Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ignore friends hints for money

333 replies

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 10:08

I have a friend who told me a couple of weeks ago on a night out that she had no money, and was in a bit of debt. She has two very young children and said she only had £30 to last a few weeks. I’d had a drink so didn’t think about the logistics behind her being out, but ended up settling our bill, DH also gave her £100 to get her through the week.

A few days later I lent her £500 but I’ve told her I can wait until after Christmas for the money back, seen as she has children and we are not struggling financially.

Since then she’s hinted a couple of times that she is really stressed / struggling mentally over this debt and only needs “x” amount more to be out of the red. I have said that she shouldn’t be getting into more debt to clear others but she just keeps reiterating how hard it is so I’ve started ignoring her.

I feel extremely guilty, but DH has said under no circumstances am I to give her any more money. He also doesn’t know it was £500 I lent her out of my savings, just that I lent money. I’m not working as I’m starting my own business, so DH is the only income we have so it is really up to him.

To add, since I have been ignoring her hints she hasn’t really messaged much, whereas she would usually text me multiple times a day/ call over for coffee etc.

I think I could have lost a friend over this, and we are only in the area a few months. DH works a lot and I don’t want to be lonely, but then another part of me thinks that she knows this and is trying to take advantage of me. What are your thoughts mumsnetters?

OP posts:
Peteryougit · 22/11/2022 11:04

You have been more than generous.

Addicted2Kale · 22/11/2022 11:03

I don't why people are friends with people who aren't on an equal financial footing. This dynamic always occurs eventually.

WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff · 22/11/2022 11:03

Oh, people begging for money is so annoying. Me and my husband have struggled badly in the past, probably 15 years or more back, where we really struggled and were quite a bit in debt and we never ever asked anybody for any money, nor would we have accepted it.

We are OK now, but from the outside we look like doing quite well. We've got a lovely little house in a rural area, a 5 year-old car, and we have our head above water, we've got around £5000 pounds savings in the bank, and a little bit of surplus each month, but we're not absolutely rolling in it.

Also my husband has a job where, if he has any time off, he doesn't get paid except the 97 pounds a week sick pay. He actually had eight weeks off on the sick a year ago because he had to have an operation, and it really affected us financially. He lost what must have been a couple of thousand pounds in wages.

As I say on the outside, we look OK, and we don't complain about anything. In the last 2 years, THREE women at DH's workplace, three different single women in their 40s and 50s are always hinting at him about money. 'Oh, I'm so broke I can't afford my bills. I don't know how I'm going to feed my kids. I can't afford my electric and gas bill. You've got plenty of money haven't you? I'm really, really struggling. I can't even find the money for my rent.' They sing this tune to a couple of other men too. Just the men.

One woman - the one of the three whose kids have left home, he has known for about 10 years, and she has had four different boyfriends in that time and has never been without a man until March this year when her most recent one dumped her. Every single one of them have never lived with her but have paid her rent, bought her mobile phones and jewellery and flashy luxury goods. Half the money she earned has been pin money.

She is 53. And single. Just lives on her own. Her 2 kids are adults now and moved out about 9-10 years ago. She has been single now for 8 months and she can't seem to find a new boyfriend anymore, and she's done nothing for the last six or seven months but hint at my husband and two other men at work that she needs money. One single man, and other two (incl DH) are married. She's actually looking to them to give her money. It's most bizarre. Some people are just absolutely bloody shameless.

@Moneylender Tell 'friends' like this that you have no money to lend them

LadyKenya · 22/11/2022 11:02

Surely the husband would be curious as to how much was given to this person?

SmileyClare · 22/11/2022 11:01

She shouldn’t keep hinting and asking, it puts you as a kind hearted person in the difficult position of saying No and feeling bad about that.

You could put a little Christmas box together if you feel sympathetic towards her children. A couple of selection boxes, some Christmas food treats, crackers or whatever.

As already suggested, point her in the direction of charities or the Citizen’s advice bureau for debt advice and to check she is claiming the benefits she’s entitled to.

Perhaps she is desperate , with no support and really struggling to afford life, and feels dreadful to ask, perhaps she wastes money and is taking advantage.

I doubt you know her well enough to judge her intentions.

Ragwort · 22/11/2022 11:00

You will never see that money again ... we've (stupidly) done the same thing - twice Blush lent two separate people - one a family member - fairly large sums to pay their deposit on a rental otherwise they would have had nowhere to live ... we never saw the money again.

If your friend is really struggling help her to get in touch with the local Food Bank, Citizens Advice, Christians Against Poverty or similar organisations.

Mooshroo · 22/11/2022 10:59

She doesn’t need X amount to get out of the red, she’s still in the red but you’re the lender now instead of a bank etc. That indicates to me she doesn’t intend to repay.

Tsort · 22/11/2022 10:58

Goldpaw · 22/11/2022 10:55

If DH is really tight with money as you say, then why did he give her £100?

That doesn't sound like the type of thing someone who would "peel an orange in his pocket" would do.

Agreed. He doesn’t sound tight at all.

OP, do you think ‘tight’ = ‘will not let me give away all our money in my bid to purchase friends’?

If you’re worried about being lonely, maybe get a job?

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 10:57

Talia99 · 22/11/2022 10:45

Sadly I think she saw you coming a mile off. Do you have anything in writing about the debt? I doubt she has any intention of paying you back anyway but if you just handed over the cash, you will have difficulty showing it wasn’t a gift.

I think you need to tell your husband what a large amount you handed over. He has probably assumed it’s around £50 or so since as a frugal person he would probably assume no one would give more than that to someone they barely knew with no proper repayment plan in place. I know it was your savings but if he is financially supporting you while you get your business off the ground, he needs to know.

Yes we arranged over text because I said I will check what I can lend etc.

I don’t think DH wants to hear about it at all, I did tell him straight away that I’d lent money but he said he didn’t want to know anything about it (probably annoyed). I wouldn’t put him at a loss if I don’t receive it back either. I’m really lucky that he is supporting me so I absolutely should have ran it past him first.

to the posters who asked if I’d met her friends, I have - I actually met her through mutual friends. Obviously I won’t be telling them at all, but it would be interesting to know if they’ve lent money too.

OP posts:
Somethingscanwait · 22/11/2022 10:57

I’m not normally prone to snark but is this really an AIBU, or is it a ‘please tell me what a wonderful person I am’ Hmm

Goldpaw · 22/11/2022 10:55

If DH is really tight with money as you say, then why did he give her £100?

That doesn't sound like the type of thing someone who would "peel an orange in his pocket" would do.

dontputitthere · 22/11/2022 10:55

So she's out on the piss but has no money to feed her kids.

I mean... come on.

I bet if you said no to her she'd soon fuck off out of your life onto the next chump

You're never getting that money back though.

Jaybird43 · 22/11/2022 10:54

You are a kind soul, @Moneylender - just think, she could've done good things with that money (i.e. gifts for her children that otherwise could have gone without). I wouldn't lend anymore to her now, but you did a very nice thing x

oakleaffy · 22/11/2022 10:53

This woman goes on nights out while skint??

She leeches of others?

She's no friend.

She sounds like a seasoned blagger.

CoastalWave · 22/11/2022 10:53

:( That's £600 you're never getting back.

Ignore her demands etc.

Ask her when she intends to pay you back - set up a payment plan £50 a week. I wouldn't let her get away with it (she probably still won't but I would definitely attempt to get it back and threaten her with taking her to court)

Goldpaw · 22/11/2022 10:52

£500 is such a lot of money to give to someone, let alone someone you haven't known long.

Like others have said, you won't get it back, but at least you're prepared for that now and it won't come as a nasty shock after Christmas when she keeps making excuses.

You need to listen to your husband more and not be such an easy mark. And you need to tell him what you've done because hiding things from your husband is not the way to go, particularly when he's supporting you financially at the moment!

TrashyPanda · 22/11/2022 10:51

Why is she going on nights out if she is so poor?
(clearly she knew she could get you to pay)

she is happy to spend money on herself despite being in debt and that should tell you something about her.

Sparklesocks · 22/11/2022 10:49

No. She’ll keep asking as long as you keep giving. She can’t rely on you as an income source.

readingismycardio · 22/11/2022 10:47

I'm pretty sure you'll never get the £500 back and I'd be terribly pissed if DH gave away £500 out of savings.

Shlomping1234 · 22/11/2022 10:46

She was on a night out and only had £30 to last her and her kids a few weeks?? Then had £500 off you??
She's a CF that should get her priorities right! You're not likely to see that money again.

oakleaffy · 22/11/2022 10:46

@Moneylender Never, ever lend or give money to people like this.
It nearly always ruins friendships, Shakespeare was so right

Neither a borrower nor a lender be,
For loan oft loses both itself and friend. And borrower dulls the edge of husbandry.”

People who are routinely with the begging bowl out are absolutely not who you should be lending to.

If you want to support her as a charity case, give the money, but she's taking the p&ss in my opinion.

Talia99 · 22/11/2022 10:45

Sadly I think she saw you coming a mile off. Do you have anything in writing about the debt? I doubt she has any intention of paying you back anyway but if you just handed over the cash, you will have difficulty showing it wasn’t a gift.

I think you need to tell your husband what a large amount you handed over. He has probably assumed it’s around £50 or so since as a frugal person he would probably assume no one would give more than that to someone they barely knew with no proper repayment plan in place. I know it was your savings but if he is financially supporting you while you get your business off the ground, he needs to know.

billy1966 · 22/11/2022 10:43

Absolutely saw you coming.

I think you were very wrong to give her money when you are not working and without being honest with your husband.

I think that is very wrong.

It is highly unlikely you will see that money again.

You barely know this woman and you have decided to put her ahead of your husband.

If the situation was reversed and your husband was giving money away, I would think HE was very wrong.

Text her to ask her when she can repay the money so that you have a record of the loan.

You are going down a dangerous path when you hide giving money from the family pot without checking with the person filling the pot.

Have a rethink about this.

She is not worth causing problems in your relationship for.

JudgeRindersMinder · 22/11/2022 10:43

don’t give her any more -because you’re not getting the £500 back, you don’t need to buy friendships

Fancylike · 22/11/2022 10:43

You’ve got a kind heart, but she’s seen you coming a mile off as fresh blood to leech off. Has she introduced you to any other local friends, by the way? If no, it’s because she’s taken what she could from them and they’ve ditched her.