Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ignore friends hints for money

333 replies

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 10:08

I have a friend who told me a couple of weeks ago on a night out that she had no money, and was in a bit of debt. She has two very young children and said she only had £30 to last a few weeks. I’d had a drink so didn’t think about the logistics behind her being out, but ended up settling our bill, DH also gave her £100 to get her through the week.

A few days later I lent her £500 but I’ve told her I can wait until after Christmas for the money back, seen as she has children and we are not struggling financially.

Since then she’s hinted a couple of times that she is really stressed / struggling mentally over this debt and only needs “x” amount more to be out of the red. I have said that she shouldn’t be getting into more debt to clear others but she just keeps reiterating how hard it is so I’ve started ignoring her.

I feel extremely guilty, but DH has said under no circumstances am I to give her any more money. He also doesn’t know it was £500 I lent her out of my savings, just that I lent money. I’m not working as I’m starting my own business, so DH is the only income we have so it is really up to him.

To add, since I have been ignoring her hints she hasn’t really messaged much, whereas she would usually text me multiple times a day/ call over for coffee etc.

I think I could have lost a friend over this, and we are only in the area a few months. DH works a lot and I don’t want to be lonely, but then another part of me thinks that she knows this and is trying to take advantage of me. What are your thoughts mumsnetters?

OP posts:
PalmLady · 22/11/2022 16:48

Dinoteeth · 22/11/2022 16:36

The loan would need to have been acknowledged by the other party. Thanks for the loan.

Sending a text means nothing. Anyone could send anyone a text saying they lent money and need it back.

If the borrower has sent a message saying that they need more time to pay back, isn't that enough for the loan to be acknowledged?

Dinoteeth · 22/11/2022 16:36

Dutchesss · 22/11/2022 16:29

Surely if the OP has it written in text messages that the money was a loan, then it would be simple enough to claim it back if OP needed to?
I'm not saying that it would necessarily be something to pursue, but I always thought that if it's in writing then it would be hard for a borrower to legally wiggle out of paying it back.

The loan would need to have been acknowledged by the other party. Thanks for the loan.

Sending a text means nothing. Anyone could send anyone a text saying they lent money and need it back.

Dutchesss · 22/11/2022 16:29

Surely if the OP has it written in text messages that the money was a loan, then it would be simple enough to claim it back if OP needed to?
I'm not saying that it would necessarily be something to pursue, but I always thought that if it's in writing then it would be hard for a borrower to legally wiggle out of paying it back.

pinkyredrose · 22/11/2022 16:10

euff · 22/11/2022 14:40

We are down over 50k due to BIL and SIL. We were supposed to get the larger loans back when they sold their business but we didn't. Found out later when the tap was turned off here BIL had gone round every other sibling for a few grand and then to cousins and then to friends for a few hundred here and there. The list is long. He would do it more than once and use money from one person to pay back another for an initial loan and then they would get bitten further down the line. We think it's horrible not to talk to people about it as it's 'shaming' someone but it helps them hide what they are doing and stops the next person from being taken in. If I were in genuine need I would be going to family and charities for help before people I don't know that well. I would also be doing whatever I could to keep my own costs down and pay family back. Also have another BIL who was lent a couple of grand a few months ago who came back and asked for a couple of hundred recently. I think he probably feels that we couldn't say no to a 'small' sum. DH said no and I know it was hard for him to do. The money we lost was inheritance and our income is only sufficient to meet our needs.

How the fuck did they get so much money out of you! 😮

Cailleachian · 22/11/2022 15:03

TBH, I think a bit of fault lies with you OP in your generosity.

When someone has no money and is struggling from week to week a sudden influx of £500 can disappear quickly on much needed things, because necessary purchases can be put off for a while, but when you have the cash, you can meet these needs.

But £500 is a lot for you, even with savings and a partner's income to rely on. Its an much bigger deal for someone in poverty, where the lack of money isnt a temporary blip, but a structural problem.

If it had been - say - £500 to pay for the first month's childcare to enable her to start earning, or £500 to move house to a cheaper rent, where the money would improve her structural situation, it would be reasonable to loan, otherwise your kindness is compounding her problems.

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 14:56

Yes, the OP isn't actually in a position to enforce repayment. The question is how she's going to respond to the situation, not whether she can materially change it.

Dinoteeth · 22/11/2022 14:52

OldFan · 22/11/2022 14:42

I wouldn't write it off and think it's ok for her to not pay it back.

Not unless you're absolutely minted and £500 doesn't matter in the slightest.

It's easy to say don't write it off, but HOW would you make her pay it back?

She can ask for it back but she'll be hit wait a string of excuses.
Op can't exactly take her to court. Op doesn't sound the sort to be friends with the local heavies.

Mumsanetta · 22/11/2022 14:51

“to the posters who asked if I’d met her friends, I have - I actually met her through mutual friends. Obviously I won’t be telling them at all, but it would be interesting to know if they’ve lent money too.”

Secrets allow people to get away with bad behaviours. You don’t have to be malicious about it but you should tell your friends because they are also your friends.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 22/11/2022 14:47

sjxoxo · 22/11/2022 14:23

@fdgdfgdfgdfg “I'd be bloody leaving you if you'd chucked £500 of family money at a friend without even talking to me about it first.”

You can’t be serious!!? You would get rid of your partner for the sake of £500??? Either you are mega tight with money or you don’t care that much about your marriage! It’s £500 not £50k

I clarified in a further post that I did leave someone over them loaning shared money to a friend. It was £3000 rather than £500, and it properly screwed us over, but it wasn't just about the money. This was something that affected us both, and she hadn't even spoken to me about it. I had to find out from bank statements.

Yes, it was a lot more money in my case, but OP has lent this money to someone she's only known for a few months. Its unlikely she'll get it back. If your partner walked up to you and burnt £500 in front of you, you'd think they were nuts and probably run away as fast as you could. This is no different really.

BobbyBobbyBobby · 22/11/2022 14:45

Unfortunately your kind hearted nature has been preyed upon and this woman sees you as being someone weak who she can tap for money.

To ignore friends hints for money
OldFan · 22/11/2022 14:42

I wouldn't write it off and think it's ok for her to not pay it back.

Not unless you're absolutely minted and £500 doesn't matter in the slightest.

euff · 22/11/2022 14:40

We are down over 50k due to BIL and SIL. We were supposed to get the larger loans back when they sold their business but we didn't. Found out later when the tap was turned off here BIL had gone round every other sibling for a few grand and then to cousins and then to friends for a few hundred here and there. The list is long. He would do it more than once and use money from one person to pay back another for an initial loan and then they would get bitten further down the line. We think it's horrible not to talk to people about it as it's 'shaming' someone but it helps them hide what they are doing and stops the next person from being taken in. If I were in genuine need I would be going to family and charities for help before people I don't know that well. I would also be doing whatever I could to keep my own costs down and pay family back. Also have another BIL who was lent a couple of grand a few months ago who came back and asked for a couple of hundred recently. I think he probably feels that we couldn't say no to a 'small' sum. DH said no and I know it was hard for him to do. The money we lost was inheritance and our income is only sufficient to meet our needs.

newnamequickly · 22/11/2022 14:40

I recall similar situation many years ago now. I was a SAHP and my husband was the main earner.

I'd lent a friend in similar circumstances £100. This was in the 1980's so it was a lot of money.

My husband found out and he was cross. I knew he'd say no so hadn't told him.

When the first repayment instalment didn't materialise (I was easy to avoid) he went to her house and formulated a repayment plan she would keep to. She repaid him, no one would dare do otherwise. She stopped asking for more loans.

I wouldn't have asked for it back. She needed it more that we did.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 22/11/2022 14:40

You sound very chill and kind, and she's a user. If she can't support her kids, why did she have them? Where is their father? Who was watching them while she was out drinking?

I don't think you'll see her money again but at least you now will see her coming and can dodge any further sob stories.

itsthefinalcountdown1 · 22/11/2022 14:39

You lost me at her being on a night out when she only had £30 to feed her two young children for the next couple of weeks. You've been a mug.

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 14:39

pompomdaisy · 22/11/2022 14:35

A fool and her partners money are soon parted!

You must have missed the bit where I said it was my savings. Not my husbands.

OP posts:
OldFan · 22/11/2022 14:39

YANBU OP, £500 is a lot. Definitely don't give her any more.

Sounds like she gets stuff on credit cards which is a big mistake, she needs to learn to budget- it is possible for those of us who are 'poor.'

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 14:37

sjxoxo · 22/11/2022 14:19

I think you’ve lent her some money as she needs it and that’s fine. She may not be able to pay you back.. she’s a good friend- fine.
The phrase ‘it’s up to DH as he’s the only one working’ bothered me though.. even then your finances should be joint so I don’t like the sound of that phrase personally. But I get what you meant… It doesn’t sound like you can afford to help her any more by giving money.
can you help her in other ways? Free childcare, help with meals or point her in the direction of places she could turn to? Can she get a job/do you know anyone who might be able to offer her a job? Why is she in this problematic situation - something sinister you could help her out of?
good luck. You could say to her you can’t afford any more money but you’re still there for her and can do XYZ. xx

I understand how that meant and luckily that’s not our dynamic - he wouldn’t ever make me ask for money and we do share everything other than savings we had before we met eachother, as we have never bothered to merge them. The majority of my savings are not in Sterling as we didn’t always live here, and so he asks me not to spend them and just to spend his wages as the exchange rate is so crap. DH works a blue collar job so had a period of time during covid where he didn’t work and so I was the sole earner, so I think it is generally quite balanced.

that’s why I would run spending by him…

she does have a part time job, I don’t think she could work much more hours than she does with the kids. I have also offered childcare etc previously but she has wanted it at her home but I’m too busy to spend the day sat in someone else’s home when I’ve things to get on with at my own 😂.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 22/11/2022 14:36

Well the money's gone. I did this once. This friend then did a moonlit flit. What came to light was that three months previous she had opened electric, gas accounts in my name as if I was a new tenant. That took some sorting out 🙈

pompomdaisy · 22/11/2022 14:35

A fool and her partners money are soon parted!

MeridianB · 22/11/2022 14:29

Lots of mentions of £500 but isn't it £600 as your DH gave her £100 the night you went out.

You won't see it again. I'm afraid I don't believe for a moment that she needs even more than that right now to feed her children, so she's clearly seeing how much she can get from you.

Please don't look at it as losing a friend. She's the one who has lost a friend.

willingtolearn · 22/11/2022 14:25

You're not a friend to her, you're a mark. Is that what you want to be?

sjxoxo · 22/11/2022 14:23

@fdgdfgdfgdfg “I'd be bloody leaving you if you'd chucked £500 of family money at a friend without even talking to me about it first.”

You can’t be serious!!? You would get rid of your partner for the sake of £500??? Either you are mega tight with money or you don’t care that much about your marriage! It’s £500 not £50k

sjxoxo · 22/11/2022 14:19

I think you’ve lent her some money as she needs it and that’s fine. She may not be able to pay you back.. she’s a good friend- fine.
The phrase ‘it’s up to DH as he’s the only one working’ bothered me though.. even then your finances should be joint so I don’t like the sound of that phrase personally. But I get what you meant… It doesn’t sound like you can afford to help her any more by giving money.
can you help her in other ways? Free childcare, help with meals or point her in the direction of places she could turn to? Can she get a job/do you know anyone who might be able to offer her a job? Why is she in this problematic situation - something sinister you could help her out of?
good luck. You could say to her you can’t afford any more money but you’re still there for her and can do XYZ. xx

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 14:16

OP you sound lovely honestly but I've been in your shoes and a long time later seruouosy regretted it when the person used me like a free ATM. She then dumped me entirely when I got cancer and couldn't work or earn money.

Wow.

Swipe left for the next trending thread