Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 12:58

C8H10N4O2

no this is not true, you are incorrect.
It’s very specific to how the NHS pension is calculated and differs from other public sector related pensions.

Blip · 23/11/2022 12:56

@BelleMarionette no, over a one year period almost nobody earns the base salary

  1. they don't work nights due to their health condition - presumably hardly anyone falls into this category
  2. they don't work in London - ok, many don't but a huge number do
  3. none of the specialties that they work in during the year require unsocial hours working or on calls
  4. there is never a need for them to work any overtime??????
OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 12:53

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 12:40

@BelleMarionette

The advantage though with accountancy is that professional exams and study are paid for, as are revision courses and study materials, and professional registration fees.

That depends on the employer. Most of the big firms provide a good support package, but lots of medium/smaller firms provide very limited support, certainly unlikely to provide paid study time, often limited support re study materials, registration fees maybe/maybe not, but yes, often paid exam entry costs. Then of course, lots of people are completely self funded if they don't have a "training contract" job, i.e. lots of book-keepers and accounts assistants pay entirely for their own self-study to put themselves through accountancy qualifications where their employer makes no contribution at all.

Apologies then, everyone I know socially doing accountancy has everything paid for, with rather generous packages. It may not be the case for everyone, but for many.

For doctors none of us ever have any of it paid. There is even controversy over whether we can claim the tax back on the money spent on exams.

ThighMistress · 23/11/2022 12:50

Apologies fnrtt, but has one mentioned the part-time working? It costs the same in time/money to train a part-time doctor as a full-time one. Many, many GPs are part-time, some very part-time, and not just women.

I read a statistic somewhere that women predominantly choose GP work, rather than surgery, as they want family-friendly conditions. If over 50% of trainees are going to ultimately work 50% of the time, then that needs to be addressed - how I do not know! If you double the trainees you may end up with too many doctors (not to mention the added cost) and also we surely want a high bar to entry? The young people I know who have gone to study medicine are top notch.

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 12:40

@BelleMarionette

The advantage though with accountancy is that professional exams and study are paid for, as are revision courses and study materials, and professional registration fees.

That depends on the employer. Most of the big firms provide a good support package, but lots of medium/smaller firms provide very limited support, certainly unlikely to provide paid study time, often limited support re study materials, registration fees maybe/maybe not, but yes, often paid exam entry costs. Then of course, lots of people are completely self funded if they don't have a "training contract" job, i.e. lots of book-keepers and accounts assistants pay entirely for their own self-study to put themselves through accountancy qualifications where their employer makes no contribution at all.

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 12:33

The comparison with accountancy is like comparing oranges and apples.

The advantage though with accountancy is that professional exams and study are paid for, as are revision courses and study materials, and professional registration fees. We have none of that in medicine, and the costs are quite considerable. We have to pay for GMC, royal college membership and medical defence union membership. Plus a union is highly advisable as we are usually underpaid as HR cannot understand/willfully misunderstands the contract.

The nature of the work is also completely different, so I am not sure why it is even raised.

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 12:28

Blip · 23/11/2022 11:58

@Coffeewinecake most F1s and F2s will earn a very similar amount over a one year period working probably in more than one different specialty over the year. There may be a few outliers at the top end of the earnings range, but NOBODY earns the base salary.

We don't need any separate analyses by hospital or specialty within hospital. We just need an average with a statement to say actual pay depends on actual rota. There simply is not a wide variation in gross pay over a year period for the vast majority of F1s and F2s.

Actually many do earn the base salary. There are specialities with no out of hours commitments. There are also doctors who are not able to work night shifts for health reasons.

The supplement is for working additional hours, weekends and nights. It's not 'free' extra money, as you are trying to portray it.

The London weighting is a pittance, and no where near reflects the additional cost of living in London. This is why all my fellow junior doctors live in HMOs, unless they have a wealthy partner. We have food banks advertised in our toilets, and I have known foundation doctors do need help from charities to meet basic living expenses, following unexpected events.

I do wonder what your purpose is here?

In other jobs where there is a lack of workers (for example HGV drivers) consideration is given to why (pay and conditions).

The leaky bucket analysis is a good one. There is no point creating extra medical school places, at great expense, if the graduates will leave the UK. We need to work on retention. Recruiting from abroad is problematic ethically as we recruit from less developed countries generally. Our graduates go to mainly Australia and New Zealand, so it is in no way an exchange.

Sluj · 23/11/2022 12:14

Wait! Junior doctors get time at work for training? I must tell my F2 son who has been spending loads of his time off travelling to different hospitals for mandatory training courses and completing his portfolio work. I'll message him in a minute but I doubt he will be back from his overnight 8 till 8 shift yet. He rarely leaves before 11am and has to get back to his lovely HMO room .

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 12:05

This is a useful comparison of average pay by jobs, both in total and also average hourly rates.

www.unionlearn.org.uk/compare-average-pay-job

Blip · 23/11/2022 12:01

In addition there is a London weighting which I don't see mentioned very clearly.

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 11:58

@Coffeewinecake most F1s and F2s will earn a very similar amount over a one year period working probably in more than one different specialty over the year. There may be a few outliers at the top end of the earnings range, but NOBODY earns the base salary.

We don't need any separate analyses by hospital or specialty within hospital. We just need an average with a statement to say actual pay depends on actual rota. There simply is not a wide variation in gross pay over a year period for the vast majority of F1s and F2s.

OP posts:
Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 11:53

Then you will understand that publishing an average is meaningless unless you break it down for each subspecialty and each trust or, in the case of accountancy, each department within each form.
The caveat being that the salary for an individual junior doctor will potentially change every 6 months depending on the intensity of out of hours work.

WatchoRulo · 23/11/2022 11:51

Havanananana · 22/11/2022 12:11

"The same reason why they don’t invest in nurse training anymore. They can’t be arsed to fund it and just rely on foreign doctors/nurses."

This is only half of the story. The UK electorate keeps voting for parties (note the plural) that do not prioritise healthcare funding to the same extent that many other countries do. The "They" in the statement is the people that the voters have elected - and if "they" don't do what is expected of them, then voters should vote for someone else.

In other countries, having 10% of the population waiting months for hospital treatment, people waiting days to see an GP and waiting hours for an ambulance would result in the Health Minister being kicked out on his or her arse. In England, the man who is the longest-serving Health Secretary, who held this position from 2012 until 2018 and whose plans for stabilising and improving the NHS should therefore by now be coming to fruition has just become Chancellor.

This is a good point but due to our shit voting system, most governments are elected by a minority of those voting - i.e. most people voted for something else.

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 11:47

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 11:17

Paid out of hours work will vary from post to post and this can also vary every 6-months for any individual doctor as they rotate through specialities and trusts.
The average out of hours commitment and, therefore, supplement can be wildly different within a given speciality let alone between different specialties and so quoting an average is pretty meaningless and not as transparent as you think it may be.

And, again, they also do unpaid overtime, as do most patient-facing staff. Hours of it every week.

Same applies with other professions though. Even within a profession, say, accountancy, different firms will have different policies/practices as regards out of hours working, and again, same applies with different departments within a firm, the out of hours working requirements of a tax dept within PWC will be different to the out of hours working requirements of their audit dept.

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 11:17

Paid out of hours work will vary from post to post and this can also vary every 6-months for any individual doctor as they rotate through specialities and trusts.
The average out of hours commitment and, therefore, supplement can be wildly different within a given speciality let alone between different specialties and so quoting an average is pretty meaningless and not as transparent as you think it may be.

And, again, they also do unpaid overtime, as do most patient-facing staff. Hours of it every week.

Blip · 23/11/2022 10:53

100% agree with badbadbunny

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 10:50

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 10:38

For the umpteenth time, it is there for anyone to see - just type in doctors salary scale UK. You analogy of accountants is pointless, because their salary is not transparent.

Here:
www.bmj.com/careers/article/the-complete-guide-to-nhs-pay-for-doctors

Published pay scales are pointless unless they include the average/required overtime. You can't compare the basic wage of a person who is required to do regular paid overtime against the basic wage of a person who has to work unpaid "overtime". You're comparing apples against bananas. The only valid comparison the actual hourly pay, taking into account the total wages earned against the total number of hours worked. Anything else is meaningless.

Blip · 23/11/2022 10:47

@walkingonsunshinekat
I'm not wrong about the waiting lists, there are huge wait times to even get onto them, several family members of mine have or are experiencing this.

I'm quite uncomfortable about the level to which you seem to want to suppress facts about the NHS by either denying them or dismissing them as "irrelevant" or "red herrings".

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 10:45

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 10:34

Sorry, I am not sure whether your point is for or against but pretty much all of what you describe is the same for junior doctors, expect the time off in lieu/flexitime for unpaid overtime.

The point is, a previous poster (maybe you) was suggesting that accountancy didn't have "out of hours" work, whereas in reality it does, albeit not a matter of life & death like some doctors, and there was a clear inferrence that accountancy trainees had a much easier time of it. But in reality it's comparing apples and bananas - accountants aren't making life/death decisions, but aren't getting paid for their training time and not usually for the extra/out of hours work. Trainee doctors are at least being paid for their training time as it's packaged as part of their working time.

As for the other argument about what salaries to use, I agree with the other poster in that if "overtime" is common and standard, then the wage, for comparison purposes, should include the average amount of overtime. It's disingenuous to just use "base" salary, when virtually no one would ever be paid as little as that due to the requirement/nature of the job to do x number of paid overtime hours as part of the job.

Blip · 23/11/2022 10:44

The point about accountants is that they don't need to have transparency over their pay unless they work for the public sector. There does however need to be transparency for NHS doctors as they are paid from the public purse.

OP posts:
walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 10:42

@Blip

Nope, i just think its irrelevant, the relevant point is the Govt has deliberately chosen a course of action to reduce the number of Doctors trained in the UK, based on demographics and demand.

After all, you called the thread "why don't we just train more doctors" NOT "I want greater transparency on junior Doctor pay"

You ve come up with a long list of "maybe's.." but the one you ve missed out is the "Maybe they want to reduce the NHS to an emergency service only?" with routine care done via insurance and charities - i.e pre NHS.

The lack of new real estate, medics, nurses/AHP's and no change to social care, shows this is the true aim of Govt policy, these simply isn't any other explanation - what possible other reason would you go and introduce tuition fees for Nurses/AHPs when you know there is a shortage of 40k of nurses, let alone OT's physio's radiographers paramedics ?

You are wrong about waiting lists, another diversion.

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 10:38

Blip · 23/11/2022 10:20

@walkingonsunshinekat
"I just think that the only salary figure relevant is that which the employee is contracted to do, OT and shifts are not guaranteed and depending on the setting, may not be available to the same extent - i.e. a Doc based in a major teaching hospital will be working more than a Doc in a stroke rehab unit in Plymouth."

I'm sorry, we are talking about junior doctors here. All of them work overtime, all of them work unsocial hours. Month to month their pay will vary but over a year they will all earn a similar amount over the base pay and it will be in the order of 25% more. It's disingenuous to try to deny this and also to describe it as a red herring. If you wish to submerge facts I'm sure there is a reason for this.

As to your other question the addition of training places is indeed in the hands of the government.
Maybe the problem is lack of public engagement and lack of facts in the public domain.
Maybe the problem is the short term nature of government
Maybe the problem is powerful vested interests that do not want the NHS to improve
Maybe the problem is that some doctors want to limit entry into the profession to safeguard their own status and salaries
Maybe the problem is incompetence of one or many parts of the system
Maybe the problem is the NHS, social care, DWP, education and/or government policy makers are not working together effectively.
Maybe all sorts of things.

We need the FACTS for the public to see and we need wider discussions on the future of healthcare provision as it is currently failing most of our society badly. Most families now have someone on a waiting list for an operation.
Even the waiting list figures are smoke and mirrors. They don't include people who need operations but haven't even had their first consultant appointment as there is a huge wait time there. There are effectively waiting lists to even get onto a waiting list.

For the umpteenth time, it is there for anyone to see - just type in doctors salary scale UK. You analogy of accountants is pointless, because their salary is not transparent.

Here:
www.bmj.com/careers/article/the-complete-guide-to-nhs-pay-for-doctors

Coffeewinecake · 23/11/2022 10:34

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 10:06

Well, trainee accountants usually have to study in their own time outside full time working hours unpaid. When I was studying for 4 years to get my chartered accountancy qualification, I'd typically work an average 15-20 hours per week studying, (more as exam season approached), in evenings and weekends. Certainly in my year of studying/taking the final exams, I had virtually no "life" outside work! Basically, the working day was for work, and evenings/weekends were for study. We also got very little "support" from our employers, i.e. they'd pay for study manuals and exam fees, and time off for exams, but we had to use our holiday entitlement if we wanted a couple of weeks off pre exams for revision or to attend residential revision schools, etc.

It's pretty basic expectation of anyone who had to do studying/exams for a profession.

As for out of hours working, yes, we did that too. Unpaid, but we got time off in lieu/flexitime. Weekend/evening working was required at busy times of the year, i.e. the few weeks ahead of tax return filing deadlines, year end stocktake attendance (31 Dec and 31 Mar). Also attending client board meetings and AGMs which were usually evenings, or sometimes daytime weekend. Obviously, none of that is a matter of life or death, but accountancy certainly isn't always a 9-5 M-F job with no working requirement out of hours.

Sorry, I am not sure whether your point is for or against but pretty much all of what you describe is the same for junior doctors, expect the time off in lieu/flexitime for unpaid overtime.

Blip · 23/11/2022 10:20

@walkingonsunshinekat
"I just think that the only salary figure relevant is that which the employee is contracted to do, OT and shifts are not guaranteed and depending on the setting, may not be available to the same extent - i.e. a Doc based in a major teaching hospital will be working more than a Doc in a stroke rehab unit in Plymouth."

I'm sorry, we are talking about junior doctors here. All of them work overtime, all of them work unsocial hours. Month to month their pay will vary but over a year they will all earn a similar amount over the base pay and it will be in the order of 25% more. It's disingenuous to try to deny this and also to describe it as a red herring. If you wish to submerge facts I'm sure there is a reason for this.

As to your other question the addition of training places is indeed in the hands of the government.
Maybe the problem is lack of public engagement and lack of facts in the public domain.
Maybe the problem is the short term nature of government
Maybe the problem is powerful vested interests that do not want the NHS to improve
Maybe the problem is that some doctors want to limit entry into the profession to safeguard their own status and salaries
Maybe the problem is incompetence of one or many parts of the system
Maybe the problem is the NHS, social care, DWP, education and/or government policy makers are not working together effectively.
Maybe all sorts of things.

We need the FACTS for the public to see and we need wider discussions on the future of healthcare provision as it is currently failing most of our society badly. Most families now have someone on a waiting list for an operation.
Even the waiting list figures are smoke and mirrors. They don't include people who need operations but haven't even had their first consultant appointment as there is a huge wait time there. There are effectively waiting lists to even get onto a waiting list.

OP posts:
Notonthestairs · 23/11/2022 10:19

Numbers of accountants or training places for accountants are not managed by the Government.
Neither are their salaries dictated by the Government.

Governments (yes successive ones) have failed in the NHS workforce planning.

Agree with previous posters that the electoral cycle isn't helpful and there needs to be an independent commission to review.

As I posted earlier an independent commission (to report on numbers of medics and the project numbers for long term workforce planning) was removed from legislation earlier this year.