Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anybody else just think patriotism is bollocks?

335 replies

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 14:23

World cup got me thinking. I just feel no affinity to England as a concept. I was raised by 2nd gen immigrants who supported their parents international teams and the background of most of the kids at my school were similar so we didn't really get into it there.

Neither do I have no affinity to my grandparents country having not been since I was a child, I know many people from that country and immigration is still common but neither they nor I see us as sharing a nationality.

I just don't see the point. I think my own example shows how arbitrary and meaningless the whole concept of nationality and patronism is.

I'm interested to know if this is a quirk of my heritage or do others with different, more "English", backgrounds feel similar.

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:29

Do you think you’re being somehow progressive in attaching one viewpoint to all Asians, Africans and Māori, and claiming that they would all be so completely intolerant to nuanced views about patriotism that they would subject me to an unspecified “worse” punishment than deportation?

Why don't you try it? You can attempt doing something of the sort in the USA also

CulturePigeon · 22/11/2022 19:28

thehorsehasnowbolted · Today 19:03
Our ancestors have also done a lot of terrible stuff. Where does that fit into this rhetoric? Or do we just ignore the bits we don't like?
I decide to focus on the positives. If they hadn't been so incredibly intelligent, ingenious, tenacious, courageous, cohesive and brave, our country would be a lot different to what it is today. I value enormously what we can enjoy here today. Many others can't

Well put!

We (and many other countries) have so much to be proud of. It's not all bad - but to hear some people (esp on the left) you'd think it was.

I remember when my son's German exchange was staying and we were chatting about something and he said 'In Germany we are not patriotic - we have so much to be ashamed about' and I thought that was incredibly sad. I said he should take pride in his country's cultural achievements and not let it be defined by the Nazi era. I just can't imagine feeling indifferent about my native land.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 19:28

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:25

Who told you you should be ashamed to be British? Can you quote it?

Yes, I have quoted it below. Am I allowed to be patriotic now?

Our ancestors have also done a lot of terrible stuff. Where does that fit into this rhetoric? Or do we just ignore the bits we don't like?

That doesn't say that.

Did you copy/paste the wrong thing or do you struggle with reading comprehension?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 22/11/2022 19:28

I’m not sure where the idea that it’s only Brits that are ashamed to be patriotic came from, or that they’re even ashamed at all. It’s not unusual to see British or English flags flying, and there’s hardly a dearth of them over in Qatar right now. You can also find people in most, if not all, countries that aren’t patriotic and find the whole concept weird.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 19:27

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:17

My answer is always yes

Would you go to New Zealand and tell the Maoris that their patriotism (or tribalism, as some have described it here) is naïve, an illusion or uncalled for? You would very swiftly be escorted out of the country or worse

What a stupid fucking question.

I presume you poorly made point is "the Moaris" wouldn't be happy as you presume all Moaris feel the same. Even if this were true and they all reacted negatively.

So what? What's your point?

OP posts:
TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 19:26

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:22

Why do you think other nations don’t have these debates?

Why don't you try going to any of these places and attempt what I've suggested?

Do you think you’re being somehow progressive in attaching one viewpoint to all Asians, Africans and Māori, and claiming that they would all be so completely intolerant to nuanced views about patriotism that they would subject me to an unspecified “worse” punishment than deportation?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:25

Who told you you should be ashamed to be British? Can you quote it?

Yes, I have quoted it below. Am I allowed to be patriotic now?

Our ancestors have also done a lot of terrible stuff. Where does that fit into this rhetoric? Or do we just ignore the bits we don't like?

CulturePigeon · 22/11/2022 19:23

Chocchops72 · Today 17:01
The landscape of Scotland is in my bones, I feel a part of it and it is part of me.

I totally get it, Chocchops. I feel that way about the British Isles in general, but for me, England in particular. I tend to think of Scotland as being stunningly beautiful with spectacular scenery and England more modest and cosy with little woods, villages and market towns (obviously cities as well...but i'm talking about he landscape).

I accept most people don't think like me (or you!) any more - we are becoming a more urban population, less connected either through work, leisure or culturally with the landscape but it still means a huge amount to me. If you feel that visceral connection it's a very real, tangible emotion and while I accept that many people don't, they need to believe that it's very important to some of us.

For me, real patriotism isn't about putting down other countries/cultures - it's exactly as you have said - a feeling in your bones towards your own country, and a completely benign emotion. Patriotism should and can connect us to other people - our compatriots and also other nations too. I remember being really moved by the Kalush Orchestra and their feeling for their country when they sang for Ukraine at the last Eurovision (not a regular viewer, but that was a very moving contest).

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 19:22

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:19

If you were told you should be ashamed of who you are it makes sense to hit back that you are proud of who you are when challenging this

Well, I've been told on this thread by a PP that I should be ashamed to be British because of xyz,. Am I allowed to be patriotic and challenge it then?

You can say whatever you want. Who told you you should be ashamed to be British? Can you quote it? Or will it be a case of you deliberately snipping out context like you did with my quote?

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:22

Why do you think other nations don’t have these debates?

Why don't you try going to any of these places and attempt what I've suggested?

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 19:20

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:17

My answer is always yes

Would you go to New Zealand and tell the Maoris that their patriotism (or tribalism, as some have described it here) is naïve, an illusion or uncalled for? You would very swiftly be escorted out of the country or worse

You think this opinion would result in deportation? And what would the worse thing be in this case?

again, why do you think other nations are incapable of introspective debate about the nature of tribalism? Why do you think other nations don’t have these debates?

BirmaBrite · 22/11/2022 19:20

I always think patriotism is a bit like being part of a family, you can slag off your family members, but if anyone else dare do it, you suddenly get all defensive.

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 19:19

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 19:08

This is baffling to me. If you cut out half of it what's the point? You're not proud of your ancestors, you're proud of fictionalised versions of them. They don't exist.

Of course we have to take the good with the bad, but that is where things get kind of murky. We have no way of knowing how things would look today had different paths been taken, because all we have is the path that was actually taken.

So, looking back through history, we can certainly see things that in hindsight could have been approached differently, and may well have been had our ancestors had our wisdom of today. Things might have ended up better by current standards, or they could have ended up way worse. We have no way of knowing.

What we do know is where things are and where things were, and on the whole, I think things are much better now than they were in the past, which suggests that our ancestors got it right more than they got it wrong.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:19

If you were told you should be ashamed of who you are it makes sense to hit back that you are proud of who you are when challenging this

Well, I've been told on this thread by a PP that I should be ashamed to be British because of xyz,. Am I allowed to be patriotic and challenge it then?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:17

My answer is always yes

Would you go to New Zealand and tell the Maoris that their patriotism (or tribalism, as some have described it here) is naïve, an illusion or uncalled for? You would very swiftly be escorted out of the country or worse

Lunar270 · 22/11/2022 19:14

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 19:04

If one judges British History in the context of its contemporary time, much of it was comparatively forward thinking.

Don't get me wrong, us Brits have done many good things. But oppressing half the world at various points in history (and some very recent) can absolutely be taken in context of modern values.

Most notably the Kenyan cover up in the 50's. Very British. Or how about the justice for the Windrush generation. Even today we're sending people to Rwanda.

I'm proud of 'some' if our achievements but unwavering patriotism is for the dogs.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 19:13

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:06

But it's also a bit scary, how easily it can overtake your brain - this is how tribalism can be manipulated, and why I'm wary of it

Do you also believe 'tribalism' in other parts of the world is pointless and should be sneered at? How about Africa or Asia? Are they wrong to feel part of a tribe, honour their traditions, land and ancestors?

This always seems to be the comeback.

Would you say that about X people being patriotic?

My answer is always yes.

I understand it more if you're from a recently oppressed group. If you were told you should be ashamed of who you are it makes sense to hit back that you are proud of who you are when challenging this. There is a reason why alarm bells go off when we here about "white pride" though. These things aren't in a vacuum and I don't think there is a place once you have equality (which admittedly isn't easy to gauge).

So I suppose my question to all those proponents of "would you say that about <insert historically oppressed culture here>"? Is to turn it round the other way.

Would you say that Russian patriotism is good?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 22/11/2022 19:11

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 19:06

I don’t think you get to decide who is patriotic though. What if the people in the pub moaning about immigration think their version of patriotism is more legitimate, vote for things based on their version, then their elected representatives bring in changes to legislation that remove a key number of civil rights from everyone?

Good point.

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 19:10

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:06

But it's also a bit scary, how easily it can overtake your brain - this is how tribalism can be manipulated, and why I'm wary of it

Do you also believe 'tribalism' in other parts of the world is pointless and should be sneered at? How about Africa or Asia? Are they wrong to feel part of a tribe, honour their traditions, land and ancestors?

I’ve already said several times that yes, I think it’s daft everywhere.

I don’t know what kind of slam dunk you and others in this thread think this is. It comes across as very patronising the way some people talk about other nations, like they’re quaintly homogeneous and never debate these concepts.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 19:08

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:03

Our ancestors have also done a lot of terrible stuff. Where does that fit into this rhetoric? Or do we just ignore the bits we don't like?

I decide to focus on the positives. If they hadn't been so incredibly intelligent, ingenious, tenacious, courageous, cohesive and brave, our country would be a lot different to what it is today. I value enormously what we can enjoy here today. Many others can't

This is baffling to me. If you cut out half of it what's the point? You're not proud of your ancestors, you're proud of fictionalised versions of them. They don't exist.

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:06

But it's also a bit scary, how easily it can overtake your brain - this is how tribalism can be manipulated, and why I'm wary of it

Do you also believe 'tribalism' in other parts of the world is pointless and should be sneered at? How about Africa or Asia? Are they wrong to feel part of a tribe, honour their traditions, land and ancestors?

TheLeadbetterLife · 22/11/2022 19:06

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 22/11/2022 18:58

Like I say it depends who you count as ‘we’. And I hope you wouldn’t count the worst kind of people but rather people who actually make a difference. Not the people who sit in the pub and moan about immigration

I don’t think you get to decide who is patriotic though. What if the people in the pub moaning about immigration think their version of patriotism is more legitimate, vote for things based on their version, then their elected representatives bring in changes to legislation that remove a key number of civil rights from everyone?

samyeagar · 22/11/2022 19:04

Lunar270 · 22/11/2022 18:56

Fairness, tolerance, truth and justice are often touted as classic British traits. You hear it all the time. But history would suggest otherwise.

If one judges British History in the context of its contemporary time, much of it was comparatively forward thinking.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 22/11/2022 19:03

Our ancestors have also done a lot of terrible stuff. Where does that fit into this rhetoric? Or do we just ignore the bits we don't like?

I decide to focus on the positives. If they hadn't been so incredibly intelligent, ingenious, tenacious, courageous, cohesive and brave, our country would be a lot different to what it is today. I value enormously what we can enjoy here today. Many others can't

HeadNorth · 22/11/2022 19:01

Chocchops72 · 22/11/2022 17:01

The landscape of Scotland is in my bones, I feel a part of it and it is part of me.

What does this mean? How can a landscape be in your bones? The land is just rock and soil and water and bugs. How can that be part of you and you, it?

It's all feelings, right, feelings of belonging somewhere and to something. that makes sense: humans couldn't survive on their own for long, back in the day. So we are programmed to seek attachment to something bigger than ourselves?

In my case I am a walker and wild camper. Thanks to our access legislation I have spent time in the wildest and most beautiful parts of Scotland, miles from any people or roads. I feel part of that landscape and it feels part of me. I can admire the natural beauty of other countries when I visit, but Scotland is the landscape of my soul.