Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Togoodtobeforgotten · 22/11/2022 14:29

Forfrigz · 22/11/2022 12:24

Honestly you need to come from a stable background with good finances to do medicine. Most of the UK population are languishing in abject squalor presently which is why we rely on the children of decent foreign homes to diagnose us

That is not true at all.

Darkstar4855 · 22/11/2022 14:24

OP, the reliance on locums is not directly a result of lack of medical school places. Many locum doctors are UK trained doctors who have quit working for the NHS due to the lack of flexibility, poor training opportunities, unpaid overtime etc. We lose many junior doctors overseas or to other professions for the same reason.

It’s pointless throwing money at extra medical school places if you don’t fix the issues that are causing many UK trained doctors to leave the NHS. The first step is to retain the doctors we’ve already trained. It’s a lot cheaper than training replacements.

Badbadbunny · 22/11/2022 14:23

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:21

Presumably other countries also need clinical placements for their trainee doctors so how come they can provide enough of these but the UK cannot?

And presumably, "immigrant" doctors who come into the NHS also need supervision/training within the NHS to satisfy regulators that they're competent and to train them in the NHS ways of doing things. So that's also a "drain" on NHS resources. Unless they come straight in and into hospitals/GP surgeries without any kind of "conversion" and supervision based on an overseas qualification?

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:21

Presumably other countries also need clinical placements for their trainee doctors so how come they can provide enough of these but the UK cannot?

OP posts:
Blip · 22/11/2022 14:19

@Soothsayer1 makes a great point - why is the UK so unable to train enough new doctors whilst other countries manage to do this?

OP posts:
Claretmum · 22/11/2022 14:17

I work within the School of Medicine at a UK University - NHS placements are limited to 'X' amount per year. We are always over-subscribed, students want to come to us but we just do not have sufficient placements available.

Coffeewinecake · 22/11/2022 14:11

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:44

A consultant is not a doctor in training, therefore it is possible to work less days, though still uncommon. The vast majority of consultants I know work full time. In fact, in my last hospital, in my speciality, there was no one who didn't work full time.

I'm not doubting that a minority do work less than full time for personal or health reasons, but it is a fallacy to claim that the majority of doctors work 'very part time' as has been claimed upthread.

Depends on the specialty- some are more conducive to part time than others and so the majority could be PT or FT.
Secondly, some consultants maybe doing compressed hours, e.g 3 long days, which could equate to FT hours but they may appear to be PT as they are not at work 2 days/wk

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 14:10

Criticising doctors for working less than full time (though this is often more than full time hours for other professions) is massively missing the point, as is overlooking the retention issues (moving abroad and leaving the profession). If we want to keep a sufficient medical work force here then we need to examine what is causing the heamorrhaging of medical professionals and fix this.

This thread has highlighted that a significant proportion of the public have no interest in this and would rather simply criticise, with prejudices based on misconceptions and misinformation.

No wonder the NHS is sleep walking into a death spiral.

GetThatHelmetOn · 22/11/2022 13:46

Because the British public keeps putting people in power who have vested interests in privatising the NHS.

The more broken the NHS looks the more likely privatisation becomes.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:44

Badbadbunny · 22/11/2022 13:40

My OH's haematology consultant only works 2 days per week as she has a young family.

A consultant is not a doctor in training, therefore it is possible to work less days, though still uncommon. The vast majority of consultants I know work full time. In fact, in my last hospital, in my speciality, there was no one who didn't work full time.

I'm not doubting that a minority do work less than full time for personal or health reasons, but it is a fallacy to claim that the majority of doctors work 'very part time' as has been claimed upthread.

Badbadbunny · 22/11/2022 13:40

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:14

Where does this statistic come from? I have never heard it before. Perhaps it refers to GPs? It is definitely not true of hospital specialities.

My OH's haematology consultant only works 2 days per week as she has a young family.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 22/11/2022 13:40

Proposals for the new medical schools were put forward to lower the teaching, assessment, examination and exit standards for the newer medical schools and would create a 2-tier medical graduate system.

This is untrue.

Soothsayer1 · 22/11/2022 13:40

Why are we so rubbish compared to other countries?😫
Why is it so easy for our government to pull the wool over the eyes of the electorate?🙁

Itsbiasedhere · 22/11/2022 13:40

That's said current medical school caps are i think because of lack of available funding and taking doctors away from front line to train might not be the immediate vote winner for the government.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:35

No source quoted, so I cannot verify.

A google search did not find this statistic, but this instead, from the same purported source, which contradicts:

www.rcgp.org.uk/News/GP-working-hours-more-complex

"GPs and our teams are working incredibly hard right now, under intense workload and workforce pressures. More than 28 million consultations we made in general practice in England in September alone - over two million more than the same month in 2019.

"When GPs work 'less than full time', the reality is they are often working more than the 37.5 hours a week that are generally considered full time. A GP working a three-day week in clinic will on average work 40 hours, with reams of paperwork to complete when they're not seeing patients. A quarter of GPs are working 50 hours a week or more. To put this into context, a pilot is restricted to flying 32 hours over seven days, because doing more would be considered unsafe.

“The size of the qualified GP workforce fell by almost 6% between September 2015 and August 2021, while the number of patients has continued to grow meaning that the ratio of patients to GPs has increased by more than 10%. Put simply, workload is escalating in general practice, whilst GP numbers are falling.

“This is unsustainable, which is why the Government needs to make good on its manifesto promise of 6,000 more full time equivalent (FTE) GPs by 2024. We are also calling for a system-wide programme to eradicate bureaucratic burdens and unnecessary workload, to prevent GP burnout and allow GPs more time to care for patients.”

Itsbiasedhere · 22/11/2022 13:34

BMA and the doctors are often the biggest restrictors of medical places
www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748#:~:text=Delegates%20at%20the%20annual%20BMA,on%20opening%20new%20medical%20schools.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 22/11/2022 13:33

My dr colleagues (I’m a lawyer in a large public sector org) tell me it’s the BMA blocking it. Sorry don’t have source. The BMA is an incredibly powerful union and govt officials terrified of them!

This is nonsense.

The BMA is concerned with ensuring that there are jobs for doctors. It opposes moves to promote competition by increasing the number of medical graduates without increasing the number of training posts for them. It is entirely unfair to put someone through 5-6 years of medical school if a proportion of them are then unable to get jobs as doctors and would have been better off doing a 3-year degree. In any case, the BMA doesn't make policy; it expresses opinions on behalf of doctors. It doesn't have any power to "block" anything. And the stuff about government officials being "terrified" of the BMA is utter horseshit.

(Disclaimer: I am not a doctor. I do work in a medical school.)

The main obstacles to training more doctors are: (a) the cost to the NHS (approx £200,000 per graduate); (b) the sclerotic approach of medical schools & teaching hospitals to clinical placements, which are inefficient and put tighter limits on placement capacity than are necessary; (c) the GMC's outcomes for graduates, which require too many specific skills to have been demonstrated at undergraduate level, when opportunities to practise them are often scarce, while not setting a high enough bar for generic skills; (d) the BMA's issue of bottlenecks in postgraduate training programmes (these are currently being addressed, although it remains to be seen whether anything genuinely changes); (e) the "leaky bucket" of junior doctors' emigrating, taking career breaks and not returning, and working part-time (especially in general practice) because of the unreasonable workload.

Some of the measures put in place to try to support the over-stretched medical workforce have made the situation worse to some extent. For example, training physician associates to take on part of the role of doctors places increased pressure on clinical placement capacity as these students also require extensive placements in the same settings. The proposed apprenticeship route to train more doctors risks causing shortages in other healthcare professions.

It seems to me there needs to be an increased number of places on accelerated (e.g. graduate-entry) medical education/training programmes with sponsorship schemes that remove financial obstacles to students but impose some requirement on them to work for the NHS for a minimum number of years in return. But to do it will still require the use of placements to be much more efficient, which, in turn, requires the doctors who teach medical students to become more immersed in education (understand what students have already learned, tailor placement activity to specific learning points, etc.), which many will be reluctant to do.

The above is my opinion. I am not aware of any organisation that shares my opinion.

Regularsizedrudy · 22/11/2022 13:33

Would you train to be a doctor? I wouldn’t.

Blip · 22/11/2022 13:29

Source was the Royal College of GPs

OP posts:
Blip · 22/11/2022 13:28

Ooops that should be 23% full time

OP posts:
Blip · 22/11/2022 13:28

@BelleMarionette you're correct 23% part time relates to GPs.

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:26

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 22/11/2022 13:23

I'm not a GP, but it's not true of GPs either. In fact, it simply isn't true at all. It's far too easy to lie, and then spread the lie as truth, on the internet.

This is true. My comment wasn't intended as derogatory to GPs, I was more wondering, as others have pointed out, that it is falsely low, if only patient contact time is counted.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 22/11/2022 13:23

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:14

Where does this statistic come from? I have never heard it before. Perhaps it refers to GPs? It is definitely not true of hospital specialities.

I'm not a GP, but it's not true of GPs either. In fact, it simply isn't true at all. It's far too easy to lie, and then spread the lie as truth, on the internet.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 22/11/2022 13:20

BMA is one of the weakest unions in terms of fighting for the rights of its members but it has an undeservedly fierce reputation as being a strong union.

The reasons doctors voted to not increase medical schools and medical school places were complex and boiled down to obvious lack of funding and totally inadequate planning. The proposals at the time we're to increase medical school places in existing medical schools but without a corresponding increase in funding, facilities, lecturers, or clinical tutors. Essentially cramming more people into the same class with no extra resources. Unfortunately, medical training is extremely resource intensive. You simply can't have 20 medical students filing past a sick patient, all of them examining the same person being supervised by the same person. You need more people teaching, and teaching students takes time away from other clinical activities so hospitals don't like doctors doing much teaching unless there are enough resources.

Proposals for the new medical schools were put forward to lower the teaching, assessment, examination and exit standards for the newer medical schools and would create a 2-tier medical graduate system.

There were also no plans to increase junior doctor posts for these doctors to be employed after graduation, no increase in training posts so that they could receive the necessary post graduate training they need to become GPs or specialists (a GP still needs 5-6 years of post grad training after 5-6 years at medical school, some hospital specialties need 6-7, others need 8-12 years additional training), no plans to increase consultant posts so that any newly trained specialist could be employed, and no funding for increasing GP numbers.

These were just some of the more easily understood issues with the proposals at the time, there were many others including changes to the training scheme application system, qualifications awarded, specialist examinations, loads more. The 2008 vote wasn't just about medical school places or new medical schools, but entire medical careers, specialist medical training, working patterns and hours and other linked issues. Many of those proposals were implemented anyway and wrecked tens of thousands of careers with huge numbers of UK doctors emigrating to Australia and Canada, which meant we had to rely even more heavily on doctors from abroad.

It's far too easy to say just train more doctors, or condemn a vote from 14 years ago for opposing proposals to increase numbers without understanding the underlying issues. It takes a huge amount of long term planning and investment that's way beyond the horizon of any government - 12 to 18 years at a minimum - to be able to get us out of the hole successive governments of all hues have dug into.

DOI: I'm a doctor and had many friends affected by the "medical career reforms" around 2008, the MMC/MTAS fiasco, which devastated the training and careers of a generation of doctors.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:19

yoyo1234 · 22/11/2022 13:16

BMA NHS payscales and NHS doctor payscales to be the same. I have found consultant payscale information to be more concise (other than private work/locum work etc). The difference at more junior levels were the out of hours / antisocial hours pay awards. At junior doctor levels these could be (if I recall correctly an additional 42% on top of basic). For consultant work it has been 8% on top of basic. With consultant work you frequently get extra sessions (each worth 10% but each taking at least an extra 10% of your time and you have to justify this to HR) you also get discretionary or clinical excellence awards. Clinical Excellence and Discretionary Award values are all noted correctly. So I think there is leeway with payscales but websites try to be open and honest.

With the new contract (that everyone in England is now on) the pay uplift for out of hours work is minimal. It was far more on the old contract, hence the motivation to change it.