Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 10:06

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 09:42

@Blip No because that extra money is earned by working extra hours, shifts, on-call and always feeling tired.. & less time with family friends etc i.e life.

Few non medical professions require shift work over nights and bank holidays, certainly accountancy doesn't!

Well, trainee accountants usually have to study in their own time outside full time working hours unpaid. When I was studying for 4 years to get my chartered accountancy qualification, I'd typically work an average 15-20 hours per week studying, (more as exam season approached), in evenings and weekends. Certainly in my year of studying/taking the final exams, I had virtually no "life" outside work! Basically, the working day was for work, and evenings/weekends were for study. We also got very little "support" from our employers, i.e. they'd pay for study manuals and exam fees, and time off for exams, but we had to use our holiday entitlement if we wanted a couple of weeks off pre exams for revision or to attend residential revision schools, etc.

It's pretty basic expectation of anyone who had to do studying/exams for a profession.

As for out of hours working, yes, we did that too. Unpaid, but we got time off in lieu/flexitime. Weekend/evening working was required at busy times of the year, i.e. the few weeks ahead of tax return filing deadlines, year end stocktake attendance (31 Dec and 31 Mar). Also attending client board meetings and AGMs which were usually evenings, or sometimes daytime weekend. Obviously, none of that is a matter of life or death, but accountancy certainly isn't always a 9-5 M-F job with no working requirement out of hours.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 10:03

@Blip

I just think that the only salary figure relevant is that which the employee is contracted to do, OT and shifts are not guaranteed and depending on the setting, may not be available to the same extent - i.e. a Doc based in a major teaching hospital will be working more than a Doc in a stroke rehab unit in Plymouth.

Its also a red herring, as i said earlier, the Govt has the means and ways to increase medical training places, they have consistently failed to do so, which to me shows they have no desire to do so.

The real question is why?

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 09:54

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 09:06

Is there a published list of salaries for accountants? Are these negotiable? How many hours extra are they expected to work as standard? No it’s not transparent

You do realise that a lot of patient-facing staff work many hours per week unpaid on top of their contracted FT and out-of-hours commitment?

No, because accountancy is an open/free market. Small firms tend to pay minimum wage or just above for their trainees. Top 10 firms pay a lot more, maybe £25k or so for trainees. Then wages rise as the trainees gain experience and qualifications. Specialisms tend to pay more, i.e. mergers/acquisitions, insolvency, tax specialisms etc. But it's all down to what the clients will pay. Businesses pay more for a Top 10 firm or a specialist than they'll pay a small town general practice. Newly qualified accountants can be on as little as £30/£40k, even experienced qualified accountants can be on as little as £40-£50k in smaller firms in the regions. Plenty of job advertisements on recruitment/job websites if you want to look at open market rates for different levels of skills/experience, etc. It's impossible for all accountants to reach the heights of being a partner in Top 10 firms earning half a million - probably only a fraction of a percentage of qualified accountants earn anywhere near that.

Blip · 23/11/2022 09:51

@walkingonsunshinekat perhaps you are misunderstanding me here.
I do not think it is wrong for doctors to be paid extra for antisocial hours or extra hours worked.

I think it is wrong that when the public is considering doctors pay they are considering the wrong figures.
What would be wrong with publishing the figure for an F1 as I suggested?

ie base salary for an F1 doctor is £28k, with additional pay of on average £7k depending on actual rotas worked.

OP posts:
walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 09:42

@Blip No because that extra money is earned by working extra hours, shifts, on-call and always feeling tired.. & less time with family friends etc i.e life.

Few non medical professions require shift work over nights and bank holidays, certainly accountancy doesn't!

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 09:35

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 09:15

It’s not about working 60hours - a lot of training happens during the normal working hours - clinics, elective surgery, endoscopy, MDMs etc.
If they do a standar 40h/wk then who will be covering the night shifts and weekends?

We come back to having more doctors so each does fewer out of hours shifts. Will salaries drop as a result? Probably.
Will people still be interested in doing medicine if salaries fall even though the work is becoming much more complex and litigious? Add to that the suggestion of a 5-year commitment to working in the NHS? Probably not.

I'm saying 60 hours as an example, because it's mentioned often. Naturally it's about doing over 40 because you're talking about covering out of hours etc. For arguments sake let's just call it anything above 40.

Doing a standard 40 hours is what's best for everyone. The employee, the organisation and the recipient of care. The EU directives for hours isn't just something plucked from thin air.

As I mentioned in another pp. Once you have x doctors working well over 40 hours, repeatedly, it's important that more staff are recruited to maintain an average of 40h by all staff.

I think you're lacking in imagination if you honestly can't work out how people can cover nights/weekends on 40h and still gain experience during critical times.

Salaries are already set for a 40h week so they're not going to drop. You're just getting someone else to do the extra 20h being done by x number of existing staff. Obviously there's pensions etc but is why I said you'd need 3-4 existing staff doing 20h to justify another doctor.

Are new doctors going to be discouraged? What, by working 40h like most people? If so it says more about them than a revised system that would be better for their (and everyone's) wellbeing.

Blip · 23/11/2022 09:30

@walkingonsunshinekat no, it's quite wrong to compare "base salaries" when ALL junior doctors work significant levels of antisocial hours and on calls and extra hours too and most work similar amounts of these with a few outliers.

Unless you always say the base salary for an F1 doctor is £28k, with additional pay of on average £7k depending on actual rotas worked.

OP posts:
walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 09:23

@Blip When comparing salaries, we should only look at base salary.
Shift allowances and OT are never guaranteed and aren't inc in employer/employee pension contributions.

I also doubt very much that Doc's dont work a lot of unpaid hours as well.

But as with Nurses, healthcare professionals are voting with their feet and leaving the NHS, often to go abroad, so whatever we all might think on salary etc, they prefer to work elsewhere.

My ex used to get David Lloyd membership, BUPA and a very nice car, he wasn't a partner either.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/11/2022 09:21

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:53

Surely the state must invest - the stakes are high!
The investment is not for the benefit of the doctors - we will train you but for that you owe us 5 years of your life - it is for society.

Social status?! It’s not the 1950s anymore

Of course doctors benefit from social status, however unhappy people may be with the state of healthcare in any one time. Overall its profession with high social status.

One of the changes over the decades in medicine is the extent to which it has become an A* applicant profession rather than one which would accept a slip in grades for someone who can demonstrate other skills or capabilities commensurate with making a good doctor. An acquaintance who used to teach at one of the London med schools found it an increasing struggle as students coming in with great A level grades had less interest in any form of public medicine - they were there to build a career which would enable them to work in private medicine.

Other countries where more of the costs are borne by the student have no lack of applicants to courses. I wouldn't actually like to see this in the UK but lets not pretend there isn't a big investment by the state into medical training.

Blip · 23/11/2022 09:18

@walkingonsunshinekat it's worth saying that although I don't have an opinion on whether pay is right for junior doctors I do think they are working too many hours.

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 09:16

@walkingonsunshinekat we will have to differ on our opinions. Many of my friends and family are accountants and don't get paid extra for extra hours or weekend working.

Bonuses do of course exist but most do not get these especially ones at the start of their careers which is what I am talking about.

It's not just accountants either. Most professional people I know work additional unpaid hours every week, I think this is widely known and accepted.

I don't have a point of view about doctors salaries I just think they should be discussed openly and honestly and I don't feel that this is the current situation. You seem touchy about this information becoming public but smoke and mirrors isn't a good way to address the problems of the healthcare service.

OP posts:
Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 09:15

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 08:58

No, I know doctors, nurses and physios that work for the NHS.

It's an excuse to say that anyone needs to work 60+ hours in order to achieve certain competences. It's not 'a very long time' but obviously just a proportion of the differential. It's not beyond the wit of humans to come up with a working schedule that achieves the goals required.

Anyone in any industry will gain experience faster if they work more hours. But flogging people to death and seeing them leave out of exhaustion etc. shows a distinct lack of comprehension of anything at all.

Ultimately what does it really matter if a doctor takes 40/60 less time? If the entire industry made a shift then what does it matter in the long term? Eventually we'd have the same thing but with staff that weren't broken in the process. Complete short termism.

It’s not about working 60hours - a lot of training happens during the normal working hours - clinics, elective surgery, endoscopy, MDMs etc.
If they do a standar 40h/wk then who will be covering the night shifts and weekends?

We come back to having more doctors so each does fewer out of hours shifts. Will salaries drop as a result? Probably.
Will people still be interested in doing medicine if salaries fall even though the work is becoming much more complex and litigious? Add to that the suggestion of a 5-year commitment to working in the NHS? Probably not.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/11/2022 09:14

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:53

C8H10N4O2

You are misinformed about the pension situation. The problem is getting a HMRC bill for 6 months of your take home pay due to theoretical rise on your pension - not actual rise. It is confounded by how it is calculated. It was fixed for judges. But think government would like NHS collapse so presume that’s why they don’t fix for senior doctors.
No I can’t afford to pay this so had to step away from NHS though would never have done so otherwise.
no doctors won’t pay to go to work, no one would.

No I understand how tax and pensions work - the sheer size of the pot in public sector pensions is huge because its final salary/career average based. That is what attracts the tax bill. The same tax implications fall on anyone who builds up a pension pot substantially above the tax limits, whatever their profession.

Rocksludge · 23/11/2022 09:11

But the topic raised by the OP is exactly the same issue we have in my field "why don't we train more developers/software engineers". There's a certain supply from Uni's now, but just not at the volume and quality level required. The companies I've worked for also end up hiring a lot from abroad, to fill the gap. We're competing for those foreign workers against the US, Canada and EU countries.

It’s definitely a big issue. Both volume and quality.

In fact, in my (somewhat related) field there’s a big quality issue even in people with a few years of experience after university. It’s a real struggle to find people who can actually think things through, adapt and problem solve rather than just following process and spitting out mediocre (or worse) outputs. At all levels really.

The result is that the UK public sector spends ludicrous amounts on consultancy, where they get lots of mediocre (or worse) outcomes because they cannot recruit or retain skilled people. And the commissioning model means that it’s almost impossible to get better than mediocre outcomes from the work they outsource.

It doesn’t make the papers like NHS problems do. But it’s a pretty widespread issue.

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 09:06

Blip · 23/11/2022 08:53

Try to compare salary for doctors just out of med school and accountants in their first job post degree though - accountants will be working extra hours and some evenings and weekends for no extra pay, so the advertised salary is what you get.

If I were an accountant looking at the published salaries for new doctors I'd assume that's what they get.

I'm making no judgement on what doctors salaries should be what I am saying is that it's really not transparent and it should be.

Is there a published list of salaries for accountants? Are these negotiable? How many hours extra are they expected to work as standard? No it’s not transparent

You do realise that a lot of patient-facing staff work many hours per week unpaid on top of their contracted FT and out-of-hours commitment?

Blip · 23/11/2022 09:04

I agree with Lunar270 that junior doctors should not have to work 60 hour weeks to achieve their competencies. We either find a way to train them more effectively or the training needs to take longer.

I don't think working over 60 hours is good for doctors - or patients - and I think it's wrong to create a system where this is required. Having doctors on duty who are over tired from over work is detrimental to the quality of their work and to their own health/quality of life. As a practice it also excludes many people from being doctors.

OP posts:
RaRaRaspoutine · 23/11/2022 09:00

Purely from an academic point of view, a lot of med candidates drop out during the course - the first dissection class is too much them and they realise the reality is much tougher than they believed, or they discover that they're squeamish, etc.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 08:58

Blip · 23/11/2022 08:53

Try to compare salary for doctors just out of med school and accountants in their first job post degree though - accountants will be working extra hours and some evenings and weekends for no extra pay, so the advertised salary is what you get.

If I were an accountant looking at the published salaries for new doctors I'd assume that's what they get.

I'm making no judgement on what doctors salaries should be what I am saying is that it's really not transparent and it should be.

I think you very much are with your constant references to salary.

I was married to an accountant, they most definitely get paid extra for extra work, often in the form of bonuses, they also don't perform live saving surgeries and treatments.

Lunar270 · 23/11/2022 08:58

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:40

This show a lack of understanding, which I understand if you are not working in the system or know someone who is.
You need doctors to do night and weekend shifts.
If a standard full time week is 40h week includes the out of hours work then the doctor will be doing fewer day-time hours. This equates to less training time and, so they won’t be able to meet their competencies and reach consultant level for a very long time.

No, I know doctors, nurses and physios that work for the NHS.

It's an excuse to say that anyone needs to work 60+ hours in order to achieve certain competences. It's not 'a very long time' but obviously just a proportion of the differential. It's not beyond the wit of humans to come up with a working schedule that achieves the goals required.

Anyone in any industry will gain experience faster if they work more hours. But flogging people to death and seeing them leave out of exhaustion etc. shows a distinct lack of comprehension of anything at all.

Ultimately what does it really matter if a doctor takes 40/60 less time? If the entire industry made a shift then what does it matter in the long term? Eventually we'd have the same thing but with staff that weren't broken in the process. Complete short termism.

DonnaHadDee · 23/11/2022 08:57

I'm not a medical doctor (but a Comp Sc Phd) and have no knowledge of how our NHS works. But the topic raised by the OP is exactly the same issue we have in my field "why don't we train more developers/software engineers". There's a certain supply from Uni's now, but just not at the volume and quality level required. The companies I've worked for also end up hiring a lot from abroad, to fill the gap. We're competing for those foreign workers against the US, Canada and EU countries.

There are probably a whole range of disciplines where there are more jobs available than trained people, medical field just being one. Conceptually the need for "levelling up" in the science areas is something we need to do. There seems to be a huge gap between having that as a goal, and actually executing it in the real world.

Blip · 23/11/2022 08:55

@Coffeewinecake are you suggesting that social status no longer exists?

OP posts:
Rocksludge · 23/11/2022 08:54

Alongside all the other issues mentioned, it’s also not a quick fix. First year medical student to competent doctor able to function effectively without significant supervision and support is a long road.

Especially if an increase in student numbers also requires a significant increase in training capacity and infrastructure - both in hospitals and in universities. Medical training doesn’t scale up and down quickly or easily to respond to demand (it cannot be a ‘just in time’ type of system!).

it’s a much, much longer road than can be achieved within any electoral cycle. That makes it spending where the results cannot possibly be realised within the timescale a political party requires to show the brilliant improvements they’ve made to the NHS for the money spent.

Blip · 23/11/2022 08:53

Try to compare salary for doctors just out of med school and accountants in their first job post degree though - accountants will be working extra hours and some evenings and weekends for no extra pay, so the advertised salary is what you get.

If I were an accountant looking at the published salaries for new doctors I'd assume that's what they get.

I'm making no judgement on what doctors salaries should be what I am saying is that it's really not transparent and it should be.

OP posts:
Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 08:53

C8H10N4O2 · 23/11/2022 08:43

Any professional whose job involves life long learning and who aspires to move up the ladder will do long hours beyond those contracted. This is not unique to medicine. The return for most is a interesting career path leading to higher earnings and depending on the path - a degree of social status such as in medicine. You don't have to look far to find grads on elite graduate programmes turning in hours which translate the salaries to minimum wage.

The actual cost of training doctors is substantially higher than most other professions where the post graduate or post doctoral costs are born by the company/individual.

I'm not generally a fan of indenturing or requirement for X FTE years "pay back" but to minimise the investment of the state in medical training for doctors is to downplay that investment quite significantly.

Surely the state must invest - the stakes are high!
The investment is not for the benefit of the doctors - we will train you but for that you owe us 5 years of your life - it is for society.

Social status?! It’s not the 1950s anymore

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 08:53

C8H10N4O2

You are misinformed about the pension situation. The problem is getting a HMRC bill for 6 months of your take home pay due to theoretical rise on your pension - not actual rise. It is confounded by how it is calculated. It was fixed for judges. But think government would like NHS collapse so presume that’s why they don’t fix for senior doctors.
No I can’t afford to pay this so had to step away from NHS though would never have done so otherwise.
no doctors won’t pay to go to work, no one would.

Swipe left for the next trending thread