Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 24/11/2022 15:40

Hillarious · 24/11/2022 13:28

Just imagine if those nurses and other medical professionals, no doubt trained in the NHS, carried out the work for the NHS instead and better use was made of the theatre time. I was shocked when I recently went to the hospital to be asked by the receptionist if I was "an NHS patient today". Does that mean private healthcare is making use of NHS facilities?

I don't know the answer to that, but if they are, they'll be paying the NHS Trust for the use of those facilities.

Lapland123 · 24/11/2022 15:30

But you are musing the point that the nhs does not want to pay for that consultant’s extra time in which they are doing private work. Anyone is free to do whatever they want in their non- contracted time. And the NHS pay has meant a 35% pay erosion since this government has been in office.

Hillarious · 24/11/2022 13:28

walkingonsunshinekat · 24/11/2022 13:24

Yes but that procedure would have been done in a private hospital.
A consultant needs scans, nurses, theatre time etc etc.

The irony is that as the NHS fails, more people are going private, hence more work for consultants and other healthcare staff who want to leave the NHS.

Just imagine if those nurses and other medical professionals, no doubt trained in the NHS, carried out the work for the NHS instead and better use was made of the theatre time. I was shocked when I recently went to the hospital to be asked by the receptionist if I was "an NHS patient today". Does that mean private healthcare is making use of NHS facilities?

walkingonsunshinekat · 24/11/2022 13:24

Hillarious · 24/11/2022 13:13

Is it unreasonable to query whether if more consultants, trained in the NHS, stuck to NHS work rather than private, they might get through the NHS waiting lists quicker?

My colleague went private for a hysterectomy and saw the same consultant six months earlier than she would have done, had she waiting for an NHS appointment.

Yes but that procedure would have been done in a private hospital.
A consultant needs scans, nurses, theatre time etc etc.

The irony is that as the NHS fails, more people are going private, hence more work for consultants and other healthcare staff who want to leave the NHS.

Hillarious · 24/11/2022 13:13

Is it unreasonable to query whether if more consultants, trained in the NHS, stuck to NHS work rather than private, they might get through the NHS waiting lists quicker?

My colleague went private for a hysterectomy and saw the same consultant six months earlier than she would have done, had she waiting for an NHS appointment.

Dinoteeth · 24/11/2022 13:04

I'd really like to know what public service has improved over the last 12 years?

Certainly none in Scotland, unless you count money being spent on unnecessary stuff like baby boxes and child top ups.

Don't forget that money is being diverted from other services.

walkingonsunshinekat · 24/11/2022 12:48

Badbadbunny · 24/11/2022 11:53

Yes, anecdotal re my practice, but I'm old enough to remember all the "save the NHS" messages from the 90s and 00s, Blair/Brown's two NIC rises to "save the NIC", the front pages of newspapers "24 hours to save the NHS", blair's ruinous GP contract in the mid 00's that was promised to "solve the GP shortage crisis", Blair/Brown trebled NHS spending over their 12 years in office.

So it wasn't just "my practice" was it? Blair wouldn't have been making speeches extolling the virtues of his new GP contract to "solve the GP shortage crisis" if there wasn't a problem back then would he?

Yes, I've no doubt things have got a lot worse over the past 20 years, but the NHS had serious problems in the 00's too!

The NHS has been in "crisis" ever since I can remember!

Have you NC'd Kazzy ?

Yes the NHS has never been up there with european health services but it was never like this in the 00's.

I used the Royal Berks a few times back then plus GP's too for some stomach issues & it was far superior, as i said, the max wait for GP appts was 2 days, its now 2 weeks and they want to bin that, despite it being just a few weeks old.

I don't know about the GP contracts, Blair certainly did nothing for dentistry but its worse again, the only NHS dentistry in my county is emergency only, i wonder if GPs will go the same way.

I'd really like to know what public service has improved over the last 12 years?

Badbadbunny · 24/11/2022 11:53

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 17:15

Thats just anecdotal, for you and your GP practice, the rot set in the mid 00's - my experience was completely different.

The point i'm making is that generally speaking, this country has had just about enough GPs and Doctors, thats no longer the case.

We certainly never had 7m waiting for treatment and a Govt promising a F2F appointment within 2 weeks, Labours target was 2 days and it was, in the main, met.

Yes, anecdotal re my practice, but I'm old enough to remember all the "save the NHS" messages from the 90s and 00s, Blair/Brown's two NIC rises to "save the NIC", the front pages of newspapers "24 hours to save the NHS", blair's ruinous GP contract in the mid 00's that was promised to "solve the GP shortage crisis", Blair/Brown trebled NHS spending over their 12 years in office.

So it wasn't just "my practice" was it? Blair wouldn't have been making speeches extolling the virtues of his new GP contract to "solve the GP shortage crisis" if there wasn't a problem back then would he?

Yes, I've no doubt things have got a lot worse over the past 20 years, but the NHS had serious problems in the 00's too!

The NHS has been in "crisis" ever since I can remember!

milveycrohn · 23/11/2022 22:57

No one has mentioned the various changes each Gov has done over the last few years. My BIL (a former GP, since retired) fell about laughing at the ridiculous generous package they received in 2007 (Was this Tony Blair or Gordon Brown?). They were basically paid more to do less.
Changes to pensions, etc have meant that many now retire early, and my BIL has since moved to France to avoid the high tax here on his very generous pension.

paintitallover · 23/11/2022 22:23

It'll get worse too, in terms of retention, not least because the doctors qualifying now feel very short changed because their contracts are worsened since 2017. Those people will soon qualify.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 17:15

Kazzyhoward · 23/11/2022 16:16

Re ease of appointments, I think the rot set in during the early noughties. I got married in 1997, can't remember problems before then. We either rang to book an afternoon appointment which would be maybe a week ahead, or we turned up and waited during the morning "open" surgery.

But mid noughties, it had become a nightmare, with long phone queues, the "open" surgery had stopped, so all appointments to be made in advance, no longer a choice of GP, you were allocated randomly, and that's when the waiting times increased to a few weeks.

I think the rot for our surgery started with the retirement of the GP partners - there were two of them who'd been there forever who both retired in the early noughties, then it was a carousel of random GPs.

Thats just anecdotal, for you and your GP practice, the rot set in the mid 00's - my experience was completely different.

The point i'm making is that generally speaking, this country has had just about enough GPs and Doctors, thats no longer the case.

We certainly never had 7m waiting for treatment and a Govt promising a F2F appointment within 2 weeks, Labours target was 2 days and it was, in the main, met.

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 17:05

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 23/11/2022 15:26

I don't think they really are giving return of service after a couple of years work when you consider how much doctors have to pay for their education in other countries - it takes the best part of their working lives sometimes.

They pay quite a lot in this country too - it certainly isn't free and certainly isn't a couple of years. I think five or seven years minimum and often far longer seems a reasonable request.

I pay for lawyers, accountants, engineers, teachers, social workers, dentists, politicians and many others to complete degrees - why should they not give back in the same way? Should people who attend FE colleges on vocational courses that I help fund pay some of that back by working in the public sector - plumbers making sure they spend a couple of years in hospitals, schools and council offices sorting their ancient plumbing? Why should doctors be singled out - particularly when the vast majority do spend most of their working life in public service.

Far better we offer incentives and rewards to encourage people to stay practicing medicine. Perhaps write off student loans, change the training so that they can settle and build a life somewhere, pay a reasonable wage for the level of responsibility and resource hospitals and GPs well enough to let them feel they can provide a good service. Perhaps vote to fund our health service at a level comparable to other developed nations?

Most doctors in other countries are working in the private sector. Most countries pay their doctors more. Luxembourg offers around £240K for a newly qualified GP. Belgium is around £115,218. In the UK it is £60,455 for a full-time salaried GP. Perhaps we should pay them more.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 23/11/2022 16:51

Teddybear120 · 23/11/2022 13:53

I am a junior doctor. There is a massive problem with retention so there may be lots of people wanting to train as a doctor but if you can’t retain them. I am 7 years post medical school and know of at least 12 doctors in my graduating class of 150ish that either have left medicine altogether or work abroad. I am not in touch with my whole class so the figure is likely to be more.

Whilst you could increase the number of places at medical school in theory there isn’t the capacity for training places once these people graduate. I am a GP trainee and they are struggling to find enough practices to take on registrars as there are certain criteria to be met and my supervisor has to complete supervisor training etc. In theory you can offer the funding for more, there aren’t the actual posts for us to go into.

Now I’ll probably be shouted down for this but I am one of these trainees who work part time. This is for many reasons. I work 60% so in theory 24 hours a week. In reality if I take patient care activity alone I work about 30 hours a week. However on top of that I have to complete my training portfolio that has mandatory requirements- that is at least an 3 hours a week of my time. I also have to study for my exams- which I pay for at between nearly £500 and £1100 an exam. Part of life is generally working more hours than is contracted but the pay is poor for the level of responsibility and experience I have. Now I will get flamed for this but I looked at increasing my percentage but by the time I have paid additional tax, membership fees to the college, my indemnity insurance, my pension and student loan contributions I will be no better off. Why add to my stress levels when I won’t be financially any better off

No shouting down from here. Why would you make your work/life balance worse and end up with no extra money, greater stress and fatigue, and less time to yourself? The amount of time you are spending on work is as much as many people do who consider themselves in full-time employment.

The whole system is a mess.

Kazzyhoward · 23/11/2022 16:16

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 14:23

What was most peoples experience of getting a GP appointment in the 2000's and onwards?

I don't know what other peoples experiences were but even as a child in the 70s, it was very easy to get GP appointments.

In 1997, it was an approx 2 year wait for heart surgery, 10 years later that was down to 3 months.

But what i just don't understand is how people cannot grasp that Austerity, Brexit then finally Covid has had on this country generally, let alone in Healthcare where we also have vastly increased demand, which spending and training just hasn't kept up with.

Re ease of appointments, I think the rot set in during the early noughties. I got married in 1997, can't remember problems before then. We either rang to book an afternoon appointment which would be maybe a week ahead, or we turned up and waited during the morning "open" surgery.

But mid noughties, it had become a nightmare, with long phone queues, the "open" surgery had stopped, so all appointments to be made in advance, no longer a choice of GP, you were allocated randomly, and that's when the waiting times increased to a few weeks.

I think the rot for our surgery started with the retirement of the GP partners - there were two of them who'd been there forever who both retired in the early noughties, then it was a carousel of random GPs.

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 15:45

Blip

im very unlikely to be called in but if I rarely was - maybe once a year- I wouldn’t be paid any more, no, because it is quiet the rest of the time. This is monitored intermittently.

but I think I’m definitely worth more than £2 an hour to be at the end of the telephone. I think everyone is worth more than that.

it’s absolute nonsense

Lapland123 · 23/11/2022 15:30

It’s not ‘a couple of years’ to independent practice
have you not read how long it takes to train as a GP and years longer to become a consultant

Sparklythingsandothercrap · 23/11/2022 15:26

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 14:45

But they are already giving return of service and have to di so to progress to independent practice. They also have to pay an amount for the privithrough MDU GMC and Royal college fees and exam fees. Those are paid by the doctor after Foundation stage.

I don't think they really are giving return of service after a couple of years work when you consider how much doctors have to pay for their education in other countries - it takes the best part of their working lives sometimes.

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 14:45

C8H10N4O2 · 23/11/2022 08:43

Any professional whose job involves life long learning and who aspires to move up the ladder will do long hours beyond those contracted. This is not unique to medicine. The return for most is a interesting career path leading to higher earnings and depending on the path - a degree of social status such as in medicine. You don't have to look far to find grads on elite graduate programmes turning in hours which translate the salaries to minimum wage.

The actual cost of training doctors is substantially higher than most other professions where the post graduate or post doctoral costs are born by the company/individual.

I'm not generally a fan of indenturing or requirement for X FTE years "pay back" but to minimise the investment of the state in medical training for doctors is to downplay that investment quite significantly.

But they are already giving return of service and have to di so to progress to independent practice. They also have to pay an amount for the privithrough MDU GMC and Royal college fees and exam fees. Those are paid by the doctor after Foundation stage.

ShinyHappyTits · 23/11/2022 14:41

Forfrigz · 22/11/2022 12:24

Honestly you need to come from a stable background with good finances to do medicine. Most of the UK population are languishing in abject squalor presently which is why we rely on the children of decent foreign homes to diagnose us

Sorry, that’s just nonsensical. I teach at three different (private) schools where there are vast amounts of ferociously clever, well supported students who make the grades but from whom there are no
medical school places. So they go abroad to study and stay there. Not denying there’s a problem with the poverty gap but universities are taking more state students than ever. What you are asserting isn’t the problem.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/11/2022 14:32

Retention clearly is part of the problem, I agree with this.

Retention is the biggest problem imo. If you cannot retain your doctors, then not are you losing their skill in treating patients and the money wasted in training them, their leaving also means a shortage of people able to train the next generation of doctors.

The problem, of course, is that the damage to the profession has been done over the last 10+ years and will take at least that length of time to fix. No government is going to be okay with that because it is more than 2 election cycles. So they go for the headlines "training more doctors than ever" and missing off the crucial "but not enough to replace those leaving". Or "paying doctors more that ever" missing off "but not enough to keep up with UK average wage inflation". They do exactly the same with teachers, nurses, police officers, railway workers etc. Headlines over substance every time.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/11/2022 14:23

Badbadbunny · 23/11/2022 13:49

For at least 50 years, probably more. I understand there was a massive recruitment drive to encourage foreign doctors to come to the UK as far back as the 1960s.

It seems that successive governments for decades havn't grasped the nettle on this problem. Though I do seem to remember that Blair's new GP contract in the early noughties was supposed to "solve" the GP recruitment/retention problem. Well that worked well didn't it?

What was most peoples experience of getting a GP appointment in the 2000's and onwards?

I don't know what other peoples experiences were but even as a child in the 70s, it was very easy to get GP appointments.

In 1997, it was an approx 2 year wait for heart surgery, 10 years later that was down to 3 months.

But what i just don't understand is how people cannot grasp that Austerity, Brexit then finally Covid has had on this country generally, let alone in Healthcare where we also have vastly increased demand, which spending and training just hasn't kept up with.

randomsabreuse · 23/11/2022 14:21

The thing with a lot of high powered,high pressure, high pay jobs is that they seem like a great idea in your teens and 20s. I was fixated on the idea of city law, got the silver circle training contract but started looking at the life my bosses and people ahead of me on the career path had and realised it wasn't going to be worth it.

As a young 25 year old doctor with colleagues you like plus your parents in their 50s/early 60s work taking over your life is kind of ok. Fast forward to marrying a fellow doctor, your rotas seemingly deliberately set so you never see each other, having to scrabble around to swap shifts so you can attend family and friends' weddings (or even your own) booked as holiday on the rota system a year in advance, parents getting a bit older and you wanting kids, you start needing more balance in your life...

Probably one of the biggest cheap solutions to retention would be rotas being set with some consideration for long time booked things like weddings, possibly even predictable days of the week off to facilitate hobbies, childcare and having a life and trying not to be shitty about it rather than seemingly deliberately putting shifts in to be as inconvenient as possible.

Blip · 23/11/2022 14:14

@Lapland123 surely you get £1.45 an hour if you are not called in but get your hourly rate on top of you are called in for hours worked? Is that correct?

I'm really talking about junior doctors salaries rather than consultants here though.

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 23/11/2022 14:11

BelleMarionette · 23/11/2022 13:36

And raising my head above the parapet here, I am a speciality registrar, nearly 10 years post qualification from medical school. I work an on call rota. My current salary, including London weighting, is 44k. I can send a screenshot to prove this. I am working over 35 hours a week.

Your joking - no wonder Docs are going abroad - £44k is very low.

The UK needs to pay properly and avoid penalising people with higher rate tax. And Scotland is worse for that than England is.

Plinkle · 23/11/2022 14:03

I'm a hospital doctor. I used to be a trainee (a qualified doctor, training to be a consultant in a particular specialty), paid according to the payscales referenced already. The comments about payscales etc seem to be implying that there is deliberate secrecy about what doctors earn. I don't think that's true.

There are 2 types of work over and above the "standard 9-5", as I see it:

  1. Unpaid overtime - all professional jobs have this I imagine. My husband is an accountant and he has this, as do I as a doctor. Coming in early to prep for the ward round. Routinely leaving at 7pm instead of 5 because of the volume of work. Skipping lunch, studying for (essential) postgtad exams. Doctors don't get paid for this.
  1. Paid antisocial hours, which attract a supplement on top of the basic salary in the salary scale. These vary so widely from post to post that, as a previous poster has said, to reference an average is meaningless. The supplement is calculated according to the percentage of rota-ed hours that occur "out of hours" and their frequency and timing. (Of note, "core hours" are defined as 7am - 7pm.)

A junior doctor may be on a training programme with 4 month rotations. Each rotation may have different scheduled hours, due to the specialty, hospital and level of other staffing. So you could absolutely have one post with no on call/out of hours commitment followed by one with lots of night shifts, etc. Junior doctors have little control over which exact posts they will be allocated to early in their training, so their take-home pay can be difficult to accurately anticipate.

Here is the BMA page about out of hours supplement, with specifics: www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/pay/pay-banding/how-pay-banding-works

Most jobs I worked as a trainee were technically 2B, for context. The important thing to note as well is that in order to be a 2B rota (for example), the average working hours over a period of weeks need to fall within the hour listed. The actual week's work would vary hugely from week to week depending on whether I was on nights/days etc. HR seemed to employ some creative tactics to ensure rotas were compliant whilst working me like a dog! (Often the medical staff would dispute that they WERE compliant - this is a whole other thread.) However, I would say this was a huge underestimate of my actual working hours. As with any professional-type job, I was working hours and hours of unpaid overtime per week.

I would also say that as a trainee, I had huge responsibility and pressure. As a 3rd year Doctor, I was the most senior person in a large DGH overnight and was genuinely making life and death decisions.

I was also absolutely rushed off my feet, chronically underslept, and spending every free minute studying for my postgrad exams. Don't even get me started on being allocated to a peripheral hospital (not my choice) an hour away from my house, and having the joys of working e.g. 9am to 10pm at the weekends, and sets of four consecutive 12 hour nightshifts, without hospital accommodation. It's a wonder I didn't kill anyone on the motorway on the way home.