Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DD to contribute to cost of school trip?

87 replies

Badabingy · 22/11/2022 09:18

My 13 year old DD’s school announced this week that it’s arranging a trip next year abroad. It’s expensive (2k+), and comes after we’ve already signed her up for a ski trip for this school year. We’re in a fortunate position where we can afford it, and it seems lots of her friends are going. However, she seems to have an absolute expectation that she gets to go, and when we suggested that she might not be able to she had a strop. I spoke to her and explained that if she could put forward a proposal to ‘earn’ some of the money towards the trip by doing jobs around the house (I’m thinking about 10% of the cost, which would equate to less than an hour’s chores a week) then we’d consider it. She thinks we are being really unreasonable.

i grew up in a poor household and I’m continually astounded by her sense of entitlement. We try to keep her grounded but are not doing a very good job! When I was younger I missed an amazing trip at school and was absolutely gutted (funnily enough my mum told me a few years later that I’d just expected to be able to go and hadn’t offered to pay anything- if I had, they would have contributed the rest of the money).

I don’t want her to miss out but I don’t want her to think she can have expensive things like this handed to her in a plate.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Highfivemum · 22/11/2022 17:26

Half of me says to tell her NO she cannot go as it is expensive and she is already going on a trip this year.
she needs to pull her weight as she will grow up entitled and have a huge shock in the real world. Yes we want to give our DC all the best things but at what costs
my 9 year old is paying for Half his trip with school. He actually feels good that he is helping around the house and paying for it himself. I am not talking sending him up the chimneys but jobs like clear the table , empty dishwasher.
get her to change her attitude or don’t sign the form.

gogohmm · 22/11/2022 16:52

@polio999

DD's school offered a variety of trips, they didn't expect the same kids on every trip, there were 600 in her year alone (4 years in total, 2200 pupils)

Shouldershoddy · 22/11/2022 15:37

All three of mine went on the school skiing trip which we paid for but then one wanted to go on a trip into the Amazon rain forest working with researchers .
The cost of the trip was over £3000!!
Son was absolutely desperate to go so we agreed that we would pay half and he had to raise the other £1500 .
My son at the time wasn’t the most productive of people but he worked really hard working at BandQ ,cafe work and fundraising with his friends…luckily all parents on the same page and they all achieved it .
I was really pleased with him and his friends and they all felt a massive sense of achievement. So yes definitely get your daughter to contribute. Could be the making of her TBH .

HelsyQ · 22/11/2022 15:22

@Badabingy you’re daughter sounds as if she is acting a little spoilt in this scenario and you are combating that by teaching her the value of money. I think it sounds like you are being a good mum and it will help her in the long run.

Stripyhoglets1 · 22/11/2022 15:19

I would say she can go but has to make up the 10%.
Butvtjst if she does this there's no more ski trips or other big trips now at that school.
Certainly don't want her thinking she can go off skiing every year automatically.
Do you have other children to consider who you will need to fund trips for as well.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/11/2022 15:15

Why are you saying yes to both trips? Even with a buy in from her. Two incredibly expensive schools trips by the time she's what? In y8? Utter madness.

2bazookas · 22/11/2022 15:13

Good for you.

Children should understand they are part of a family economy, and share a concerted communal effort to get all the jobs done and dusted. So that EVERYONE has time and space to do stuff they really enjoy.

boboshmobo · 22/11/2022 14:28

The problem is with private schools is you may be ok for money but some will have bottomless pits so give their kids whatever they want . There will be an element of her panicking that her friends her stuff and if she doesn't she won't fit in .

Have you spoken to her about it ? I was spoilt as a child and it didn't do me any good tbh

Caspianberg · 22/11/2022 14:20

Whilst I think getting her to do chores and help contribute it’s a good idea, I don’t think it’s her fault the trips are so expensive if you have chosen private school.
Private schools don’t get additional funding for trips so all the money will be on the parents to pay, which you kind of signed up for.

Paq · 22/11/2022 14:11

YANBU. Unfortunately many teenagers have a sense of entitlement, whether or not they come from a privileged background.

It's really hard work for parents to make them see sense.

DuesToTheDirt · 22/11/2022 14:08

"I spoke to her and explained that if she could put forward a proposal to ‘earn’ some of the money towards the trip by doing jobs around the house (I’m thinking about 10% of the cost, which would equate to less than an hour’s chores a week)"

We did exactly this for one of the expensive trips our daughters. We made a list of chores that they wouldn't normally do, like washing the car, a list of payment for each, and a target sum, don't remember exactly how much. We said they could either pay the sum out of their savings/pocket money etc., or earn it by doing chores, or a combination. They were about 16 at the time. I don't think it was unreasonable, and they didn't either.

Badabingy · 22/11/2022 14:02

polio999 · 22/11/2022 10:11

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4680101-daughter-says-im-controlling?page=5&reply=121633751

op if you carry on the way you are consider the above thread a pretty accurate prediction of the future...

Oh god yes I can totally see this happening!

OP posts:
Badabingy · 22/11/2022 14:01

Thank you everyone for your views, really appreciated and am going to put my foot down.

It’s a private school and the trip is to the US (the ski trip is this school year, the new trip is next school year). Educational trips and activities are a big part of it but as another person said, I’m not sure that’s the part of the trip they will remember. Certainly I wouldn’t see it as a core part of any of her subjects.

thank you again.

OP posts:
fatherchr · 22/11/2022 14:00

Apparently we are mean compared to other parents

no you aren't, that's emotional blackmail. If you spoil her you'll raise an entitled brat as an adult, don't say you weren't warned.

Badabingy · 22/11/2022 13:58

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 22/11/2022 13:28

I’m going to go against the grain here and say that your daughter isn’t being entitled. She has an expectation that she’ll be able to go, and you’ll be able to pay, because it sounds like this is what you’ve always done. Her norm is to ask and you cover the costs.

Whenever we pay for anything big for ours, we remind them how lucky they are that we are able to afford whatever it might be. I also try and extend this down to extras, but smaller extras, eg they have a new Xmas jumper for Xmas jumper day at school, but not everyone does. We take things to the charity shop regularly and donate to a local collective for those in need. If they find cash in the street, it goes straight in the next charity box we see.

It is hard though, OP. Mine have way more than I had as a child. On the one hand, I don’t want them to miss out. On the other, I don’t want them to think everything will be handed to them on a plate.

Thanks, good to have the other side of the argument too! I don’t think we have always given in to her expectations though- there are constant battles (eg with phone, type of coat, the Victoria’s Secret pyjamas she wants for Christmas, - argh- where we do say no to her. Apparently we are mean compared to other parents…!). And school trips haven’t been an issue really until now as they weren’t happening due to Covid.

OP posts:
fatherchr · 22/11/2022 13:56

Who gives a fuck? Of all the reasons why you may or may not contact a school about an issue, how cowardly would you have to be to worry about gossiping teachers

because if there is ever a genuine thing then directly affecting op's daughter then at the school the school won't take you as seriously if you complain over something like a school trip. Pick your battles. The trip will go ahead regardless whether a parent moans about it so why bother?

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 22/11/2022 13:28

I’m going to go against the grain here and say that your daughter isn’t being entitled. She has an expectation that she’ll be able to go, and you’ll be able to pay, because it sounds like this is what you’ve always done. Her norm is to ask and you cover the costs.

Whenever we pay for anything big for ours, we remind them how lucky they are that we are able to afford whatever it might be. I also try and extend this down to extras, but smaller extras, eg they have a new Xmas jumper for Xmas jumper day at school, but not everyone does. We take things to the charity shop regularly and donate to a local collective for those in need. If they find cash in the street, it goes straight in the next charity box we see.

It is hard though, OP. Mine have way more than I had as a child. On the one hand, I don’t want them to miss out. On the other, I don’t want them to think everything will be handed to them on a plate.

RedHelenB · 22/11/2022 12:53

You can afford it, her friends are going I don't see why it needs to be such a big deal. Different if it stretched you financially. 1

sheepdogdelight · 22/11/2022 12:48

I think the concept of a 13 year old (who can't really earn their own money) paying for a trip is odd. You are either prepared to pay for it or you're not. I think 2 expensive trips in 2 years is a lot - but that's up to you.

The chores around the house things is separate - our DC have always been expected to do chores because they are part of living in this family. They aren't negotiable, and they aren't paid. I think that paying for routine chores sets a bad example - that they are optional and should be paid for!

One off "bigger" tasks that are out of the ordinary/you might otherwise have paid someone to do are different - for example we paid DS to paint our garage recently. However, I suspect you won't have enough of these tasks in a year for DD to earn any sizeable amounts of money. You will also be very much in the minority amongst her peers as I doubt very much that others will be expecting a 13 year old to contribute.

Soproudoflionesses · 22/11/2022 12:33

ButterCrackers · 22/11/2022 10:32

I would be having a word with the school about teaching the pupils the value of money. A ski trip, another school trip plus I suppose other costs. The school could do local visits surely and activities at school. No need for this costly trip. You are right to point out the cost and have your daughter helping around the home.

My dd's primary school already do this when they annouce a trip- they teach them not to assume which is much appreciated. Obvs we do this at home too.

Hillarious · 22/11/2022 12:23

We asked our secondary school to give us notice of proposed trips throughout each of our kids' five years there, rather than finding out about them piecemeal. I was quite happy to pay for each of them to go on the ski trip, given we're not a family which skis every year. Knowing what was on the agenda gave me the ability to turn down the sports trip to France in Year 7 and the trip to Iceland in Year 10 because they knew I would be saying yes to the activity trip to the Peak District in Year 8 and the ski trip in Year 11. Father Christmas had a lot to contribute to the trips!

FourTeaFallOut · 22/11/2022 11:57

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:06

I would be having a word with the school about teaching the pupils the value of money. A ski trip, another school trip plus I suppose other costs. The school could do local visits surely and activities at school. No need for this costly trip. You are right to point out the cost and have your daughter helping around the home

Do not talk to the school about this. You'll just sound like an interfering parent with too much time on your hands, it will have no impact on their decision and if the need arises that you must address something with the school it will greatly undermine you as you''ll be remembered as ''that parent''.

Who gives a fuck? Of all the reasons why you may or may not contact a school about an issue, how cowardly would you have to be to worry about gossiping teachers?

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:06

I would be having a word with the school about teaching the pupils the value of money. A ski trip, another school trip plus I suppose other costs. The school could do local visits surely and activities at school. No need for this costly trip. You are right to point out the cost and have your daughter helping around the home

Do not talk to the school about this. You'll just sound like an interfering parent with too much time on your hands, it will have no impact on their decision and if the need arises that you must address something with the school it will greatly undermine you as you''ll be remembered as ''that parent''.

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:03

If the trip is not educational and is basically a bit of a "jolly" like the ski trip, then there's no reason why she should be going at all

Unless it's a Geography field trip that is directly part of the curriculum or maybe seeing an English play, school trips are rarely if ever ''educational''. There might be some historical sight seeing but on the face of it it is mostly a jolly trip for them. I went on 1 and we had speakers talking to us at the historical site seeing places but we were all teens and didn't listen to a word. We were more interested in the fun and shenanigans.

TabithaTittlemouse · 22/11/2022 10:43

Of course she should be doing more to contribute.
She does extra or doesn’t go. Simple.