Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anybody else just think patriotism is bollocks?

335 replies

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 14:23

World cup got me thinking. I just feel no affinity to England as a concept. I was raised by 2nd gen immigrants who supported their parents international teams and the background of most of the kids at my school were similar so we didn't really get into it there.

Neither do I have no affinity to my grandparents country having not been since I was a child, I know many people from that country and immigration is still common but neither they nor I see us as sharing a nationality.

I just don't see the point. I think my own example shows how arbitrary and meaningless the whole concept of nationality and patronism is.

I'm interested to know if this is a quirk of my heritage or do others with different, more "English", backgrounds feel similar.

OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 23/11/2022 10:59

When my mum does this, it’s because she wants to steer every conversation on to her current personal bugbear

Listen to your mum, she's older and undoubtedly wiser

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 09:46

whumpthereitis · 23/11/2022 09:32

It is interesting. I know full well I’m shaped by my own experiences of patriotism/nationalism (where is the line drawn?) and how the very worst in people can surface in the name one’s country.

In the museum of Yugoslavia there’s a section of Milosevic era propaganda, some of which I remember from being a child. It absolutely stoked and played on nascent fears that the ‘other’ was coming to wipe us out. Unfortunately it is a sentiment that is ripe for manipulation of those in power, but then it if it wasn’t that it would be something else.

Humans are a tribal species, and I don’t believe there’s been a time in human history where that hasn’t been war.

Not being patriotic doesn’t mean you can’t appreciate a country, or even love living in it. It also doesn’t mean that you’re ashamed of your country or disdainful towards it. Like I said in a previous post, I’ve lived in a few and travelled to more, and I can point out great and shit things in all.

Although I wouldn’t call myself patriotic, it’s always seemed to me to be a valuable thing, if you are, to acknowledge where your country has been, and is doing, wrong. If you love your country, I would think you’d want the best for it. But patriotism is very often used to shut down any criticism, as if any action of a country can be justified by virtue of it being committed by that country.

If you take out the you must be ashamed angle and the you’re all scoundrels angle which tends to make people defensive on either end it’s quite a good question to consider.

Culture’s post is good, I agree generally but also a definition of patriotism might help as we could be coming at it from different places.

whumpthereitis · 23/11/2022 09:32

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 08:19

It could be a good debate though - in a classroom

Are countries a good idea or whatever

On one side you could argue that they allow humans who can be territorial (like other animals) the ability to exist in populous places without breaking out over most things due to common ground. Then cheering your country’s football team can be a relatively benign way to express emotion for that collective idea.

Others might take the other side and say wars wouldn’t happen etc as has been said already and other arguments

It is interesting. I know full well I’m shaped by my own experiences of patriotism/nationalism (where is the line drawn?) and how the very worst in people can surface in the name one’s country.

In the museum of Yugoslavia there’s a section of Milosevic era propaganda, some of which I remember from being a child. It absolutely stoked and played on nascent fears that the ‘other’ was coming to wipe us out. Unfortunately it is a sentiment that is ripe for manipulation of those in power, but then it if it wasn’t that it would be something else.

Humans are a tribal species, and I don’t believe there’s been a time in human history where that hasn’t been war.

Not being patriotic doesn’t mean you can’t appreciate a country, or even love living in it. It also doesn’t mean that you’re ashamed of your country or disdainful towards it. Like I said in a previous post, I’ve lived in a few and travelled to more, and I can point out great and shit things in all.

Although I wouldn’t call myself patriotic, it’s always seemed to me to be a valuable thing, if you are, to acknowledge where your country has been, and is doing, wrong. If you love your country, I would think you’d want the best for it. But patriotism is very often used to shut down any criticism, as if any action of a country can be justified by virtue of it being committed by that country.

CulturePigeon · 23/11/2022 09:26

3 succinct points:

  • to OP and others saying patriotism (or pps' explanations of it) makes no sense. It does to us! I'm not going to pour my heart and soul out on MN, but it's something you feel in your heart - and if you don't, you don't. No problem. T understand - think of something which has this effect on you personally.
  • Pps saying that 'our ancestors have done terrible things in the past' . And - whose ancestors haven't? Different times! I bet everyone's ancestors have clubbed someone to death at some point, or gone to watch someone burned at the stake. It's universal - Britain is just one of those countries with a pretty well-documented history so we know about these things. It's a really silly, childish comment. Look at the good stuff too - the courage, the enterprise, the inventiveness etc.
  • Yes - all this anti-British stuff for the sake of it was one of the reasons I stopped me reading the Guardian. It just got so predictable. There would be a report of some tragedy/injustice somewhere in the world and you could skip to the final paras to read that yes, it was in fact Britain's fault in some bizarre way. I think the Labour Party realised a few years ago that it wasn't a good look when trying to get elected and they've sensibly moved away from mocking patriotism.

But over and above what I've written above - OP - you should have defined clearly what you mean by patriotism, or the whole discussion is going to be rather confused and pointless. I find that people who are defiantly unpatriotic think it means marching around like the SA in Nazi Germany, when all most people mean is supporting the team or tearing up listening to Nimrod from the Enigma Variations.

Brefugee · 23/11/2022 09:18

I didn't because i don't think he's right 😀

SerendipityJane · 23/11/2022 09:16

How can a thread be this long and no one quotes the good Doctor Johnson ?

Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel.

Brefugee · 23/11/2022 09:08

wanted to bring up another point and this one shows it really well:

I’m Welsh and proud of it. My parents were from the same part of rural West Wales and I like to think the soil there is full of my DNA. I’m proud of my country’s language and culture having prevailed despite centuries of attempts to wipe it out. Yma o Hyd!

Some languages (tied up with a country, generally) have a word for that feeling of it being home, and have so much more meaning than "home" which is difficult to describe. Apologies to Welsh speakers, i hope i have spelled it correctly: Hierath (in Welsh) or Heimat in German. I'm sure other countries have that.

For me a lot of what is described as patriotism is tied up with feelings of being home and being comfortable with where and who you are.

(you have to be careful with German words sometimes for obvious reasons. But as pp pointed out with the English flag and the EDL, slowly slowly some of these words and meanings are being taken back from the Nazis and re-integrated into normal German)

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 09:05

No one is ‘pretending’ just having a discussion trying to ascertain what these woolly concepts mean in conclusion.

People get defensive and bring in their ‘Mum does this’. Terrible debating though, it should be done more at school.

Brefugee · 23/11/2022 09:02

Intresting thread. Reminds me of an essay question on my IR course.

In order to answer the title question it is surely necessary to define the terms, i'd suggest "patriotism" and "bollocks" for starters.

There is a fine line between patriotism and nationalism IMO, and I'd define the former as the flag-waving, national-sport-team-supporting folk and the latter as the "we are superior because we come from X".

Assuming we are talking about a nebulous "proud of the country but not trying to force people to confirm and rejecting all others as undesirable" types, there is a lot to be said for "patriosm". Humans are social animals who function best in groups. The basic group would be a nuclear family, wider family, then ever increasing communities until you get to the (somewhat arbitrary, but in the cases of places like Britain and Australia pretty easy to define) geographical area called "country".

And yes, it is all accident of birth, but so is everything pretty much. So outside of accident of birth what ties you to a country? Moving elsewhere is a pretty massive move, and you do risk the chance of being a permanent outsider, for generations to come. And then the 2nd generation are often conflicted, especially where the immigrating generation really do go all out to show loyalty to their new home, but still retain strong ties to the old one. (and then you get idiots like Tebbit and his "cricket test")

In terms of generally supporting English/British teams in big events, yeah, why not? I was born here, they're selected from the best people with the same passport as me, and why not? It's arbitrary. Even if i don't care about indoor-ballooning, i'd probably "support" (ie be happy for them if they do well) the English/British team. I can get inter-British rivalry so long as it remains light-hearted and am not of the ABE mindset (notwithstanding: i'm actually English and i totally understand why Scottish people will always support England's opponent). In terms of support for sports teams (probably any other type of team) I'm usually: England, then NI, Wales, Scotland, Germany (I'm an immigrant), Ireland, European country, underdog. Not because i think they are best in any way, but they are the ones i feel closest affinity to.

For sport (again) i do notice that groups of nationals tend to be a bit over the top if they are watching their team in a different country. (singing a bit louder, embracing total strangers in the team shirt when a goal is scored etc)

And if you want to talk about feeling unable to display the national flag in their own country, speak to Germans who have only really started to embrace that since the world cup was held here. It is complicated.

the tl;dr version: it boils down to your reaction to the question "my country, right or wrong?"

TheLeadbetterLife · 23/11/2022 08:48

Nobody on this thread said wars wouldn’t happen if there were no countries or patriotism. A couple of posters pretended or imagined it was said, presumably because they’re determined to argue against points no-one is actually making.

When my mum does this, it’s because she wants to steer every conversation on to her current personal bugbear (usually some bonkers conspiracy theory she’s picked up on Facebook. At the moment it’s the Great Reset, but she definitely knows all the words to “Everyone Else In The World Is Allowed To Be Patriotic”).

KimberleyClark · 23/11/2022 08:37

PurpleButterflyWings · 22/11/2022 21:59

@Changeyncchange

YANBU to feel that yourself, but you would be unreasonable to think everyone should feel the same. Also, it is annoying that SOME people claim if you're patriotic (in England especially,) that you're automatically a bigot/racist/gammon.

ANY OTHER COUNTRY can be patriotic and it's OK. But the English get bashed! Even down to the English flag; you're a flag shagger and a thick racist if you fly the English flag, yet no-one else is accused of this, if they fly THEIR flag, not even Wales or Scotland.

In the past the Union flag and St George’s flag have regrettably been hijacked and appropriated by extreme right wing racist groups like the National Front and the EDF. This is not the case with the Welsh or Scottish flags. I don’t think anyone could describe Plaid Cymru or the SNP as extreme right wing.

I’m Welsh and proud of it. My parents were from the same part of rural West Wales and I like to think the soil there is full of my DNA. I’m proud of my country’s language and culture having prevailed despite centuries of attempts to wipe it out. Yma o Hyd!

QuizzlyBear · 23/11/2022 08:35

Born and bred in the UK - family British going back generations, and I still don't have a sense of patriotism.

I like aspects of our country, I like a decent proportion of the people in it, but I can't imagine I'd feel differently about another country if I lived there.

I also have zero affinity for the class system or 'respect' for the monarchy, which seems to define patriotism in the UK. I just don't get it.

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 08:19

It could be a good debate though - in a classroom

Are countries a good idea or whatever

On one side you could argue that they allow humans who can be territorial (like other animals) the ability to exist in populous places without breaking out over most things due to common ground. Then cheering your country’s football team can be a relatively benign way to express emotion for that collective idea.

Others might take the other side and say wars wouldn’t happen etc as has been said already and other arguments

whumpthereitis · 23/11/2022 08:14

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 07:56

Mn tends to throw up more anti U.K. posts, people are reacting to that.

The conversation over whether any patriotism is ok is more balanced but when it reaches the idea if everyone was completely indifferent re patriotism we wouldn’t have wars it seems far fetched and utopian.

Human qualities of protecting and defending a space aren’t new, animals engage in it. So it’s a bit like saying if we got rid of other human qualities we’d all be happy.

If people didn’t post to just say this tiny island blah blah and did it on every country level that’d be better

Don’t know so much, might want to ask the Americans on that one. Got a worse reputation around these parts than mother in laws.

the mn userbase is predominantly British, so it’s no surprise it’s uk-centric. Go to a predominantly German, Russian, American etc site and it plays out the same on those. I’m Serbian by birth, and half by blood. Believe me, if I had to envision eternal torment it would be having to sit there and listen to how it’s Serbs and Serbs alone that are picked on for patriotism. As if I haven’t already heard enough of that one for a lifetime.

Workawayxx · 23/11/2022 08:07

As has been brought to the forefront and exemplified in bold neon by the Qatar World Cup...there are an awful lot of people who benefit from their prevailing "British" culture beyond old white guys.

@samyeagar agreed, they were just one example.

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 07:56

Mn tends to throw up more anti U.K. posts, people are reacting to that.

The conversation over whether any patriotism is ok is more balanced but when it reaches the idea if everyone was completely indifferent re patriotism we wouldn’t have wars it seems far fetched and utopian.

Human qualities of protecting and defending a space aren’t new, animals engage in it. So it’s a bit like saying if we got rid of other human qualities we’d all be happy.

If people didn’t post to just say this tiny island blah blah and did it on every country level that’d be better

BosaNova · 23/11/2022 07:53

whumpthereitis · 22/11/2022 22:22

of course. As someone who is neither patriotic nor English, and has seen the same arguments play out in more than one other country and in at least two other languages, I am in fact a unicorn.

slap my ass and call me Pegasus I suppose.

😂

whumpthereitis · 23/11/2022 07:47

Changeyncchange · 23/11/2022 06:21

ANY OTHER COUNTRY can be patriotic and it's OK. But the English get bashed! Even down to the English flag; you're a flag shagger and a thick racist if you fly the English flag, yet no-one else is accused of this, if they fly THEIR flag, not even Wales or Scotland

People keep saying this and completely ignoring the fact that I and other poster have said we feel the same way about all patriotism. Indeed one Scottish poster specifically spoke about their dislike of this kind of thing in Scotland.

It's really odd.

8 billion people in the world, and every single person that’s ever been criticised for patriotism has been English. Anyone that isn’t English that says they’re not patriotic either doesn’t exist, or is lying in order to cover up the great conspiracy to victimise the patriotic English that we’re all apparently in on.

In reality, these exact same arguments play out in plenty of other countries. Maybe even all of them. Even down to the hyperbolic claims that ‘it’s fine for everyone else but not us’. Can personally vouch for hearing that one from at least four other nationalities. Complaining about not being allowed to be patriotic whilst waving their flags.

Changeyncchange · 23/11/2022 06:21

ANY OTHER COUNTRY can be patriotic and it's OK. But the English get bashed! Even down to the English flag; you're a flag shagger and a thick racist if you fly the English flag, yet no-one else is accused of this, if they fly THEIR flag, not even Wales or Scotland

People keep saying this and completely ignoring the fact that I and other poster have said we feel the same way about all patriotism. Indeed one Scottish poster specifically spoke about their dislike of this kind of thing in Scotland.

It's really odd.

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 22/11/2022 23:32

You may not feel this way but the fact that most people on this planet feel proud of the country they belong to proves that feeling patriotism is normal.

Sorry but that doesn't seem to be true. A poll showing roughly 50/50 would suggest otherwise.

Patriotism in the UK is also declining year on year.

yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2015/07/14/decline-british-patriotism

I love this country but am no patriot.

The UK is in the top 10 but nothing to write home about.

worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-patriotic-countries

DownNative · 22/11/2022 23:28

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 16:23

Well if countries are purely made up and ‘not real’ as a pp put it what does that mean in terms of protecting them

Indeed. Isn't it a concept that causes wars?

Russia feel Ukraine is rightfully theirs. A good majority of the Northern Irish think they are occupied. China and Tawain. India/Pakistan and Kasmir. Christ we could be here all night.

Are these good things. Have they had good outcomes?

@Changeyncchange and where exactly are you getting this idea a "good majority of the Northern Irish think they are occupied" from?!

Additionally, it looks to me that you've not considered carefully enough the crucial difference between patriotism and nationalism.

"Nationalism is based on the belief that one's nation is superior to others, while patriotism is based on one's love and devotion to country."

While the two can go hand in hand, it is Nationalism that is the true root of conflict since its either presented as being about taking over or expelling an other. It can be both as in the case of Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA, for example. They actually regarded themselves as the only true legitimate government of the entire island of Ireland all along.

Patriotism recognises the destruction and death that conflict brings. Nationalism ignores or justifies it as "you made us do it!" which Hume asserted is the hallmark of the fascist. Hence why John Hume was a patriot, but Martin McGuinness was NOT.

You may well agree with Hume's statement that "you can't eat a flag" - in other words, nationalistic feelings won't clothe or feed the people. He preferred job creation and education which are patriotic endeavours aiming at bettering the people and the country.

There is a difference between patriotism and nationalism. Orwell wrote about it too.

Usernamesarboring · 22/11/2022 23:06

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 15:49

Also my point was your sentence at the end about prevailing against all odds. Such an emotive phrase, exactly what I think of when I think of patriotism. Meaningless sentiment.

Perhaps having immigrant ancestors make you not patriotic? In fact, I find other nationalitoes to be far more patriotic and proud of their countries than British overall.

You may not feel this way but the fact that most people on this planet feel proud of the country they belong to proves that feeling patriotism is normal. People love their countries for familiarity and for intangible reasons, it's not based on logics. Like people love their families, and would have unconscious bias in favour of their family.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/11/2022 22:43

Personally, there are things I like about Britain and things I don’t (I see myself as British rather than English, as heritage is mixed British and other countries), and things I don’t.

I want the best for the country as I see it.

I wouldn’t call myself patriotic as such.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/11/2022 22:41

Depends what you mean by “patriotism” I guess.

Blind loyalty to you country whatever it does - even if it turns into a fascist state, come what may - I don’t agree with. That’s unthinking loyalty and I don’t agree with that.

Wanting the best for your country and all the people who live in it - I’m on board with. Even though we should really be caring equally for everyone in the world, it’s easier to work towards improving your own country that the whole whole.

Agreeing with the values your country happens to have, whether it be democracy, diversity etc or the opposite end of the scale (if that’s your genuine belief, however misguided) I’d probably just call that agreement rather than patriotism.

DownNative · 22/11/2022 22:38

Tekkentime · 22/11/2022 16:38

I'm English and i'm very proud. I also think Scotland, Wales and Ireland are great and support them in any games that aren't against England 😂

Seems you forgot Northern Ireland there.....🤔