Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nosy friend with finances

191 replies

LololaLo2012 · 21/11/2022 21:21

My DH is very fortunate to have CEO level job with good salary. He has worked hard to get to where his is, has to work many hours and take trips away most weeks.

I work part time as we have 3 children 6, 5 and 2. My money that I earn is my own and for the kids/extra food after the main shop/myself.

I am just going to state and reiterate that we are in a very fortunate position and I am very grateful. Neither of us grew up as financially comfortable. My mum was a single mum, husband dad was a teacher and mum stayed home)
The kids don’t go without anything, we can afford days out/holidays/decent clothes/x2 cars. Live in a semi detached x4 bed house.
We are not fancy people or materialistic.

I have this friend “Anna” that constantly comments on anything and everything we have.
Like:
how do you afford 2 cars such big fancy cars?
Please don’t tell me you pay £xx amount to go to this gym? (As she is sat in the softplay for free with her children)
Why don’t you claim children benefit again? (I have repeatedly told her nicely and brushing it of almost as not to come across like a bitch - my husband is over the salary threshold)
Why didn’t your daughter do 30 hours at preschool? (Again, nicely, you can only do 15 hours over the threshold)
How much did you spend on your kitchen again?
You do a clothes order from Zara for the kids???
comments on our friends car (same as mine) how much did they pay for that?
Questioning me on how our friend took their 3 children to Disney Paris and the cost?
She alway comments when my husband is “working late” or “working away” as she puts it. Commenting on me having to deal with the kids alone and he needs to pull his weight and help (I’m fine, he has to work these hours. More money comes more responsibly 🤷‍♀️)

So today.. this is why I’m pissed off. I know before anyone says - whatever, get over it! I know I’m just annoyed and I know there are more important things in the world going on!!!

I spoke to “Anna” about my sons Frog for his birthday a couple of days ago just casually as I got a good deal secondhand.
We brought him a secondhand Frog bike £190 vs £380 new.

I found out that “Anna” has been speaking to a mutual friend “Jane” of ours about me and the Frog bike.
“what bike will you get “Sam” this Christmas… not one of those fancy and stupidity expensive Frog bikes” she was trying to get a reaction out of my Jane and Jane felt like “Anna” wanted a “yeah it is a really fancy and expensive bike for a child” Jane did not take the bait, and is actually thinking of getting her son in too!

”Anna” then went on to talk out my friends new car and how much it costs and your husband must be on a good wage! “Jane” was shocked at her basically trying to get out of her how much her husband earns!

I don’t know or want to know “Annas ”financial situation. She works part time and her husband works and they seem to be doing ok? X2 Okish cars, Kids do after school activities, nice clothes and days out and holidays! So I’m a bit shocked that she’s like this at times.

I just ignore her on the whole, it’s more the talking behind my back that I don’t like - but today I just felt a little sad that maybe our friendship isn’t as I thought.
Any advice?

OP posts:
2bazookas · 24/11/2022 14:06

The correct answer to her comments is "Mind your own fucking business Anna and shut your face". Don't use gentle voice.

nanodyne · 24/11/2022 13:38

Haven't read the full thread, for me it's not so much gossiping, but that she's trying to put you down behind your back, that's not what friends do.

Her pushing to know about your finances could be her way of being ok with the fact that you're obviously wealthier than her. Like the more she knows the more she can reconcile with the obvious differences in your circumstances. I don't think it's a problem that she's sometimes blatantly envious, but it's that tendency to lash out because of it that would be making me unsure about the friendship.

Lolapusht · 24/11/2022 12:50

Total derail and apologies if it’s already been mentioned, but claim CB but decline the payment then you will receive the NICs you will need for your pension. If you don’t claim at all then your contributions will be short when you come to retire.

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 12:25

@peonyprincess
I really like ‘we paid what it was worth to us’ or something flippant like ‘Ah, now that’s a secret & if I told you that, I’d have to kill you’ !!

OP posts:
LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 12:22

@Maybebabyno2
@Firethrice

So maybe, I seem a bit flippant when I say B&M for cleaning stuff, I go for a look around B&M and pick up those kind of items myself.
I meant it in general sense - I want lunch at work - walk to Aldi buy myself a sandwich and a coke. I like having my own money so I don’t have to “ask” every time I wanted to do something.

Like I have stated from the start and reiterated, I know I am in a very fortunate position that I can essentially use my money as pin money. Even with a higher household income you have to still be accountable for where money is going!

I really don’t think just because one person in the household earns the 1% top salary doesn’t automatically meant the other person money HAS to go on luxuries only.

My friend brings it up. I don’t tell her, come over and see my £xx kitchen. Or can you guess where and how much I paid for this… Now that would be weird!

She also buys herself plenty of “things”, decorated her house, went to centre parks recently over half term. I know how expensive centre parks is but I didn’t ask her. That’s my point! I don’t ask!

OP posts:
snowbellsxox · 24/11/2022 12:07

I would just say outright how well your husband earns, why's she acting like she is unaware!

JennyJenny8675309 · 24/11/2022 12:02

She sounds jealous and you sound a bit of a braggart to be honest.

After reading the FT and all viewpoints, this is my conclusion. Why bother continuing this “friendship”? It doesn’t sound fun or supportive.

peonyprincess · 24/11/2022 11:56

LololaLo2012 · 21/11/2022 21:21

My DH is very fortunate to have CEO level job with good salary. He has worked hard to get to where his is, has to work many hours and take trips away most weeks.

I work part time as we have 3 children 6, 5 and 2. My money that I earn is my own and for the kids/extra food after the main shop/myself.

I am just going to state and reiterate that we are in a very fortunate position and I am very grateful. Neither of us grew up as financially comfortable. My mum was a single mum, husband dad was a teacher and mum stayed home)
The kids don’t go without anything, we can afford days out/holidays/decent clothes/x2 cars. Live in a semi detached x4 bed house.
We are not fancy people or materialistic.

I have this friend “Anna” that constantly comments on anything and everything we have.
Like:
how do you afford 2 cars such big fancy cars?
Please don’t tell me you pay £xx amount to go to this gym? (As she is sat in the softplay for free with her children)
Why don’t you claim children benefit again? (I have repeatedly told her nicely and brushing it of almost as not to come across like a bitch - my husband is over the salary threshold)
Why didn’t your daughter do 30 hours at preschool? (Again, nicely, you can only do 15 hours over the threshold)
How much did you spend on your kitchen again?
You do a clothes order from Zara for the kids???
comments on our friends car (same as mine) how much did they pay for that?
Questioning me on how our friend took their 3 children to Disney Paris and the cost?
She alway comments when my husband is “working late” or “working away” as she puts it. Commenting on me having to deal with the kids alone and he needs to pull his weight and help (I’m fine, he has to work these hours. More money comes more responsibly 🤷‍♀️)

So today.. this is why I’m pissed off. I know before anyone says - whatever, get over it! I know I’m just annoyed and I know there are more important things in the world going on!!!

I spoke to “Anna” about my sons Frog for his birthday a couple of days ago just casually as I got a good deal secondhand.
We brought him a secondhand Frog bike £190 vs £380 new.

I found out that “Anna” has been speaking to a mutual friend “Jane” of ours about me and the Frog bike.
“what bike will you get “Sam” this Christmas… not one of those fancy and stupidity expensive Frog bikes” she was trying to get a reaction out of my Jane and Jane felt like “Anna” wanted a “yeah it is a really fancy and expensive bike for a child” Jane did not take the bait, and is actually thinking of getting her son in too!

”Anna” then went on to talk out my friends new car and how much it costs and your husband must be on a good wage! “Jane” was shocked at her basically trying to get out of her how much her husband earns!

I don’t know or want to know “Annas ”financial situation. She works part time and her husband works and they seem to be doing ok? X2 Okish cars, Kids do after school activities, nice clothes and days out and holidays! So I’m a bit shocked that she’s like this at times.

I just ignore her on the whole, it’s more the talking behind my back that I don’t like - but today I just felt a little sad that maybe our friendship isn’t as I thought.
Any advice?

How incredibly annoying - it sounds like she’s trying to embarrass you, so just refuse to be embarrassed….if it was me I think I’d be completely bluntly honest on my replies:
‘How do you afford the cars?’ ….’Well, we pay money for them’
’please don’t tell me…the gym’ ‘Yes, I do’
’…child benefit’… ‘because we earn too much between us’
‘Zara…’ ‘yes, I love their clothes’
The only one I wouldn’t answer openly is the ‘how much did you spend’ questions - I’d either say ‘we paid what it was worth to us’ or something flippant like ‘Ah, now that’s a secret & if I told you that, I’d have to kill you’ !!

Maybebabyno2 · 24/11/2022 11:42

Firethrice · 24/11/2022 11:23

I'm telling you that your DH earns in the top 1% in the country and it is very unusual that you say you work to pay for extras like food and cleaning materials from B&M. If you said you work to build up your pension, your escape if your dh runs away with another women savings, to pay for lux holidays, for private school, cosmetic surgery, your expensive handbag habit, your expensive hobby or some other large expense but you work to buy extra food and cleaning material at B&M like your household income wouldn't cover it otherwise - it's very curious and unusual... I'm saying I'd question you too because it's so odd and I can't believe given how odd it is that you haven't come out with other odd things regarding money with your friend. Please remember I don't know you - I am going by what you have said but I'm offering you an alternative explanation for why you are getting the third degree.

You're right, it is really odd!

Firethrice · 24/11/2022 11:23

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 10:31

@Firethrice im not really sure what your saying?

Are you saying I don’t know how much my husband earns? Or that I don’t have access to “his” money?
Im sure a lot of households split finances in different ways - all of which is know ones business!

You earn money to buy B&M bits - are you for real? - I’m just giving an example after you asked about the extra food! Are you telling that that people do a weekly/big shop and never top up over the week/buy cleaning stuff/cheaper things from B&M over supermarkets?

My main post was stating that I’m not talking about money with her - I gave background to my situation. She in my daily life and can see my life, I can’t hide my possessions from her. She is the one that brings the conversation to how much things cost.

I'm telling you that your DH earns in the top 1% in the country and it is very unusual that you say you work to pay for extras like food and cleaning materials from B&M. If you said you work to build up your pension, your escape if your dh runs away with another women savings, to pay for lux holidays, for private school, cosmetic surgery, your expensive handbag habit, your expensive hobby or some other large expense but you work to buy extra food and cleaning material at B&M like your household income wouldn't cover it otherwise - it's very curious and unusual... I'm saying I'd question you too because it's so odd and I can't believe given how odd it is that you haven't come out with other odd things regarding money with your friend. Please remember I don't know you - I am going by what you have said but I'm offering you an alternative explanation for why you are getting the third degree.

heartbroken22 · 24/11/2022 10:51

Honestly life's too short to let these things bother you.

heartbroken22 · 24/11/2022 10:51

Maybe she's just curious and working out how she can do the same for her kids?

Seems like you don't want to be her mate because you can't stand her asking you stuff. You decide.

PollyAmour · 24/11/2022 10:43

Just change the subject. Say to her that she knows full well that you and your family are wealthy, therefore can afford expensive stuff, so can she please stop making digs about your spending. Talk about the latest book you've read, series you've watched on Netflix, anything other than money.

She sounds jealous and you sound a bit of a braggart to be honest.

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 10:40

Claim child benefit, yes DH will have to repay it under the high income charge, BUT you will get a deemed NI credit for each year you claim

I think over £65k income or something it's advised that you don't claim at all. There are calculators online somewhere - probably on the Martin Lewis site. You just fill in the claim form to get the NI credit but say you don't want to actually claim the payments.

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 10:31

@Firethrice im not really sure what your saying?

Are you saying I don’t know how much my husband earns? Or that I don’t have access to “his” money?
Im sure a lot of households split finances in different ways - all of which is know ones business!

You earn money to buy B&M bits - are you for real? - I’m just giving an example after you asked about the extra food! Are you telling that that people do a weekly/big shop and never top up over the week/buy cleaning stuff/cheaper things from B&M over supermarkets?

My main post was stating that I’m not talking about money with her - I gave background to my situation. She in my daily life and can see my life, I can’t hide my possessions from her. She is the one that brings the conversation to how much things cost.

OP posts:
Time4adrink · 24/11/2022 10:21

In my old job I was expected to wear smart (expensive) suits but worked with the general public so often got pointed questions and comments about my clothes. I always smiled and said ‘it’s amazing what you can get in M&S these days, isn’t it.’ These days I would talk about how great Vinted is.
@LololaLo2012 this could work for you.
Alternatively, just start being vague with Anna. How much was your kitchen? Shrug, not sure.
It’s a bit gauche and embarrassing really. Does she lack social skills generally?

Zilla1 · 24/11/2022 10:19

HNRTT. Some people have no filter. The repeated questions might be to catch you out and see if the answers change. You could change the answers on principle or 'I don't recall' or allude to a side gig if you don't want to engender interest in your DP's job if you don't want to front her up?

DragonflyNights · 24/11/2022 09:57

Have you actually tried saying that her constant queries into your finances make you uncomfortable? Seems to me like she’s trying to start some form of conversation or be pointed about how much money she thinks you have but doesn’t have the guts to come right out and say it - so she keeps trying to provoke a response and you keep brushing it off.

If you are actually friends then the friendship should be able to survive a frank conversation about why she keeps asking.

Just tell her it makes you uncomfortable, or every time she asked reply ‘why do you want to know that?’ - put it back to her each time so she has to reflect on why she’s asking. Potentially she may not even realise how much she does it and thinks she’s just making conversation- or, more likely, she is trying to have a dig.

If you ask her to explain every time why she wants this information, for what purpose, she will be forced to explain. I bet she will stop after a bit.

But, really, an open conversation and asking her to stop should be enough - IF she is really your friend.

Firethrice · 24/11/2022 09:45

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 09:11

@Firethrice sorry when I say extra food I mean top up shop food. My husband pays for the main shop (as it’s money in the joint account) and I just pick up those extra like B&M bits.

I don’t tell my friend about what the money I earn goes on. Why would anyone need to know how are finances are split? She asks that’s my main point. The stuff she asked about are things I can’t really hide - I can’t hide I have a 1 year old car and she has a 10 year old car? I’m not saying that my car is better because it’s newer. I would never say it the other way around - like my cars so new and yours is old, what did you pay for that?! (As that would be rude!)

DH is in no way controlling - very much a lovey guy!

I also work for myself! I have been A SAHM for a period but I needed to work for my own sanity! 2 days out the house away from my kids is dreamy!

I think you are not very self aware. You seem very keen to talk about money. You earn money to buy B&M bits - are you for real? How much do you think a CEO earns? The more you post the more I’m not convinced.

Bleachmycloths · 24/11/2022 09:45

HowDoYouOwnDisorder · 21/11/2022 22:43

Just from reading your post you sound like you really really like talking about money

so you are well matched as friends

I strongly disagree. The OP is simply giving us the background and perspective. She is making it clear that they are no way struggling, but not really wealthy either.

JaceLancs · 24/11/2022 09:32

I know someone like this and they are the same with others - asking intrusive questions most wouldn’t dream of - but it’s just their obsession and I just disengage or make up stuff
For example when I changed my car they instantly said ‘ooh nice car - how much was it’ I usually do really vague - so ‘it was a bargain’ or ‘tons I felt like treating myself’ or ‘£50k’ when it patently wasn’t
They normally then get the hint - occasionally they don’t take a hint and I just say ‘I said x because I don’t want to discuss costs’

FlamingJingleBells · 24/11/2022 09:26

Start asking Anna the same questions about money she asks you & you'll find that she'll back off soon enough. I have an aunt like this and she shut up as soon as I started asking about her finances.

Dibbydoos · 24/11/2022 09:26

This is a game and needs to be called out.

You don't have to be nasty you do need to be clear talking money is off limits its jeopardising your friendship.

Flutterbybudget · 24/11/2022 09:24

Me being me, would have to be a total wound up merchant and make the stories more and more ridiculous just to give her something to gossip about, but that’s me.

Best advice, is ignore and decide whether you want to continue the friendship who says/ does what she does. Weigh up the positives and negatives of the friendship, and see how it balances out.

On a serious note, as another poster said, register for child benefit in your own name. Put it to one side. You may well have to pay it back, but it will count towards to your own state pension contributions. I don’t want to a nay sayer, but you can’t guarantee what the future holds. I was in a similar financial position to you - DH on a great salary, I just earned pin money for the “extras”, but after 25 years we split up. He’s now on his lovely salary, with his flourishing career, while I’m struggling financially. And I promise I’m not saying that I think you will do so, but make sure that you have your back covered and have your NI contributions covered as a back up.

Itsybitsyminion · 24/11/2022 09:22

You need a salt bath to wash away all the jealousy. RUN!

Swipe left for the next trending thread