Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

9 degrees inside - is it now a false economy to not put heating on?

541 replies

blanketseverywhere · 22/11/2022 13:54

I'm trying to get by without putting heating on. According to the smart meter, it's currently 9 degrees in the sitting room (north-facing). The house feels very cold, but if I sit in the kitchen (south-facing) in many layers, with scarf and fingerless gloves on etc, it's not unbearable for WFH. In the evening I can use blankets / hot water bottles etc while watching tv and have two duvets on the bed at night.

However, at what point will temperatures of this level start to damage the house - or me? I feel achey all the time which I think is from being 'tense' in the cold, if that makes sense. I also have a constantly red and running nose / scratchy throat although I don't really feel ill.

I'm not using the tumble dryer so drying washing inside most of the time, although do try and keep windows open for air circulation... but then that makes it colder! I don't think we have any damp but I'm worried about the house constantly being cold - is this an issue in itself?

Is it going to get to a point where it's a false economy not to put the heating on because it will possibly be doing damage to the house, or should I carry on trying to hold out if possible and just carry on layering up? I realise this probably sounds a bit daft but I really don't want to store up even bigger problems!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Notjustabrunette · 22/11/2022 17:18

I listen to a podcast recently on the most efficient ways to heat the house. If you’ve got GCH it’s better to use that than a small electric heater in one room.

pinkrupee · 22/11/2022 17:18

We were congratulating ourselves how little we'd needed the heater on during a relatively warm November. Then on Friday my cleaner pointed out that several of the window frames - most of which are only a few years old - had developed black mould....

Newlifestartingatlast · 22/11/2022 17:17

PerkingFaintly · 22/11/2022 14:06

This is why I prioritise using a dehumidifier over putting the heating on.

I've done many years with minimal heating, often with the house at 10 degrees, and can tell you that you will indeed get damp, mould and have health issues if you try to dry laundry indoors at these temperatures just by opening windows.

Your books will be ruined, and your clothes and furniture may be too.

A dehumidifier will dry out the laundry, keep the moisture levels down generally, and it puts out slightly warmed dry air so can help get the temperature up in that room.

I find it's a win all round. Yes it costs to run, but it solves multiple problems.

Also pay out for a cheap humidity metre. Thy don’t cost much though I appreciate you have no money.
They can save a fortune in repairing damage caused by mold

Littlemisspawpatrol · 22/11/2022 17:15

I've got my heating on. I pay a direct debit all year round to save up for the winter. Before the price hike it was £32 a month for gas (but I lived in a place I had to heat water for a bath and now I live in a place with an electric shower) and now I pay £40 a month for gas, all year round. Then the government are putting £400 into our banks for the heating this year. Surely you can afford to put it on low for a few hours of the day in one or two rooms?

Gastonia · 22/11/2022 17:14

I saw that BBC article but it raised more questions than it answered for me. Is "working hard" a bad thing, for younger, averagely fit people? What about going outdoors? Surely it's not unhealthy to venture outside in winter?
Totally agree. People keep quoting this article, but it was about a man wearing shorts and an open shirt! It's 14c here, I'm healthy and wearing warm clothes. My hands are warm. It's fine for me. Obviously, it's not good for sick people etc, but that article is so misleading, and just worries people like me, unless you read it carefully.

Sewaccidentprone · 22/11/2022 17:14

We’ve only had the central heating on twice in the past month, but our house retains the heat well (we’ve spent the past 10 years increasing the thermal capacity of the house to achieve this though).

if I’m in a room long term I try to keep it to around 18 degrees. Anything lower than that makes me feel generally unwell.

I'm currently relying on a small portable electric heater and a heated throw, as well as a dehumidifier.

I’ve worked out that to run the central heating/hot water costs around £2 an hour, whereas I keep the heater on the 700W setting which I believe works out around 25p per hr. The heated throw is 150W, which I have on the lowest setting which costs less than 2p per hour.

what did you used to pay for your heating and electricity as it can be reasonably straightforward to work out how much a heater costs to run ie 1KW = 34p per hr.

but the cold/damp will damage your health and your house, so unsure unless you’re generally on the bones of your arse financially why you couldn’t run a low KW heater for a few hours a day etc

Daffodilsandtuplips · 22/11/2022 17:13

Put the heating on. You’re risking damp and mould and ill health by sitting in purgatory.
My father in law was a miser, (I’m not saying you are), he really was, he had the gas fire in one heated one room, he refused to put the heating on in the rest of the house. When he died and we had to empty the house we found wardrobes full mouldy clothes and shoes. And these were in the bedroom they’d been sleeping in.

tootiredtospeak · 22/11/2022 17:12

My heated blanket costs 40p to have over me whilst I work for about 6 hours. It was seriously worth the £40 I paid for it. Do you have a smart meter. I watch mine religiously and work out what I am spending each day to make sure I dont exceed my direct debit plus government grant. It means I can normally heat the house at least an hour or 2. I think some people have decided they will simply not heat at all but to what end my grandparents dont want to line the pockets of the fat cats so are sat freezing in their eighties when they have thousands saved in the bank. Its crazy they are prepared to risk their own health.

AdoraBell · 22/11/2022 17:12

It’s the room/environment temperature etulosba I’m sure it be more comfortable with clothes rather than naked. I haven’t tested it naked tbh, I’m not that brave.

longestlurkerever · 22/11/2022 17:10

I saw that BBC article but it raised more questions than it answered for me. Is "working hard" a bad thing, for younger, averagely fit people? What about going outdoors? Surely it's not unhealthy to venture outside in winter? I'm not being extreme with our heating but also think you don't actually need houses to be that hot

Notjustabrunette · 22/11/2022 17:07

I’ve read a few articles recently on the effects of cold on people, if your house is at 10 degrees your health is at risk due high blood pressure and your brain doesn’t function so well. You don’t need to have it on constantly to achieve a comfortable temperature. I’ve found laying helps with a thermal long sleeve top as a base, sweatshirt then gilet works well. Plus a bit of heating on if the temp starts to drop too much.

Ihavedogs · 22/11/2022 17:06

@blanketseverywhere

Is it going to get to a point where it's a false economy not to put the heating on because it will possibly be doing damage to the house, or should I carry on trying to hold out if possible and just carry on layering up? I realise this probably sounds a bit daft but I really don't want to store up even bigger problems!

Yes, it is going to get to a point where it is false economy and you are potentiality harming your health. You either currently have a bug, or your health is already suffering.

Have you sat down and gone through last years usage and then worked out what the same usage will cost this year? If you were not in your current home last winter you will have to try and work the usage out. For us, December and January are when we used the most energy followed by February, November and October. You can then work out from there as to what is affordable this year taking into account the £66 government support that virtually every household is getting.

If you need to cut back on usage of energy generally are you aware of how to do this? It may be that you find that making a lot of little changes can add up. We used far too much energy and have cut back with lots of small changes which have not impacted on our comfort much, but have halved our usage. It will not be so easy to make big reductions if you didn’t use a great deal in the first instance. There may also be other things you can cut back on to allow you to prioritise heating.

Drying laundry indoors will create damp, can it be placed in a room away from the main living area with a window opened a little to help reduce condensation and damp?

Please put some heating on.

etulosba · 22/11/2022 17:05

18 degrees is the cut off point at which our bodies start working hard to keep our core temperature up.

Is this naked people or people wearing appropriate clothes?

SingMeToSIeep · 22/11/2022 17:04

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 17:01

I am on prepayment. At this point dd prices are the aame anyway.
You could buy adapter for non shower tap. If I remember correctly they are about a tenner.
That gas saved could easily go on heating.

We rent and aren't allowed to use shower attachments or install anything shower-like unfortunately.

AdoraBell · 22/11/2022 17:03

I read an article on BBC, probably under their Health section, yesterday about the effects of cold. 18 degrees is the cut off point at which our bodies start working hard to keep our core temperature up. At 13 degrees the risk of stroke and heart attack rises because our hearts are pumping hot blood around to keep our vital organs warm.

If you can afford to heat the house then do put the heating on. If not could you stay in the warmer south facing rooms?

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 17:01

SingMeToSIeep · 22/11/2022 16:56

Three adults here, and we're on prepayment, so we pay more. We also don't have a shower so have to have baths, which cost more as more.

I am on prepayment. At this point dd prices are the aame anyway.
You could buy adapter for non shower tap. If I remember correctly they are about a tenner.
That gas saved could easily go on heating.

Poppingmad123 · 22/11/2022 16:58

I mean electric radiator & tumble dryer is on drying my clothes as well as warming my kitchen at the same time.

Softleftpowerstance · 22/11/2022 16:58

SingMeToSIeep · 22/11/2022 16:54

Saint Sunak is absolutely not 'pretty much wholly covering our heating costs'.

I explained in my last post how much of a shortfall that £66 still leaves. For those on a low income, and having to pay more for their fuel because they're on prepayment meters, putting the heating on will be a rare luxury. There's hundreds of pounds a month still to find, even with that help.

“Our” has a personal as well as collective meaning.

Unless I’ve missed it the OP isn’t on a prepayment metre and appears to own their home, which they managed to purchase recently suggesting adequate financial health.

Poppingmad123 · 22/11/2022 16:56

Sounds like you need the heating on. How can your clothes get dry inside?

I’ve put my tumble dryer in the kitchen instead of the utility & it warms the whole room up. I use hot water bottle all day as I work from home & do have to reheat it a couple of times. In the evening I’ve been using a radiator to heat one room. I’ve not yet put the main heating on yet but I think I’m am going to need to start doing it for 1 hour in morning & 1 hour in evening.

Just keep an eye on your meter and the bills. Keep well op.

SingMeToSIeep · 22/11/2022 16:56

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 16:52

If you are putting £120 with no heating you need to look at a massive overuse somewhere.
We have 2 showers, cook on gas cooker in the evening, sometimes twice a day and heating on for half an hour in a morning and hour and half in the evening and are on about £3 a day....
There is 2 of us, but 2 more showers, for example, for 4 deb household will not make it to 120 without heating.

Three adults here, and we're on prepayment, so we pay more. We also don't have a shower so have to have baths, which cost more as more.

thelobsterquadrille · 22/11/2022 16:55

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 16:49

An hour a day is considerably better than nothing so yes, it does make a difference.

Of course it's better than nothing, but people still need to weigh up the pros vs. cons.

An hour of heat a day when your house is already 9 degrees inside won't do anything to get rid of the mould or the damp - so some people would rather spend that £66 on more directly beneficial things - and some have no choice but to spend it on other essentials instead.

Whereas if you're house is sitting at 15-16 degrees, an hour could bring it up to 17-18 degrees which would feel considerably warmer and make a big difference.

SingMeToSIeep · 22/11/2022 16:54

Softleftpowerstance · 22/11/2022 16:50

I can’t believe it took this long for someone to point out the actually quite generous government support. Sunak will pretty much wholly cover our heating costs this winter.

I know so many people being tight with the heating who can very much afford it. It’s baffling.

Saint Sunak is absolutely not 'pretty much wholly covering our heating costs'.

I explained in my last post how much of a shortfall that £66 still leaves. For those on a low income, and having to pay more for their fuel because they're on prepayment meters, putting the heating on will be a rare luxury. There's hundreds of pounds a month still to find, even with that help.

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 16:52

SingMeToSIeep · 22/11/2022 16:41

Thing is, it's not just heating, is it. It's hot water, too. This time last year I was putting about £40pm in my gas meter, and that was with a bit of heating (maybe an hour or so a day). Now I'm putting about £120pm in, and that's with no heating so far.

Then there's the same again for the electricity.

So we've gone from about £80pm altogether to almost £250pm, with no heating as yet. And with cutting down our electricity (one lamp in the living room, oven used minimally, no fire, etc). A pp suggested that an extra £120pm on top of that for heating would be affordable. How?

When people talk about the £66pm as if it's the magic cure-all, they might like to consider that even without heating (and to use our flat as an example) that still leaves a £100 shortfall compared to last year. Add heating onto that and it's an extra £220pm to find. And that's on top of the huge rise in grocery prices and everything else we have to accommodate.

People are not being martyrs.

If you are putting £120 with no heating you need to look at a massive overuse somewhere.
We have 2 showers, cook on gas cooker in the evening, sometimes twice a day and heating on for half an hour in a morning and hour and half in the evening and are on about £3 a day....
There is 2 of us, but 2 more showers, for example, for 4 deb household will not make it to 120 without heating.

GreyhairedHobbit · 22/11/2022 16:52

Angelofthenortheast · 22/11/2022 16:45

This woman and her family are existing in 9c temps. They are currently at a very real risk of hypothermia - lighting a fire is the safer option. But even then, chimney sweep is £60 once a year.

Seasoned wood just means that it has been dead a long time. It's easy to find it in woods - but tbh if we are down to gathering wood from parks to burn, the OP may as well quit her job because she's living in the same temps as a homeless person

Lighting a fire in an unsafe fireplace could risk a house fire, not a cheaper option. Most sweeps are about £75 nowdays. Finding enough seasoned wood in a park or woodland with the right moisture content to prevent tar build up would be unlikely without a trailer or pickup.

Fluffy40 · 22/11/2022 16:51

We’ve had the heating on for a month, for about 3 hours a day. The bill is just over 90 pounds, just for the gas only.