Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for positive PIP / DLA experiences.

35 replies

ItsTheSmallThings · 22/11/2022 10:55

Just that really. DSD had an assessment and have heard nothing but negative experiences. Has anyone had a positive experience?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rosio · 24/11/2022 09:47

Can I ask a q for you knowledgeable people. My DH got his assessment back in September with nothing awarded, sent off the mandatory reconsideration but haven't heard back yet and he's been 7 weeks. He's going to call up in morning to chase, I've heard that it's unlikely to be changed at this stage though but appeals are much more successful. Is it normal it takes this long to hear again?

gublercullen · 23/11/2022 18:34

My experience was 50/50. Stressful in the sense that the paperwork and gathering enough evidence was difficult but I had my mum to help me. Bit of background, I was a healthy working mum of 2 five years ago. My family came down with a bad cold, I caught it and was floored but because everyone else was ill I carried on as best I could. Ended up with a sinus and ear infection, which led to mastoiditis which then ended up in bacterial meningitis. I was gravely ill in hospital for 3 weeks. Side effects from the BM have been unbelievable. I have numerous neurological conditions, one that requires lumbar punctures every 4 weeks and is basically debilitating.

My paperwork for PIP was awkward and difficult and the stress of waiting was unreal. BUT when it came to my face to face appointment with the assessor, I had only heard awful things. However I was lucky enough to get an assessment with a lovely woman who's previous work history involved time spent on a stroke unit where she'd seen first hand just how debilitating my neurological condition could be.

My health still hasn't improved (gotten worse) so I've been on PIP for four years. I have to say it's been very easy after the initial application because nothing has changed and I'm still unable to work. If you need any help with anything feel free to give me a message.

Fifthtimelucky · 23/11/2022 18:31

I have no experience of this personally, but am heartened by the positive experiences so many people have reported.

As others have said, it does tend to be the negative ones that we hear/read about.

LakieLady · 23/11/2022 17:43

I work in welfare rights and do a couple of PIP applications a month.

One of my clients had an incredibly positive experience. Two to three months after the form went in, she got a phone call from someone at PIP, who asked her a few questions, but nothing like the questions she would have got at an actual assessment.

Two days later, she got another call from someone different at PIP, who told her that they were going to award her enhanced daily living and lower mobility.

I think it may have been connected with the fact that about 6 weeks before the first phone call, she had been awarded limited capability for work and work-related activity for her UC. The same thing had happened to a colleague's client, who was in the same position, a few weeks earlier. We suspect that they used information from that assessment in reaching their decision for PIP.

Artygirlghost · 23/11/2022 17:28

I had to take them to the tribunal stage and the tribunal ruled in my favour.

I had plenty of evidence from GP, hospital consultant and psychiatrist when I made my application as well as copies of tests results from MRIs and scans.

The DWP first claimed to have lost my initial form so I had to redo my application.

Then they said they had found it.

They then failed to book an assessment for me for months until I chased them on the phone.

Then at the assessment the person who conducted the interview completely ignored or distorted what I had told her and wrote something that had no resemblance whatsoever to my situation & contradicted medical advice & records.

So I was determined to go the tribunal stage and I won. They had to pay me thousands of pounds in backlog.

I would say that you need to be persistent as the private companies who got the contracts to assess people are often not fit for purpose and the whole system seems to be geared towards fobbing people off.

AllTheCoolThings · 23/11/2022 17:24

Windtunnel · 22/11/2022 21:02

I work in that area (not DWP) advising and filling in the forms. My boss told me they watch you the moment you get out of the car!

This was commented on on my first PIP report. While my mobility at that time was poor, I could walk slowly but painfully down the corridor. It was noted I walked with no issues, along with various other untruths. I asked for my 2nd medical assessment to be recorded, amazingly that came back accurate to what I had said.

It doesn't beat my DD's report though - Non-verbal ASD. Her universal credit assessor reported that she spoke accurately and clearly throughout the assessment! Since that experience I will always ask for it to be recorded Smile

Windtunnel · 23/11/2022 17:22

FluffyPancake · 23/11/2022 13:59

She’s half right. When they ask the question ‘how did you get here?’ It’s not to be nice. You need to say things like.

  1. I was dropped at the door by a friend as I struggled to walk from the car park
  2. I then used the lift the get to the second floor so I could have my appointment with you
  3. I parked in the disabled bay using my blue badge so I could be closer to the entrance as I can’t walk far
  4. It took me Xx mins to walk from xx to the front door as I got breathless
  5. My friend/spouse needed to support me in case I fell over
  6. I used a mobility aid to get to you

They don’t sit there gazing out the window as they need to be doing the assessments for other claimants.

It's just something my supervisor said!

Theonewiththecandles · 23/11/2022 17:19

I got standard rate for daily living earlier this year and found it quite plain sailing. As a pp said, you can find the guides online on the scoring, descriptors etc. They're judging it based on how you are on the majority of your days, so you have to be quite specific eg usually one or two days a week I am almost bedbound, three days a week I am a bit better but cannot venture far and I usually have two good days a week where I am able to wash/dress/cook normally.

It took a good while but I had a video assessment which turned into a phone assessment as the assessor was having technical trouble. She was actually really lovely and explained what will happen and was just over an hour on the phone. She sent the report to DWP almost straight away so I phoned up and asked for a copy, and it took about 3 more weeks for them to basically just agree with the report and award PIP for 3 years

RatSlave · 23/11/2022 16:45

I applied for PIP it took a while for me to get up the courage to even try and claim as it was for my mental health and I heard all the stories of people being turned down constantly. Prepared myself to be refused and to go to appeal and I got it straight away after a medical over the phone - High rate care and standard mobility. They're not always monsters.

Legallypinkish · 23/11/2022 16:07

Windtunnel · 22/11/2022 21:02

I work in that area (not DWP) advising and filling in the forms. My boss told me they watch you the moment you get out of the car!

I remember being sat with my son at his assessment. I watched a girl run a cross the road outside. She came into the reception and crumpled onto the floor asking for a chair saying she couldn’t walk. The receptionist had clearly seen her running in the street outside too. It was comical to say the least.

Legallypinkish · 23/11/2022 16:01

My son gets enhanced rate for both on PIP. No problems getting it. Forms were easy compared to the DLA forms, assessor was lovely.

x2boys · 23/11/2022 14:16

My 12 year old son has been getting DLA since he was three ,got medium rate cate for 13 years! With Lrate mobillity added on at five ,however it became apoarent that his nerds were very complex so to cut a long story short i enedd up doing a change of circimstances when he was nine and goiing to tribunsl he now gets High rate care and high rate mobility under SMI rules (severe autism and learning disabillities ) just renrw3d a few months ago renrewed for five yeats which will take him up to PIP..

Afterfire · 23/11/2022 14:10

FluffyPancake · 23/11/2022 13:54

Did you automatically get an ongoing award? I’ve got PIP but keep only getting 2 year awards despite having a lifelong condition which will never go away. I’ve told them that and they never change their minds.

Sorry to hear you get such short awards. I really don’t know how they decide these things. Yes, mine was completely automatic. I didn’t have to challenge anything.

WolvesOfTheCalla · 23/11/2022 14:08

I had a fucking awful experience with PIP, including being asked if I was so depressed, why I hadn't killed myself? Never mind that there was evidence in the application of me attempting just that. I was awarded MRC and LRM anyway, without the need for an MR or an appeal.

Anyway. I was dreading DDs DLA claim. It took months to fill in. 16 weeks for it to be assessed. The only other person they spoke to was her MH nurse. I was surprised when she was awarded HRC and LRM immediately, no MR, no appeal.

But my PIP assessment vs hers - mine was horrific, the report she wrote was a bunch of lies that she must have just sat down and made up off the top of her fucking head. Her DLA was fine - the assessor didn’t ask any horrible questions, seemed very on the ball with her specific issues.

ItsTheSmallThings · 23/11/2022 14:01

FluffyPancake · 23/11/2022 13:59

She’s half right. When they ask the question ‘how did you get here?’ It’s not to be nice. You need to say things like.

  1. I was dropped at the door by a friend as I struggled to walk from the car park
  2. I then used the lift the get to the second floor so I could have my appointment with you
  3. I parked in the disabled bay using my blue badge so I could be closer to the entrance as I can’t walk far
  4. It took me Xx mins to walk from xx to the front door as I got breathless
  5. My friend/spouse needed to support me in case I fell over
  6. I used a mobility aid to get to you

They don’t sit there gazing out the window as they need to be doing the assessments for other claimants.

🤣🤣 I have visions of some man in a black cloak and mask spying through a peep hole to see how we get out the car and up the road.

OP posts:
nokidshere · 23/11/2022 14:01

I got PIP for the first time 5yrs ago. I didn't send evidence, I simply filled in the form and out my Drs details. The assessor came to the house, she was polite and friendly although quiet. I got the award for 3yrs. When it was reviewed 2yrs ago it was just a phone call, they asked me a couple of questions then sent me a letter saying I had got the award and it would be 'ongoing' and they would contact me again in 2032.

It was easy and stress free.

FluffyPancake · 23/11/2022 13:59

Windtunnel · 22/11/2022 21:02

I work in that area (not DWP) advising and filling in the forms. My boss told me they watch you the moment you get out of the car!

She’s half right. When they ask the question ‘how did you get here?’ It’s not to be nice. You need to say things like.

  1. I was dropped at the door by a friend as I struggled to walk from the car park
  2. I then used the lift the get to the second floor so I could have my appointment with you
  3. I parked in the disabled bay using my blue badge so I could be closer to the entrance as I can’t walk far
  4. It took me Xx mins to walk from xx to the front door as I got breathless
  5. My friend/spouse needed to support me in case I fell over
  6. I used a mobility aid to get to you

They don’t sit there gazing out the window as they need to be doing the assessments for other claimants.

FluffyPancake · 23/11/2022 13:54

Afterfire · 22/11/2022 20:35

Positive here!

Both Ds and I accepted for high rate as ongoing awards, no issues whatsoever and neither of us needed an assessment- they judged it on the form alone and also spoke to my rheumatologist (I have lupus and lots of other conditions, son has autism and learning disabilities).

You just don’t hear about the positive stories as people have no reason to post about them.

Did you automatically get an ongoing award? I’ve got PIP but keep only getting 2 year awards despite having a lifelong condition which will never go away. I’ve told them that and they never change their minds.

Afterfire · 23/11/2022 13:52

If you do have an assessment make sure you ring and ask for a copy of their report. You can then see what they’ve said about you and if you need to appeal it will help you.

forlornlorna1 · 22/11/2022 21:10

I applied in January, sent in everything I had evidence wise, consultants letters, physio report, occupational health report etc. had a phone assessment in April and was awarded in may. Got a copy of my assessment report and it was accurate and fair.

I think you only really hear the bad experiences online really

GordonRamsaysBumCrack · 22/11/2022 21:07

My teen got awarded PIP via paper based assessment. After dreading the worst the process was straightforward. We were fully prepared for mandatory reconsideration and appeal.

Asher33 · 22/11/2022 21:02

ItsTheSmallThings · 22/11/2022 20:47

If anyone has had an assessment how was it? What was the assessor like? Is it like an interview?

She didn't have a clue. Decided that my consultant was a liar and so is my GP. And she decided before doing an eye test there's no medical reason why I can't drive. Virtually everyone with my diagnosis can't drive.

It's more of an interrogation than an interview. It's supposedly to get more information. They do it to try and catch you out.

Got 4 points on care and 0 on mobility. Got it looked at again and got standard care and enhanced mobility.

Windtunnel · 22/11/2022 21:02

I work in that area (not DWP) advising and filling in the forms. My boss told me they watch you the moment you get out of the car!

Friolero · 22/11/2022 21:02

We had a fairly positive experience, DS was awarded high rate mobility and mid rate care DLA at age 3 until he's 16, so no need to keep filling in the forms until he's due to switch to PIP.

Tirrrrred · 22/11/2022 20:53

ItsTheSmallThings · 22/11/2022 20:47

If anyone has had an assessment how was it? What was the assessor like? Is it like an interview?

The accessor seemed ok but reading the report made me think they had mixed me up with someone else. Lots of inaccuracies!!