Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DD to contribute to cost of school trip?

87 replies

Badabingy · 22/11/2022 09:18

My 13 year old DD’s school announced this week that it’s arranging a trip next year abroad. It’s expensive (2k+), and comes after we’ve already signed her up for a ski trip for this school year. We’re in a fortunate position where we can afford it, and it seems lots of her friends are going. However, she seems to have an absolute expectation that she gets to go, and when we suggested that she might not be able to she had a strop. I spoke to her and explained that if she could put forward a proposal to ‘earn’ some of the money towards the trip by doing jobs around the house (I’m thinking about 10% of the cost, which would equate to less than an hour’s chores a week) then we’d consider it. She thinks we are being really unreasonable.

i grew up in a poor household and I’m continually astounded by her sense of entitlement. We try to keep her grounded but are not doing a very good job! When I was younger I missed an amazing trip at school and was absolutely gutted (funnily enough my mum told me a few years later that I’d just expected to be able to go and hadn’t offered to pay anything- if I had, they would have contributed the rest of the money).

I don’t want her to miss out but I don’t want her to think she can have expensive things like this handed to her in a plate.

AIBU?

OP posts:
daisyjgrey · 23/11/2022 09:17

My daughter - state school - is doing all the trips that have been offered. There are a lot, and this academic year they total about 2.5k (four trips) and the next academic year there is currently one booked that is 1.8k.

The ones that are happening this academic year I've been paying for in instalments since about last May, as have most other parents who's children are going.

There is no pressure to go from the school and there are different mixes of children going on the trips from multiple years. Some of the trips have more educational trips than others, some just look like they'd be loads of fun.

I only have one child, and when I/we go abroad we tend to do city breaks so it's a different type of holiday. Plus it's brilliant for her to travel in a supported, safe way but without her parent.

She's lucky, and she knows she is, and I'm glad that she's not developed a sense of entitlement past not being keen on tidying her room (yet).

I think if you can afford it then things like this are so good for them, seeing other countries, experiencing other cultures, the food, climates etc.

Kagusta · 23/11/2022 09:11

@Testina yes my son is at uni, in private halls of residence and even for £7.3k a year there is no dishwasher.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 23/11/2022 09:09

FourTeaFallOut · 22/11/2022 09:33

A school ski trip and a 2k school trip in the same year? Is this a state school?

Exactly.

I’m continually astounded by her sense of entitlement
You are contributing to that tho OP, no way would my DC have gone on 2 expensive trips in one year and we could have afforded it.
When my DC did go on more expensive trips (although nothing like a £2k ski trip), all their birthday and Christmas gifts from us and family were things for the trip (clothes/suitcase/rucksack etc) or spending money.

Whether she goes on the other trip or not of course is your decision to make. It would be a no from me!
You need to be more assertive with her, any chores she does to 'earn' the trip need to be on top of what is regularly asked to do.

Testina · 23/11/2022 09:04

@Kagusta “washing up afterwards (no dishwashers at uni)”

Oh bless you. Are you perhaps living in that sweet spot where your own uni days were 90s and your children are young teens?

Have you seen typical student blocks these days? 🤣

Kagusta · 23/11/2022 08:55

I know it seems obvious to us adults but have you ever sat her down and explained that chores are part of being an adult and she is an adult in training. That at some point, probably at 18, she will be shopping for food, cooking, washing up afterwards (no dishwashers at uni) traipsing her laundry to the launderette, washing, drying and putting all her washing away, cleaning her room and bathroom when it is her turn, emptying the kitchen bins, managing her finances and on top of all of that, uni work. She starts with small stuff now and builds it up although by 13 she hopefully has quite a few chores to do.

As I am a sahm I have done a "bring your child to work day" and made sure I included all the really nasty stuff like cleaning the dishwasher trap which ensured they scraped their plates properly and cleaned the underside of the dishwasher seal that never gets fully cleaned even on a cleaning cycle. Get her to look up minimum wage for a child of her age and see what she can earn in an hour. Pay her that. We call this every day maths. How many hours would she have to work to earn that 10%. Teach her the value of money.

Chores that are done with attitude result in a loss of a privilege in this house, so whatever she values most. Any back chatting or attitude that she wouldn't dare do to a teacher results in the same. Bring it down to basics, you do what I want, you get what you want. Worked in this house.

sheepdogdelight · 23/11/2022 08:50

I do think it’s unfair to pile on like this teen is some entitled brat for thinking it’s OK to have two expensive trips in two separate academic years. It’s her parents who chose the school, and put her in that environment.

Agree - and her parents who said she could go on both! I always think on the private school threads where people post that they won't be able to afford all the extras that posters are being disingenuous by coming in and saying that not everyone goes and it's totally fine. It hurts as a child if you are missing out on something that all your peers are automatically getting. I applaud OP's aim to make her daughter appreciate that she is lucky and not everyone gets what she does; unfortunately I really don't think that paying to do normal jobs round the house is the way to do it. If she was older she could of course contribute from a part time job as some posters have noted that their older DC did. At 13, it's pretty much a case of you get what your parent choose to give you. Your point about no birthday present as token towards the trip (though I'm disappointed to learn you don't move in circles where 2K is the norm for presents :) ) is probably a better idea, but I suspect this might still just rearranging the deckchairs if OP's DC will still get a new phone or new clothes or whatever else she might have got as a birthday present, it just won't be packaged as such.

This thread slightly hits a nerve because I was the "poor " child at private school. My parents paid for the trips, but I didn't get anything other than basics at home, which marked me out to my peers in a different way. Somehow I suspect OP won't be telling her DD she can't have new clothes or not go on other than very cheap outings with her friends as she's getting a trip - which would be the way to make her see the value of money (if unpleasant, as I can vouch for).

jtaeapa · 23/11/2022 08:50

She’s 13 and you can afford it. Just let her go and have a lovely time with her mates. People on here are like Victorian taskmasters.

(And yes I have brought up 2 teens older than this).

BecauseICan22 · 23/11/2022 08:48

I think the ski trip is ample. There is a lesson here, we don't always get what we want, we need to practice gratitude and we must be proactive in our own lives to support them, irrelevant of age.

The fact that you recognise her entitlement is good and shows that you're a good parent and you're not burying your head in the sand like so many others do.

Your daughter is only reacting in a way she has become accustomed to and that reaction alone would get the trip taken away if it was one of my DC's.

How much insight does she have into how much things cost? Or how hard you work to make those things happen or how blessed she is to have what she has?

ButterCrackers · 23/11/2022 08:47

Testina · 23/11/2022 08:41

@ButterCrackers OP didn’t say until after you posted, but it’s a private school. They’re not going to reduce the number of big trips - it’s a selling point for their customers!
OP chose a school with this kind of programme.

Thanks for explaining. I’m not sure what’s best in this situation. I’d still be showing the kids the costs but it’s a different world. Perhaps they could explain the minimum wage and that people have to live off of that.

Testina · 23/11/2022 08:43

@Thereisnolight “Fundraising? For a holiday? Now that’s teaching entitlement.”

Yep. Nothing like a bit of voluntourism paid for by others 🙄

Testina · 23/11/2022 08:41

ButterCrackers · 22/11/2022 10:32

I would be having a word with the school about teaching the pupils the value of money. A ski trip, another school trip plus I suppose other costs. The school could do local visits surely and activities at school. No need for this costly trip. You are right to point out the cost and have your daughter helping around the home.

@ButterCrackers OP didn’t say until after you posted, but it’s a private school. They’re not going to reduce the number of big trips - it’s a selling point for their customers!
OP chose a school with this kind of programme.

Thereisnolight · 23/11/2022 08:39

Shouldershoddy · 22/11/2022 15:37

All three of mine went on the school skiing trip which we paid for but then one wanted to go on a trip into the Amazon rain forest working with researchers .
The cost of the trip was over £3000!!
Son was absolutely desperate to go so we agreed that we would pay half and he had to raise the other £1500 .
My son at the time wasn’t the most productive of people but he worked really hard working at BandQ ,cafe work and fundraising with his friends…luckily all parents on the same page and they all achieved it .
I was really pleased with him and his friends and they all felt a massive sense of achievement. So yes definitely get your daughter to contribute. Could be the making of her TBH .

Fundraising? For a holiday? Now that’s teaching entitlement.

Bumpsadaisie · 23/11/2022 08:38

Hmm.

My DD is 13 and she's not going on the £900 languages trip all her mates are going on because we can't afford it - She hasn't had a strop though.

If your DD is already going on a ski trip she's v privileged already.

I think you're wise to talk with her about it and think with her about entitlement.

Caravanheaven22 · 23/11/2022 08:35

ButterCrackers · 22/11/2022 10:32

I would be having a word with the school about teaching the pupils the value of money. A ski trip, another school trip plus I suppose other costs. The school could do local visits surely and activities at school. No need for this costly trip. You are right to point out the cost and have your daughter helping around the home.

Why on earth is it the school's issue? They are offering opportunities, the pupils don't have to go. And the vast majority won't go

Lopilo · 23/11/2022 08:30

children naturally have expectations according to their environment and how their family spends money. I grew up in an extremely poor country and think most people in the uk seem incredibly entitled. It is all relative and we are all guilty of it.

Testina · 23/11/2022 08:28

sheepdogdelight · 23/11/2022 08:07

That’s the norm in my Y9’s social circle (state school but generally reasonably off parents) - big trips become birthday presents.

2K on a birthday present? Blimey. I guess your point about people living their school norm is spot on. I suspect the country norm is more likely parents not being able to afford the trip full stop or possibly scrimping and saving for one trip during the whole time in secondary school.

@sheepdogdelight I didn’t mean that if they didn’t go on the £2K trip they’d get a full £2K birthday present instead! 🤣
Just as a contribution, so that they’re genuinely saving the parent money, and giving up something to do so.

Birthday present cost among my Y9’s friends is really variable, and it’s not the same every year. But, as an example one friend has been given a £100 concert ticket. The real cost to the parent is higher, as they’ve had to buy themselves a ticket and there’ll be a hotel too. Of course, it’s also fun for the parent! She’s been told - no birthday party. Parents could afford both, but they want her to see that there isn’t money to burn.

So no £2K birthday present - but knowing that because you’re on a £2K trip, you’re not getting the £100 present you might have got.
It’s not the exact money so much as the understanding of choices and not always getting it all.

Right back when mine were pre-schoolers, sometimes I’d refuse sweets or a magazine explaining, “I don’t have enough money for that this week.” I was lucky that that was never true - but I think it’s good for kids to grow up hearing the sounds of a budget being consulted and no bottomless pit!

I do think it’s unfair to pile on like this teen is some entitled brat for thinking it’s OK to have two expensive trips in two separate academic years. It’s her parents who chose the school, and put her in that environment. Doesn’t mean she should get everything and she needs guidance to appreciate what she has.

I was recently around a private school girl who had just done a sports tour in South Africa. She referred to an upcoming Paris trip as, “not a proper trip”. Not in a shitty way, just I suppose like an adult might feel they hadn’t been “on holiday” after a long weekend in the U.K. compared to a week in Spain. My daughter was there, and afterwards I told her that I never wanted her to feel that 3 days in Paris didn’t count as a proper trip! We talked then about the environment you’re in - that girl was lovely, not an entitled brat at all. But her expectations and what a “proper trip” looked like were entirely down to her parents’ choices, not hers.

Diverseopinions · 23/11/2022 08:25

ButterCrackers

Absolutely.

Quitelikeacatslife · 23/11/2022 08:18

With my dd ski trip, there was no big birthday or Christmas presents for the year before, all ski gear was Christmas presents.
Instead of laying down the law ask her how can she raise some money, what is fair? I mean nothing is not an option, but she is old enough to realise you are not kidding here

CaronPoivre · 23/11/2022 08:13

We were in a similar position when our eldest wanted to go with her (state) school to Russia having already been to France and Poland that year. We made her contribute a token amount of her allowance and to save her own spending money. She babysat for us, cleaned our cars and earned from teaching sailing.

Thinking back, it was the right thing to do and probably added to her enjoyment knowing she had earned it.

TWAWmearse · 23/11/2022 08:11

Bookworm20 · 22/11/2022 10:15

I think the fact she is already going on the ski trip is surely enough?

And the fact she had a strop when you said she may not be able to go and then resented having to contribute towards it. She is 13, yes, and lets face it alot of 13 years olds can be a bit blinkered about the cost of things, but it sounds like she has pretty much always got what she wanted and therein lies the issue. She simply isn't used to being told it might not be an option? I'm just guessing here, based on her reaction.

I would definitely say she can only go is she contributes a certain amount towards it. And I'd certainly make it more than 10% given she is already having a ski trip paid for.

We were in a similar position, my DD school was doing an expensive trip (it was £1500). I however could not justify that cost for 1 dc. And I certianly could not afford that sort of trip for all of them. DD was the one who suggested she pay £1000 if I was able to pay the £500. She really wanted to go and knew it was unreasonable to just demand I pay for it, so thats what we agreed on. She was 14, so similar age but she did have a part time job at the weekends, and then also picked up extra babysitting work to help towards it. She ended up paying around £800, as just couldn't make up the full amount, which I let her off of as she had definitely worked hard to save what she had.

That’s brilliant.

We’re in a similar situation with dd (who can be a bit entitled) going on two expensive trips next year. I think I’m going to make her earn some money towards them on the back of this thread!

User38899953 · 23/11/2022 08:09

I would be saying no, regardless of whether I could afford it.

Your daughter needs to learn that she can't have everything, particularly as she doesn't seem to appreciate it

sheepdogdelight · 23/11/2022 08:07

That’s the norm in my Y9’s social circle (state school but generally reasonably off parents) - big trips become birthday presents.

2K on a birthday present? Blimey. I guess your point about people living their school norm is spot on. I suspect the country norm is more likely parents not being able to afford the trip full stop or possibly scrimping and saving for one trip during the whole time in secondary school.

Testina · 23/11/2022 07:58

You have actively chosen to send her to a private school where actually it most likely becomes true that, “all my friends are going”. So I think you have to keep that in mind. This isn’t an entitled child wanting all of the once in a “school lifetime” trips - it’s a child living the school norm that you’ve chosen for her.

I disagree with making her do chores to go, for two reasons:

  1. I disagree with chores for money - including pocket money - anyway. You lived here, you contribute. Chores are an expectation of life in my household.
  2. It’s not logical - the extra chores don’t actually create the money to pay for this trip. It’s not like you’re cancelling the cleaner because she’s taking over and putting £30 a week to it. It just looks like you’re punishing her, for being born to parents who can afford nice things. (and she will be surrounded by 13yo’s who want VS pyjamas - and get them)

I would say yes to the trip - isn’t it part of why you chose the school? But her financial contribution would be real - I would tell her that it was her birthday present. Probably not Xmas as that’s a shared gifting time. But birthday - yes. That’s the norm in my Y9’s social circle (state school but generally reasonably off parents) - big trips become birthday presents.

unkownone · 23/11/2022 07:56

If i had the money I’d do …for an extra bit of quiet 🤣 but I’d explain I’m happy to pay but help out more, no attitude or there’s no trip.

sheepdogdelight · 23/11/2022 07:45

Highfivemum · 22/11/2022 17:26

Half of me says to tell her NO she cannot go as it is expensive and she is already going on a trip this year.
she needs to pull her weight as she will grow up entitled and have a huge shock in the real world. Yes we want to give our DC all the best things but at what costs
my 9 year old is paying for Half his trip with school. He actually feels good that he is helping around the house and paying for it himself. I am not talking sending him up the chimneys but jobs like clear the table , empty dishwasher.
get her to change her attitude or don’t sign the form.

I'd expect a 9 year old to be doing jobs like clearing the table and emptying the dishwasher without being paid for them tbh. When he's "paid" for the trip does he get to stop doing those things?