Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most managers are bad?

35 replies

Avisitboss · 22/11/2022 17:37

I have worked for a few different companies and various teams within them and on the whole, I would say you get more bad managers than good managers in terms of line managing and actually being able to do the people management part of the job well (development, criticism when needed) and remain professional?

I have had managers / directors who either get too friendly and want to be liked and then struggle to be tough when needed or a total nightmare and their personal mood / happiness dictates the whole team culture.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Overandunderit · 22/11/2022 23:18

Dammit hit send too soon

"What do you think we should do" because part of my job is to help my team be self sufficient independent. I've had people on my team react poorly to this responding "you're the manager you need to tell me" then wonder why they don't get promotions...

Overandunderit · 22/11/2022 23:16

Some are good some are bad.

I think people also have too high expectations of managers expecting them to have all the answers and not think for themselves.

When a colleague comes to me for advice I always ask "what do you think we sho

Laurendelaney1987 · 22/11/2022 22:46

I’ve had mainly good managers over the last 2 decades. But I did have meet quite a few arseholes when I worked in McDonald’s as a teenager

DarkKarmaIlama · 22/11/2022 19:17

The worst manager I ever had was a deputy head in a secondary school. The second worst manager I ever had was a head teacher in a primary school. Shockingly, shockingly poor management. Woeful.

Ive had some great managers too so it’s pretty much a 50:50 split.

Sparklesocks · 22/11/2022 19:15

I think one problem sometimes is that a lot of organisations use the manager role solely as a career progression thing, you get promoted to it after X amount of experience/high performance etc. But just because you’re good at your job doesn’t mean you’ll also be a good people manager. It’s often a completely different set of skills. Decent organisations need to invest in management training and do something like mentoring schemes for new managers.

I’ve had a real mix over the years. Most have been fine. A couple great, a couple really awful. I think the worst ones are those who ‘won’t get their hands dirty’ so to speak, and won’t muck in to help out with the work in high pressure periods because they’re above it all. So the direct reports feel resentment that they’re being run ragged and the manager looks like they’re twiddling thumbs. A good manager should never ask you to do something they wouldn’t also do themselves.

Spiderboy · 22/11/2022 19:15

CatJumperTwat · 22/11/2022 17:42

Did any of these companies give people training before promoting them to management? None of the ones I've worked for have. We're promoted based on our technical skills, given people to manage and expected to know how to motivate, develop, and give constructive feedback.

I do think this is a valid point. In my current work place all my managers have been internal promotions. None had additional training prior to being given a managerial role and it SHOWS. X2 we’re not people people, 1 was but struggled more with the business side of things. And my current one gets it all and is brilliant but I was hesitant as I didn’t think they have enough of a back bone initially but I was proved wrong

Kenwoodmixitup · 22/11/2022 19:11

My current line manager has effectively thrown me under the bus due to their lack of training and awareness

Spiderboy · 22/11/2022 19:11

I have a wonderful manager.

I have previously had managers that have took a people manager job because it is the next logical step…and nothing to do with them actually wanting to manage people, motivate them and drive their careers. They only want them to make them look good. You always felt their bad moods, they could be abrupt, sometimes you’d walk on egg shells. They all had good points too but you never knew what you were going to get.

My manager right now is amazing, consistent, reliable, motivating and wants to know where you excel and help you develop that in the right way. But also appreciates some people just wanna do 9-5 and clock off and values their work too.

thecatsthecats · 22/11/2022 19:08

Many are bad managers because they KNOW what they don't like about bad managers, but aren't confident enough to step away from the bad practices, because those are the trappings of power. They think if they let go of them, they let go of the power too.

I had some great training, which highlighted the pain points of management and taught you how to remove them. Management isn't about control to me - it's about removing obstacles, and taking advantage of the enthusiasm you can develop in an employee.

I think I was a great manager :D My current manager is shite!

balalake · 22/11/2022 19:06

I think I have had about 20 line managers, and would only say three were good people managers. YANBU.

Technical skills and business knowledge are not people skills.

WaveyHair · 22/11/2022 19:00

I have had both end of the scales - a couple of fantastic managers who behaved like a decent human beings to others who were utter monsters, who lied, bullied and blamed the team for their bad management and decisions.

Plenty of mediocre ones in the middle.

greenshirt06 · 22/11/2022 19:00

YABU- I think a lot depends on industry too. I've had some horrendous managers but luckily my last couple at my current company have been great. I manage a team of 6 and use my experiences from having crap managers to try & be the best manager I could possibly be (and I love being a manager too!).

restisall · 22/11/2022 18:59

I’ve gotten on well with most of my managers and don’t have anything against them as people, but would say there was only one who was really good at being a manager.

I was rubbish at it in my last job too though so I can’t talk! Just taken a new job with no line management responsibilities, and so far really like my own manager!

Berlinlover · 22/11/2022 18:53

I work in retail, the vast majority of managers are awful.

ColdHandsHotHead · 22/11/2022 18:12

I think quite often people get management jobs because they say the right things to the people above them, not because they are thought to have the right qualities. I had one manager who had this technique off to a fine art. She'd sit in meetings saying nothing until the most senior person there expressed an opinion. She would then back that person up.

She herself was an absolute nightmare to work with, chaotic, pushing blame for her own mistakes on to other people, spending most of her time on office politics.

Babyroobs · 22/11/2022 18:08

My last 2 before current job have been poor. One young , inexperienced, told a lot of lies to benefit himself etc, the one before that was frankly a bully. Current one is ok, a lovely person but ineffective, doesn't monitor her team properly and lets them get away with all sorts. On the whole most have been poor. They are either ogres and bullies or too soft and ineffective to manage.

TidyDancer · 22/11/2022 18:08

I've had one exceptionally good manager. She was caring and strong, extremely knowledgeable and not afraid to get stuck in when needed. I loved her and was really sad when she left. Things when downhill after that!

I have two in a job share at the moment. One is too soft and doesn't deal with anything properly and the other is a robot who sticks to the party line with no deviation. Neither are terribly observant regarding the problems in the team and have failed to deal with a fairly significant bullying situation which has seen one of the team struggling mentally.

I've had managers who are lazy, childish and dictatorial. It can be very hard to get it right admittedly, but I've had far more terrible ones than good.

Jumbojem · 22/11/2022 18:07

OP are you a manager yourself? I am and find it the most challenging aspect of my role. I try to get a feel for the person I'm working with, and the situation and adapt my management style to suit. It's really hard to do it well and I def get it wrong sometimes.
I had some not so good managers but none truly awful. My current one isn't great as he never makes notes so comms lack clarity and he avoids conflict which means sometimes issues are left to fester.
The biggest issue is being measured on results/delivery which means there's often no incentive to people manage well but just to hammer a team for results.

WelshNerd · 22/11/2022 18:04

I've recently been promoted into a role with line management. To echo other comments, I have been given no training and don't feel I'm managing my team as effectively as I could.

I'm going to put together a development plan for 2023 and source training so I can get to where I want to be but this is completely self driven. I've received no negative feedback from my superiors.

ErrolTheDragon · 22/11/2022 18:01

Ah....Just the way I'm feeling today maybe, RampantIvyGrin

Toooldtoworry · 22/11/2022 17:59

I went for a promotion to a management role, my training consisted of 20 minutes chat in to how to write a 1-1.

I left because I knew I wasn't giving my team what they needed.

RampantIvy · 22/11/2022 17:57

My current two (one is on Mat Leave, so he's covering for her) are brilliant. Very supportive and understanding. Our whole team is really happy with them and with each other. The morale is quite high.

That describes my line manager and HOD. They are very approachable and flexible. We have no narcissists or dead wood in our team, and there is give and take on both sides.

iklboo · 22/11/2022 17:52

My current two (one is on Mat Leave, so he's covering for her) are brilliant. Very supportive and understanding. Our whole team is really happy with them and with each other. The morale is quite high.

The one before them drove me to a breakdown and near suicide.

Thingsdogetbetter · 22/11/2022 17:52

Howdydodat · 22/11/2022 17:43

Peter principle

This and the fact that very few are trained. They get promoted and just expected to get on with it. In teaching it's either good teachers or good blaggers who get promoted but very few have the actual skills set to manage others.

Seymour5 · 22/11/2022 17:52

I’ve had some inspirational managers and some real idiots. I learnt how not to manage people by suffering those who see management as power, but ignore responsibility. More good than bad I’d say. I’ve managed teams, albeit at a low level, and its a rare joy if everyone pulls together.

However, after decades of work in different public sector organisations, I’ve also come to realise that some employees see managing as bullying, just because their manager was perhaps trying to get them to do their job?. They are often entitled (been there a long time, don’t like change) or bitter (how can someone outside the team got promoted over them?) or just lazy, inept etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread