Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 23/11/2022 13:56

Could you create specific training roles? A burnt out doctor might consider moving into a training/mentoring role rather than quitting altogether. It would keep them in the field plus support new students coming through. A hospital would presumably need a variety of these for different specialties, but they would pay for themselves if they increased student numbers and retention.

Teddybear120 · 23/11/2022 13:53

I am a junior doctor. There is a massive problem with retention so there may be lots of people wanting to train as a doctor but if you can’t retain them. I am 7 years post medical school and know of at least 12 doctors in my graduating class of 150ish that either have left medicine altogether or work abroad. I am not in touch with my whole class so the figure is likely to be more.

Whilst you could increase the number of places at medical school in theory there isn’t the capacity for training places once these people graduate. I am a GP trainee and they are struggling to find enough practices to take on registrars as there are certain criteria to be met and my supervisor has to complete supervisor training etc. In theory you can offer the funding for more, there aren’t the actual posts for us to go into.

Now I’ll probably be shouted down for this but I am one of these trainees who work part time. This is for many reasons. I work 60% so in theory 24 hours a week. In reality if I take patient care activity alone I work about 30 hours a week. However on top of that I have to complete my training portfolio that has mandatory requirements- that is at least an 3 hours a week of my time. I also have to study for my exams- which I pay for at between nearly £500 and £1100 an exam. Part of life is generally working more hours than is contracted but the pay is poor for the level of responsibility and experience I have. Now I will get flamed for this but I looked at increasing my percentage but by the time I have paid additional tax, membership fees to the college, my indemnity insurance, my pension and student loan contributions I will be no better off. Why add to my stress levels when I won’t be financially any better off

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 13:49

Notonthestairs · 23/11/2022 13:06

There has been a long term failure by successive Governments of workforce planning in the NHS.

It shouldn't come as a surprise. Hunt was talking about this a couple of years ago

committees.parliament.uk/committee/81/health-and-social-care-committee/news/136782/committee-chair-jeremy-hunt-criticises-failures-that-make-a-mockery-of-nhs-workforce-planning/

For at least 50 years, probably more. I understand there was a massive recruitment drive to encourage foreign doctors to come to the UK as far back as the 1960s.

It seems that successive governments for decades havn't grasped the nettle on this problem. Though I do seem to remember that Blair's new GP contract in the early noughties was supposed to "solve" the GP recruitment/retention problem. Well that worked well didn't it?

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 13:47

Sorry that’s after tax.
I should say £2 or so per hour, gross
Erm still disgraceful

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 13:47

Blip

consultants definitely don’t get much above the base published rate.
As explained earlier, £16.50 for 24 hours on call on a Saturday or Sunday. I’m definitely worth more than £1.45 per hour, thanks

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 23/11/2022 13:37

There have also been years in recent times when medical schools have had to go to clearing, so it is also effecting medical school applicants.

To be fair, the reason for medical schools going into Clearing isn't a lack of high-quality applicants. It's the uncertainty about how many will accept offers (given that they might have multiple offers) and how many of those will achieve the required grades. Medical schools were more or less told by government last year to go into Clearing rather than risk over-recruiting. Because of the instability of A-Level grades in the previous 2 years (and, to be honest, since Gove's "reform" of A-Levels a couple of years previously) it became very difficult to predict how many students we would end up with for a certain number of offers. We have ways of dealing with under-recruitment (e.g. Clearing); dealing with over-recruitment is very difficult and ruinously expensive, so we do whatever we can to avoid it.

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:36

And raising my head above the parapet here, I am a speciality registrar, nearly 10 years post qualification from medical school. I work an on call rota. My current salary, including London weighting, is 44k. I can send a screenshot to prove this. I am working over 35 hours a week.

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:35

@BelleMarionette the base salary isn't what most earn and the majority earn around 25% more than this.

I absolutely don't think it's true that we don't have enough people of the right calibre in the UK who want to train to be doctors. Your opinion may differ.

Retention clearly is part of the problem, I agree with this.

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:31

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 13:26

But retention is a huge issue.
To say there is no need to improve pay and T&C s because there are lots of intelligent youngsters applying to medical school is wildly short sighted.

there is a huge shortage of actual doctors. So what if there is no shortage of school leavers applying for medical school.

the pay erosion and conditions need addressing to improve retention

👋
This

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:30

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:24

@BelleMarionette once again, I have never said, or even suggested that doctors receive any "free money", your repeated accusations are completely without basis in reality and are frankly ridiculous.

Your insinuation that the quoted base salary is not realistic is frankly rediculous. I have said this many times, this is what many earn. Those who work more, get a little more.

Retention is the biggest issue, and needs tackling. Retention is down to pay and conditions.

Medical schools going to clearing indicates reduced demand for medical school places. This is an issue if it means choosing candidates who are not suited for the profession. Contrary to popular belief it's not all about academic ability.

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 13:26

But retention is a huge issue.
To say there is no need to improve pay and T&C s because there are lots of intelligent youngsters applying to medical school is wildly short sighted.

there is a huge shortage of actual doctors. So what if there is no shortage of school leavers applying for medical school.

the pay erosion and conditions need addressing to improve retention

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:26

@BelleMarionette
"If there is such a glut, then why do medical schools need to go to clearing?"

I don't know, could be any number of reasons eg they didn't allocate enough places originally.

And going to clearing is no real problem if there are loads of suitable A grade students ready and waiting to take up places which is the current situation.

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 13:24

@BelleMarionette once again, I have never said, or even suggested that doctors receive any "free money", your repeated accusations are completely without basis in reality and are frankly ridiculous.

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:20

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:17

There is never any shortage of people who want to become doctors and who have the intellectual abilities necessary.

This is the case in the UK even given current pay and conditions. There is no issue finding people who want to train to be doctors, that's very clearly not where the problem lies.

That's because a significant proportion will take their degree and go abroad.

If there is such a glut, then why do medical schools need to go to clearing?

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:19

Sluj · 23/11/2022 13:16

In his F1 year, my DS only had 1 rotation with any kind of unsociable hours/weekends in it - not overtime though he works at least 20% of every day for free. So 2/3rds of his F1 year was at base rate. This year, he has 2 rotations with weekends etc so he will get paid for those hours. However, he hates working a 14 hour shift in a hospital where he is usually the only one available surgical cases for his hospital and also one in the neighbouring town, no food available and the Doctors Mess is 10 minutes walk away and he doesn't have time for that. He spends the extra money he will have made that night on a full English breakfast on the way home. He doesn't think the extra money is worth it.

Absolutely, the night and weekend allowance is only for time worked. It's not 'free' money as purported by the OP. It can also involve a lot of extra expenses, including childcare (which is prohibitively expensive out of hours).

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:17

There is never any shortage of people who want to become doctors and who have the intellectual abilities necessary.

This is the case in the UK even given current pay and conditions. There is no issue finding people who want to train to be doctors, that's very clearly not where the problem lies.

OP posts:
Sluj · 23/11/2022 13:16

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:04

@BelleMarionette are you really telling me that there is a significant number of F1 & F2 doctors who work zero hours of overtime over a 12 month period?

In his F1 year, my DS only had 1 rotation with any kind of unsociable hours/weekends in it - not overtime though he works at least 20% of every day for free. So 2/3rds of his F1 year was at base rate. This year, he has 2 rotations with weekends etc so he will get paid for those hours. However, he hates working a 14 hour shift in a hospital where he is usually the only one available surgical cases for his hospital and also one in the neighbouring town, no food available and the Doctors Mess is 10 minutes walk away and he doesn't have time for that. He spends the extra money he will have made that night on a full English breakfast on the way home. He doesn't think the extra money is worth it.

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:14

There have also been years in recent times when medical schools have had to go to clearing, so it is also effecting medical school applicants.

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:12

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:02

I think there may well be a case to pay doctors more, or maybe not, I'm not sure if pay is the best way to help increase the number of doctors or not. It certainly doesn't stop enough highly intelligent people wanting to become doctors. It is probably a factor in retention of doctors but I suspect it's just one of many factors, some of which eg working hours and workload, work/life balance, working conditions etc are probably more key than pay rises in my opinion.

What I am sure of is that we need to understand what doctors are paid at the moment and the base salary does not inform this.

It's pay and conditions. When graduates can go abroad, be paid twice as much, and have much better working conditions and training, of course many will leave. I have stayed due to family ties, but for many the pull is stronger.

As a foundation doctor my salary didn't even cover childcare. I was on the old contract so my base was even less than it is now.

The pay is dismal, truly.

Notonthestairs · 23/11/2022 13:06

There has been a long term failure by successive Governments of workforce planning in the NHS.

It shouldn't come as a surprise. Hunt was talking about this a couple of years ago

committees.parliament.uk/committee/81/health-and-social-care-committee/news/136782/committee-chair-jeremy-hunt-criticises-failures-that-make-a-mockery-of-nhs-workforce-planning/

Blip · 23/11/2022 13:04

@BelleMarionette are you really telling me that there is a significant number of F1 & F2 doctors who work zero hours of overtime over a 12 month period?

OP posts:
Blip · 23/11/2022 13:02

I think there may well be a case to pay doctors more, or maybe not, I'm not sure if pay is the best way to help increase the number of doctors or not. It certainly doesn't stop enough highly intelligent people wanting to become doctors. It is probably a factor in retention of doctors but I suspect it's just one of many factors, some of which eg working hours and workload, work/life balance, working conditions etc are probably more key than pay rises in my opinion.

What I am sure of is that we need to understand what doctors are paid at the moment and the base salary does not inform this.

OP posts:
Generalmanageroftheuniverse · 23/11/2022 13:01

Blip · 22/11/2022 12:05

@ChiefPearlClutcher that is mind blowing

Text from the BMJ article
"Delegates at the annual BMA conference voted by a narrow majority to restrict the number of places at medical schools to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.” They also agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical schools.
David Sochart, from Manchester and Salford, warned that in the current job climate allowing too many new doctors into the market would risk devaluing the profession and make newly qualified doctors prey to “unscrupulous profiteers.” A glut of doctors would undermine competition and would therefore lower standards and ensure mediocrity, he claimed.
He said, “Patients and health care should not be treated as mere commodities, and neither should medical students. We must not allow another lost tribe of doctors to be consigned to the wilderness.”
Grant Ingrams, representing GPs, said that doctors should not be trained if there was no job at the end. He warned that this could spark another “brain drain,” adding: “It is wrong and immoral and a waste of taxpayers’ and students’ money.”

That's horrific.

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:00

Blip · 23/11/2022 12:56

@BelleMarionette no, over a one year period almost nobody earns the base salary

  1. they don't work nights due to their health condition - presumably hardly anyone falls into this category
  2. they don't work in London - ok, many don't but a huge number do
  3. none of the specialties that they work in during the year require unsocial hours working or on calls
  4. there is never a need for them to work any overtime??????

They may be training in a speciality without out of hours commitments. The London weighting is pitiful, and contrary to what you think, the majority of doctors in the UK don't work in London.

Health reasons are not unusual either, particularly considering the health effect of working in medicine.

I'm not sure why you seem so sure, given you quite clearly do not work in healthcare.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 12:58

Blip · 23/11/2022 10:47

@walkingonsunshinekat
I'm not wrong about the waiting lists, there are huge wait times to even get onto them, several family members of mine have or are experiencing this.

I'm quite uncomfortable about the level to which you seem to want to suppress facts about the NHS by either denying them or dismissing them as "irrelevant" or "red herrings".

As i told you earlier, pay hours worked isn't relevant to the question of why the UK hasn't enough Doc's.

We don't train enough and we don't retain the ones we do.

On waiting lists, you nor your friends would be told that your on a waiting list for a waiting list & no such thing exists.

Why am i so sure? because a very good friend of mine works within the NHS on managerial side (non medical) and has complete over sight on waiting lists in her trust, plus neither the Kings fund or the Nuffield trust have mentioned this in their in depth analysis into NHS wait times.

But again, its not relevant to why the UK hasn't enough Dr's.

Focus on the thread title please.