Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anybody else just think patriotism is bollocks?

335 replies

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 14:23

World cup got me thinking. I just feel no affinity to England as a concept. I was raised by 2nd gen immigrants who supported their parents international teams and the background of most of the kids at my school were similar so we didn't really get into it there.

Neither do I have no affinity to my grandparents country having not been since I was a child, I know many people from that country and immigration is still common but neither they nor I see us as sharing a nationality.

I just don't see the point. I think my own example shows how arbitrary and meaningless the whole concept of nationality and patronism is.

I'm interested to know if this is a quirk of my heritage or do others with different, more "English", backgrounds feel similar.

OP posts:
Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:57

Our identity, if you will

Yeah this is probably another reason I dislike it.

I'm not a fan of "identity" as this conceptually inexplicable innate thing we all have.

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 22/11/2022 16:57

I am Scottish - born and bred. I dislike patriotism and despise Scottish nationalism. The landscape of Scotland is in my bones, I feel a part of it and it is part of me. I love my home and my country. But pride? It is an accident of birth that I am Scottish. It is my choice to stay and make it my home. I am worth no more than all the other people who have chosen to make Scotland their home, just because I happen to have been born here. There is a very ugly streak of 'wha's like us', saltires painted on faces, Scottish exceptionalism that I utterly reject. But I still love Scotland.

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 16:57

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:54

You are confusing me with somebody else.

You keep throwing Ukraine in the discussion as if it supports the concept of patriotism.

I am pointing out that your logic is faulty.

I'll spell it out.

You seem to be implying that patriotism is good because it inspires people to defend their country if invaded.

I am pointing out that by that logic patriotism is often also the reason for the invasion and really doesn't help your argument.

It's also bizarre in the extreme to assume that patriotism is the reason people would prefer not to be bombed.

Hope that helps.

Nope. I’ve just asked you two straightforward questions.

No answer though to either post. Just around the houses so muddled responses.

pizzaHeart · 22/11/2022 16:56

That's why Ukraine will prevail against all the odds.
@Changeyncchange I think it’s about Russia being much bigger and stronger then Ukraine at the first sight but fighting for its land and way of life makes Ukraine much more stronger then Russia. “prevailing at all odds” is not a meaningless sentiment for Ukrainians. They are fighting life and death to achieve this.

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 16:54

I think the nation we grow up in forms some core aspects of our personality and values. Our identity, if you will. And it is natural, and arguably even rational to be proud of this.

So in England we value honesty and fairness.

I am forgetful and have lost my purse on a number of occasions. I have always got it back. Usually with the money inside.

We famously queue, and wait our turn.

We allow the wierd and eccentric. Harder for me to give a concrete example here, more something I feel to be true having lived elsewhere.

We by and large and not without exceptions treat our women and minorities well.

We have the freedom to be religious (or not).

These are not things that happened by luck or accident. We built them together.

Of course, there are some truly awful things in our past. Some even in the fairly recent past. Of course borders are tricky and somewhat arbitrary, but national identity is still real with real effects on the world.

Overall, I am fond and proud of our nation as it is today.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:54

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 16:42

Er it’s not naive I’m just asking you questions.

You suggested war was a bad outcome to having countries so I asked how would you resolve it peacefully?

Are you now admitting it’s not possible to do that (plus throwing in an insult). I don’t get why it’s hard to answer straight questions though. You make it sound easy to avoid conflict if everyone just accepted countries ‘aren’t real’, but maybe it’s not.

You are confusing me with somebody else.

You keep throwing Ukraine in the discussion as if it supports the concept of patriotism.

I am pointing out that your logic is faulty.

I'll spell it out.

You seem to be implying that patriotism is good because it inspires people to defend their country if invaded.

I am pointing out that by that logic patriotism is often also the reason for the invasion and really doesn't help your argument.

It's also bizarre in the extreme to assume that patriotism is the reason people would prefer not to be bombed.

Hope that helps.

OP posts:
DuncanBiscuits · 22/11/2022 16:52

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:06

*Because every person, including you, contributes to your country even if you don't realise it.

If you take your litter home rather than chucking it on the verge, you are contributing to a pleasant environment. If you don't discriminate against people you are contributing, if you maintain your house and garden to the benefit of your neighbourhood, your sense of humour, all these things add to your home country*

That's nice. I like that. I ccould get on board with patriotism if it's about community and working together. Then it veers into

*I love that I can wash my car on the street and no-one minds. If you do that in Switzerland you get fined.

You might not value it, but it isn't bollocks*

And it's lost me again.

The second bit is necessary though isn't it? You have to be think "we're" special/better than other countries otherwise its not patriotism. It's just being considerate.

👆🏻What they said.

Sillysop92 · 22/11/2022 16:46

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:31

I live 20 minutes from the Welsh border and was born even closer.

If I had been born 10 minutes down the road across the border would I be Welsh?

If you were Welsh, I'm sure you'd feel different ;)

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 16:45

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 16:37

Do you find it equally strange to take pride in other things that are completely chance where a person has no control over? Such as gay and trans pride? Black pride? Being proud to be a woman?

Speaking for myself, I'm not proud to be a woman, I just am one.

And those examples are not really comparable because they're about political movements campaigning for equal rights, not people randomly declaring they are proud of their race / sex / sexuality.

You might as well ask if it's equally strange for people to take pride in being white - the people that do that are not often benign forces.

Which brings us back to the patriotism point the OP is making - a lot of people forget that in e.g. a war, both sides consider themselves patriots. No-one self-identifies as the baddies.

Sillysop92 · 22/11/2022 16:45

blackberrybat · 22/11/2022 16:36

@Sillysop92 me too! I don't know if I'm patriotic as such, and I'm not a fluent Welsh speaker, but I love our language, music, our history, our beautiful hills and beaches. And I bloody love hearing the national anthem. Obviously there are a ton of shit things about Wales same as there are anywhere, but at my core I'm happy and proud to be Welsh.

DH is English and we've discussed this quite a bit, he said he struggles to find anything to feel patriotic about, and feels quite envious of how I feel about my country.

Yes, I love being Welsh as it means I'm not English - only joking ;)! Yma o hyd! I'm married to an English man, but he can't help not being perfect! Tongue-in-cheek!

beastlyslumber · 22/11/2022 16:44

Very proud to be English and Britain. This is an incredible country with an incredible history.

Pisses me off that it's considered wrong in some way to be proud of being British. We're the only country where it's seen as weird and racist to fly our flag.

derxa · 22/11/2022 16:43

There is no Utopia.

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 16:42

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:38

We very much don't get a say. Realistically in that scenario the US would be the one with the say.

Just like Ukraine didn't really get a say with Russia and depend absolutely on UN support and international pressure.

Just like Scotland isn't getting their referendum nor Catalan.

Patriotism does not help.

The problem with your niave view is you keep forgetting that all sides are patriotic.

Er it’s not naive I’m just asking you questions.

You suggested war was a bad outcome to having countries so I asked how would you resolve it peacefully?

Are you now admitting it’s not possible to do that (plus throwing in an insult). I don’t get why it’s hard to answer straight questions though. You make it sound easy to avoid conflict if everyone just accepted countries ‘aren’t real’, but maybe it’s not.

Kabalagala · 22/11/2022 16:41

caroleanboneparte · 22/11/2022 16:33

I'm proud of my local area, an area quite close where I grew up, the city and country I live in/ was born in. I've done genealogy and can trace ancestors back 200 years to 2 miles away.

My heritage is in the air I breath, the streets I drive on, the parks I walk in, the food I eat and water I drink.

I go to the same shops and civil buildings my Victorian ancestors went to.

They worked to pay taxes for the infrastructure I now use.

I love that the values we have shared have been handed down through the generations and have benefitted us all- rule of law, womens rights, anti- corruption, collectivism through the welfare state, trial by jury, individual liberty.

There's no where else I'd rather live. Free healthcare. Gun control. No death penalty. Free abortion and contraception. Social security. Social care. Freedom of speech. Privacy rights.

I'm proud because I've been an active citizen in supporting these privileges. I vote, engage with politics, do activism etc. I can be proud of that. Of being part of creating the kind of society I want my decedents to live in.

To me patriotism is a force for good.

But how do you reconcile that with the not so nice stuff?

derxa · 22/11/2022 16:40

Just like Scotland isn't getting their referendum Thank fuck for that

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:38

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 16:33

I think the difficulty is who gets the land / ownership. Yes wars are awful and struggles are terrible but how do you see it resolving?

Say China / Russia or other superpower wants England do we get a say? Maybe you do have a way to peacefully deal with that, I’m interested as may be missing it

We very much don't get a say. Realistically in that scenario the US would be the one with the say.

Just like Ukraine didn't really get a say with Russia and depend absolutely on UN support and international pressure.

Just like Scotland isn't getting their referendum nor Catalan.

Patriotism does not help.

The problem with your niave view is you keep forgetting that all sides are patriotic.

OP posts:
Tekkentime · 22/11/2022 16:38

I'm English and i'm very proud. I also think Scotland, Wales and Ireland are great and support them in any games that aren't against England 😂

2bazookas · 22/11/2022 16:38

@ caroleanboneparte ·

go girl; go.

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 16:37

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:31

I live 20 minutes from the Welsh border and was born even closer.

If I had been born 10 minutes down the road across the border would I be Welsh?

Do you find it equally strange to take pride in other things that are completely chance where a person has no control over? Such as gay and trans pride? Black pride? Being proud to be a woman?

blackberrybat · 22/11/2022 16:36

@Sillysop92 me too! I don't know if I'm patriotic as such, and I'm not a fluent Welsh speaker, but I love our language, music, our history, our beautiful hills and beaches. And I bloody love hearing the national anthem. Obviously there are a ton of shit things about Wales same as there are anywhere, but at my core I'm happy and proud to be Welsh.

DH is English and we've discussed this quite a bit, he said he struggles to find anything to feel patriotic about, and feels quite envious of how I feel about my country.

derxa · 22/11/2022 16:35

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:32

Well you remind me of my Grandparents.

One day you may end up with grandkids like me. Equally unmoved by bagpipes or God save the King.

I like the sound of your grandparents

Coyoacan · 22/11/2022 16:35

There's patriotism that thinks your fellow countrymenxare as good as anyone and there is patriotism where you think your country is better than any where else

Chocchops72 · 22/11/2022 16:35

It's weird isn't it?

I'm Scottish. What does that mean? It's really hard to say. Scottish isn't a nationality, legally speaking, at the moment. I was born on that part of the Earth's surface that we've labelled 'Scotland'. My parents were too. So that seems to make me Scottish. It appears I am also British - and I do have the papers to prove that. But I don't 'feel' British. I feel Scottish - if I feel anything. I don't think I'd like to have no nationality / identity to identify with, and Scottish is a pretty cool one.

One of my children was born in New Zealand. The other was born in France. Does that make them not-Scottish? I don't think it makes them Kiwi or French.

My youngest, born in France, can exercise his 'droit du sol' and claim French nationality at 13 - literally because he popped out of me on French soil (or in a hospital in France). Such a weird idea - that just being born on a specific piece of dirt somehow imbues him with some mystical essence or quality that the rest of us don't have? That he's more 'French' somehow because of it? Bizarre.

Humans are inherently tribal and whereas in the past our tribe was fairly small, local, mostly related to us (and therefore we had a genetic interest in contributing to the overall wellbeing of our tribe - to pass 'our' shared genes on most successfully), our tribes are much much bigger now. Same instincts, totally different setting.

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 16:33

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:23

Well if countries are purely made up and ‘not real’ as a pp put it what does that mean in terms of protecting them

Indeed. Isn't it a concept that causes wars?

Russia feel Ukraine is rightfully theirs. A good majority of the Northern Irish think they are occupied. China and Tawain. India/Pakistan and Kasmir. Christ we could be here all night.

Are these good things. Have they had good outcomes?

I think the difficulty is who gets the land / ownership. Yes wars are awful and struggles are terrible but how do you see it resolving?

Say China / Russia or other superpower wants England do we get a say? Maybe you do have a way to peacefully deal with that, I’m interested as may be missing it

caroleanboneparte · 22/11/2022 16:33

I'm proud of my local area, an area quite close where I grew up, the city and country I live in/ was born in. I've done genealogy and can trace ancestors back 200 years to 2 miles away.

My heritage is in the air I breath, the streets I drive on, the parks I walk in, the food I eat and water I drink.

I go to the same shops and civil buildings my Victorian ancestors went to.

They worked to pay taxes for the infrastructure I now use.

I love that the values we have shared have been handed down through the generations and have benefitted us all- rule of law, womens rights, anti- corruption, collectivism through the welfare state, trial by jury, individual liberty.

There's no where else I'd rather live. Free healthcare. Gun control. No death penalty. Free abortion and contraception. Social security. Social care. Freedom of speech. Privacy rights.

I'm proud because I've been an active citizen in supporting these privileges. I vote, engage with politics, do activism etc. I can be proud of that. Of being part of creating the kind of society I want my decedents to live in.

To me patriotism is a force for good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread