Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our expectations of childbirth are too high?

203 replies

RimmersLoveMonster · 21/11/2022 21:48

Just that really. It’s inherently agonisingly painful and dangerous, but a lot of posters seem to be surprised that it is and feel traumatised afterwards. I think our expectations around birth are unrealistic and that women are being sold a fantasy by ‘positive birth’ companies and pictures of pools with twinkly lights etc. This then leads to disappointment when their experience doesn’t go that way. AIBU?

OP posts:
FishnetsNightdressCrisis · 22/11/2022 20:29

@AutumnScream whilst it may be hugely safer than developing countries in the UK, it's nowhere near as safe as it should be. Again, thanks to lots of the issues raised on this thread. Shocking.

amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/nov/16/uk-has-second-highest-maternal-death-rate-in-eight-country-european-study

AutumnScream · 22/11/2022 20:22

Notmysolution · 22/11/2022 19:51

Your response is absolutely bonkers! It really is! There has been no healthcare for most of history, so yes, birth has evolved to be hazardous for women for most of history. You quite clearly outline some of the reasons it is hazardous in your post. Healthcare alleviates these hazards. As you also outline.

I have never read such a bizarrely illogical post as yours. Ever. You literally present a stream of evidence to support my position, then conclude you’ve countered it.

Bizarre!

Its not bizarre at all. You have implied in your post that childbirth in the UK in 2022 is the most dangerous awful thing a woman can go through.

I pointed out that we have medical care that prevents a vast majority of death in pregnancy and childbirth therefore saying that childbirth is still the most dangerous and painful thing a woman can experience in the UK is patently nonsensical. We have one of the lowest maternal mortality rates in the world.

Notmysolution · 22/11/2022 19:51

AutumnScream · 22/11/2022 11:00

severe bleeding (mostly bleeding after childbirth)

infections (usually after childbirth)

high blood pressure during pregnancy (pre-eclampsia and eclampsia)

complications from delivery

unsafe abortion.

The remainder are caused by or associated with infections such as malaria or related to chronic conditions like cardiac diseases or diabetes.

These are the main causes of maternal and infact death in childbirth both now and in the past. Most are caused by poor sanitation. They discovered over 100 years ago that Washing your hands with soap before delivering a baby cut deaths by a massive margin. That is from the WHO, so not relevant in 2022 UK unless you advocate freebirthing and wild pregnancy.

Saying that childbirth is not the worst thing you can ever do is not bloody rejecting medical science. If you have antinatal care and access to health care in pregnancy then you are very much guaranteed to get treatment for things that would have killed you in the past hence why women are checked for things like pre eclampsia or diabetes. We also know to wash and sterilise rooms and equipment and hands before touching a new patient as we have access to soap and water so using history as a gotcha is an absolute straw man argument.

Your response is absolutely bonkers! It really is! There has been no healthcare for most of history, so yes, birth has evolved to be hazardous for women for most of history. You quite clearly outline some of the reasons it is hazardous in your post. Healthcare alleviates these hazards. As you also outline.

I have never read such a bizarrely illogical post as yours. Ever. You literally present a stream of evidence to support my position, then conclude you’ve countered it.

Bizarre!

Cameleongirl · 22/11/2022 17:13

@TooManyGerms It bloody hurts, doesn’t it?! My second delivery was drip-induced and the contractions were unbelievably painful-I’d opted for no pain relief as I’d previously developed a spinal headache from a poorly administered epidural.

But, DS did pop out quickly and scored a 10 on his Apgar test as he was so angry at being rudely ejected. Screaming at the top of his lungs. 🤣

I agree with @justanoldhack in some ways in that expectant Mums can do some things to try and make birth easier, for example, keeping fit during pregnancy. It doesn’t guarantee anything, but it helps.

TooManyGerms · 22/11/2022 16:34

“Personally, I feel a good birth can be chalked up to good preparation.”

@justanoldhack I don’t even know where to start with this one. I’m very pleased it worked out for you, I really am. But are you seriously implying that “bad” or traumatising births are down to a lack of preparation on the mother’s part? All the prep in the world can’t prepare you for unforeseen emergencies or many other of the weird and disturbing things labour throws our way. Even if I’d prepped like a pro nothing could have taken away the pain of two syntocinon drip induced births. Hence the cascade of interventions, yada yada. It doesn’t mean I’m a slacker.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 22/11/2022 14:57

I went to natural birthing classes when I was pregnant. We were told we would not need pain relief. I had a birth plan, none of which was adhered to. I had an epidural and a healthy baby and I felt like I had failed. Also the Midwife told me mid labour that I had spots on my back.

MrsHughesPinny · 22/11/2022 13:46

I knew birth would be hard, but nothing could have prepared me for how bad my experience was. Hence, only one baby!

IDontWantToBeAPie · 22/11/2022 12:24

Personally I think most women are terrified and know it will be the most painful event in their lives.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 22/11/2022 11:35

FishnetsNightdressCrisis · 22/11/2022 11:21

*And I think some people believe that a c-section is easier than a vaginal birth, but they don't seem to really consider the fact that it is major surgery!!!

And I'm sorry for those who suffer "traumatic" births but really, people seriously need to manage their expectations better*

You think that people aren't 'managing their expectations' when they feel traumatised after being assaulted by medical staff, denied pain relief, suffered life changing injuries etc etc?

Do you really think women consider a c-section an easy option? I didn't think it would be easy. It wasn't. But my god I preferred it over the idea of a vaginal delivery, and I don't regret my decision for a second. Both my sections were calm, controlled, I didn't go through labour, I wasn't exhausted because of that, I had adequate pain relief afterwards, no awful ongoing birth injuries/incontinence, healthy baby, and me in the best possible physical and mental state to begin life as a new mum. I was aware there would be a recovery period and I managed it fine. There's often a long recovery period for vaginal deliveries too.

It's a brilliant option that should be available easily to anyone who chooses it. It should never be forced on anyone. But it's a great way of giving birth.

I agree with this also, two planned csections and both were fab. No regrets!

CatLoaf · 22/11/2022 11:34

Ringmaster27 · 22/11/2022 11:18

@CatLoaf i know it’s anecdotal coming from me - I’m not sure if there actually is any actual statistic on tearing during subsequent births…but I tore with my first baby. She was a small one too - 6lb 12oz. But had not as much as a graze with babies 2 and 3. Baby 2 was smaller than Baby 1, but Baby 3 was my biggest! 7lb 13oz, which is big for someone my size!! And she practically birthed herself an hour after my first contraction! My water broke (on my uncovered sofa of all places! I thought I’d have plenty of time to get the plastic sheets out 🤦🏻‍♀️😂), and I managed to scramble onto all fours as her head was coming out - I don’t even recall pushing at that stage! It was almost as if my body just did it of it’s own accord.

Aw, thanks @Ringmaster27! That is comforting 😁

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 22/11/2022 11:34

d sorry but agree to an extent. I remember on my birth board with DS and DD people were sharing their birth plans and it was all stuff like scented candles, what song must be playing when baby comes out, their DH must* be the first one to touch the baby and to tell the mother what the sex was etc. I just thought that was batshit. Also the people who expected their midwives to be personally on call to answer their texts 24 hours a day.

However in terms of pain relief and proper care before/during/after birth - I don't think people can possibly have too high of expectations.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 22/11/2022 11:29

I've not read the entire threa

FishnetsNightdressCrisis · 22/11/2022 11:21

*And I think some people believe that a c-section is easier than a vaginal birth, but they don't seem to really consider the fact that it is major surgery!!!

And I'm sorry for those who suffer "traumatic" births but really, people seriously need to manage their expectations better*

You think that people aren't 'managing their expectations' when they feel traumatised after being assaulted by medical staff, denied pain relief, suffered life changing injuries etc etc?

Do you really think women consider a c-section an easy option? I didn't think it would be easy. It wasn't. But my god I preferred it over the idea of a vaginal delivery, and I don't regret my decision for a second. Both my sections were calm, controlled, I didn't go through labour, I wasn't exhausted because of that, I had adequate pain relief afterwards, no awful ongoing birth injuries/incontinence, healthy baby, and me in the best possible physical and mental state to begin life as a new mum. I was aware there would be a recovery period and I managed it fine. There's often a long recovery period for vaginal deliveries too.

It's a brilliant option that should be available easily to anyone who chooses it. It should never be forced on anyone. But it's a great way of giving birth.

VapeVamp12 · 22/11/2022 11:20

I expected severe pain. I expected to be uncomfortable.

I didn't expect a fumbling anaesthetist to fuck up so badly I had to have an emergency C Section under general anaesthetic.

I didn't expect the hospital staff to drop me when moving me from my hospital bed to the surgical bed. Causing the tubes in my wrist and hands to be ripped away from me. All whilst in huge amounts of pain.

I didn't expect to suffer a huge haemorrhage when on the post natal ward and for the staff to be more bothered about clearing up the blood from the floor than helping me.

I didn't expect to be discharged 12 hours after coming round from general.

This is why I will 100% not have any more children after this, my first. It's also why I think maternity care in the UK is absoultely appalling. When you speak about it you realise you are actually in the majority when you have a traumatic birth, and not in the minority.

Ringmaster27 · 22/11/2022 11:18

@CatLoaf i know it’s anecdotal coming from me - I’m not sure if there actually is any actual statistic on tearing during subsequent births…but I tore with my first baby. She was a small one too - 6lb 12oz. But had not as much as a graze with babies 2 and 3. Baby 2 was smaller than Baby 1, but Baby 3 was my biggest! 7lb 13oz, which is big for someone my size!! And she practically birthed herself an hour after my first contraction! My water broke (on my uncovered sofa of all places! I thought I’d have plenty of time to get the plastic sheets out 🤦🏻‍♀️😂), and I managed to scramble onto all fours as her head was coming out - I don’t even recall pushing at that stage! It was almost as if my body just did it of it’s own accord.

FooFighter99 · 22/11/2022 11:13

Totally agree

It's supposed to hurt, it's a natural bodily function that isn't supposed to bloody tickle! And yes, we have drugs that can combat the pain but that doesn't mean you won't feel anything at all...

And I think some people believe that a c-section is easier than a vaginal birth, but they don't seem to really consider the fact that it is major surgery!!!

And I'm sorry for those who suffer "traumatic" births but really, people seriously need to manage their expectations better

CatLoaf · 22/11/2022 11:07

I am dreading my next child being born - I immediately panic that I am going to tear, just like I did with my first. Planning to ask for an epidural...

AutumnScream · 22/11/2022 11:00

Notmysolution · 22/11/2022 09:59

Even reading these its clear that the issues are from healthcare failures rather than birth itself being inherently the worst possible thing you could do

Um no. The outcomes for women in countries, or at times of history, who do not have access to proper medical health care are poor. High maternal death rates, high child mortality. High complications afterwards with dreadful impacts. Did you know there are charities in some countries which provides homes for women who are permanently kicked out by their families after developing incontinence after childbirth?
There was an extremely popular book in the 18th century in England which provided guidance to women on how to write a letter for their unborn child, in case they died in childbirth, giving them all the advice they would have given them if they survived. I suspect few of us know a woman who has died in childhood. Almost certainly all of us would of if we had lived before modern obstetrics, or we’d have died ourselves.

Birth has always been hazardous for women due to the size of our babies brains. Pressures on NHS services mean there’s a lot of poor practice. But we are still better off having these services than nothing at all.

severe bleeding (mostly bleeding after childbirth)

infections (usually after childbirth)

high blood pressure during pregnancy (pre-eclampsia and eclampsia)

complications from delivery

unsafe abortion.

The remainder are caused by or associated with infections such as malaria or related to chronic conditions like cardiac diseases or diabetes.

These are the main causes of maternal and infact death in childbirth both now and in the past. Most are caused by poor sanitation. They discovered over 100 years ago that Washing your hands with soap before delivering a baby cut deaths by a massive margin. That is from the WHO, so not relevant in 2022 UK unless you advocate freebirthing and wild pregnancy.

Saying that childbirth is not the worst thing you can ever do is not bloody rejecting medical science. If you have antinatal care and access to health care in pregnancy then you are very much guaranteed to get treatment for things that would have killed you in the past hence why women are checked for things like pre eclampsia or diabetes. We also know to wash and sterilise rooms and equipment and hands before touching a new patient as we have access to soap and water so using history as a gotcha is an absolute straw man argument.

FishnetsNightdressCrisis · 22/11/2022 10:49

Sparklesocks · 22/11/2022 10:44

I don’t think anyone is expecting birth to be sunshine and rainbows, but if you are receiving care that’s not up to what it should be then you have every right to feel let down. My friend gave birth a few months ago and so many errors were made that’s it’s triggered an internal review.

Exactly, it's not expecting too much for to expect birth to be is good as it possibly can be in the 21st century with the medical options we have available. It's not expecting too much to have competent, compassionate care and for maternity to be properly resourced. And it's not expecting too much to expect to be able to have choices like ELCS, epidurals, birthing pools, etc etc.

Expecting a post natal ward to be like a 5 star hotel would be in the realms of unreasonable expectations. Proper choice, well resourced maternity wards and proper care are not unreasonable.

vitahelp · 22/11/2022 10:47

I agree to some extent. However, did expect the worst and had read horror stories, so was never going to be too shocked at what happened. But I did have a personal belief that if I ticked all the boxes with regard to preparation (and trust me I ticked all the boxes) that it would go as I planned. Sadly it didn't as DD was just a very big baby and I needed a c-section in the end.

I think logically I knew the majority of variables relating to a birth are out of your control, but I somehow still thought I could control it.

I also had a foolish belief that because I was a fit/healthy person (continued in gym/spinning classes until 8 months pregnant and ate very well throughout) I would have an easy birth because my body was physically stronger and in better condition. It turns out this is unlikely to make any difference.

Sparklesocks · 22/11/2022 10:44

I don’t think anyone is expecting birth to be sunshine and rainbows, but if you are receiving care that’s not up to what it should be then you have every right to feel let down. My friend gave birth a few months ago and so many errors were made that’s it’s triggered an internal review.

Onnabugeisha · 22/11/2022 10:42

Meseekslookatme · 22/11/2022 10:34

It can squirt out as fast as they put it in you know...

Perfectly elegant and simple way to put it. Blood transfusions are not just top ups.

Onnabugeisha · 22/11/2022 10:40

bloodyplanes · 22/11/2022 10:07

@Onnabugeisha your sister lost 10 pints of blood? So her whole entire supply of blood? Ok then

Yes. She did. If they hadn’t had her on a constant transfusion for two days, she would have died. You can lose more than your entire supply when you look at blood lost over time. The hospital has to be getting transfusions into you as fast as you lose it while they work to slow and then stop the haemorrhage. Look up massive transfusion, its what a transfusion that is enough to entirely replace your entire blood volume within 24hrs is called. And they can do it on repeat if they have to.

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 22/11/2022 10:39

It's down to luck and the care you receive. Like most places with a caring role they are very good at proving care for patients with low needs and utterly shit and unprepared when things are more complex.

My first birth was fast and chaotic, but I didn't feel too traumatised as I knew it would be shit. Forceps felt very brutal, but they were needed at the time, so that's how I reflect on that.

Second birth was very easy. It was painful, but I could have asked for better really.

I did hypnobirthing both times and this very much helped. I retreated into myself.

The worst part was being stuck on a shared ward with my first after the birth, not knowing what the hell I was doing and with a baby that was screaming and waking everyone up. I was exhausted because I was too scared to sleep and had no help at all. I stupidly though that there would be staff available to help you with the first day and maybe take the baby for a while if you were sleep deprived as thats what they did when my mother gave birth. How naïve I was.

Meseekslookatme · 22/11/2022 10:34

bloodyplanes · 22/11/2022 10:07

@Onnabugeisha your sister lost 10 pints of blood? So her whole entire supply of blood? Ok then

It can squirt out as fast as they put it in you know...