Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't we just train more doctors?

267 replies

Blip · 22/11/2022 11:42

The UK has had a shortage of doctors for decades now and we have relied a lot on using doctors trained overseas.

I understand that it's expensive to train doctors but it's clearly a lot more expensive to not have enough doctors and have to pay locums at locum rates.

It's also a lot more expensive when people are unable to work due to waiting sometimes a year or more for medical treatment that will let them get back to work.

Lots of people make the grades for medical school and there is no shortage of applicants, nor has there ever been.

What has been the blocker to training more doctors, I just don't get it?

OP posts:
randomsabreuse · 22/11/2022 13:16

The problem is that doctors "work" time is often defined as time spent seeing patients or "sessions". However each session will have additional paperwork time resulting from it which is still work but not allocated to a session.

Also, time spent training juniors, lecturing medical school students is not sessional work and is obviously essential.

Classic issue is you need more doctors to train more doctors and doctors firefighting doing 2 or 3 jobs are not in a position to train others effectively

yoyo1234 · 22/11/2022 13:16

BMA NHS payscales and NHS doctor payscales to be the same. I have found consultant payscale information to be more concise (other than private work/locum work etc). The difference at more junior levels were the out of hours / antisocial hours pay awards. At junior doctor levels these could be (if I recall correctly an additional 42% on top of basic). For consultant work it has been 8% on top of basic. With consultant work you frequently get extra sessions (each worth 10% but each taking at least an extra 10% of your time and you have to justify this to HR) you also get discretionary or clinical excellence awards. Clinical Excellence and Discretionary Award values are all noted correctly. So I think there is leeway with payscales but websites try to be open and honest.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:14

Blip · 22/11/2022 13:10

Seems like only 23% of doctors work 37.5 hours or more per week

Where does this statistic come from? I have never heard it before. Perhaps it refers to GPs? It is definitely not true of hospital specialities.

DuchessDandelion · 22/11/2022 13:11

I want to retrain as a doctor but can't afford to.

I don't have dependents, I'm as free and unencumbered as I'm ever likely to be, but it's impossible to train without money to live on and my savings would support me for a year, no more.

itsjustnotok · 22/11/2022 13:10

Retention is also a problem. Quite honestly I don’t blame them. There is so much negativity about doctors, the NHS that I would avoid. DD mentioned going into medicine and I asked her to seriously think about it because it’s brutal at the moment. Nothing is good enough, no one is happy and the abuse they get is awful. I don’t want that for her. Her dad has already had a breakdown because of his job in the NHS and never thinking he’s good enough. I don’t want that for her .

Blip · 22/11/2022 13:10

Seems like only 23% of doctors work 37.5 hours or more per week

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:05

Badbadbunny · 22/11/2022 13:02

There's also no point in spending so much time and money training them for so many to work just 1 day per week! When the trend started for part time working in the past 25 years or so, training places should have been doubled to provide the staff to replace full time retiring doctors. If the average doctor is now working, say, half time, it's common sense you need twice as many doctors as you needed in the 80s/90s when most doctors worked full time.

Again, factually incorrect. In training, the minimum training percentage is 50%, but in practise it is 60%. The majority of doctors who work less than full time work 80%, which together with the out of hours commitments that most specialities have, generally works out at 35-40 hours a week, which is full time for a normal person. This isn't counting the unpaid overtime which is inevitable, or the locum shifts which are often expected.

Rowthe · 22/11/2022 13:05

Because during to the working conditions.

No matter how many you train they will leave for better working conditions.

If you make the job attractive it will retain the current workforce and attract more from overseas. But currently the NHS is haemorrhaging staff.

Badbadbunny · 22/11/2022 13:04

Cornishmumofone · 22/11/2022 12:45

I work in a medical school which is under pressure to take on more students... however we can't magic up additional placement capacity and don't have the time/staff/space to provide alternative teaching such as ward-based teaching spaces or VR experiences. Also, huge numbers of students failed during the pandemic (they thought they could watch videos and catch up later, but didn't have the required time management skills), so we now have another bottleneck.

It' hardly the students' fault if medical schools/Unis reverted to virtual lectures instead of face to face is it? You make it sound like the students' fault!

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 13:02

ChiefPearlClutcher · 22/11/2022 12:58

Apologies if I take pay scales from the BMA website with a massive pinch of salt!!!

Here it is from the NHS website, with the exact same figures:

www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/explore-roles/doctors/pay-doctors/pay-doctors

Feel free to verify it with your local hospital. It's a national contract, with no room for variation. This is exactly what junior doctors are paid.

Badbadbunny · 22/11/2022 13:02

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 12:42

New medical schools have opened recently, but there is a question of capacity: the needs to be enough hospital capacity for these students.

Moreover, most importantly, work needs to be done in retention. There is no point training doctors, at cost of over £200k each, only for the poor training, pay and conditions in the UK to mean that they go abroad soon after graduation. This is the reality now.

There's also no point in spending so much time and money training them for so many to work just 1 day per week! When the trend started for part time working in the past 25 years or so, training places should have been doubled to provide the staff to replace full time retiring doctors. If the average doctor is now working, say, half time, it's common sense you need twice as many doctors as you needed in the 80s/90s when most doctors worked full time.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 12:59

Blip · 22/11/2022 12:05

@ChiefPearlClutcher that is mind blowing

Text from the BMJ article
"Delegates at the annual BMA conference voted by a narrow majority to restrict the number of places at medical schools to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.” They also agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical schools.
David Sochart, from Manchester and Salford, warned that in the current job climate allowing too many new doctors into the market would risk devaluing the profession and make newly qualified doctors prey to “unscrupulous profiteers.” A glut of doctors would undermine competition and would therefore lower standards and ensure mediocrity, he claimed.
He said, “Patients and health care should not be treated as mere commodities, and neither should medical students. We must not allow another lost tribe of doctors to be consigned to the wilderness.”
Grant Ingrams, representing GPs, said that doctors should not be trained if there was no job at the end. He warned that this could spark another “brain drain,” adding: “It is wrong and immoral and a waste of taxpayers’ and students’ money.”

Before everyone starts frothing at the mouth regarding this, some points:

  1. This was from 2008, before a significant proportion of doctors qualified today, were qualified, myself included
  2. This was a vote from the BMA, a trade union. They do not represent all doctors, not do they often do a particularly good job at representing doctors. I have left them previously as they are incredibly ineffective as a trade union. Trade unions also have no power to prevent the opening of medical schools
  3. It was passed by a 'narrow majority '
  4. Workforce planning is key. There is no point in opening new medical schools and creating new doctors, if there are no jobs for them when they qualify. This would be a waste of public funds apart from the personal impacts to those effected.
ChiefPearlClutcher · 22/11/2022 12:58

Apologies if I take pay scales from the BMA website with a massive pinch of salt!!!

SquirrelSoShiny · 22/11/2022 12:46

Blip · 22/11/2022 12:05

@ChiefPearlClutcher that is mind blowing

Text from the BMJ article
"Delegates at the annual BMA conference voted by a narrow majority to restrict the number of places at medical schools to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.” They also agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical schools.
David Sochart, from Manchester and Salford, warned that in the current job climate allowing too many new doctors into the market would risk devaluing the profession and make newly qualified doctors prey to “unscrupulous profiteers.” A glut of doctors would undermine competition and would therefore lower standards and ensure mediocrity, he claimed.
He said, “Patients and health care should not be treated as mere commodities, and neither should medical students. We must not allow another lost tribe of doctors to be consigned to the wilderness.”
Grant Ingrams, representing GPs, said that doctors should not be trained if there was no job at the end. He warned that this could spark another “brain drain,” adding: “It is wrong and immoral and a waste of taxpayers’ and students’ money.”

Mmhmm. It was basically about keeping medicine as an elite profession which offered huge pay opportunities especially for doctors working in the private sector. Keep the supply of doctors small and keep pay high.

Except conditions deteriorated for docs in the NHS (because of doc shortage) and they started bailing like rats from a sinking ship. And the ship really is sinking now.

Cornishmumofone · 22/11/2022 12:45

I work in a medical school which is under pressure to take on more students... however we can't magic up additional placement capacity and don't have the time/staff/space to provide alternative teaching such as ward-based teaching spaces or VR experiences. Also, huge numbers of students failed during the pandemic (they thought they could watch videos and catch up later, but didn't have the required time management skills), so we now have another bottleneck.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 12:45

ChiefPearlClutcher · 22/11/2022 12:25

Pay and conditions my arse.

The pay is not bad at all. Their main complaints come from overtime/pension contributions/how they are taxed.

The conditions are totally of their own making, they should take their own union to task on that one.

Nurses are criminally underpaid for their workload and the legal and moral responsibility they bear.

I asked people at a party how much they thought I earnt as a 'junior doctor' several years after graduation. Most thought I earnt double what I do.

You can look up the pay scales on the bma website, it is shocking given the length of training, debt, level of responsibility and trauma of the job.

BelleMarionette · 22/11/2022 12:42

New medical schools have opened recently, but there is a question of capacity: the needs to be enough hospital capacity for these students.

Moreover, most importantly, work needs to be done in retention. There is no point training doctors, at cost of over £200k each, only for the poor training, pay and conditions in the UK to mean that they go abroad soon after graduation. This is the reality now.

Fifiesta · 22/11/2022 12:40

6 years to train a Doctor with an intercalated degree, + 2 foundation years of general hospital training before specialist training. E.G. Paediatrics was a further 8 years, now shortened to 5, however those doctors who started training under the original 8 years are still training now and therefore count as Junior Doctors almost 10 years later.
Anyone who has relatives or offspring going through training can see the toll taken on the NHS workforce, and please disregard the media quotes regarding salary, they always use G.P salaries, never the shift working Junior Doctors at the hospital rockface…

SquirrelSoShiny · 22/11/2022 12:40

Swedishmeatball · 22/11/2022 12:16

My dr colleagues (I’m a lawyer in a large public sector org) tell me it’s the BMA blocking it. Sorry don’t have source. The BMA is an incredibly powerful union and govt officials terrified of them!

This. They can deny it all they want but the BMA are a significant chunk at blame here.

HoppingPavlova · 22/11/2022 12:37

Capacity to train and supervise plays a late role in this. There are not enough staff to do this to increase the pool basically. First hand experience.

2bazookas · 22/11/2022 12:32

Graduation from 5 yrs in medical school is only the very basic qualification . The medical training takes up to a further nine years ; while working full time and studying for very demanding professional exams. The post-grad hospital training is done by more senior doctors who are also working fulltime at their medical job with patients.

ChiefPearlClutcher · 22/11/2022 12:25

Pay and conditions my arse.

The pay is not bad at all. Their main complaints come from overtime/pension contributions/how they are taxed.

The conditions are totally of their own making, they should take their own union to task on that one.

Nurses are criminally underpaid for their workload and the legal and moral responsibility they bear.

Forfrigz · 22/11/2022 12:24

Honestly you need to come from a stable background with good finances to do medicine. Most of the UK population are languishing in abject squalor presently which is why we rely on the children of decent foreign homes to diagnose us

yoyo1234 · 22/11/2022 12:20

Not surprised at BMA . Very powerful and does not surprise me at all that vote mentioned by previous posters.

yoyo1234 · 22/11/2022 12:19

Time scales may play a part. It costs a lot to train a doctor ( I think medical school alone is over 250, 000 - many years ago). You do not see benefit of increased numbers for many years (5 year medical school- 4 year if postgraduate fast track , 6 years if intercalated degree etc) . Then there are junior doctor years. This takes more than a parliamentary term. The government will not see the benefits of its investment in the term.