Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think job application forms have become nuts?

113 replies

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 16:26

Why does everyone have an online form lately?

20+ criteria boxes to write in at length? It seems counter intuitive. Surely with cover letters and CVs you can judge much better the candidates literacy, ability to write at length and capabilities using computers? Particularly if they’ll be writing reports in the job.

Drop down menus for employment history, an hour or more of slow clicking instead of a few minutes typing up an employment record.

I’m looking at a shortage area too, with real recruitment issues. Disproportionately low pay too. Yet they give themselves another hoop with a 15/16 section form with fiddly drop downs.

The process with applying for someone jobs has become so lengthy it puts candidates off. I’ve just applied to two jobs with reasonable forms and ignored three with stupid forms. One of these contacted me to ask me to reply, I was eager, but I’m busy. I don’t have a life where I can or want to waste 6-8 hours on forms which could be potentially skim read and ignored.

Even a preliminary stage of CVS would be useful, before expecting candidates to wade through hoops.

Before my current role I withdrew from a job I wanted because they had a form, then test, then more online forms, then more tests (all with massive time delays too) for a 28k position!

I used to recruit, like of CVS and cover letters. Easy to read, simple and spoke volumes. I wouldn’t as a recruiter either want to deal with the fuss of online forms sectioned into many pages on my
screen.

OP posts:
Cornishmarketingtithead · 22/11/2022 21:02

Woo hoo found my people. Down ere in Cornwall we often get application forms dated from the 90s to fill in. Seasalt even asked for a presentation and an application form - for a NMW marketing job. 😂

Anyway, I'm unemployed thanks to redundancy. And desperately want a job so I'm focusing on remote jobs now (for a bit of diversity & an interesting role!) Can anyone recommend any decent recruiters?

My brain is FRIED from scanning LinkedIn. But since it's the topic of this thread I just thought I'd ask.

So yeah... digital marketing recruiters. Anyone? 😊

Usernamesarboring · 22/11/2022 20:58

Op, it is to make candidates fill up the data for their candidate database, in the end they also ask you to attach CV which is used for interviewing.

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 20:55

I’ve had such awful experiences with companies I don’t want to devote hours to the process.

One of my worst was an observation for a teaching role. I was given a rowdy class, nice enough but with clear needs, by a TA who then informed me it was just their role to show me to the room. I’d prepared a good lesson and no one showed up. After 20 min I was pretty annoyed and stuck my head out the door. No one in sight, no internal phones and I wasn’t sure about which pupils it was safe to send out or even where to send them (it was a funny layout, they’d just moved into a new building and where the only occupied room on the corridor).

After 55 min the deputy strolled in! I was annoyed and just left her with the class to dismiss them for lunch, having wasted a whole observation of planned sideways. As well as dealing with some significant SEN needs that were unclear.

The bizarre bit though is they ring me an hour later to offer the job.

OP posts:
Beancounter1 · 22/11/2022 20:08

Merlott · 22/11/2022 19:44

Recruitment agencies are absolutely cleaning up, in part due to this trend.

I've never got an offer from a stupid form job. Worst was 8h not even joking . For a uni who made me do a presentation on top of that and interview. They already had an internal person lined up and never intended to hire! Never again.

Agencies are the way to go!

Yup. If I was job hunting again, I would just use agencies.

I was unemployed and doing several applications a week. Sent in my (fully comprehensive) CV with cover letter to a junior job, got a form back in the post, so I binned it and moved on to the next application.
I was simultaneously signed up with a few agencies to find me a permanent job. One agency later sent my CV in to the employer whose application form I had binned, I went along to an interview and got the job. The employer had to pay a hefty finder's fee to the agency!
A few weeks later, someone in HR put two and two together and I was asked if I had already sent in my CV before the agency did, so of course I said I had, and they were a bit put out to find out that I had just binned their form. They were of the opinion that if a candidate couldn't be bothered to fill in the form, then they shouldn't get the job. I was of the opinion that if they really wanted to recruit, they should have accepted my CV. It was clearly a job-hunter's market, as was proved when they ended up paying an agency just to get someone.

This was not even an online form - just a paper one sent in the post.

IveDroppedMiBiscuitInMiBrew · 22/11/2022 20:06

I'm about to do an application form, I'm sat here procrastinating about it as I don't want to have to sit and enter everything with the god dam drop down menus. Hours it'll take. I have a cv ready to go, it could take me an hour to tweak a personal statement and add a line to my cv, but no. Stupid form it is.

I helped to sift for a job that had 180 applications recently, we literally binned anyone who didn't have the correct degree when the person specification had said "or equivalent experience" it wasted so many people's time. Just put that in the add if that's your criteria!! I felt awful the speed people were binned when I knew the form must have taken hours.

JaceLancs · 22/11/2022 20:03

We mainly use application form which is 2 A4 pages
when we have tried cvs we just get loads of people who aren’t interested submitting generic cvs to fulfil their job searching criteria
shortlisting cvs takes longer and it’s harder to remove details
we shortlist blind without knowing age, gender etc

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 22/11/2022 20:01

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:55

I end up ‘lying’, being asked to provide the exact date I left a role in 1994 or the date a qualification was issued in 2001 is frankly guesswork on my part.
Stuffing self-employment into the employment boxes requires more fudging.
It may have worked when I was a graduate, but these dates stuffing in details to drop down boxes is mind boggling.

I also end up "lying" when they want to know qualifications, because their boxes tend to have predefined inputs that don't match what I have — I have an Access to HE diploma rather than A levels or BTEC, and sometimes end up having to put something like the A level equivalent according to the UCAS points tariff, which doesn't do me any favours.

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 20:00

ChillysWaterBottle · 22/11/2022 19:54

The job application process should be one of mutual respect and effort - it benefits the company to hire the right person, and it benefits the applicant to be hired for the right role. These forms are disrespectful to the applicant as they demand they waste time copying and pasting information that they will already have laid out in a CV into a specific format for no real or good reason. Doing this for your education history, work history, training and professional qualifications etc can take ages. The only thing that should take time is the statement laying out your suitability against the person specification, why should you spend hours (unpaid) making the life of the recruiter (paid) easier? I vowed never to bother with one of those and when I was recruiting for my last project I pushed back and refused to use application forms. It was all the rage in my sector for a while but funnily enough it seems to be falling out of fashion. We have mostly staff from diverse backgrounds coming through non-traditional routes and the idea that these terrible forms improve DEI is just silly. They are a massive barrier to a huge subset of the population. I've recruited several times and I believe strongly in respecting your applicants.

This is my thinking. What are my chances of being respected in a company with these processes.

I look at too many friends on p/t contracts working all the hours every day. They eat their time with meetings online on days off etc.

I don’t want that kind of job. I’d earn more in a far simpler role on an hourly rate than they often do in f/t high level roles working this way.

OP posts:
HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 22/11/2022 20:00

I don't think recruiters look at the forms, the point is to sift out anyone who doesn't meet the criteria - i.e. get candidates to filter themselves out of the process - like education level, location, salary expectation etc. I understand it's a pain but when you're hiring hundreds of people I think manually reading CVs would be much, much more time consuming for the employer.

FirewomanSam · 22/11/2022 20:00

I’ve only ever really applied to jobs that use online application forms (been working for the past 15 years) so I’m completely used to it, even though I agree it’s tedious. What irritates me though is when they have a long application form AND ask you to uploaded a CV. If I have to go to the trouble of entering it all into many, many boxes on a form then why do you need it uploaded in my CV too?

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:55

Colacoco · 22/11/2022 19:50

Isnt there a legal thing in that you can leave info out on a CV and obscure facts but you can be dismissed if you lie/ deliberately mislead on an application form?

I end up ‘lying’, being asked to provide the exact date I left a role in 1994 or the date a qualification was issued in 2001 is frankly guesswork on my part.
Stuffing self-employment into the employment boxes requires more fudging.
It may have worked when I was a graduate, but these dates stuffing in details to drop down boxes is mind boggling.

OP posts:
ChillysWaterBottle · 22/11/2022 19:54

The job application process should be one of mutual respect and effort - it benefits the company to hire the right person, and it benefits the applicant to be hired for the right role. These forms are disrespectful to the applicant as they demand they waste time copying and pasting information that they will already have laid out in a CV into a specific format for no real or good reason. Doing this for your education history, work history, training and professional qualifications etc can take ages. The only thing that should take time is the statement laying out your suitability against the person specification, why should you spend hours (unpaid) making the life of the recruiter (paid) easier? I vowed never to bother with one of those and when I was recruiting for my last project I pushed back and refused to use application forms. It was all the rage in my sector for a while but funnily enough it seems to be falling out of fashion. We have mostly staff from diverse backgrounds coming through non-traditional routes and the idea that these terrible forms improve DEI is just silly. They are a massive barrier to a huge subset of the population. I've recruited several times and I believe strongly in respecting your applicants.

JennyForeigner · 22/11/2022 19:53

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:28

I’m having this issue. I’m working self-employed in three different areas around family life!

I'm going to have this issue in future as I have young children and have decided to set up alone, doing the things I used to do professionally across a couple of sectors. I've set up a company for this reason - it took a few minutes online and I'm taking advice from an accountant to make sure it's the right structure and so on for me.

I figure if it works out, great. If I want to return to one job in future, I have a tidy basket to put it all in for my cv, and I may even look at restructuring and routing a part time role through the company as I understand this might simplify things like our childcare eligibility. I was surprised how straightforward it was though.

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:52

Merlott · 22/11/2022 19:44

Recruitment agencies are absolutely cleaning up, in part due to this trend.

I've never got an offer from a stupid form job. Worst was 8h not even joking . For a uni who made me do a presentation on top of that and interview. They already had an internal person lined up and never intended to hire! Never again.

Agencies are the way to go!

This is what makes me so reluctant to engage. So often in roles such as university lecturing you are just part of a show of open interviewing.

OP posts:
barskits · 22/11/2022 19:52

Topseyt123 · 22/11/2022 17:45

I agree. I think it is totally absurd. All of these long winded online forms with psychometric testing are disillusioning and off-putting.

These days it seems like a rarity even to get to interview stage. Personally, I can sell my myself and my skills much better if I can just get into a position where I am talking to an actual person, not just doing a box ticking exercise.

One interview I did get to was with Waitrose. There were 8 (I think) of us. We were divided into twos and each pair were given a packet of dried spaghetti and a packet of jelly babies! We were then told to build a tower with them. 🤔🙄

I never did understand what that was all about. Didn't get the job (shelf stacking), and was no longer bothered after that.

I'm feeling the urge to build a tower with dried spaghetti and jelly babies now!

Xenia · 22/11/2022 19:51

It has got completely out of hand and in a sense is a theft of people's time.

Colacoco · 22/11/2022 19:50

Isnt there a legal thing in that you can leave info out on a CV and obscure facts but you can be dismissed if you lie/ deliberately mislead on an application form?

WednesdaysChild11 · 22/11/2022 19:49

Completely agree, I don't even tend to apply for jobs with application forms anymore unless they're really simple.

SoFreshAndSoCleanClean · 22/11/2022 19:47

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 22/11/2022 18:12

I think of it in terms of externalities.

Unless you legislate against it or force companies to bear costs somehow, a company will always prefer to dump a load of pollution that makes people ill and costs taxpayers a fortune to clean up, rather than dispose of it safely for a fraction of what cleanup would cost, because dumping it is very cheap for them and they're not the ones who bear the costs of the unsafe dumping.

And a company doesn't care that they're forcing applicants, successful and otherwise, to spend hundreds and hundreds of hours on going through their recruitment process, because those hours and that effort don't cost them anything. If imposing a laborious process means that they think they're less likely to hire the wrong candidate candidate or that they can do the recruitment with fewer staff hours, they'll do it, no matter the cost in time and effort to candidates, because the company aren't the ones bearing that cost. If you can save one staff hour by making a hundred candidates waste an hour each they'll do it. Applicant time and effort is an externality so they don't give a shit unless it starts to affect their bottom line by e.g. making it impossible for them to recruit.

Well said.

Merlott · 22/11/2022 19:44

Recruitment agencies are absolutely cleaning up, in part due to this trend.

I've never got an offer from a stupid form job. Worst was 8h not even joking . For a uni who made me do a presentation on top of that and interview. They already had an internal person lined up and never intended to hire! Never again.

Agencies are the way to go!

emmylousings · 22/11/2022 19:39

YANBU. Apparently we have dire labour shortages in many areas. I'm guessing a lot of people don't have the tech or literacy skills to do these long-winded application forms; though they could do the actual job perfectly well. Why are we creating additional barriers to work when there are enough already!!

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 19:38

FluffyPancake · 22/11/2022 19:31

Oh the irony of this post 😆

Weak humour I know…

OP posts:
mummybear2104 · 22/11/2022 19:36

Just to pop on and mention National Careers service you can have your own mentor that can support with CV's, applications. I found it of great support and a real eye opener when developing a new CV

ping78 · 22/11/2022 19:35

It's horrible as a recruiter as well. Takes so much time. I'm pretty sure I could gauge whether someone could do a job just with a CV and interview. Maybe a short covering letter.

Daviduk86 · 22/11/2022 19:34

This reply has been deleted

We have deleted all posts and threads from this user as we have suspicions about how genuine they are.