Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ignore friends hints for money

333 replies

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 10:08

I have a friend who told me a couple of weeks ago on a night out that she had no money, and was in a bit of debt. She has two very young children and said she only had £30 to last a few weeks. I’d had a drink so didn’t think about the logistics behind her being out, but ended up settling our bill, DH also gave her £100 to get her through the week.

A few days later I lent her £500 but I’ve told her I can wait until after Christmas for the money back, seen as she has children and we are not struggling financially.

Since then she’s hinted a couple of times that she is really stressed / struggling mentally over this debt and only needs “x” amount more to be out of the red. I have said that she shouldn’t be getting into more debt to clear others but she just keeps reiterating how hard it is so I’ve started ignoring her.

I feel extremely guilty, but DH has said under no circumstances am I to give her any more money. He also doesn’t know it was £500 I lent her out of my savings, just that I lent money. I’m not working as I’m starting my own business, so DH is the only income we have so it is really up to him.

To add, since I have been ignoring her hints she hasn’t really messaged much, whereas she would usually text me multiple times a day/ call over for coffee etc.

I think I could have lost a friend over this, and we are only in the area a few months. DH works a lot and I don’t want to be lonely, but then another part of me thinks that she knows this and is trying to take advantage of me. What are your thoughts mumsnetters?

OP posts:
Coffeetableposhbooks · 22/11/2022 11:57

I doubt you’re getting your money back and she’s binning you off. I can’t believe you gave someone you hardly know so much money and also didn’t tell your husband when he’s financially supporting uou,

you can’t buy friendship op.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 22/11/2022 11:56

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:48

You're right.
I had an ex who gave away 3 grand of joint money as a series of "loans" without telling me. I ended the relationship when I found out.
I saw the OPs first post and the red mist descended a bit and I posted without RTFT.
@Moneylender, apologies for sticking the boot in. Please tell your husband how much it was though, it'll be far better coming from you than if he spots it on the bank statements at some point in the future

ok so you wouldn't stand for your ex doing it but make allowances for the op doing it?

Sorry, not sure what you mean. Op isn't my partner, so its not for me to make allowances.

I've apologised for posting in anger when I should have read the whole thread, and offered some advice based on my previous situation. I'd have been a lot less likely to end the relationship had my ex been upfront rather than hide the situation.

Byelaws · 22/11/2022 11:54

Omg cannot believe people would ask their colleagues for money.

CarmenBizet · 22/11/2022 11:54

YABU to have given her so much money. That's ridiculous. Consider that money gone, a true friend would be awash with gratitude and not keep asking you for dosh, she's seen you coming. I bet she hasn't repaid any of it, made mention of repaying it or set up a payment plan.

Dillydollydingdong · 22/11/2022 11:52

It's never a good idea to lend money. Neither a borrower nor a lender be. It's a surefire way to lose friends.

GasPanic · 22/11/2022 11:52

Lending people money is nearly always a no win situation.

Normally you're better off just giving it to them if you want to help out.

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:50

Omg! That’s shocking! Does she still work there? I don’t know how she’d have the confidence to walk through the office - I’d be mortified

cfers don't have shame in the same way psychopaths have no remorse.

Scottishskifun · 22/11/2022 11:49

If she tries again then reply with contact details of debt charities. This will help her so much more then continually bailing her out long term.
Sort out a affordable repayment plan of £20 a month it will take a long time but also have the benefit of her learning debt management!

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 11:49

PollyAmour · 22/11/2022 11:47

What's the saying? Never lend money you can't afford to lose. She's probably borrowed money off all her friends, family and neighbours and you were her last post of call.

Write off the £500 and never lend money again. A woman I worked with asked me for £400 for childcare fees - I declined and later found she'd asked every single person in the department. Several had given her the full amount, so she had a lot of money in the bank by the end of the day, and no, she didn't pay anybody back.

Omg! That’s shocking! Does she still work there? I don’t know how she’d have the confidence to walk through the office - I’d be mortified!!

OP posts:
polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:48

You're right.
I had an ex who gave away 3 grand of joint money as a series of "loans" without telling me. I ended the relationship when I found out.
I saw the OPs first post and the red mist descended a bit and I posted without RTFT.
@Moneylender, apologies for sticking the boot in. Please tell your husband how much it was though, it'll be far better coming from you than if he spots it on the bank statements at some point in the future

ok so you wouldn't stand for your ex doing it but make allowances for the op doing it?

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 11:48

Talia99 · 22/11/2022 11:40

You may want to think about whether your husband is really mean or just fed up with you being overly open handed. Mean people who ‘peel an orange in their pocket’ don’t usually give £100 to strangers or agree to be the sole financial support of the family while their partner sets up a business.

I totally get what you’re saying, and will speak to him but I don’t think it is like it’s coming across. The imbalance in contributions is a new thing - I do have a lot of savings and have always worked. Now I’ve stopped to try this new business he is happy to support us while I try. He is a lovely kind and generous man, I call him mean in jest he would do anything for our family but just doesn’t have the sympathy for strangers that I stupidly do!

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 22/11/2022 11:47

NewIdeasToday · 22/11/2022 10:11

Well you haven’t lent her the money. You’ve given it to her. How would she ever be able to repay if she only had £30 to last a few weeks.

Given that she’s your friend and has kids I’d probably just accept that this money has gone. But I’d also explain that I won’t be in a position to give her any more.

This, I'm afraid.

You have been more than generous towards her. - Good heavens! She's had £600 from the two of you.

If she is genuine, then this extra debt will weigh very heavily on her and won't be good for her mental health. if she's not genuine, you continually subsidising her will not help her because she'll continue to spend beyond her means and leech off you, and nor will you keep her as a friend, because she will see you only as a cash cow.

It's hurtful I know,, but you may have to accept that she isn't a true friend to you. NewIdeas is right - tell her that you are sorry but that you aren't in a position yourself to let her haven more money. And in your heart write off what you have already given her. If you do ever get it back it will be a bonus..

PollyAmour · 22/11/2022 11:47

What's the saying? Never lend money you can't afford to lose. She's probably borrowed money off all her friends, family and neighbours and you were her last post of call.

Write off the £500 and never lend money again. A woman I worked with asked me for £400 for childcare fees - I declined and later found she'd asked every single person in the department. Several had given her the full amount, so she had a lot of money in the bank by the end of the day, and no, she didn't pay anybody back.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 22/11/2022 11:47

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/11/2022 11:38

Yeah I think OP realises now that she shouldn't have lent the money, no need to stick the boot in.

You're right.

I had an ex who gave away 3 grand of joint money as a series of "loans" without telling me. I ended the relationship when I found out.

I saw the OPs first post and the red mist descended a bit and I posted without RTFT.

@Moneylender, apologies for sticking the boot in. Please tell your husband how much it was though, it'll be far better coming from you than if he spots it on the bank statements at some point in the future

Sparklybutold · 22/11/2022 11:46

Personally your friend sounds she does need help. She has reached out and to have very generously given her a loan but if that was my friend who would also make some time to sit down with her and go through her finances and see what she can do practically. Step change are a fantastic organisation who will help her to do things to stop the debts rolling - such as contacting creditors on her behalf. People are struggling, more so now than ever and sadly we are not all made equal in terms of safety nets. Personally, your friend needs you. I would encourage you to reach out.

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 11:44

I would politely ask her when you can expect your £500 back.

jtaeapa · 22/11/2022 11:43

You’ve been very kind and naive, sorry to say. You have helped her massively and she’s smacked you in the face by a) wanting more and b) not bothering to text you. You are now just a cash cow to her and it’s likely you’ll have to accept your £500 is gone. You should not have lent it, but on the positive side, it’s best you learnt that now rather than making a bigger mistake later on. People like her prey on people like you.

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 11:43

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/11/2022 11:38

Yeah I think OP realises now that she shouldn't have lent the money, no need to stick the boot in.

Haha thank you! I absolutely do, of course I feel very stupid. Luckily my husband won’t leave me over £500. Jesus, no wonder divorce rates are so high 😉 😂.

but , as I said lesson learnt and I won’t be doing it again. And I of course wouldn’t have lent £500 if it would have set us back or made us short on anything, I’m not totally irresponsible but it is a ridiculous amount to give someone. I’m just clearly a sucker for a sob story.

I think I will let her get Xmas out of the way before bringing it up, and then say I need it - like the above poster said perhaps say that the business is costing more than we originally planned.

OP posts:
polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:41

Yeah I think OP realises now that she shouldn't have lent the money, no need to stick the boot in

yea save that for men who do this on mn, when a woman does it then it's because she's compassionate,caring etc...

Talia99 · 22/11/2022 11:40

You may want to think about whether your husband is really mean or just fed up with you being overly open handed. Mean people who ‘peel an orange in their pocket’ don’t usually give £100 to strangers or agree to be the sole financial support of the family while their partner sets up a business.

whattodo1975 · 22/11/2022 11:40

Moneylender · 22/11/2022 10:16

I know it’s silly to lend people money but I grew up SO poor and so I always try and help others out, and probably always the wrong way. DH is the opposite he also grew up very poor so holds onto everything 😂😂😂.

thank you all for telling me exactly what I needed to hear, she just has the sweetest children and it’s the thought of them going without that gets me.

You are poor too. You have limited income as you say in OP.

Your husband on the other hand seems to be doing ok, and you should consider yourself very fortunate to have a husband capable of financially supporting you whilst you set up a business.

To make your friends financial situation your husbands problem is a pisstake.

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:39

To all the people saying op was a good soul etc for giving her the 500 quid, if an op came on mn saying she was supporting her husband and he gave his friend 500 quid he'd be called a cock lodger and roasted.

SmileyClare · 22/11/2022 11:38

Fundays12 · 22/11/2022 11:27

No it doesn’t I have friends far worse of financially than me and friends far better of. Money has never come between us and never will.

I agree, “This dynamic” isn’t inevitable if friends have differing financial circumstances at all.

To add, I have three sisters and our lifestyles and income vary enormously. I’ve never asked for money from them and wouldn’t dream of dropping huge hints about my finances to garner money and sympathy.

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/11/2022 11:38

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 22/11/2022 11:36

I'd be bloody leaving you if you'd chucked £500 of family money at a friend without even talking to me about it first.

Such a stupid thing to do.

Yeah I think OP realises now that she shouldn't have lent the money, no need to stick the boot in.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 22/11/2022 11:36

I'd be bloody leaving you if you'd chucked £500 of family money at a friend without even talking to me about it first.

Such a stupid thing to do.