Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anybody else just think patriotism is bollocks?

335 replies

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 14:23

World cup got me thinking. I just feel no affinity to England as a concept. I was raised by 2nd gen immigrants who supported their parents international teams and the background of most of the kids at my school were similar so we didn't really get into it there.

Neither do I have no affinity to my grandparents country having not been since I was a child, I know many people from that country and immigration is still common but neither they nor I see us as sharing a nationality.

I just don't see the point. I think my own example shows how arbitrary and meaningless the whole concept of nationality and patronism is.

I'm interested to know if this is a quirk of my heritage or do others with different, more "English", backgrounds feel similar.

OP posts:
derxa · 22/11/2022 17:31

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 17:29

How would it? Are they particular patriotic countries?

Have you ever spent any time in France OP? 😂

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 17:31

Well my grandparents and parents were patriotic. Just not to the country they lived in

So it's not bollocks then

Underanothersky · 22/11/2022 17:29

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 17:23

I don't trust people who are not patriotic

Your background is tainting your view OP

I'm off to become a spy, clearly.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 17:29

derxa · 22/11/2022 17:24

I'm wondering how this conversation would go down in France or Italy 😆

How would it? Are they particular patriotic countries?

OP posts:
Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 17:28

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 17:23

I don't trust people who are not patriotic

Your background is tainting your view OP

Yikes.

Well my grandparents and parents were patriotic. Just not to the country they lived in. Is that better or worse?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 17:27

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 17:24

If everybody gets to define Britishness as they please it's even more meaningless, surely?

If someone is going to claim e.g. "fairness" as a British value, they then need to go on to define fairness and show how it uniquely manifests in the British.

Otherwise I call bullshit.

No it’s not it’s just their interpretation and that’s fine.

If you did some focus groups you’d probably get overlap with some themes emerging.

People would get some consensus - apart from the outraged one in the corner who says this is BS and leaves (or stays for a voucher and is annoyed after)

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 22/11/2022 17:25

I don't trust people who are not patriotic

That's got such a sinister ring to it.

Whatsshecalled · 22/11/2022 17:24

I am British going back as far as anyone has bothered to trace. My worry about patriotism is it makes people see other nations as different in some way and their own country as inherently better for some reason. I might be jaded though as i live in Cornwall and some Cornish are so vocal about Cornwall being amazing and anyone from elsewhere being an outsider that I absolutely despair about why we have to narrow ourselves down eg "Im not European Im British....Im not British Im English....Im not English Im Cornish...Im not from whatever town I'm from whatever village" Why????? It makes no sense, we're all people.

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 17:24

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 17:18

Obviously it’s their interpretation of British values and it means something to them, even if not everyone.

So no I wouldn’t say it’s nonsense.

If everybody gets to define Britishness as they please it's even more meaningless, surely?

If someone is going to claim e.g. "fairness" as a British value, they then need to go on to define fairness and show how it uniquely manifests in the British.

Otherwise I call bullshit.

derxa · 22/11/2022 17:24

I'm wondering how this conversation would go down in France or Italy 😆

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 17:24

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 17:16

Yes but they're not innate to any given nation, or even that clearly defined. They vary over time depending on prevailing politics. When people say they're proud of "British values" it's a total nonsense.

I disagree.

English people in general have different values to someone raised in Russia, or China or America or even France or Italy.

Look at, for example, views on private health care in the USA.

Yes, they change over time. But not impossible to define or discuss.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 17:23

I don't trust people who are not patriotic

Your background is tainting your view OP

FancyFanny · 22/11/2022 17:20

Patriotism is very much alive and well. My family, who are all of white British heritage, have a very strong sense of their 'roots' and are very proud to be Britsh- and even more so of their Yorkshireness!

Tekkentime · 22/11/2022 17:19

*arbitrary

Tekkentime · 22/11/2022 17:18

Concepts and beliefs can be deconstructed and analysed to the point that they appear arbitary. You can analyse pretty much anything if you want until it seems to make little sense.

Off the top of my head - ironing - over analyse ironing and it will begin to appear pointless.

MarshaBradyo · 22/11/2022 17:18

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 17:16

Yes but they're not innate to any given nation, or even that clearly defined. They vary over time depending on prevailing politics. When people say they're proud of "British values" it's a total nonsense.

Obviously it’s their interpretation of British values and it means something to them, even if not everyone.

So no I wouldn’t say it’s nonsense.

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 17:16

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 17:00

Not innate. Created by the environment we grow up in.

At least those elements relevant to this discussion.

Not innate in the strict sense, rather in the sense that where we are born and how we are raised is pure chance and is something we have no control over, so in the broad sense it is a difference without distinction.

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 17:16

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 17:12

Well ideas like honesty and freedom are conceptual but not inexplicable.

Explained by what we teach our children, what we write read and watch on TV. Who we vote into power. What we do for a living. And so on.

Yes but they're not innate to any given nation, or even that clearly defined. They vary over time depending on prevailing politics. When people say they're proud of "British values" it's a total nonsense.

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 17:12

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 17:06

Fair enough. Not innate but still entirely conceptual and utterly inexplicable.

Well ideas like honesty and freedom are conceptual but not inexplicable.

Explained by what we teach our children, what we write read and watch on TV. Who we vote into power. What we do for a living. And so on.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 17:06

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 17:00

Not innate. Created by the environment we grow up in.

At least those elements relevant to this discussion.

Fair enough. Not innate but still entirely conceptual and utterly inexplicable.

OP posts:
Chocchops72 · 22/11/2022 17:01

The landscape of Scotland is in my bones, I feel a part of it and it is part of me.

What does this mean? How can a landscape be in your bones? The land is just rock and soil and water and bugs. How can that be part of you and you, it?

It's all feelings, right, feelings of belonging somewhere and to something. that makes sense: humans couldn't survive on their own for long, back in the day. So we are programmed to seek attachment to something bigger than ourselves?

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 17:01

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 16:57

But those things are not exclusively political movements. People often do take pride in and form their own groups and communities based on intrinsic and chance characteristics completely apart from politics.

Pride and patriotism are extensions of the feeling of belonging which is an inherent part of the human condition. People form and take pride in groups for all sorts of reasons, around all sorts of things. Nations are just one of many.

Yes they do, doesn't make any of it less arbitrary. It's just tribalism.

I've never seen anything to convince me that there are intrinsic national traits.

FluffletheMeow · 22/11/2022 17:00

Not innate. Created by the environment we grow up in.

At least those elements relevant to this discussion.

Choconut · 22/11/2022 16:58

I love being British/English and I love England despite all it's issues and although I love to travel, there's nowhere else I would rather have been born. I'm not sure it that makes me patriotic or not.

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 16:57

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 16:45

Speaking for myself, I'm not proud to be a woman, I just am one.

And those examples are not really comparable because they're about political movements campaigning for equal rights, not people randomly declaring they are proud of their race / sex / sexuality.

You might as well ask if it's equally strange for people to take pride in being white - the people that do that are not often benign forces.

Which brings us back to the patriotism point the OP is making - a lot of people forget that in e.g. a war, both sides consider themselves patriots. No-one self-identifies as the baddies.

But those things are not exclusively political movements. People often do take pride in and form their own groups and communities based on intrinsic and chance characteristics completely apart from politics.

Pride and patriotism are extensions of the feeling of belonging which is an inherent part of the human condition. People form and take pride in groups for all sorts of reasons, around all sorts of things. Nations are just one of many.