Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 08:15

Regarding doctors' actual gross salaries, they are paid around 25% more than the salaries in the published pay scales due to additional pay for weekend work and nights. So the published salaries are only the basic salary, the junior doctors actually receive considerably more than this.

This website explains more:

www.juniordoctorfinance.co.uk/junior-doctor-salaries/

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:11

Lunar270

weve already been over this- the BMA is a union. They have no say on medical school places. Or anything else it seems, given we have had a 35% pay cut equivalent , and the pension situation forcing senior doctors out.

Dinoteeth · 23/11/2022 08:04

I think we probably need to tackle the issue from both ends, train more and stop doctors from leaving both to retire (ie fix the pension issues) and to stop them leaving for Australia/Canada ie make the pay and conditions better.

Across many sectors of the UK, the pay and conditions needs to improve. And we probably need to review students fees for those who become public sector employees.

Stompythedinosaur · 23/11/2022 07:59

I think this is a very naive viewpoint.

Medical training is not some box that you pop people in and they come out a doctor, it is something that the already overstretched doctors have to support despite their workloads, which are already difficult because of the shortage of doctors.

Also, a newly qualified doctor is not a replacement for an experienced doctor who has left because or poor pay or conditions.

It's pretty much the same as why we can't just "train more nurses".

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 07:52

randomsabreuse · 23/11/2022 07:37

It's the shortage of doctors that limits the training places. You can't just throw a fresh new grad into a&e without consultant/senior registrars being available to train them.

There weren't enough initial training places for a record number of graduating doctors this year - and probably most years since the new system began. Some get places found, others give up, move abroad or move away from support networks.

A bit chicken and egg but it's an engineered situation. I have very little sympathy for doctors given they've voted for this. All this talk and complaining about working 70 hours a week. You make your bed...... And then you have doctors leaving the UK because conditions are poor. Unbelievable.

I can't imagine any other profession where you can vote for your own interests. It's disgraceful. We'd all like to protect our interests but that's not generally how life works.

A pp posted the BMJ vote to restrict numbers 14 years ago. I've no idea how long that lasted (likely a few years at least) but given a degree takes 5 years and training the same again (at least), it's quite clear that this leaves a huge hole. The age and experience gap can be significant if allowed to continue and it would seem, like you say, that we now have insufficient numbers to actually train students.

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 07:50

Jtaeapa
we’ve already covered that the BMA is a union. It has no control over medical school places. Have a read of the earlier points made

fivemins

the part time GPS working 39 hours? And the full time ones working 60? Those who you call part - time are not part time in the known meaning of the word. I thought we covered this already, but maybe that was another thread.

a full time nhs nurse often works 3 x 12 hour shifts a week, or thereabouts. Do you also consider all those nurses to be part time, and should do 5x 12 hour shifts a week to be considered full time?

by national and government standards, I believe full time work is over 35 hours per week?

LakieLady · 23/11/2022 07:47

This is only half of the story. The UK electorate keeps voting for parties (note the plural) that do not prioritise healthcare funding to the same extent that many other countries do. The "They" in the statement is the people that the voters have elected - and if "they" don't do what is expected of them, then voters should vote for someone else.

So true, and it applies equally to almost every public service that people gripe about.

"Because people voted for it" is now my stock answer to every gripe about schools/police/NHS/DWP/libraries and every other damn service that has been starved of funding for years.

One of my Tory ILs was moaning about how they had to take the kids out of the local comp and pay thousands per term for them to attend an independent. They were sick of the school lacking staff, equipment, facilities etc. When I pointed out that they had voted for this, they claimed not to have voted for cuts in education.

They seemed to think voting was like a stroll down the pick'n'mix aisle, ffs.

randomsabreuse · 23/11/2022 07:37

It's the shortage of doctors that limits the training places. You can't just throw a fresh new grad into a&e without consultant/senior registrars being available to train them.

There weren't enough initial training places for a record number of graduating doctors this year - and probably most years since the new system began. Some get places found, others give up, move abroad or move away from support networks.

FiveMins · 23/11/2022 07:32

DH works in a large GP surgery (not as a doctor). Out of the 17 GPs only 2 work full time.

jtaeapa · 23/11/2022 07:26

wtf at the “lack of hospital places” for new/training doctors. We waited in hospital (not A&E) for 4 hours to see a doctor who had already worked a day and night without sleeping. It’s commonplace. There’s plenty of demand for doctors everywhere - at any level, training or not. I’ve no issue with the foreign doctors - in fact they need to be doubled. Build some more fucking hospitals whilst you’re at it. We are desperate. Patients are choosing to forego essential treatment because the waiting is an endurance test. My db had to piss in a bottle whilst immobile with others in the room in his latest endurance test in hospital. My dm had a mastectomy and had to spend the night on a trolley pushed around periodically as no bed available. Waiting lists are up to 2 years for some things. For a first world country, we are a disgrace.

BMA must be managed by people who don’t have to fight for medical care like the rest of us.

so what if we train a few doctors who can’t get jobs.

i know of 2 kids with 4 A stars at a level who couldn’t get a medical school place. Whilst we sit begging for a GP appointment.

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 07:12

Passportpondery

and also consider that the directors etc likely have not been through such a lengthy process to get to the higher end scale. The highest level is for a consultant who has worked as NhS consultant for 20 years. Given most only become a consultant after years of training in mid- late thirties, they are only paid that highest ( yet often quoted) higher end of the scale in their mid- late fifties. So they are not paid it for most of their careers, assuming retirement 10 years later. Currently such consultants are getting tax bills of enormous quantity of their yearly take home pay, so can’t stay on for those years anyway. They retire and are often then doing some scaled back private work, but it is not if their choosing. They would have happily continued in same NHS role if HMRC weren’t landing them with unaffordable tax bills ( based on theoretical rise in pension value, not actual value)

Blip · 23/11/2022 07:06

It's my understanding that the published figures for doctors salaries are not what doctors are actually paid given that they are paid extra for antisocial hours which the lower grades work - the pay given is the basic pay without these extra allowances.

Can any doctors confirm this?

OP posts:
Passportpondery · 23/11/2022 05:21

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:02

Here it is from the NHS website, with the exact same figures:

www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/explore-roles/doctors/pay-doctors/pay-doctors

Feel free to verify it with your local hospital. It's a national contract, with no room for variation. This is exactly what junior doctors are paid.

I didn’t realise the pay was so low, it surprised me! For a teacher the starting salary is similar but the training is less and the responsibility a lot less! Obviously doesn’t have quite the same progression though.

As a director in an NHS trust you would earn in-line with a specialist doctor. Most trusts have around 4 directors all earning similar, plus a chief exec I assume earning more. There is money in the NHS, it’s just not on the front line.

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 05:06

Orangepolentacake

yes I thought Boonawoona22 ‘s comment on doctors earring ‘mega bucks’ in the nhs was hilarious too, then I thought must just be a wind up. I think most people are surprised as junior doctors ‘s salaries and how low they are ( even judging by a recent thread on that). Consultants have had the equivalent of a 35% pay since this government came in.

The question is, how healthy are these people, who are happy to see doctors leave the NHS. Why would anyone go through the extensive postgraduate training to become a consultant now when it has been so eroded? I know I wouldn’t if I had my time again.

as for the BMA as avery powerful and terrifying union, that gave me my laugh of the night. While the BMA are great when you need support and advice when the trust is trying to break the terms of your contract, if they were terrifying and powerful, why on earth have we had that 35% pay erosion/ cut, and why have we not balloted for strike on the pensions mess that’s causing many senior consultants to leave NHS to avoid a huge tax bill that takes months of their annual take home pay.

lifeinthehills · 23/11/2022 01:13

I'd love to train as a GP and I know I'd be good at it. It will never happen though due to cost of training and length of training. It's just not a commitment I can make at this time and probably never will be able to.

Areyouactuallyserious · 23/11/2022 00:37

I’ve often wondered why we don’t require newly qualified doctors to commit to x number of years within the NHS as a pre requisite of their training place, in order to get more of a ‘return on investment’ after which doctors are free to work in any place/way they please.

Orangepolentacake · 23/11/2022 00:06

Boonawoona22 · 22/11/2022 16:20

@Blip @ChiefPearlClutcher

Yes, I totally believe this. Doctors are earning megabucks through the NHS due to being in high demand. Those same doctors are taking on private work on the side. They don’t want more doctors. The BMA holds a lot of power and I don’t think change will be coming anytime soon.

There should me more university places, and subsequently more doctors. Also, I don’t agree an NHS doctor should be able to do private work. There seems to be a conflict of interest here, ie; longer NHS waiting list are, the more people go private… more money in their pocket.

doctors are earning mega bucks in the NHS?

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Lapland123 · 22/11/2022 23:44

Just seem a few comments on BMA. The BMA have absolutely no power in restricting medical student places. Nor are any doctors wanting to restrict places for spurious reasons such as keeping demand for their skills high.

the training needs and various bottlenecks have been described well above. So hopefully OP you are now clear on the problem. It’s what to do about a solution ….

resistingreality · 22/11/2022 22:24

I’m a sociologist who studies these things. There’s something called the ‘professional project’ where professionals restrict access to generate an artificial scarcity which raises the values of their skills. Lawyers and doctors have been especially good at this historically - lawyers struggled as higher Ed expanded but they found other ways to restrict entry other than credentials. The BMA is implicated in this in medicine. (It is also true that there are more lawyers doing degrees than training places).

HowcanIhelp123 · 22/11/2022 22:18

I have a niece that did medicine. There was a significant number of medical students in her year that passed their degree but there were no places for them to do their foundation training. So you lose those ... then the ones that get the places get overworked and burnt out and leave ... so you lose them. Its a long long training period to get fully qualified doctors and the NHS does not have the capacity to train enough or the retain the ones that get through.

AsdaYellowTins · 22/11/2022 22:12

Places at medical school are capped by the govt at 7,500 per year. This may include vets as well, not sure. There are plenty of A* students that want to study medicine but the acceptance rate is something like 7%. Add to this difficulty in getting a place, a medical degree is incredibly hard, much longer hours studying than other degrees, 5 or 6 years plus then the junior doctor years. They come out of this to horrific working conditions, not great pay and £100k student debt. I am working 7 days a week to get the money together for DD who is applying for medicine. There is no way she could pursue that option if I dont fund her. I wont be able to retire until she is through to the other side. I figure it is going to be stressful enough for her without having to get a job on the side. When we went to open days I really did get the feeling that most of the families there were pretty rich. Easier to get the high grades etc if you go to private school and have tutors, and doing a long degree is easier if mummy and daddy can pay for everything. BTW the last year of the degree, they dont get a normal student loan, they get an NHS bursary of about £2000 for the year - that has to do them for food/rent etc, regardless of the students income. It is going to be a push to cover the costs etc, even with her getting the max student loan, if she does get a place.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 22/11/2022 21:02

What we need is a root and branch reform of the NHS to look at what we can and can't fund from taxes. The work the NHS did nearly 80 years ago when it was founded has changed out of all recognition. Do we need the same professions as we did then? Why do we have to pay through the nose for dental care and not for other medical care when lack of treatment for dental issues can be really serious? (Just as one example.)

Governments are abysmally bad at long-term planning and we all pay the price. Nobody has grasped the nettle of how to fund social care for the elderly and people with disabilities and chronic health issues. It's long overdue that the political parties put their differences aside and set up a Royal Commission or similar, but not one that takes a decade to hear all the evidence and another few years writing up. We need some rapid action on this.

One thing nobody has really got to grips with is the effect of medicine moving from being an almost all male profession to being about 50 50 male female. Inevitably most of the female doctors take time out for maternity leave and don't want to work 70+ hours a week when their children are young. Increasingly male doctors don't want to live like that either, especially as they are now very unlikely to have a wife at home holding everything together, answering the phone to patients and putting her own career on hold or more likely abandoning it altogether, as was often the case 50 years ago.

We need to find a way for doctors to get the experience and training they need without destroying their physical and mental health in the process.

Ineedacoffee · 22/11/2022 20:57

As many others have pointed out it is retention that is the problem. At the senior end stupid tax and pension rules mean the most senior Dr's have to effectively pay to work extra. So they don't work extra. Or they retire because the stress is ridiculous.
In the middle- consultant's and GPs in their late 30s/40s the stress of working in a completely broken system, juggling childcare with very long shifts, getting treated for ptsd following covid, getting abused by patients. The knowledge that they would be paid a lot more for less hours and less demanding pts if they moved abroad.
The junior doctors being forced to move hospital every 6 months, often having fixed annual leave do missing weddings, birthdays etc. Not getting your new rota until 2 weeks before your 6 month placement starts (imagine trying to plan you childcare). Having nowhere to rest on a nightshift. Having your colleague die driving a ridiculous distance after a set of nights because they were too tired and had been sent far from home. Again knowing you would get paid a lot more for a lot less abroad.
We are hemorrhaging staff at every level. You have to make the working conditions better otherwise there is no point training anyone.

Mango101 · 22/11/2022 20:40

It's kind of cheaper to avoid doctors retiring in their 50s. Sort pension tax Mr Sunak!

LeroyJenkinssss · 22/11/2022 20:26

the Department I work in has just accepted medical students for training. The load on us is huge (and which we are deeply unhappy about). Even having a student in the room slows things down and when clinics are overbooked that is a big impact.

also just having more doctors doesn’t help. Our clinic is fully booked - there’s no space to see more people. Same with theatres - you can have all the surgeons you like but you need the ODPs, scrub staff, recovery, HSDU, porters never mind the beds to put people in.

out of my department, one consultant has dropped his hours to protect his mental health and another has done a retire and return on less hours. Everyone else is either 40 hrs or more. Part of the problem at junior level is the working time directive - they have to have multiple zero hour days which scuppers medical training, continuity and staffing levels.