Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have not included DH in holiday booking?

63 replies

PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 08:00

I'll preface this by saying that DH and I had spoken, and acknowledged, that he wouldn't get any holidays with us this year. During this conversation he made no suggestions and just approached it with more of a "ah bad luck that" attitude.

So, as the title suggests, I booked a holiday for DC and I over the Easter break (a UK getaway for 4 nights) but didn't include DH.
Both DH and I have set holidays, we cannot take them at other times. I am term time, meaning I have all the school holidays. DH works on a rota that has his days off plus annual leave accounted for, and bar a day here or there, it is nearly impossible to swap shifts with someone.

This year none of DHs holidays fall over the term time - something he enjoys as it means he gets 2 weeks off when I'm at work at the kids are at school. 10 whole days, 9 to 3, of peace and quiet.

When we spoke about this I said I wouldn't not be going away because he wouldn't be there and he agreed. We had this issue a few years ago, with a larger family holiday, and DH had to drop out as he couldn't swap his shifts with anyone.

Fast forward to my booking of a holiday, just a 4 night UK break in Easter, and DH is now in a massive huff because "I should have waited for him to see if he could swap," or I "should have just booked him in case". I've only paid the deposit as there were Black Friday discounts and it was a very good deal. As I said, none of our previous conversations took this turn and he was more than happy to have time alone, in theory, when discussing it. I'm also not clairvoyant and had no idea that his "yeah it's rubbish we won't be off together" also meant "I'll try to swap shifts despite this not working before".

Now DH is in a bit of a huff.
However I don't believe I was in the wrong, we had conversations.

So AIBU to not have included him?
Yanbu - not unreasonable, why would you include him after all of the above?
Yabu - are unreasonable, why would you not include him?

OP posts:
LannieDuck · 22/11/2022 12:19

"I also could change the booking to two adults."

So tell him you'll increase the booking to include him as son as he swaps his shifts around. I can't see the issue here...

heldinadream · 22/11/2022 12:11

I'm baffled by the posters saying you were not clear enough. You said you were about to book it, having discussed all the ins and outs more than once - you put him on notice - I'm booking it, any objections? I can't see you could have been any clearer OP. Personally I'd be shrugging my shoulders and letting it blow over. I think he's probably more frustrated at the constraints of the job than at you. And it's 4 days for the children, really, how can he object to that? Baffling all round.

Tsort · 22/11/2022 11:36

PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 11:28

Mentioned it again as in "I am wanting to book that holiday, it is on these dates and I know you are working. The deal will be gone soon and I will be booking it within the next day or two".

To me that is mentioning it.
We have had conversations before. This did not require a sit down conversation.

He has poor communication. For years I have organised everything, checking and triple checking. We spent more than two months talking about the summer holidays and holidays in general when going through his rota, with me constantly speaking about the fact that he would need to change his shifts, if possible, and him saying it wasn't possible.
I then spoke about this break on at least 4 or 5 different occasions and he still said he was working, shift swaps weren't easy. I then mentioned again that I would be booking the holiday within the next day or two and to let me know.

He was then working last night when I booked the holiday and I let him know this morning that I had booked it, as he hadn't got back to me about shift swapping. This is when he fell out with me.

Nobody is saying it required a sit down conversation, just direct questions.

I'm honestly not trying to be unkind, but your communication doesn’t seem great. I’m sure his isn’t either, which is how this has all come about.

SommerTen · 22/11/2022 11:36

Your husband sounds like a right pain in the arse

PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 11:30

Crunchyb · 22/11/2022 11:24

I was going to say, ‘I hope communication isn’t a big part of your job’, because you explained the situation really badly in your OP. Then you tell us you are a teacher. What can I say to that?

Because at 8am, or whenever it was, I was dealing with the fall out from this, trying to gain perspective on this, getting myself ready and sorting out a child who inexplicably became unwell and didn't want to go to school.

I hope your job doesn't involve kindness, compassion, understanding or generally being a nice person because what can I say to that ...

OP posts:
PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 11:28

Tsort · 22/11/2022 10:39

I then mentioned again that I was going to book it and nothing. So I booked it.

Again, ‘mentioning’ it. Do you agree that there could have been more clarity and directness here?

I also don't feel as though I should be the only one to make the suggestion of "change it just in case" because he is a grown adult and should be able to do that himself.

And here? How is that not the first thing that came up when he objected to the booking? This obviously isn’t just on you, but do you two have poor communication generally? As this all just sounds weirdly passive aggressive.

Mentioned it again as in "I am wanting to book that holiday, it is on these dates and I know you are working. The deal will be gone soon and I will be booking it within the next day or two".

To me that is mentioning it.
We have had conversations before. This did not require a sit down conversation.

He has poor communication. For years I have organised everything, checking and triple checking. We spent more than two months talking about the summer holidays and holidays in general when going through his rota, with me constantly speaking about the fact that he would need to change his shifts, if possible, and him saying it wasn't possible.
I then spoke about this break on at least 4 or 5 different occasions and he still said he was working, shift swaps weren't easy. I then mentioned again that I would be booking the holiday within the next day or two and to let me know.

He was then working last night when I booked the holiday and I let him know this morning that I had booked it, as he hadn't got back to me about shift swapping. This is when he fell out with me.

OP posts:
Crunchyb · 22/11/2022 11:24

I was going to say, ‘I hope communication isn’t a big part of your job’, because you explained the situation really badly in your OP. Then you tell us you are a teacher. What can I say to that?

HarvestThyme · 22/11/2022 10:50

Sounds like you did not have a proper discussion about it, so yes YABU.

A proper discussion being, you and DH are speaking to each other, both listening and paying full attention. And you say, I am booking xx on xx dates. Can you come along, or shall I book for just me and dc?

And he replies, I can't make it. Or, I will try for a shift swap. You might need to tell him there is no time for swapping, as you need to book asap to get the deal.

If that conversation happened, YANBU. If it didn't, you both need to work on communicating effectively.

Tsort · 22/11/2022 10:39

PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 10:33

Sorry I'm at work now.

I have confused things as I was getting ready for work.
I work term time - I am a teacher. I cannot take holidays outside of the school holidays.
DH works for another public service, seven weeks on and two weeks off. His two weeks off includes his days off for time worked and his annual holiday entitlement. It is a set rolling rota. He is telling the truth, I've spoken to his colleagues and we went over his contract together before signing it.

This year it meant that he had time off over the school holidays and we went away in Easter and summer plus an overnight in October.
Next year I meant to say he has no holidays in the school holidays only term time.

For those asking when he is present there are other long weekends, weekends in general (he works 3/4 in 7) etc. Plus during the school holidays there may be a day or two during the week when he is off and we are too.

It's unfortunate that next year our holidays don't align but that is that.

If he were to shift swap he'd need to find someone on a different rota but they can only do it a block I'm advance, I.e. he'd need to wait until February/March time to check.

Our conversations started back in summer when looking at next summer and we realised this would be the case. He then double and triple checked in work.
We've then spoken back and forth at length about how I'd still like to get away and take the boys.
When this deal came up I mentioned it to him and spoke about booking it. I brought up that I'd need to book it ASAP and he didn't say he'd try to come. I then mentioned again that I was going to book it and nothing. So I booked it.

It's only a Haven break for 4 nights, more for the kids than me. The youngest loves it, loves the activities and swimming. He's hardly missing out on much. I also could change the booking to two adults. However he also hasn't asked me to change it. He has just complained that he wasn't included, that he "could have swapped shifts if I waited" (despite knowing it was a deal and we couldn't wait - that selective memory).

I don't feel that booking it was wrong, he knew. I also don't feel as though I should be the only one to make the suggestion of "change it just in case" because he is a grown adult and should be able to do that himself.

I then mentioned again that I was going to book it and nothing. So I booked it.

Again, ‘mentioning’ it. Do you agree that there could have been more clarity and directness here?

I also don't feel as though I should be the only one to make the suggestion of "change it just in case" because he is a grown adult and should be able to do that himself.

And here? How is that not the first thing that came up when he objected to the booking? This obviously isn’t just on you, but do you two have poor communication generally? As this all just sounds weirdly passive aggressive.

PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 10:33

Sorry I'm at work now.

I have confused things as I was getting ready for work.
I work term time - I am a teacher. I cannot take holidays outside of the school holidays.
DH works for another public service, seven weeks on and two weeks off. His two weeks off includes his days off for time worked and his annual holiday entitlement. It is a set rolling rota. He is telling the truth, I've spoken to his colleagues and we went over his contract together before signing it.

This year it meant that he had time off over the school holidays and we went away in Easter and summer plus an overnight in October.
Next year I meant to say he has no holidays in the school holidays only term time.

For those asking when he is present there are other long weekends, weekends in general (he works 3/4 in 7) etc. Plus during the school holidays there may be a day or two during the week when he is off and we are too.

It's unfortunate that next year our holidays don't align but that is that.

If he were to shift swap he'd need to find someone on a different rota but they can only do it a block I'm advance, I.e. he'd need to wait until February/March time to check.

Our conversations started back in summer when looking at next summer and we realised this would be the case. He then double and triple checked in work.
We've then spoken back and forth at length about how I'd still like to get away and take the boys.
When this deal came up I mentioned it to him and spoke about booking it. I brought up that I'd need to book it ASAP and he didn't say he'd try to come. I then mentioned again that I was going to book it and nothing. So I booked it.

It's only a Haven break for 4 nights, more for the kids than me. The youngest loves it, loves the activities and swimming. He's hardly missing out on much. I also could change the booking to two adults. However he also hasn't asked me to change it. He has just complained that he wasn't included, that he "could have swapped shifts if I waited" (despite knowing it was a deal and we couldn't wait - that selective memory).

I don't feel that booking it was wrong, he knew. I also don't feel as though I should be the only one to make the suggestion of "change it just in case" because he is a grown adult and should be able to do that himself.

OP posts:
TomTraubertsBlues · 22/11/2022 10:24

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/11/2022 10:20

She did

I guess it's a question of interpretation.. To me "I mentioned the deal, mentioned wanting to book it" isn't particularly concrete. She didn't say "Right, I'm booking this today".

Shouldershoddy · 22/11/2022 10:23

Absolutely nothing wrong with enjoying a few days with peace and quiet. My husband used to regularly take the kids skiing and I would have a wonderful week to myself but it would feel odd having absolutely no family holidays when the children are still school age .
Are your husbands AL weeks so inflexible even if he booked a year in advance?

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/11/2022 10:20

TomTraubertsBlues · 22/11/2022 10:14

I agree with this.

In this scenario, I'd have said to DH "Ok, I'm going to book that trip i mentioned to you last week - if you think there's any chance you can get the time off then I need to know now"

She did

TomTraubertsBlues · 22/11/2022 10:19

Venetiaparties · 22/11/2022 09:15

It all sounds very sad.
No family holidays
No family memories
Everyone doing their own thing

It wouldn't be a set up I would enjoy. What exactly does this marriage offer either of you?

It's not like he's out with his mates, he's earning a living to contribute towards the family! It's not either of their fault that his annual leave is structured like this!

Labnehi · 22/11/2022 10:15

Why can't he just join you at the time if he gets time off?

TomTraubertsBlues · 22/11/2022 10:14

Tsort · 22/11/2022 09:58

As I said, none of our previous conversations took this turn and he was more than happy to have time alone, in theory, when discussing it. I'm also not clairvoyant and had no idea that his "yeah it's rubbish we won't be off together" also meant "I'll try to swap shifts despite this not working before".

Have you said this to him?

I did double check. I mentioned the deal, mentioned wanting to book it and there wasn't one moment where he said he'd try to arrange shifts. I think he's more annoyed that I actually did it, instead of sitting at home twiddling my thumbs. He had about a week to come up with a solution and, when he didn't, I booked it.

That’s not really double checking. Double checking would be ‘I am booking this today for XX days on XX date, do you have thoughts?’ and even carrying on from there.

I don’t think you’re in the wrong, but I do think there could have been more clarity and communication. People always seem to ‘mention’ things on MN, as opposed to having conversations.

I agree with this.

In this scenario, I'd have said to DH "Ok, I'm going to book that trip i mentioned to you last week - if you think there's any chance you can get the time off then I need to know now"

melj1213 · 22/11/2022 09:58

Bellaboo01 · 22/11/2022 09:03

Can he put in a request for holidays?

Why does he just get 'given' his holiday days in his workplace?

Any employer can mandate when an employee takes their holiday but most employers have flexibility so don't mandate this unless they have to eg with teachers where they are needed for set dates and so teachers holidays are set as the school holidays. Some employers don't book holidays but will have certain "blackout periods" where you can't book holidays so it has to be taken at other times eg in retail there's often blackouts over Easter and the Christmas/New Year periods where no holidays can be taken as they are so busy etc.

I work in a supermarket and if you don't book in a certain amount of your holidays by a set date every year then management will put the holidays in for you. There have been years in the past where people haven't booked holidays and then, with 4 weeks left of the holiday year, they have multiple people across loads of departments with 2-3 weeks worth of holidays to take and have had to let them be off enmass and it has left the store massively understaffed.

Tsort · 22/11/2022 09:58

PixieAndProsecco · 22/11/2022 08:26

I did double check.
I mentioned the deal, mentioned wanting to book it and there wasn't one moment where he said he'd try to arrange shifts.

I think he's more annoyed that I actually did it, instead of sitting at home twiddling my thumbs.
He had about a week to come up with a solution and, when he didn't, I booked it. I couldn't have waited until almost April to see if he could swap.

This has been a conversation we've come back to many times.
I'm looking at going away in the summer and DH doesn't care because "I can ask my mum and dad to come" and he'll get his few days off and, depending on his shift, might have some time off in the day too.

As I said, none of our previous conversations took this turn and he was more than happy to have time alone, in theory, when discussing it. I'm also not clairvoyant and had no idea that his "yeah it's rubbish we won't be off together" also meant "I'll try to swap shifts despite this not working before".

Have you said this to him?

I did double check. I mentioned the deal, mentioned wanting to book it and there wasn't one moment where he said he'd try to arrange shifts. I think he's more annoyed that I actually did it, instead of sitting at home twiddling my thumbs. He had about a week to come up with a solution and, when he didn't, I booked it.

That’s not really double checking. Double checking would be ‘I am booking this today for XX days on XX date, do you have thoughts?’ and even carrying on from there.

I don’t think you’re in the wrong, but I do think there could have been more clarity and communication. People always seem to ‘mention’ things on MN, as opposed to having conversations.

OneFrenchEgg · 22/11/2022 09:53

'This year none of DHs holidays fall over the term time - something he enjoys as it means he gets 2 weeks off when I'm at work at the kids are at school. 10 whole days, 9 to 3, of peace and quiet.'

So he would be available during school holidays? I read that he liked term time leave but didn't have any this year.

OneFrenchEgg · 22/11/2022 09:52

I don't understand - you've said 'this year none of his holidays fall on term time' and you've booked a break in school holidays - so he would have been free? Why didn't you include him?

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/11/2022 09:46

It sounds sad that he doesn't really seem to want to spend much time with you or the kids

Risslan · 22/11/2022 09:33

Goodness, all of these people who've never known anyone in an industry where their holidays are fixed. Like teachers?

That was my entire life as a child, we had to go on holiday during term time because of my dad's holidays. He worked in a chemical processing plant on shifts. Its still very common.

BankseyVest · 22/11/2022 09:27

I think you're right op, you've had several conversations with him about it, never once has he mentioned trying to swap shifts to go on holiday. I think he's just pissed you've booked it and will have a lovely time - surely you should be staying at home, pining for him, bored, heaven forbid you actually have the ability to go without him

Barkin2themoon · 22/11/2022 09:24

Goodness ! What’s his job ?

Schnooze · 22/11/2022 09:20

So he never ever gets to pick some holiday time? All of his 20/25 days? Are you not in the uk op?