Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think job application forms have become nuts?

113 replies

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 16:26

Why does everyone have an online form lately?

20+ criteria boxes to write in at length? It seems counter intuitive. Surely with cover letters and CVs you can judge much better the candidates literacy, ability to write at length and capabilities using computers? Particularly if they’ll be writing reports in the job.

Drop down menus for employment history, an hour or more of slow clicking instead of a few minutes typing up an employment record.

I’m looking at a shortage area too, with real recruitment issues. Disproportionately low pay too. Yet they give themselves another hoop with a 15/16 section form with fiddly drop downs.

The process with applying for someone jobs has become so lengthy it puts candidates off. I’ve just applied to two jobs with reasonable forms and ignored three with stupid forms. One of these contacted me to ask me to reply, I was eager, but I’m busy. I don’t have a life where I can or want to waste 6-8 hours on forms which could be potentially skim read and ignored.

Even a preliminary stage of CVS would be useful, before expecting candidates to wade through hoops.

Before my current role I withdrew from a job I wanted because they had a form, then test, then more online forms, then more tests (all with massive time delays too) for a 28k position!

I used to recruit, like of CVS and cover letters. Easy to read, simple and spoke volumes. I wouldn’t as a recruiter either want to deal with the fuss of online forms sectioned into many pages on my
screen.

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 23/11/2022 13:21

I don't mind forms as long as they basically allow for information to be lifted directly from a cv. Anything that's pages and pages long (and worst, still requires a CV to be attached) can just fuck off.

Recruiters and HR types need to make these things as simple and as quick as possible for people to complete, demanding a 10 page form be filled in just to make their lives easier is just plain rude.

Phineyj · 23/11/2022 13:12

I have given up seeking teaching jobs through normal means. I just use contacts now so I can evaluate the place and the job before filling in the damn forms!

queenofthewild · 23/11/2022 12:56

School recruitment forms. They need to cover a lot of detail because after recruitment processes are important. But it took me several evenings to fill in the form for a school office job. I gritted my teeth and got on with it because a few years ago a school office job - term time school hours was desirable.

No one is applying for these jobs now. Schools can't recruit. The pay and conditions aren't great but the application process must put off so many people.

Meseekslookatme · 23/11/2022 12:38

I no longer bother with anything other than agencies.

When I got made redundant a few years ago I couldn't believe the amount of hoops you're expected to jump through for really quite mundane jobs.
Maybe now there's a bit of a labour shortage they'll calm down on that crap.
I abandoned one application because it just was hours of work, I felt my time was better used elsewhere.
The same company approached me and asked me to interview because they spotted me on LinkedIn! 🤣
I get that it's to weed out the non serious applications, but FFS respect my time too. If you don't respect me and my skills I'm not interested in your company.

WhiteFire · 23/11/2022 00:16

I am currently applying for a new job. Thankfully for small mercies the majority will be through one of two portals.

So the first one I did took ages as I had to fill out everything, DH asked if I could c&p where job role had changed but employee the same for example, but everything was an individual (as in an address line) or drop down box so you couldn't. Luckily I had applied for another job a few years ago and had printed out all the info so I could just fill in the new one.

That was unsuccessful, it was a long shot as I didn't meet one of the essential criteria (nothing training wouldn't have resolved). However I am now doing another one and the main information has transferred over, so I just need to do the unique / specific parts.

I'm still to do one on the NHS portal though.

My early career was so much easier with pen and paper.

Obbydoo · 22/11/2022 23:32

fairywhale · 22/11/2022 23:21

Must be an army of useless HR people producing those firms to show they have something to do. Very off-putting for the applicants and I'm sure many will avoid.

If you can't see why the 'useless HR people' do it, that suggests you are considerably more useless than they are! With such ill-informed views, I'd suggest putting you off applying is probably very useful rather than useless.

Obbydoo · 22/11/2022 23:28

I work in recruitment and can see it from both sides. I appreciate it's time consuming but on the flipside, it often means that the employer gets a smaller but better quality field. Those that are just time wasters, wanging their CVs out left, right and centre with little care for whether they actually match the spec won't apply and, if you can't answer the questions you'll give up. That should leave the employer with just those who genuinely match the spec and want that specific job, (as opposed to any old job).

It also helps the candidate as, if you can't answer the questions then you're not right for the job so better not to waste your time cimpleting the application. If you could answer the questions but can't be bothered then you clearly don't want the job that much in which case, you've saved your time and the recruiters by not applying.

fairywhale · 22/11/2022 23:26

In fact it's a good way to weed out the best applicants and have mostly those who are truly desperate apply, usually the ones out of work. People with options won't waste time filling out lenghty application forms.
The official reason will be to make all applications uniform and comparable. Which does not actually happen.

fairywhale · 22/11/2022 23:21

Forms

fairywhale · 22/11/2022 23:21

Must be an army of useless HR people producing those firms to show they have something to do. Very off-putting for the applicants and I'm sure many will avoid.

MangyInseam · 22/11/2022 23:16

IveDroppedMiBiscuitInMiBrew · 22/11/2022 20:06

I'm about to do an application form, I'm sat here procrastinating about it as I don't want to have to sit and enter everything with the god dam drop down menus. Hours it'll take. I have a cv ready to go, it could take me an hour to tweak a personal statement and add a line to my cv, but no. Stupid form it is.

I helped to sift for a job that had 180 applications recently, we literally binned anyone who didn't have the correct degree when the person specification had said "or equivalent experience" it wasted so many people's time. Just put that in the add if that's your criteria!! I felt awful the speed people were binned when I knew the form must have taken hours.

What's also terrible is that many good candidates get missed with this kind of emphasis on certain tick-boxes. Which is why they usually have said "or equivalent experience."

My experience is that these kind of complicated forms don't make it easier to find the best people.

And I also will say that where I have been in or interviewed with employers that has the most processes in place to supposedly make their hiring less biased - it did not work. If anything, it hid the fact that they were working on preconcieved ideas as much as anyone could be.

Luellie · 22/11/2022 22:57

I don't mind an application form - irritating to fill out but I can see their purpose.

What I object to is the ridiculous pseudo-scientific personality tests some companies insist on making you do. I also cannot stand multiple interviews for jobs that just don't warrant it.

Years ago, I applied for an entry-level position when I graduated uni. Barely over minimum wage. I had to do some irritating personality tests and then go for two interviews. The two interviews were basically identical, just with different people. Same questions, same conversations, same everything - I felt like I was having deja vu. I got the impression they just wanted to feel important by dragging the process out in multiple stages. When they gave me the job offer, I rejected it and told them why! I think a company's recruitment process shows you the level of respect they have for employees.

futuremoneyinbank · 22/11/2022 22:41

I completely agree. Makes me think it's a computer deciding at HR rather than someone actually deciding based on employment history. Having to do one for every position is mind-numbingly tedious when we all have CV's on file.

Waitingfordecember · 22/11/2022 22:31

Duttercup · 22/11/2022 16:30

It's mad. My mum wanted to change jobs after 20 years in the same job and has no idea where to begin. She only wanted a nice little admin job.

Now if she wants a job, I do the application for her in return for dinner. But I worry about people who don't have someone on hand to help...

I get that it’s annoying but I wouldn’t want to hire someone for an admin job if they couldn’t navigate an online application from… surely that means that their IT skills aren’t up to scratch?

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 22:22

lap90 · 22/11/2022 21:40

My issue is that a lot of jobs dont even state salary or claim some 'competitive' BS and yet they want you to complete a tiresome application.

YES. It’s like a NMW klaxon

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 22/11/2022 21:46

Don't get me started on the full career history, including any gaps.

My 20s were interesting. Quite a few jobs, travelling. Is that relevant many years later? It does put me off job applications.

lap90 · 22/11/2022 21:40

My issue is that a lot of jobs dont even state salary or claim some 'competitive' BS and yet they want you to complete a tiresome application.

Cornishmarketingtithead · 22/11/2022 21:21

😂 omg that's so funny!

Well in true Cornish style I was asked "who'd be home cooking tea if you were ere working?"

For a sizeable well known charity with a 14 page application form

as soon as mortgage rates come down, I'm off

LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 21:18

echt · 22/11/2022 21:15

Thinking of the UK where I taught for 25+ years, all jobs were application forms, and it's about uniformity of response, and accuracy. Supporting statements were allowed, but covering letters had to be just the indication of what was in the envelope, i.e application for X job. Specifically no CVs.

A CV can be full of irrelevancies and omissions, a form can't. Or at least you can be pulled up for lying. I remember there used to be a question asking had you ever taught under another name - to weed out the serial shit/weird teachers.

The ‘other name’ question is just to cover those of us who taught under both married and maiden names. My QTS certificate is not in the same name as my most recent job, it’s pretty common in female dominated industry.

OP posts:
LiveIngSun · 22/11/2022 21:17

Cornishmarketingtithead · 22/11/2022 21:02

Woo hoo found my people. Down ere in Cornwall we often get application forms dated from the 90s to fill in. Seasalt even asked for a presentation and an application form - for a NMW marketing job. 😂

Anyway, I'm unemployed thanks to redundancy. And desperately want a job so I'm focusing on remote jobs now (for a bit of diversity & an interesting role!) Can anyone recommend any decent recruiters?

My brain is FRIED from scanning LinkedIn. But since it's the topic of this thread I just thought I'd ask.

So yeah... digital marketing recruiters. Anyone? 😊

I once was asked to do a presentation I wasn’t expecting. Left with a flipchart and 4 different coloured maker pens.

On feedback I was told my use of colours made it look ‘unprofessional’, as I used all 4.

I stopped giving a fuck halfway through tbh, they are lucky I didn’t just doodle rainbows.

OP posts:
echt · 22/11/2022 21:15

Thinking of the UK where I taught for 25+ years, all jobs were application forms, and it's about uniformity of response, and accuracy. Supporting statements were allowed, but covering letters had to be just the indication of what was in the envelope, i.e application for X job. Specifically no CVs.

A CV can be full of irrelevancies and omissions, a form can't. Or at least you can be pulled up for lying. I remember there used to be a question asking had you ever taught under another name - to weed out the serial shit/weird teachers.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/11/2022 21:12

At the age of 61 I do have an issue with having to retype the details of every single job I've had in 40 years of working, especially as I spent a fair amount of time in contract roles, when they've also asked for a CV. And guess what - no I don't have available the details of my line manager or HR department from 25 years ago when the company folded a few years after I left, or they were taken over, or they moved head office a number of times since

I'm a bit older than you, temped for years, and when I was offered a temp to perm had considerable problems with the external reference checker company that Could Not Understand that temping is a) sporadic b) can be for a few weeks and I'm not clogging my CV up with the time a local charity needed an accounts stand in for a couple of weeks. And half of those jobs I either can't remember or don't want to. They wanted to know what I did with my time off between every assigment and back up from friends that I was actually between jobs and not, as I assume they suspected, in prison. Pointed out that I didn't keep my social circle THAT updated with my work history and take what I'd told them or leave it.

One reason why I'm going back to temping via an agency next year. They know me and can vouch for my work.

LadyGaGasPokerFace · 22/11/2022 21:09

It’s the several interviews as well as tests. And a partridge in a pear fucking tree. Not sure how the expect you to take time off for all those stages.

FearofQueefing · 22/11/2022 21:07

It's insane. HR teams take note.

I switched jobs last year and one of the things that really sold me on the organisation was the ease of their application and interview processes. All very candidate friendly. It spoke volumes about the company culture. A year in and I'm very happy 😊

A580Hojas · 22/11/2022 21:05

Yanbu. What are CVs for? What a fucking waste of time for everyone.