Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think job application forms have become nuts?

113 replies

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 16:26

Why does everyone have an online form lately?

20+ criteria boxes to write in at length? It seems counter intuitive. Surely with cover letters and CVs you can judge much better the candidates literacy, ability to write at length and capabilities using computers? Particularly if they’ll be writing reports in the job.

Drop down menus for employment history, an hour or more of slow clicking instead of a few minutes typing up an employment record.

I’m looking at a shortage area too, with real recruitment issues. Disproportionately low pay too. Yet they give themselves another hoop with a 15/16 section form with fiddly drop downs.

The process with applying for someone jobs has become so lengthy it puts candidates off. I’ve just applied to two jobs with reasonable forms and ignored three with stupid forms. One of these contacted me to ask me to reply, I was eager, but I’m busy. I don’t have a life where I can or want to waste 6-8 hours on forms which could be potentially skim read and ignored.

Even a preliminary stage of CVS would be useful, before expecting candidates to wade through hoops.

Before my current role I withdrew from a job I wanted because they had a form, then test, then more online forms, then more tests (all with massive time delays too) for a 28k position!

I used to recruit, like of CVS and cover letters. Easy to read, simple and spoke volumes. I wouldn’t as a recruiter either want to deal with the fuss of online forms sectioned into many pages on my
screen.

OP posts:
Woodlandarchitect11 · 22/11/2022 19:32

University of Exeter job application forms are ridiculous. 🤣 I binned it off after an hour

FluffyPancake · 22/11/2022 19:31

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 16:27

(I do check for typos went not ranting online 😆)

Oh the irony of this post 😆

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:30

Surely this could have been weeded out in a half decent interview process? How on earth was it missed? If relevant to the role a short task would have covered this

OP posts:
LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:29

AffIt · 22/11/2022 16:35

I work in information systems and part of my job includes system selection and implementation for automated processes, including recruitment.

Most companies, especially large public sector / global orgs, will use some form of AI to view applications, which will often be in the 100s, if not 1,000s. It would not be possible to expect a human to correctly and evaluate that volume of data.

The problem with personal CVs is that they are rarely, if ever, written in a standard form, so almost impossible for an AI-driven platform to interpret, hence pre-determined data capture methods which are programmed to seek out particular keywords / phrases etc.

Appreciate it's a hassle for employees, but recruitment is an ENORMOUS pain in the back end for employers and this is the way the world is moving.

My top tip would be that you prepare a 'cheat sheet' of the sort of questions asked (most are more or less the same), and then tweak it to ensure you capture the keywords listed in the job description, because that's what the tool is looking for.

I don’t think I have any interest in writing for hours just to be viewed by AI

OP posts:
LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:28

Phineyj · 22/11/2022 19:22

I've experienced the same as @Allergictoironing. I'm a decade younger, but because I freelanced for a number of years it's almost impossible for me to comply with 'list every job you've had in chronological order' forms as I used to often have a part time employed job overlapping with freelance work - it just doesn't work.

I'm a teacher now and every school needs to know the same stuff yet every school has a wildly different application form. Now that is a sector with serious skills shortages and where the applications absolutely could be standardised.

Fiddly forms select out people busy doing a job similar to the one you want to hire them for and select in people with time on their hands.

I’m having this issue. I’m working self-employed in three different areas around family life!

OP posts:
LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:27

AceofPentacles · 22/11/2022 16:33

When I worked with care leavers this was definitely totally off putting - Tesco's had a long form and an online test - for stacking shelves!

I feel old. I used to work for Tesco and sift the forms as a receptionist. They were handwritten and stacked in old photocopy boxes under the desk!

Actually worked well. Handed them out in person, so never got too many and only handed them to people who asked in a reasonable manner.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 22/11/2022 19:22

I've experienced the same as @Allergictoironing. I'm a decade younger, but because I freelanced for a number of years it's almost impossible for me to comply with 'list every job you've had in chronological order' forms as I used to often have a part time employed job overlapping with freelance work - it just doesn't work.

I'm a teacher now and every school needs to know the same stuff yet every school has a wildly different application form. Now that is a sector with serious skills shortages and where the applications absolutely could be standardised.

Fiddly forms select out people busy doing a job similar to the one you want to hire them for and select in people with time on their hands.

thecatsthecats · 22/11/2022 18:50

I find it extremely hypocritical when employers have huge long application processes but then a statement about diversity and inclusion.

Well, actually, not everyone has the time to jump through a billion and one hoops to apply for your job - and if you're that keen on diversity, you don't want to be throwing up obstacles that don't actually assess the ability to do the job.

I'm actually a fan of a a lot of the processes in the education services sector though. You upload your CV, and answer a few interview style questions. They shuffle and mark the questions before they look at the CVs. I think that's both manageable and fair.

jetadore · 22/11/2022 18:43

Look these companies probably waste spend a lot of money on IT contracts to ”deliver” “services” like these tedious application forms, which is why the salaries are so low and staff turnover is so high.

Allergictoironing · 22/11/2022 18:31

I have absolutely no problem in filling in forms with stuff like diversity data, any criminal record, right to work in UK etc, and a section in free text on how you fulfil the requirements for the role. At the age of 61 I do have an issue with having to retype the details of every single job I've had in 40 years of working, especially as I spent a fair amount of time in contract roles, when they've also asked for a CV. And guess what - no I don't have available the details of my line manager or HR department from 25 years ago when the company folded a few years after I left, or they were taken over, or they moved head office a number of times since.

Another one I find makes me want to give up is when the company is in a "blue collar" sector, and 3/4 of the form relates to things like "do you have a cherry picker license", "which of the manufacturing machine types have you ben trained on" or asking when you took various manual handling qualifications - when the job you're applying for is back office admin.

I was also mildly irritated to be asked to show my "O" level certificates from 45 years ago (hint - don't still have them). Luckily they were happy to accept copies of assorted professional Project Management qualification certificates in their place, but them actually seeing the certificates or equivalent was a mandatory requirement for recruitment there. And no, not all roles in the organisation needed this because higher level roles (managerial) in a different area didn't need them.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 22/11/2022 18:12

I think of it in terms of externalities.

Unless you legislate against it or force companies to bear costs somehow, a company will always prefer to dump a load of pollution that makes people ill and costs taxpayers a fortune to clean up, rather than dispose of it safely for a fraction of what cleanup would cost, because dumping it is very cheap for them and they're not the ones who bear the costs of the unsafe dumping.

And a company doesn't care that they're forcing applicants, successful and otherwise, to spend hundreds and hundreds of hours on going through their recruitment process, because those hours and that effort don't cost them anything. If imposing a laborious process means that they think they're less likely to hire the wrong candidate candidate or that they can do the recruitment with fewer staff hours, they'll do it, no matter the cost in time and effort to candidates, because the company aren't the ones bearing that cost. If you can save one staff hour by making a hundred candidates waste an hour each they'll do it. Applicant time and effort is an externality so they don't give a shit unless it starts to affect their bottom line by e.g. making it impossible for them to recruit.

TellMeWhere · 22/11/2022 18:06

I hate LinkedIn as a social media platform but it can be very useful for avoiding forms... upload your cv and just ping it out. Although you never know if "apply now" is going to take you to an external link... TO THE FORM...

My pet peeve is no salary info. I work in an admin role where salaries can range from £20-80k+. I really need to know which end of the scale you're on before I waste my time applying. When recruitment team members call me, money is always one of the first things I raise. People like to shy away from talking money but I'm not gonna interview without knowing salaries.

LuciferRising · 22/11/2022 17:53

We do blind recruiting, which can't be done via cover letter or CV. We also need to ensure certain criteria have been met before we get to interview stage.

It enables us to assess standardised applications, which is important when there are many applicants. We have to grade each application again a set criteria. You may miss all of those if you send in a CV and covering letter. All of this is to ensure fairness, consistency and to reduce bias.

GiltEdges · 22/11/2022 17:52

Maybe it’s the level of job you’re applying for, as it’s not been my experience at all in the past 3-4 years, despite changing jobs 3 times. If anything, LinkedIn EasyApply means I haven’t filled out a single application form.

Also, CVs tell you nothing about a candidate’s literacy when so many people use standard templates and/or CV writing services to do the job for them.

MangyInseam · 22/11/2022 17:49

Yes, they really can be. I was filling out applications last year for jobs in a big health care org, and the forms, and the drop down boxes, were crazy. And not easy to use, they seemed to constantly lose information. In fact at one point I asked a friend why I hadn't heard from them and it was because somehow the box for "country" said I lived on another continent altogether.

I am reasonably computer literate, too, this organization is always complaining that they can't get people, well, no wonder.

Fleabigg · 22/11/2022 17:48

I don’t like CVs, but our application forms are just basic employment history, academic history and then 2 sides supporting statement where you demonstrate you meet the person spec. Not too onerous and easy to shortlist from.

Topseyt123 · 22/11/2022 17:45

I agree. I think it is totally absurd. All of these long winded online forms with psychometric testing are disillusioning and off-putting.

These days it seems like a rarity even to get to interview stage. Personally, I can sell my myself and my skills much better if I can just get into a position where I am talking to an actual person, not just doing a box ticking exercise.

One interview I did get to was with Waitrose. There were 8 (I think) of us. We were divided into twos and each pair were given a packet of dried spaghetti and a packet of jelly babies! We were then told to build a tower with them. 🤔🙄

I never did understand what that was all about. Didn't get the job (shelf stacking), and was no longer bothered after that.

BellePeppa · 22/11/2022 17:26

PontinsBeach · 22/11/2022 16:43

I nearly applied for an evening bar job and in the end, I got put off by the application. The last question was “What’s the most mortifying thing that has ever happened to you in your personal life, and how did you deal with it?”. My thoughts were “Well I’m not going to tell you about the time I was severely ill after giving birth and dropped my baby in front of my husband’s family, and hated myself for months, and I can’t be arsed coming up with a story, so fuck off”.

That’s ridiculous! Years ago people got bar jobs by walking in and asking if they needed help and if they did you started the next day. I had loads of bar jobs when I was younger without any of the hassle we get today.

JennyForeigner · 22/11/2022 17:26

A friend of mine is a Principal and cannot get exam invigilators for love of money. I am at home round the corner and would've been happy to help out. I'm registered with the Trust for various reasons including safeguarding training related, so they hold all of my information including references and DBS.

The form was 8 pages long including a full career history. I'd agreed with my friend that I would point to the answers they already had filed information for rather than doing it in full.

Didn't work. They had some kind of automatic screening process that meant it was spat back at me 23 times. I eventually had to fill it in as a career starter :-/

meanderingthrough · 22/11/2022 17:05

I've got some actual data on this. The longer the form, the greater the drop off in completion (no surprises there!), simple fact. They'll get the people motivated to finish the form, but miss everyone that gets fed up and leaves. It's for their benefit not yours, IT tail wagging the recruitment dog!

PontinsBeach · 22/11/2022 17:01

I’ve also found a lot of the big supermarkets post fake job listings. I noticed my local ASDA was constantly hiring for nights, I repeatedly applied, never got so much as a rejection email. Spoke to my niece who worked there and she was very confused, said there’d been no talk of needing anybody for nights and that they were actually very well staffed, in fact there’d even been a couple of redundancies! They must just be trying to fill a corporate quota.

SavingsThreads · 22/11/2022 16:59

It weeds out the time wasters, is more EDI proficient, and shorterns the burden on recruiters.

We've just moved to this system and I hate it :D

musicviking1 · 22/11/2022 16:54

What's worse is when you get past the application process and find out there's then a six stage interview process taking up hours of prep time - get past that to find out they aren't sure what they are looking i.e they just wanted some free consultancy.

Lcb123 · 22/11/2022 16:48

As an employer, it's actually so much easier to review candidates fairly with a standard application form. Otherwise you spend so much time digging around everyone's CV and cover letter in a different format. As an applicant I'd much rather fill in a section related to each criteria than try and formulate a cover letter. You avoid all the waffle as well, you often get in cover letters. Appreciate it's time consuming but I always keep a Word document with what answers I've used on these forms before, so if doing multiple applications I can refer to that. I think companies will move towards form more and more as it also allows for 'name blind' recruitment

NotTooOldPaul · 22/11/2022 16:45

I can remember interviewing someone who had a well presented CV. The CV included that he had good IT skills. I gave him a job and was showing him.the company's system. He suddenly asked me how I was typing capital letters!! It turned out that a friend had produced his CV for him so that it looked good.
There is no way to weed out such dishonesty but online forms can help.