Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Cornishmumofone · 22/11/2022 20:22

@Badbadbunny "It' hardly the students' fault if medical schools/Unis reverted to virtual lectures instead of face to face is it? You make it sound like the students' fault!"

Students were directed to take part in online classes which were synchronous. The classes were recorded, so many students chose not to attend and then couldn't cram everything at the end so they failed. That wasn't the fault of the Unis. Students who attended the online sessions did well.

WindyHedges · 22/11/2022 20:04

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

It’s a complex issue, but here are some answers to your simplistic question:

  • Lack of capacity in UK universities due to chronic under-investment over the last decade.
  • The £9k tuition fee doesn’t cover anywhere near the actual cost of a medical degree. Have a look at what international students are charged: that’s nearer to the real cost.
  • Lack of training posts and current capacity because of deliberate underinvestment in the NHS over the last decade. (as a side note, most people don’t realise that the NHS is an educational organisation as much as a medical treatment service).
2tired2bewitty · 22/11/2022 19:18

www.politico.eu/article/france-doctors-europe-too-far-too-old-too-few/ I read this article today which suggests this is not just a UK problem, and that some of the problems here are found elsewhere too

Pixie2015 · 22/11/2022 19:14

The doctors leave nhs to be locums as more money - less stress , better hours, holidays when want and making it an even worse place for permanent staff to be - make all doctors locums or regulate the industry

noworklifebalance · 22/11/2022 19:12

It’s usually the doctors pleading for more colleagues so they can run extra clinics and lists, rather than having two patients booked into one appointment slot - unsurprisingly, by the end of a clinic everyone is stressed and frazzled, hardly conducive to good patient care or experience.

noworklifebalance · 22/11/2022 19:09

Also, it’s not possible to keep lists artificially long - there are targets and layers up layers of manages that monitor them

noworklifebalance · 22/11/2022 19:08

Boonawoona22 · 22/11/2022 16:20

@Blip @ChiefPearlClutcher

Yes, I totally believe this. Doctors are earning megabucks through the NHS due to being in high demand. Those same doctors are taking on private work on the side. They don’t want more doctors. The BMA holds a lot of power and I don’t think change will be coming anytime soon.

There should me more university places, and subsequently more doctors. Also, I don’t agree an NHS doctor should be able to do private work. There seems to be a conflict of interest here, ie; longer NHS waiting list are, the more people go private… more money in their pocket.

Depends what you mean by megabucks - their salary scale is clearly available on the internet.

Dinoteeth · 22/11/2022 16:25

Op I've asked the same thing.
Recruiting from other countries seems cheap but how are other countries managing to train their own people?

Why are we landing Doctors and Nurses with student debt, why not refund it / write it off after say 15 years working for the NHS?

I knew a boy who was thinking about becoming a Doctor, reviewed the training and salaries and decided that Dentistry was less training and more money. 8 years down the line he's a qualified dentist in a flash merc.

Rewis · 22/11/2022 16:21

Don't know about UK but where I'm from the doctors unions are against it cause their salaries would go down if there was enough doctors. Also doctors work in public sector for a short time and then move on to private practises for better pay. Also small town that really need doctors are undesirable for younger doctors to move to.

Boonawoona22 · 22/11/2022 16:20

@Blip @ChiefPearlClutcher

Yes, I totally believe this. Doctors are earning megabucks through the NHS due to being in high demand. Those same doctors are taking on private work on the side. They don’t want more doctors. The BMA holds a lot of power and I don’t think change will be coming anytime soon.

There should me more university places, and subsequently more doctors. Also, I don’t agree an NHS doctor should be able to do private work. There seems to be a conflict of interest here, ie; longer NHS waiting list are, the more people go private… more money in their pocket.

Terven · 22/11/2022 16:13

Keeping the numbers down keeps their wages up.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 22/11/2022 16:09

Does this happen with medical students too?

No. Some medical schools (the most recent wave of new ones: Sunderland, Anglia Ruskin, Kent & Medway, Lincoln) aren't allowed to recruit international fee-paying students. For most others, the number of international fee-paying students is capped at 7.5% of their 2017 intake. (Their total intake numbers might have increased since then but the number of international students they're allowed to accept has not increased.)

This is complicated, though, by the recent emergence of some private medical schools that either only recruit international students at no cost to the central NHS (e.g. Brunel) or recruit any suitably qualified student who can pay the fees but, again, don't receive NHS funding in the same way as mainstream medical schools (e.g. Buckingham). However, these medical schools are accredited in the same way as all other UK schools and are in a position to take standard-funded home students whenever numbers are expanded.

I was encouraged to read recently that some British students are going abroad to study medicine, so the constraints that our our half-baked system impose on doctor supply are not an absolute blocker. I think people were going to Eastern Europe, or possibly one of the ex-Soviet republics, where apparently there are plenty of places in medical schools and local hospitals for trainee doctors. (I don't remember the details of how this was funded, presumably it is self-funded, but not expensive.)

But, of course, many of these were displaced by the war in Ukraine and have been unable to complete their training. Students who train in other countries have to go through an additional assessment before they can practise in the UK. From 2024 this will become the medical licensing assessment (MLA), which anyone who wants to practise medicine in the UK will have to pass, regardless of where they have trained (UK, Europe, rest of world). While this might - or might not - increase the number of medical graduates wanting to work in the UK, it doesn't do anything about the bottleneck of foundation training. At present, graduates have to complete a foundation training year before they are fully licensed and a second foundation year before they can enter specialist training programmes. Unless the number of foundation places expands (or the postgraduate training pathway is completely changed), it makes no difference how many medical graduates we have: they won't be able to work as doctors.

(I do not know who exactly is responsible for this. I don't think it's just the money)

Numbers are capped by the Office for Students on the instructions of the Department of Health & Social Care. DHSC attempts to match the number of medical & dental graduates to the number of jobs available to new graduates. Medical & dental schools that exceed the cap are subject to severe financial penalties.

gogohmm · 22/11/2022 16:08

There's also a problem with doctors choosing to work part time - increasing pay, especially for gp's partly is the cause, only one gp at our practice is full time, the ones I've spoken to openly admit they are fortunate to be able to work 25-30 hours a week on a good salary. I'm not suggesting that we pay doctors less but more there is an incentive to work full time, not necessarily money perhaps annual leave

MandUs · 22/11/2022 15:51

It's also a retention problem not just a training problem.

Same as nurses. There are plenty enough nurses being trained, certainly more than the NHS actually has capacity to train. But then they get disillusioned with the job and burn out so quickly, they leave the NHS for better paid and more flexible work.

It's the working conditions in the NHS that need to change. Not the training.

milveycrohn · 22/11/2022 15:37

The number of training places in medecine (and vertinary medecine) is strictly controlled, and it takes many years to train doctors properly.
(I do not know who exactly is responsible for this. I don't think it's just the money)
Others have stated the lack of suitable training posts at hospitals.
I hate the fact we rely on overseas doctors and nurses, but there are also many who train here and then go abroad.

Getoff · 22/11/2022 15:24

I have been very frustrated by our system. My understanding was that it was the lack of training places. Recently I have seen people blaming doctors leaving NHS. Perhaps if we deliberately aimed for an over-supply of doctors, and allowed many of them to work part-time they would find a work-life balance that suited them and stay. There would be extra cost from training a surplus, but not in actually employing them, assuming part-time pay is pro-rata.

I was encouraged to read recently that some British students are going abroad to study medicine, so the constraints that our our half-baked system impose on doctor supply are not an absolute blocker. I think people were going to Eastern Europe, or possibly one of the ex-Soviet republics, where apparently there are plenty of places in medical schools and local hospitals for trainee doctors. (I don't remember the details of how this was funded, presumably it is self-funded, but not expensive.)

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:54

It would be good to see a lot more transparency about this issue and a lot more facts and figures.

OP posts:
Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 14:53

It's expensive, takes a lot of time to train, increasingly media graduate go into the city, medics emigrate etc etc etc. A lot and I mean a lot of European countries import from elsewhere e.g. Switzerland from Germany, Germany from Romania - that pipeline for the UK ended with Brexit, a lot of European medics left and couldnt be bothered. The UK is now trying to import from elsewhere. If you are only looking at the individual country - the most efficient system is to import from abroad rather than train locally. It's cheaper and much more responsive to current needs. But for all of it, you need money - the British electorate dont want to spend that money.

Alexandra2001 · 22/11/2022 14:48

All anecdotal.. i accept but on my DD course AHP, half the students were overseas and had no intention of working in UK, her friend is on a nursing course... very similar.

I was treated at a dental school... many students also paid full fees and would leave uk once trained.

Does this happen with medical students too?

We have independent world leading uni system, anyone can come here and train, subject to the fees, as far as i know, places are not reserved for UK only students.

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:48

@AntlerRose that's an interesting idea.
I don't understand though why is there countries seem to have more capacity to provide clinical training than the UK has. Are they approaching the training differently and more efficiently?

OP posts:
AntlerRose · 22/11/2022 14:46

On another thread it was explained that basically the exusting doctors do the training - i know its through a university with lots of books learning, but much of it is on the ward. So you cant train more doctors than the existing level of doctors can train.

i actually thought that we should approach some other countries that did have more capacity to train and put some extra cohorts through - paying there fees etc, rather than poaching other countries trained doctors.

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:41

One third of UK doctors were recruited from overseas. I find that ridiculous.

OP posts:
Blip · 22/11/2022 14:40

I don't think the cost of training lots of new medical students is prohibitive at all. Just think of how much is paid out in benefits and lost in tax paid for all the people who cannot work due to lack of or delayed healthcare provision. There are hundreds of thousands of people in this category.

And if we trained lots of new doctors some would leave to work overseas yes. And that seems fair considering how many doctors we have recruited from overseas.

And with the ones who stay this will help workload for our existing doctors which is one reason why many leave or reduce their hours. It would get us back into a positive spiral instead of a negative one.

OP posts:
Didiplanthis · 22/11/2022 14:39

Blip · 22/11/2022 13:10

Seems like only 23% of doctors work 37.5 hours or more per week

If by that you mean full time...I work half time and do 34 hours/ week... my DH works full time and works 60 + hours/ week... both GPs

I am currently chucking it in after 20 years to work in a minimum wage job as I cannot get far enough away from it .. its utterly utterly shit....

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:31

Within the OECD countries the UK is firmly in the bottom half for doctors per capita.

OP posts: