Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:48

Areyouactuallyserious · 23/11/2022 00:37

I’ve often wondered why we don’t require newly qualified doctors to commit to x number of years within the NHS as a pre requisite of their training place, in order to get more of a ‘return on investment’ after which doctors are free to work in any place/way they please.

Good luck with recruitment.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 08:47

I think what most posters are missing is the Govt doesn't want more Doctors or for that matter more nurses.

This nonsense about the BMA ? this is the Govt that faced down junior doctors, will face down the RCN, has never given into a union.

The Tories want a poor service, more go private, less money spent on the NHS, so look at the way below inflation increases for the NHS & nothing on social care, introduced tuition fees for nurses and other AHPs, froze pay for years during austerity & most importantly have had 12.5 years to sort out staffing in the health service.

The public don't care either, so good luck coming up with solutions for the shortages of Doc's and 7m waiting for treatment.

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:47

Just to add as consultant on 1:10 out of hours rota I was paid 1% extra of annual salary, so that’s £1000 per year before tax, so £600 per year after tax.
For 1:10 rota which was quiet - that’s why it was paid 1%- but nonetheless disruptive and limiting to your life and plans.

thats £50 per month after tax, for 3 nights or weekend days each month.
That’s £16.50 for a Saturday on call? 24 hours available by telephone
yes I am worth significantly more than that. Everyone is worth significantly more than that.

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:44

Blip · 23/11/2022 08:25

Maybe doctors are paid too little, maybe too much, that's another discussion, I just think we need to be open and honest about what they actually earn.

No newly qualified doctor actually earns the salary on the published salary scales.

It is transparent- it’s all available for anyone to look up.
The out of hours supplements they earn for doing approx extra 50% work I’m addition to their 40h FT week and these extra hours are done overnight and weekends.
Of course they should be paid more for this!

FluffyPancake · 23/11/2022 08:44

Funding is the biggest one.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/11/2022 08:43

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 08:28

Perhaps because we don’t insist those with ancient history degrees to work as museum curators or those with engineering degrees to serve in the Navy? You can’t single out one profession for return of service unless there was an option to give a bursary and pay off tuition fees.

All doctors qualifying in U.K. already give return of service as part of their training pathway.

Two years horrendous rotas, very limited choice of where they live in the country, frequently moved, as Foundation Programme doctors, paid at an hourly rate that often ends up being less than minimum wage. That’s not optional.

A couple of years doing core medicine or core surgery. Again, little choice of where they go, horrendous rota, nights, days, not in their own area of interest etc. Has to be done before they can move to speciality training. The alternative is a three year GP pathway with eighteen months treading the wards around the clock.

Minimum five years ‘pay back’. More usually at least seven.

Any professional whose job involves life long learning and who aspires to move up the ladder will do long hours beyond those contracted. This is not unique to medicine. The return for most is a interesting career path leading to higher earnings and depending on the path - a degree of social status such as in medicine. You don't have to look far to find grads on elite graduate programmes turning in hours which translate the salaries to minimum wage.

The actual cost of training doctors is substantially higher than most other professions where the post graduate or post doctoral costs are born by the company/individual.

I'm not generally a fan of indenturing or requirement for X FTE years "pay back" but to minimise the investment of the state in medical training for doctors is to downplay that investment quite significantly.

jtaeapa · 23/11/2022 08:42

Stompythedinosaur · 23/11/2022 07:59

I think this is a very naive viewpoint.

Medical training is not some box that you pop people in and they come out a doctor, it is something that the already overstretched doctors have to support despite their workloads, which are already difficult because of the shortage of doctors.

Also, a newly qualified doctor is not a replacement for an experienced doctor who has left because or poor pay or conditions.

It's pretty much the same as why we can't just "train more nurses".

Then we need to buy some experienced ones in from other countries. We need more hospitals, doctors and nurses. People aren’t getting treated and it’s causing lifelong consequences and further cost for the NHS.

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:40

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 08:34

Yes and no. A great many responsible jobs in industry require a certain amount of effort. I've been places where 10% is expected. But a continuous 20% is unreasonable and should be compensated accordingly.

But this is where trusts etc are a bit short sighted IMO (dare I say a bit thick). If you have three or four doctors doing 20 hours a week extra, long term. That is about the tipping point and justification for taking on another doctor surely.

Quality suffers past about 50 hours/week so should be obvious and whilst doctors may feel they're letting the public down by not working more, are probably doing the opposite by perpetually working 60+ hours.

This show a lack of understanding, which I understand if you are not working in the system or know someone who is.
You need doctors to do night and weekend shifts.
If a standard full time week is 40h week includes the out of hours work then the doctor will be doing fewer day-time hours. This equates to less training time and, so they won’t be able to meet their competencies and reach consultant level for a very long time.

sashh · 23/11/2022 08:35

verytired42 · 22/11/2022 12:01

Also - Notoriously difficult to plan medical workforce because of 1.) how long it takes and 2.) changes in medical technology and it’s impact on need. Classic example is the advent of interventional cardiology - putting in stents instead of open heart surgery - to a large extent killed off the need for cardiothoracic surgeons and increased need for cardiologists. AI may have similar impact on diagnostic specialties.

If you are putting in stents you need a theatre and personnel on call.

You still need surgeons to perform bypasses.

You also need them to do things like transplants which are much more common.

Yes stents are more successful than angioplasty alone but there are cases where you can't use them.

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 08:35

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 08:30

Just to be clear. The BMJ doesn’t vote. It’s a magazine.

Yes apologies, but am sure you know what I was referring to back on page one.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/11/2022 08:34

Mango101 · 22/11/2022 20:40

It's kind of cheaper to avoid doctors retiring in their 50s. Sort pension tax Mr Sunak!

You mean give doctors additional tax perks over and above those they already enjoy as higher tax payers in pensions?

The fact that doctors hit the max tax free limit in their pension schemes relatively early is a reflection of the generosity of the scheme and the high levels of pay.

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 08:34

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:20

Yes the junior doctors are paid a proportion more for doing a huge proportion more in addition to full time work.

if you took on an additional 20 hours work on top of your full time job, unsocial hours - would you want to be paid more?

Yes and no. A great many responsible jobs in industry require a certain amount of effort. I've been places where 10% is expected. But a continuous 20% is unreasonable and should be compensated accordingly.

But this is where trusts etc are a bit short sighted IMO (dare I say a bit thick). If you have three or four doctors doing 20 hours a week extra, long term. That is about the tipping point and justification for taking on another doctor surely.

Quality suffers past about 50 hours/week so should be obvious and whilst doctors may feel they're letting the public down by not working more, are probably doing the opposite by perpetually working 60+ hours.

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 08:31

Boonawoona22 · 22/11/2022 16:20

@Blip @ChiefPearlClutcher

Yes, I totally believe this. Doctors are earning megabucks through the NHS due to being in high demand. Those same doctors are taking on private work on the side. They don’t want more doctors. The BMA holds a lot of power and I don’t think change will be coming anytime soon.

There should me more university places, and subsequently more doctors. Also, I don’t agree an NHS doctor should be able to do private work. There seems to be a conflict of interest here, ie; longer NHS waiting list are, the more people go private… more money in their pocket.

This is such misinformed cobblers.

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 08:30

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 07:52

A bit chicken and egg but it's an engineered situation. I have very little sympathy for doctors given they've voted for this. All this talk and complaining about working 70 hours a week. You make your bed...... And then you have doctors leaving the UK because conditions are poor. Unbelievable.

I can't imagine any other profession where you can vote for your own interests. It's disgraceful. We'd all like to protect our interests but that's not generally how life works.

A pp posted the BMJ vote to restrict numbers 14 years ago. I've no idea how long that lasted (likely a few years at least) but given a degree takes 5 years and training the same again (at least), it's quite clear that this leaves a huge hole. The age and experience gap can be significant if allowed to continue and it would seem, like you say, that we now have insufficient numbers to actually train students.

Just to be clear. The BMJ doesn’t vote. It’s a magazine.

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:29

Blip · 23/11/2022 07:06

It's my understanding that the published figures for doctors salaries are not what doctors are actually paid given that they are paid extra for antisocial hours which the lower grades work - the pay given is the basic pay without these extra allowances.

Can any doctors confirm this?

At consultant level it’s up to 8% extra so on the very top scale it’s approx £10k year on top but that’s after 20y at consultant level and for the most demanding out of hours commitment.
Junior doctors have a greater percentage supplement, again, depending on how frequent and unsociable the hours are.

The “extra” pay is for hours worked above your contacted 40h (full time) or part time hours.

However, it doesn’t make sense to compare salaries this way. Need to look at what pay is for a standard 40h week across comparable professional for the training and the level of training and responsibility required.
Also at pay progression and the timescale.
Post graduate qualifications.
Need for out of hours commitment etc

Notonthestairs · 23/11/2022 08:28

A proposed amendment to the Health and Care Bill – which would have made it compulsory for the Government to publish regular, independent assessments of how many doctors and nurses the NHS needs – has been defeated.

The amendment would have helped inform long-term decisions about workforce planning in the NHS – something that has been missing for many years.
We are disappointed that Government has removed this amendment, and it is now unclear how ambitious targets laid out in the Elective Recovery Plan and other NHS delivery plans can be met. 

Without a long-term workforce plan, heart patients will likely experience further delays, further cancellations and poorer outcomes.

www.bhf.org.uk/what-we-do/news-from-the-bhf/news-archive/2022/march/government-rejects-health-bill-workforce-amendment

Jeremy Hunt, chair of the Health and Social Care Committee, said the government has missed an opportunity to address the “cycle of crises”.
He said: “It is disappointing the government has again rejected our call for transparent and independent projections of the number of doctors and nurses we need to meet future demand.
“Unless we have future-proof workforce planning, it will not be possible to address the NHS backlog and the cycle of crises putting dangerous pressure on staff will continue.
“We hope the government will be persuaded by the case for independent workforce planning as the health and care bill progresses through parliament. Without it, we see little hope that the workforce crisis will be alleviated.”
Last week, NHS Providers chief executive Chris Hopson told Sky News he was “incredibly frustrated” that health secretary Sajid Javid had refused to support a long-term workforce plan for NHS staff,

www.civilserviceworld.com/professions/article/government-rejects-mps-plea-to-overhaul-nhs-workforce-planning-despite-crisis-warning

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 08:28

Areyouactuallyserious · 23/11/2022 00:37

I’ve often wondered why we don’t require newly qualified doctors to commit to x number of years within the NHS as a pre requisite of their training place, in order to get more of a ‘return on investment’ after which doctors are free to work in any place/way they please.

Perhaps because we don’t insist those with ancient history degrees to work as museum curators or those with engineering degrees to serve in the Navy? You can’t single out one profession for return of service unless there was an option to give a bursary and pay off tuition fees.

All doctors qualifying in U.K. already give return of service as part of their training pathway.

Two years horrendous rotas, very limited choice of where they live in the country, frequently moved, as Foundation Programme doctors, paid at an hourly rate that often ends up being less than minimum wage. That’s not optional.

A couple of years doing core medicine or core surgery. Again, little choice of where they go, horrendous rota, nights, days, not in their own area of interest etc. Has to be done before they can move to speciality training. The alternative is a three year GP pathway with eighteen months treading the wards around the clock.

Minimum five years ‘pay back’. More usually at least seven.

hettie · 23/11/2022 08:27

The training is archaic and in many trusts/specialties the culture is piss poor. Far too many consultants treat juniors and other staff poorly. They use concerns about standards and safety to resist any changes in practice or models of training. There is a bit of "well we had to go through it/suck it up". Honestly changing anything is a bloody nightmare, takes ages, faces rigidity and inflexible thinking. There are a fair few consultants who desperately want to do things differently but it is difficult to take the more reactionary ones along with them.... The rigid ones then just complain about how about it all is. I think the selection process historically favoured slightly perfectionist over thinkers tbh and it's reflected in the culture of our consultant body... So suggesting we changed training pathways to allow for us to train more medics is never going to happen...(or at least not in my career, it'll be a generational shift)

Pinkcadillac · 23/11/2022 08:26

Blip · 22/11/2022 14:21

Presumably other countries also need clinical placements for their trainee doctors so how come they can provide enough of these but the UK cannot?

Spain has the exact same problem

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 08:25

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:11

Lunar270

weve already been over this- the BMA is a union. They have no say on medical school places. Or anything else it seems, given we have had a 35% pay cut equivalent , and the pension situation forcing senior doctors out.

So doctors vote for no reason at all? What's the point in being involved in something that has no say or power to do anything? Sounds a bit odd.

Recently hundreds of medical students missed out because there were no placements to accommodate them. Someone is engineering the situation and I guess the government is to blame? Or perhaps the trust's themselves.

Most of the country has had an 'equivalent' pay cut unfortunately and private sector pension are shocking by comparison, but we're not all fleeing the country or being forced out.

Blip · 23/11/2022 08:25

Maybe doctors are paid too little, maybe too much, that's another discussion, I just think we need to be open and honest about what they actually earn.

No newly qualified doctor actually earns the salary on the published salary scales.

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 08:22

@Lapland123 of course antisocial hours should be remunerated.
I just think that when most people see doctors salary scales they assume that is what the doctors are paid but this is not the case.

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 08:20

If the bottleneck is providing enough clinical training in hospitals perhaps we need to reconsider how this is provided using technology so that we can train more people.

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:20

Yes the junior doctors are paid a proportion more for doing a huge proportion more in addition to full time work.

if you took on an additional 20 hours work on top of your full time job, unsocial hours - would you want to be paid more?

LaGioconda · 23/11/2022 08:16

There's a quicker fix through retention. DNiece is two years out of medical school and says that a number of her friends are already disenchanted and talking about leaving medicine, leaving the UK, or going into side specialisms that offer less pressures and reasonable working hours. It's a horrendous waste if he don't improve working.conditions so as to retain the people we train.