Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DD to contribute to cost of school trip?

87 replies

Badabingy · 22/11/2022 09:18

My 13 year old DD’s school announced this week that it’s arranging a trip next year abroad. It’s expensive (2k+), and comes after we’ve already signed her up for a ski trip for this school year. We’re in a fortunate position where we can afford it, and it seems lots of her friends are going. However, she seems to have an absolute expectation that she gets to go, and when we suggested that she might not be able to she had a strop. I spoke to her and explained that if she could put forward a proposal to ‘earn’ some of the money towards the trip by doing jobs around the house (I’m thinking about 10% of the cost, which would equate to less than an hour’s chores a week) then we’d consider it. She thinks we are being really unreasonable.

i grew up in a poor household and I’m continually astounded by her sense of entitlement. We try to keep her grounded but are not doing a very good job! When I was younger I missed an amazing trip at school and was absolutely gutted (funnily enough my mum told me a few years later that I’d just expected to be able to go and hadn’t offered to pay anything- if I had, they would have contributed the rest of the money).

I don’t want her to miss out but I don’t want her to think she can have expensive things like this handed to her in a plate.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Irritateandunreasonable · 10/04/2023 22:32

Testina · 10/04/2023 19:13

@Irritateandunreasonable Oh bore off zzzzz

🤣🤣🤣 couldn’t bring yourself to say, “oooops!” then?

Weirdo.

Testina · 10/04/2023 19:13

@Irritateandunreasonable Oh bore off zzzzz

🤣🤣🤣 couldn’t bring yourself to say, “oooops!” then?

savingmysanity · 10/04/2023 16:11

When I was about 14/15 I went on a school trip to Italy, to pay my way I had to do the laundry and ironing for our family of five for an entire year. Seemed reasonable then seems reasonable now

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/04/2023 15:51

Guess as it's a private school the trip £2k is costing less then a terms fees / often £3/4k

So children will want /expect it

But yes making them pay towards a holiday/trip is essential imo

So that they don't expect trips like this all the time

If they want to go they need to earn /spend some of their money

christmastreefarm · 10/04/2023 14:19

My y11 came home to tell me about a school trip when she is in Y13. Haven't got cost yet but I am estimating £2-2.5k

She wants to go and I have told her that if it's in that region I am happy for her to do it but I expect her to be contributing approx 1/3 of the cost and any spending money.

She is happy with this and knows than I cannot afford to pay the whole lot.

My parents did same for me - I paid half the cost of school trip which was the only way I was able to go.

SittingOnTheChair · 10/04/2023 14:02

euff · 22/11/2022 09:51

Oh wow, I know not the point but what is this trip? My Dd is only in year 8 and not had any trips brought up yet. I was expecting expensive and been told to expect 1k but not 2k! Is this normal?
I'm sorry no advice for dealing with the entitlement, maybe because her peers get all that? I think it's different as my DD would know that affordability is a factor for us.

Depends on the school. My DD went to the Galápagos Islands! Cost a small fortune.

I think its fair she earns something towards it. I'd type up a sheet stating the job that need doing and how much she will earn from doing them.

Irritateandunreasonable · 10/04/2023 13:30

Testina · 10/04/2023 13:00

@Irritateandunreasonable that’s not my grumpy face 🤣
I’m still vaguely curious what led you to bump a months old thread though and not even read it and make a comment irrelevant to private schools!

Oh bore off zzzzz

WandaWonder · 10/04/2023 13:06

We pay for school costs because to us,it is part of school, our teenager was going to go on a overseas trip but covid stopped that

Our teenager have never acted entitled and is appreciative so we happily pay, and if this behaviour continues we will do so

Testina · 10/04/2023 13:00

@Irritateandunreasonable that’s not my grumpy face 🤣
I’m still vaguely curious what led you to bump a months old thread though and not even read it and make a comment irrelevant to private schools!

Irritateandunreasonable · 10/04/2023 10:05

Testina · 10/04/2023 09:06

@Irritateandunreasonable “What terrible advice! The more people that talk to the school the better, it’s outrageous to organise a 2k trip and they should be called out on it.”

Why did you bump a months old thread and not even read the OP posts properly?!!
🙄

It’s a private school. This is part of the point why people pay for them… they want the £2K ski trips. Nothing outrageous about it at all!

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 go back to bed and get some more sleep grumpy 🤣🤣🤣

MyAnacondaMight · 10/04/2023 09:30

OP, this is on you. You speak of “giving in” to her expectations, but you have created these expectations. If the money is (to her) seemingly endless, for both her and her peers, then she’ll have no idea of where the line is or what she should really value.

I can think of a few ways you could position this (too late for the ski trip now):

  • Allow her to choose between the family holiday next year, or the school trip (and go stay with a relative while you go on holiday). Present it that there’s a budget pp for holidays, and if she’s using hers on school trips then she’s not coming to Aruba.
  • If she has an allowance, she could pay £x per month for 18 months towards the trip: 12m before and 6m after. The 6m after part is an important lesson in credit, as it feels even less worthwhile to be paying for something that has been and gone.
  • It could be birthday and/or Christmas gift for next year. This isn’t about a cash exchange value - it’s about learning that you’re going above and beyond for her in a way that isn’t an everyday occurrence. It’s a gift.

I would probably ask for something like £20/month from her allowance for 18m towards it, for her to fund any spends from her savings, and then the rest to be her birthday present (at the closest birthday to the trip). Birthday easier than Christmas, as it’s not like everyone else is getting physical gifts.

SoShallINever · 10/04/2023 09:16

If you treat her like a princess, she'll behave like one. We were offerred free private school places (public school actually) for our DC as DH taught there.
We declined as we really dont like the sense of entitlement they can breed.

Testina · 10/04/2023 09:06

@Irritateandunreasonable “What terrible advice! The more people that talk to the school the better, it’s outrageous to organise a 2k trip and they should be called out on it.”

Why did you bump a months old thread and not even read the OP posts properly?!!
🙄

It’s a private school. This is part of the point why people pay for them… they want the £2K ski trips. Nothing outrageous about it at all!

BCBird · 10/04/2023 09:04

It is not the school's responsibility to teach pupils about the value of money. If she will not take onresponsibilty for earning extra money then she can't go.Simple. I would definitely stand firm- if not you risking with a pampered princess.even in adult hood we cannot always have what we want

thegrain · 10/04/2023 09:01

Or perhaps she could ask for money towards it for Christmas

RudsyFarmer · 10/04/2023 09:01

If you send your child to private school they are going to have a sense of entitlement alongside their friends and the lifestyle of those friends. These things just go hand in hand and you’re going to struggle to contain it.

I live with someone who had a very exclusive education and entitlement is the very core of him. Thankfully he’s a wonderful man in other ways but if it wasn’t for me keeping him grounded he would be a total nightmare.

thegrain · 10/04/2023 09:01

I'd have made her "pay" towards the skiing but not the educational trip

Irritateandunreasonable · 10/04/2023 08:57

polio999 · 22/11/2022 11:06

I would be having a word with the school about teaching the pupils the value of money. A ski trip, another school trip plus I suppose other costs. The school could do local visits surely and activities at school. No need for this costly trip. You are right to point out the cost and have your daughter helping around the home

Do not talk to the school about this. You'll just sound like an interfering parent with too much time on your hands, it will have no impact on their decision and if the need arises that you must address something with the school it will greatly undermine you as you''ll be remembered as ''that parent''.

What terrible advice! The more people that talk to the school the better, it’s outrageous to organise a 2k trip and they should be called out on it.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/11/2022 10:20

Sorry but she’s entitled because you’ve allowed her to become so (not a criticism, poor upbringing myself and guilty of the same)
stick to your guns, 13 year olds ought to be helping out regardless of “payment”.

BobLemon · 23/11/2022 10:18

IME getting young teens to do “extra” jobs they don’t really want to do is a whole lot of extra work for you.

Mowing the lawn? Might as well do it yourself

Cleaning windows? They’ll end up worse than they started

Does she have any Xmas money/birthday money savings? Our teens seem to sit on piles of cash!

Kagusta · 23/11/2022 10:14

@Testina it has a games room, a tv room, a study space but no dishwasher. I can do the whole you don't know you are born as my uni days were in complete poverty whereas Dh was in catered halls for 1st and 3rd year with lunch included for 2nd year. But the reason we were willing to spend over £7k on accommodation was because he earned it. As will Ds2 who is in sixth form. Not just academically because he did get incredible grades but because they will drop everything if you come through the door laden with shopping, help unpack supermarket shops and put things away. Make family dinners for everyone, unpack a dishwasher each 3 times a week when Ds1 is home, take bins out etc. All without being asked.

Learning the value of labour, minimum wage, what salaries people earn and what houses cost in terms of initial price plus utilities, insurance etc makes children have an understanding of adulthood and that they will be expected to take all this on themselves. Plus simple things like a meal out is almost the same as a week's worth of supermarket shopping, or that spending £2k for one child for a school trip isn't really guaranteed when they already have a ski trip booked too. No doubt the OP's child will also be expecting a family holiday too. I would absolutely make her earn it and show her the cost of it too with what a child her age would be paid for an hour's work.

SisterGeorgeMichael · 23/11/2022 09:54

My DD's school,offer trips on a two year cycle. Nobody is going on all of them. Some go, some don't. Some go to Belgium in year eight, some go in year ten. Some don't go at all.

It's not up to the school to teach the children the value of money.

Testina · 23/11/2022 09:52

Kagusta · 23/11/2022 09:11

@Testina yes my son is at uni, in private halls of residence and even for £7.3k a year there is no dishwasher.

My two stepsons recently finished uni - we regularly did the “you don’t know you’re born” routine over their (different) uni / student accommodation having dishwashers. And gyms, pool tables… not in all! But I think 4/6 places they had over each of their 3 years had them. Obvious not universal - but gone are the days when you could just assume uni year’s accommodation would be basic!

Henuinequest · 23/11/2022 09:50

Our DS -12 - paid for a 3rd of his school trip. He protested too as he knew we could just pay it but that really wasn’t the point.
he put some of his pocket money each week away, added ££ from birthday money and did jobs for ££.
He was till expected to do his normal chores for nothing, cleaning, tidying, walk dog, dishes etc separately.
His claim that no one else’s parents were making them contribute fell on deaf ears, because even if that was true, our house has its own rules!

Meklk · 23/11/2022 09:33

In my opinion - she needs to learn a lesson NOW. No way I would pay £2k for a child who thinks that money coming from the sky.
My 3,5 year old son is already told that in case he wants to get a Pudsey jumper for Pudsey day or have a visit at the playground - he must do something - at his age to tidy up toys, put his plates to the sink, help for mummy.
She goes to private school, she IS SPOILED already. There is nothing to be sorry "about.