big problem, but I don't give to any charity on the street...money, details, nothing. If they were just trying to stop you for a chat and give you a leaflet that would be fine, but they don't, so I won't. I don't buy that having youth clubs etc stops this kind of thing, unless you get get behind the gang cultures that exist nothing will help.

caringcarer · 22/11/2022 19:22

I don't mind contributing to some charities but I do object to the CEO getting hundreds of thousands in salary, money meant to go to the cause.