Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you about my first week as a HCA in a hospital?

215 replies

atronger · 22/11/2022 15:59

I am gobsmacked.

I didn't get any training. I did an online video training series, that lasted about an hour. Then done.

Some competencies like blood pressure checks etc signed off by a RN during my shift. And that's it

Second day in and I was asked to administer paracemtol twice by two different doctors! I said to them both I'm not a nurse. I cannot administer drugs but I can ask someone to do it. They both told me off, and the last one told me I was 'just being useless'

I was on a morning shift today and a senior nurse was extremely rude to me because I couldn't fix a cast (fracture clinic). I am not trained to! More snidey remarks

Yesterday I was on a night shift and asked by a senior nurse to help clean a wound. Didn't really feel it waa my place to do so, spoke out about it but she showed me once and I got it, so did the other leg for this very lovely patient. All fine. But felt pressured to do it when I wasn't really sure I was allowed. Was completely brushed off like I was being ridiculous and of course I could. Then got a telling off by ward sister for doing so Sad

I came into this because I'm very interested in becoming a Nurse when the time is right in my personal life. But I'm shocked at how some medical staff speak to their colleagues EnvySad

OP posts:
MandUs · 22/11/2022 18:45

Nurses and HCAs have different uniforms. At least in all of Scotland. They are different colours so doctors would know not to ask HCAs to give any meds.

doitwithlove · 22/11/2022 18:44

Basically this outlines the state of the NHS !!!

BirdyWoof · 22/11/2022 18:44

You did the right thing by protecting yourself and your patients.

If it happens again I’d put it in very plain terms of how you are refusing to do any task that you have not been trained to do, as you have a duty of care to your patients, and doing so breeches protocol. Any more shit from anyone, regardless of stature, I’d be filing an HR complaint.

No one should be speaking to anyone like dog shit. I don’t care how tired or stressed out you are, it isn’t fucking on. I work in a very busy sector and I have never spoken to anyone like they’re beneath me. It isn’t acceptable in professional practice.

maliafawn · 22/11/2022 18:43

Hobbitlover · 22/11/2022 18:41

Not much better being a student nurse sadly.

Amen

Least as a hca i got paid to be spoken down to and used as a dogs body. As a student im just used as an extra HCA but not one valued enough to be part of the actual team constantly with no regard for supernumerary status or learning needs

CrunchyTime · 22/11/2022 18:42

I'm totally with you OP. In health, its your responsibility to only carry out those tasks which you're trained in. It's also the responsibility of the qualified staff to support you in this. There are certain procedures you have to follow and that includes recording which medication has been administered.
I used to be a nurse and we relocated and I recently started as an HCA as it suits me better at the moment. I have seen how some of the other HCAs, without any previous healthcare experience, I might add, are being trained. It's been a real eye opener and I've noticed how different people work differently and have shown them to do the same thing but in different ones. This wouldn't be so bad but they're constantly going on about the importance of following the SOPs (Standard Operating Procedures) yet they don't all follow them in the order they're meant to!
It's really worrying. It's also unprofessional of them to express their own frustrations at you when they should be welcoming you when the NHS is so short staffed. One of the HCAs I work with is already taking about looking for work elsewhere which is a shame as she's good with patients but she's been treated so badly that I don't blame her.

Hobbitlover · 22/11/2022 18:41

Not much better being a student nurse sadly.

kateandme · 22/11/2022 18:38

And the trouble is when you scare away the good ones who want to treat,care look after patients.your left with the nasty,god complex abusive bastard ones.

ExHCA · 22/11/2022 18:37

atronger · 22/11/2022 17:47

What if they're putting someone's well-being over God forbid, life in danger? Still don't say anything?

Nobody should have to learn to live with blatant nasty behaviour

Which is why I suggested telling them straight.

CPL593H · 22/11/2022 18:32

BTW, that is no criticism of HCAs, just an environment that is extremely unfair to them.

MMUmum · 22/11/2022 18:30

As a nurse we were repeatedly reminded never to do something outside of our competencies, and this goes for HCA's too. Your training is totally inadequate so well done to you for standing your ground, and of course as a HCA you are right that you cannot administer medication, hope it gets better for you, but if not please have a rethink as it doesn't sound like a safe environment to work in

CPL593H · 22/11/2022 18:29

Keyansier · 22/11/2022 16:03

Well I can see why you couldn't fix a cast, I may not have necessarily knew how to either, but surely you know how to clean wounds and give people paracetamol? Hmm I know how to do that without any training or not working in your industry so I'm not surprised they were short with you if you kept refusing to do very simple things on your first day and moaning. You don't really sound cut out to be a nurse IMO unless you learn to toughen up a bit

If you want someone with no training cleaning a wound (being done in a healthcare setting, so presumably not a small scratch) you may be very much alone.

JCoverdale · 22/11/2022 18:28

It doesn't surprise me OP. I have spent a lot of time sitting with very sick people in various hospitals. The HCAs did what nurses used to do. It was always they who changed my dad's catheter for example, reassured him, checked his progress. They had different coloured uniforms to the nurses, and all the patients assumed they were the "real" nurses because they did so much work and never stopped. They were absolute gold. I didn't like to see how the nurses spoke to them - it was quite disgusting.
Good luck - I bet the patients love you because I can tell from your post you care about them.

Avrenim · 22/11/2022 18:28

I've worked for several Trusts. Some are excellent. Some are okay. Others are bloody awful - and even within the same Trust some units are great and others awful. Hopefully you'll find one that works for you, and go on to qualify and make sure new staff on your ward aren't treated like this.

Rachie1973 · 22/11/2022 18:27

I give meds, including controlled meds as an HCA. The training is worth it’s weight in gold for future jobs.

Neanov · 22/11/2022 18:26

@DohaDragon there's so many agencies I guess they operate differently to a HCA that's permanently working for NHS.

A basic level of maths and English is expected because you are expected to add observations up, total fluid balances and record input and output.... I know a lot of things are on electronic devices but this has only been the case recently.

MoonlightMemories · 22/11/2022 18:24

I had a nurse once try to get me to give a patient their morning medication...I know it was because they were short staffed and this patient often was quite slow with things like that, eating etc and the nurse had lots of patients to see to...I said I couldn't as I had other things I was busy with and needed to do (which was true, and also I was refusing because it's not part of my job to do so)...said nurse came back to me a little while later saying it's a good job "we" (erm...me!) didn't as actually the patient seemed to have an unsafe swallow when she tried them with them and she could have choked on them!

I will give them under direct supervision of a nurse at his/her instruction (rg. Nurse putting tablet(s) in the patient's yoghurt or whatever, known to have a safe swallow and they make sure it's gone and they stay with me the whole time I am assisting with the feed/administration until all meds are given and they are happy it's safe), but any other ocassion I will have nothing to do with them as I don't feel happy being put in that situation alone with meds that I don't know if it's safe for that patient to have or not.

Neanov · 22/11/2022 18:19

@Battlecat98 is must be a case of different trusts. I started as a HCA 10 years and I had to have a NVQ 2 in health and social care, relevant experience in care too so I didn't do the apprenticeship which was 6 months back then.

My friend applied for the same role as a HCA and they wanted evidence of maths... this was recently this year. It's interesting! How it varies

maliafawn · 22/11/2022 18:17

Also, in our trust atleast,
HCA - band 2
CSW - band 3
nursing associate/assistant practitioner - band 4

HoofWankingSpangleCunt · 22/11/2022 18:15

Some stupid comments on here but also excellent ones, definitely join Unison if not already a member.

@FlissyPaps had a great post Op.

Im sorry that they’ve treated you like this. It’s all quite alarming, what’s been allowed /encouraged to happen in some Trusts.

You sound like you’d make exactly the nurse the NHS so vitally needs. 👍

maliafawn · 22/11/2022 18:14

RoomOfRequirement · 22/11/2022 18:07

What trust is this? I haven't heard stories like this in over a decade, it's hard to believe it's real.

The one I worked for had 1-2 weeks classroom training and then a 1 YEAR apprenticeship as a band 1 before being a HCA - now called a CSW Clinical Support Worker.

theres no band 1 anymore, you can pretty much walk into a band 2 role. I did years prior in care as a senior administering meds and managing the team, so when i went to NHS i had no training, no shadowing, just expected to crack on even though i went from and EMI care home to an emergency surgery ward and the jobs were polar opposite. It was just assumed i knew what to do.

Battlecat98 · 22/11/2022 18:14

Neanov · 22/11/2022 18:02

This is false info. Most band 2s now do the apprenticeship route and it takes 15 months. Aside from that you need your maths and English for a start.

My trust has stopped the apprentice route and there is no need for English and maths. They finally realised these things don't necessarily produce the best staff and actually excludes some great HCA'S.

Orangelikeajaffacake · 22/11/2022 18:13

Keyansier · 22/11/2022 16:03

Well I can see why you couldn't fix a cast, I may not have necessarily knew how to either, but surely you know how to clean wounds and give people paracetamol? Hmm I know how to do that without any training or not working in your industry so I'm not surprised they were short with you if you kept refusing to do very simple things on your first day and moaning. You don't really sound cut out to be a nurse IMO unless you learn to toughen up a bit

I'm guessing you don't work in the medical field at all. Unless they have done extra training to dispense from dossett boxes HCAS/carers or whatever label are not allowed to give medication. Full stop.

Spidey66 · 22/11/2022 18:13

Bluekerfuffle · 22/11/2022 16:43

I assume if you’re directly asked to give drugs by a doctor it’s ok. It’s not as if you’re the one making the decision.

Nope, not how it works at all.

Even a qualified nurse can't just administer them on a doctors say so, they need to be written up, though there maybe local policies for emergency situations and for paramedics etc

DPotter · 22/11/2022 18:12

atronger
I didn't get any training. I did an online video training series, that lasted about an hour. Then done.

I work in adult education and my annual training in safeguarding alone is 5 hours long. Manual handing is a day, as is fire safety.

HCAs are the backbone of personal care given on most Trust wards and you're being treated very poorly. At absolute minimum you need training in safeguarding, manual handing, infection control, fire safety and basic personal care (because despite what Keyansier thinks its not straightforward).

Can you approach the senior clinic sister and ask for a mentor ?

Museya15 · 22/11/2022 18:12

I worked in an office for two years when I left school, then started my nurse training, I didn't think I'd ever last due to how people (nurses, doctors, physios, OCC health etc etc) speak to you. By Eck you have to have a tough skin and learn not to be a walk over if you work in the NHS.